Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I see we have Biden is above any blame and criticism cult building here.
I know what the thinking is, any criticism of Biden helps the GOP, so Biden should not be criticised.
SOrry, but the actual withdrawal was messed up and it happened on BIden's watch.
Not that there are lots of people to blame....including Trump of course...but please;only members of the Personaity Cult will buy that Biden has no responsiblity for this.
 
Biden promised we would get the Afghans who worked for the US out. He broke that promise.That is reprehensible.
Who will trust us after this?
 
Blaming other posters for not knee-jerk agreeing with you is poor form. No one here has political power, no one can help get Afghanis out to safety, our posts here are farts in the wind that go no further than the handful of other members' screens. If everyone here all replied to you with "oh yeah Biden totally blew it he should be impeached for it even though Trump wasn't" what would that do exactly?

As for trust, that was completely destroyed back when the Kurds were abandoned. That was recent enough that no trust could build up.
 
Last edited:
Biden said it wouldn't end like this and then it's ending like this. He can try to blame Trump all he wants, but it's not going to work. He rescinded other plans from his predecessor; he had room to maneuver here but chose to follow Trump's timeline. Executive Abstract: Presidents only have incentives to start stupid wars, not end them. It's remarkable Biden went along with this in his first term.

What have people been saying about Afghanistan for twenty years? It's unforgiving terrain, extremely tribal, and exceedingly hostile to outsiders. "A graveyard of empires." "The invaders have the watches, but we have the time." "Me against my brother. Me and my brother against my cousin. Me, my brother, and my cousin against my neighbor. Me, my brother, my cousin, and my neighbor against the foreigner."

Trump's responsibility in this can't be downplayed as some are trying to do, including Trump himself (which comes as no surprise). As Christiane Amanpour, who has a great understanding of Afghanistan, said on CNN, Trump negotiated only with the Taliban without the Afghan government and with no way to way to verify that they would adhere to the agreement. Also, by letting the Taliban know the US would be withdrawing its troops by May 1 (Trump's date), it gave them forewarning and a time schedule to strategize and prepare which they are very good at. It's a major reason why they succeeded so quickly.
Rep. Liz Cheney, R-Wyo., spoke on "The Brian Kilmeade Show" about the devolving situation in Afghanistan and appeared to lay some of the blame on the Trump administration.

"The fact that Mike Pompeo was the first Secretary of State to meet with the Taliban, the fact that they were considering inviting the Taliban to Camp David on 9/11 -- that set this all in motion," Liz Cheney said of former President Donald Trump and his administration.

She continued to say that she, as well as other ranking members of the party, were told by the former president and Pompeo that "we were going to renounce the Taliban, we were going to renounce Al-Qaeda...none of that happened."

As the well-known war hawk warned in early 2020, as the Trump administration left the Afghan government out of negotiations with the Taliban, "Any deal that the United States would contemplate entering into with the Taliban should be made public in its entirety." The peace agreement, she warned, may be lopsided in the Taliban's favor without a verification mechanism. "I've expressed my serious concerns about the lack of verification mechanism, about the commitment and the agreement that we would go to zero and primarily about the fact that what we have here are a number of promises by the Taliban."


She continued: "Many of them are promises that have been made before, and I think that the decisions about American troop levels in Afghanistan have to be made based on America's national security interests, not based on empty promises from the Taliban and an agreement that doesn't have any disclosed verification mechanism."

On Monday, however, after Afghan President Ashraf Ghani fled the country, Cheney still laid the ultimate blame on the Democrat currently occupying the White House. "What we are seeing today absolutely is the responsibility of Joe Biden."
 
Last edited:
Why? You brought it up. If you don't want to discuss something, don't bring it up in the first place.

The road I am talking about it a disregard of ethics for political expediency. As in “do you think it matters if we leave Afghanistan to the tender mercies of the Taliban?”

You could choose;

1.) Yes, it matters because whatever fault lies at the door of other administrations we do have a duty to those who worked hard to rebuild Afghanistan, particularly those who will most likely be killed or imprisoned by the Taliban.

Or

2.) if it doesn’t affect Biden’s poll numbers then who cares?

I am saying, don’t choose number 2.
 
I see we have Biden is above any blame and criticism cult building here.
I know what the thinking is, any criticism of Biden helps the GOP, so Biden should not be criticised.
SOrry, but the actual withdrawal was messed up and it happened on BIden's watch.
Not that there are lots of people to blame....including Trump of course...but please;only members of the Personaity Cult will buy that Biden has no responsiblity for this.

Will you please provide links to anyone who has said that Biden is 'above any blame' in this debacle?
 
Trump's responsibility in this can't be downplayed as some are trying to do, including Trump himself (which comes as no surprise). As Christiane Amanpour, who has a great understanding of Afghanistan, said on CNN, Trump negotiated only with the Taliban without the Afghan government and with no way to way to verify that they would adhere to the agreement. Also, by letting the Taliban know the US would be withdrawing its troops by May 31 (Trump's date), it gave them forewarning and a time schedule to strategize and prepare which the are very good at. It's a major reason why they succeeded so quickly.

Absolutely! Trump made an awful “deal” and Biden decided to follow it.

Let’s face it, given that some people only care about how this will affect poll numbers I can very easily see Biden’s words about how there will be no evacuation of the roof an embassy played over footage of the evacuation off the roof of an embassy during the presidential election campaign.
 
Will you please provide links to anyone who has said that Biden is 'above any blame' in this debacle?

Not in so many words, of course, but the way that some people bristle at the mere thought that Biden might have made mistakes there.
The problem is not in the idea of withdrawal, but in the execution of it which was way too quick. Another couple of months could have resulted in amore orderly withdrawal and allowed us to get those who worked with US Troops out of Afghansitan.
Of course I fully expect some to say that that those left behind in Afghanistan have it coming, given I am already seeing on many internet sites what amounts to apologetics for the Taliaban.
 
Absolutely! Trump made an awful “deal” and Biden decided to follow it.

Let’s face it, given that some people only care about how this will affect poll numbers I can very easily see Biden’s words about how there will be no evacuation of the roof an embassy played over footage of the evacuation off the roof of an embassy during the presidential election campaign.

As Biden just said, after May 1, the deal with the Taliban not to attack US soldiers would have expired. The Taliban were at their strongest in 20 years and it was the spring fighting season. If he had not agreed to abide by Trump's deal, he would have had to increase our forces that had been depleted by Trump and fighting would have resumed with more US casualties.

As he also said, they did not predict how fast the Afghan government and army would fold for the reasons we've already discussed.
 
IKf Biden is to get my trust back on foreign affiars, some heads has better roll at State of the Pentagon. If we were getting bad intelligence, the people responsible for that need to go.
 
Absolutely! Trump made an awful “deal” and Biden decided to follow it.

Let’s face it, given that some people only care about how this will affect poll numbers I can very easily see Biden’s words about how there will be no evacuation of the roof an embassy played over footage of the evacuation off the roof of an embassy during the presidential election campaign.

I don't think Biden will run again, but ,yeah, the GOP will use that.
 
As Biden just said, after May 1, the deal with the Taliban not to attack US soldiers would have expired. The Taliban were at their strongest in 20 years and it was the spring fighting season. If he had not agreed to abide by Trump's deal, he would have had to increase our forces that had been depleted by Trump and fighting would have resumed with more US casualties.

As he also said, they did not predict how fast the Afghan government and army would fold for the reasons we've already discussed.

:jaw-dropp

Is that supposed to make him look good?
 
I blame Reagan (for arming Taliban) Bush, Obama and Trump. Congress has powers to act on this too, they never did.

Reagan expanded what started under Carter.

Trump's responsibility in this can't be downplayed as some are trying to do, including Trump himself (which comes as no surprise). As Christiane Amanpour, who has a great understanding of Afghanistan, said on CNN, Trump negotiated only with the Taliban without the Afghan government and with no way to way to verify that they would adhere to the agreement. Also, by letting the Taliban know the US would be withdrawing its troops by May 31 (Trump's date), it gave them forewarning and a time schedule to strategize and prepare which the are very good at. It's a major reason why they succeeded so quickly.

If the terms were so bad, why didn't Biden squash it? Biden predicted months ago that what's happening would not happen. Neo-cons like Liz Cheney have been relatively consistent: They criticized Trump then, and they're criticizing Biden now. Which is not to say I have any affection for the Kristols, Lakes, and Cheneys (a million Iraqi ghosts say, "Hi").

It was always curious how Obama selected Biden primarily for the goof's "foreign policy experience." Of course, it was for the appearance of foreign policy experience. This part of the establishment was always better described as "The Blob" rather than another tentacle of the "Deep State."
 
Not in so many words, of course, but the way that some people bristle at the mere thought that Biden might have made mistakes there.


I thought not. IOW, you're interpreting posts according to your own bias rather than what is actually being said. Unless it's "Biden is totally at fault for this" your see "Biden is blameless". Very black and white.


The problem is not in the idea of withdrawal, but in the execution of it which was way too quick. Another couple of months could have resulted in amore orderly withdrawal and allowed us to get those who worked with US Troops out of Afghansitan.

I agree that the execution was poor. The preparation for the evacuation of Americans and our Afghan allies should have been ready going back to the last administration. However, Biden just said that the Afghan government did not want their citizens evacuated earlier as it would create a 'crisis of confidence' and many Afghan allies did not want to leave earlier. He plans to continue evacuating with a warning to the Taliban that, if they intercede, the military will counter swiftly and strongly.

Of course I fully expect some to say that that those left behind in Afghanistan have it coming, given I am already seeing on many internet sites what amounts to apologetics for the Taliaban.

I highly doubt you'll see that stupid claim here unless made by a troll.

Links to those sites you say are making it? I'd like to see what these idiots are saying.
 
I don't think anyone can say the Biden administration didn't blow it. That said, the US has been blowing it there for two decades.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom