Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reagan expanded what started under Carter.



If the terms were so bad, why didn't Biden squash it? Biden predicted months ago that what's happening would not happen. Neo-cons like Liz Cheney have been relatively consistent: They criticized Trump then, and they're criticizing Biden now. Which is not to say I have any affection for the Kristols, Lakes, and Cheneys (a million Iraqi ghosts say, "Hi").

It was always curious how Obama selected Biden primarily for the goof's "foreign policy experience." Of course, it was for the appearance of foreign policy experience. This part of the establishment was always better described as "The Blob" rather than another tentacle of the "Deep State."

Biden has plenty of foreign policy experience. As he just explained, "squashing" the Trump agreement would have meant returning to active combat against the Taliban and sending in more U.S. troops. For how long? To what end? How many more Americans should die for Afghans who won't fight for themselves?
 
Reagan expanded what started under Carter.



If the terms were so bad, why didn't Biden squash it? Biden predicted months ago that what's happening would not happen. Neo-cons like Liz Cheney have been relatively consistent: They criticized Trump then, and they're criticizing Biden now. Which is not to say I have any affection for the Kristols, Lakes, and Cheneys (a million Iraqi ghosts say, "Hi").

For the reasons he just gave.

It was always curious how Obama selected Biden primarily for the goof's "foreign policy experience." Of course, it was for the appearance of foreign policy experience. This part of the establishment was always better described as "The Blob" rather than another tentacle of the "Deep State."

Nonsense. Biden had a lot of actual foreign policy experience. To call it an 'appearance' is disingenuous.
 
I see people reminding other people that Biden's not the only one to blame, rather.

But I agree. It was a terrible withdrawal.

Idk, if they can pull off a withdrawal that’s free of US casualties I think that’s something. It’s conceding defeat and retreating, tough make it look good. And I think the Taliban is making a show of it also.
 
Reagan expanded what started under Carter.



If the terms were so bad, why didn't Biden squash it? Biden predicted months ago that what's happening would not happen. Neo-cons like Liz Cheney have been relatively consistent: They criticized Trump then, and they're criticizing Biden now. Which is not to say I have any affection for the Kristols, Lakes, and Cheneys (a million Iraqi ghosts say, "Hi").

It was always curious how Obama selected Biden primarily for the goof's "foreign policy experience." Of course, it was for the appearance of foreign policy experience. This part of the establishment was always better described as "The Blob" rather than another tentacle of the "Deep State."

Well I think they were right and wrong. I think the Afghan papers shed a lot of light on this situation. Saying we need to stick around and fix this otherwise the Taliban will take over but having no way to fix it or even an idea of what “this” is isn’t being right either imo
 
Why not address what he said instead of resorting to the above?

He confidently asserted what was definitely not going to happen in Afghanistan (are you sure this is not going to be like the fall of Saigon?) and then it happened, and now he says nobody could have known that it would have happened like that.
 
Look, I'm not asking a water is wet question here.


For everyone saying this withdrawal was bad, how do you know? What data out there says it could have been improved? What if this is as good as it gets under the circumstances?
 
Last edited:
He confidently asserted what was definitely not going to happen in Afghanistan (are you sure this is not going to be like the fall of Saigon?) and then it happened, and now he says nobody could have known that it would have happened like that.

When he said that, it's what he believed. He never said "nobody could have known it would happen like that". He said they were surprised it happened so quickly.
“The truth is this did unfold more quickly than we had anticipated.”
 
Last edited:
I was there in 2002-2003. When they invaded Iraq, nobody gave Afghanistan a second thought. And nobody cared what went on over there after until this week. A poorly planned withdrawal that nobody really thought about and will be quickly forgotten is a fitting end to a war nobody really noticed imo
 
He confidently asserted what was definitely not going to happen in Afghanistan (are you sure this is not going to be like the fall of Saigon?) and then it happened, and now he says nobody could have known that it would have happened like that.

I heard Biden's statement. He is going to have to do better then that.
He is not addressing the main issue:which is not our withdrawal, but how the withdrawal was carried out.
And yeah, his repeated statements that this woul dnot be another Saigon look pretty ridiculous.
Major damage control is needed, and Biden did not provide it.
I am very disspaointed in him at the moment.
And I think a "we must support everything Biden says and does because not to do so will help the GOP and Trump" is not a good strategy.
 
When he said that, it's what he believed. He never said "nobody could have known it would happen like that". He said they were surprised it happened so quickly.
“The truth is this did unfold more quickly than we had anticipated.”

Clear the in your mind Biden is infallible .
 
Biden has plenty of foreign policy experience. As he just explained, "squashing" the Trump agreement would have meant returning to active combat against the Taliban and sending in more U.S. troops. For how long? To what end? How many more Americans should die for Afghans who won't fight for themselves?


So we betray the Afghans who worked with US troops by not getting htem out due to a hasty and ill planned withdrawal??
Nice.
But Trump ,excuse me, Biden is God and cannot make a mistake.
 
Biden has plenty of foreign policy experience.

Let me clarify. Biden has foreign policy experience the way Trump has business experience. Or the way a basketball coach with 300Ws and 500Ls has experience: Consistently being on the wrong side. He's part of the Blob. Look at Biden's wavering on the Iraq War, then voting for authorization, then opposing the surge. His advice on Bin Laden.

As he just explained, "squashing" the Trump agreement would have meant returning to active combat against the Taliban and sending in more U.S. troops. For how long? To what end? How many more Americans should die for Afghans who won't fight for themselves?

And I agree with that. The Boltons and Cheneys would just try to delay what is most likely inevitable. But the fact remains things did not turn out the way Biden and his team expected. At least he didn't have a "Mission Accomplished" sign in the background.

Nonsense. Biden had a lot of actual foreign policy experience. To call it an 'appearance' is disingenuous.

Clarified.
 
So we betray the Afghans who worked with US troops by not getting htem out due to a hasty and ill planned withdrawal??
Nice.
But Trump ,excuse me, Biden is God and cannot make a mistake.

There is a multi year backlog in visa approvals for those who worked with US troops. Waiting to make progress on that could be a multi year delay.
 
Sooo...who was in charge of securing the airfield? It doesn't look like there are any protection forces beyond a couple Apaches.
 
Sooo...who was in charge of securing the airfield? It doesn't look like there are any protection forces beyond a couple Apaches.

There are troops on the ground at Kabul Airport, and the have exchanged fire with Taliaban troops.
 
So we betray the Afghans who worked with US troops by not getting htem out due to a hasty and ill planned withdrawal??
Nice.
But Trump ,excuse me, Biden is God and cannot make a mistake.

Nobody says that. The process for getting these people out should have started months ago. And maybe the U.S. exit could have been delayed a few months. But the ultimate result would have been the same.
 
Nobody says that. The process for getting these people out should have started months ago. And maybe the U.S. exit could have been delayed a few months. But the ultimate result would have been the same.

I agree, but IMHO delyaing a few months might have made a difference to the Humantarian disaster about to happen.
 
That footage of the planes taking off with Afghans clining to the wheels won't help Biden much.
ANybody who thinks this not going to hurt the Democrats politically is living in another reality.
 
There is a multi year backlog in visa approvals for those who worked with US troops. Waiting to make progress on that could be a multi year delay.

There's no reason why it should take years. As some commentators are observing, the U.S. has biometric databases of everybody who worked for us, and the Taliban is using that captured information to look for those people. It would have been easy for the U.S. to say "If we can identify you in our database, we'll take you and your family to Guam and process your visa there."
 
I heard Biden's statement. He is going to have to do better then that.
He is not addressing the main issue:which is not our withdrawal, but how the withdrawal was carried out.
And yeah, his repeated statements that this woul dnot be another Saigon look pretty ridiculous.
Major damage control is needed, and Biden did not provide it.
I am very disspaointed in him at the moment.
And I think a "we must support everything Biden says and does because not to do so will help the GOP and Trump" is not a good strategy.

I don't see people doing that and it's certainly not happening on CNN. Your penchant to exaggerate...and just make things up... has become tedious. In just the last three pages:

"But Trump ,excuse me, Biden is God and cannot make a mistake."

"Clear the in your mind Biden is infallible ."

"I see we have Biden is above any blame and criticism cult building here.
I know what the thinking is, any criticism of Biden helps the GOP, so Biden should not be criticised."


"SOrry, but the actual withdrawal was messed up and it happened on BIden's watch.
Not that there are lots of people to blame....including Trump of course...but please;only members of the Personaity Cult will buy that Biden has no responsiblity for this."

"And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it."

"Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake."

"I think the idea that Biden is above criticism for this is really no better then what I get from the GOP."

And for cripes' sake, it's Taliban, not Taliaban.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom