Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Which military? It's turning out that Afghan army and police units were making deals with the Taliban a year ago. How much more support should the U.S. give to a corrupt government that won't fight for itself? There's an argument to be made that the Taliban, like the Viet Cong, couldn't survive without broader support from the populace. I don't think too many Americans will consider this a defeat for us.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/08/15/afghanistan-military-collapse-taliban/


There are sooooo many parallels with Vietnam. With the Afghan military reprising the role played so disastrously by the ARVN. Throw in a whole bunch of other similarities:

1) invade a small country half way around the world, with the stated aim of "protecting the US" (and the World);

2) not only entirely fail to win the "hearts and minds" battle, but also actively alienate very large numbers of moderate locals by destroying their homes and livelihoods and killing civilians in collateral damage;

3) fail to understand that even moderate locals take extreme umbrage at a foreign superpower invading their country and telling them how to run it "properly";

4) engage in mission creep when it becomes clear (as it should have done from the start, actually) that the original objective is unmeasurable and unattainable - so invent a whole different set of objectives in order to give the semblance of progression and success and justify ongoing invasion presence and previous/continuing deaths & injuries;

5) install a pliant (arguably "puppet") local government and military, and throw money and materiel at them - a sure-fire recipe for local corruption, inefficiency and poor performance;

6) get stuck in an insoluble conundrum: either keep significant numbers of troops and non-military officials in-country more-or-less in perpetuity (costing ever more money and lives, with little or no discernible benefit in the eyes of US Congress/media/public)..... or withdraw most/all troops and advisers, leaving the locals at the inevitable mercy of the very people the US went there fighting against for all those years, to face the glaringly-obvious question of what the heck all that money and all those lost lives actually achieved for the US.


And I think most Americans considered the Vietnam debacle to be.... a defeat. Though obviously Afghanistan - and Iraq - count as lesser defeats, especially in the domestically-important ratio of US lives lost vs tangible/intangible benefits to US interests.



(BTW, I agree with some others in this thread that the real fault lies with previous US administrations, particularly W and Obama. Biden was presented with the conundrum I listed in (6) above: arguably the withdrawal might have been delayed, slowed, and/or less chaotic than it turned out to be, but IMO the US had no pragmatic option but to withdraw - with a large dose of dishonour and with the field left wide open for the Taliban to take control...)
 
I disagree. A humiliation like this might not matter much in the liberal enclaves; but to most Americans it hurts, badly.
Biden messed up badly here. No way to rationally deny it. The withdrawal was horribly planned.

Yea they had 20 years to get the forces working and it folds in a couple of weeks. So what another decade and it could have lasted another week?

The speed that it fell is more damning of the american role there than anything else.
 
Yea they had 20 years to get the forces working and it folds in a couple of weeks. So what another decade and it could have lasted another week?

The speed that it fell is more damning of the american role there than anything else.


Yes. It's somewhat astonishing that at exactly the time when the official US Govt line was that the withdrawal was taking place entirely on the allies' terms and in an orderly, calm manner..... it seems that CIA and State officials in-country were hurriedly burning/destroying sensitive documents and a disorganised withdrawal to the airport was being stepped up.
 
Yes. It's somewhat astonishing that at exactly the time when the official US Govt line was that the withdrawal was taking place entirely on the allies' terms and in an orderly, calm manner..... it seems that CIA and State officials in-country were hurriedly burning/destroying sensitive documents and a disorganised withdrawal to the airport was being stepped up.

Even in the best of times government work is slow progress with a sudden upswing at the end.
 
Trump has called on Biden to resign in disgrace for what he has allowed to happen in Afghanistan along with the tremendous surge in Covid, the border catastrophe, the destruction of energy independence and the crippling of the economy.
 
(BTW, I agree with some others in this thread that the real fault lies with previous US administrations, particularly W and Obama. Biden was presented with the conundrum I listed in (6) above: arguably the withdrawal might have been delayed, slowed, and/or less chaotic than it turned out to be, but IMO the US had no pragmatic option but to withdraw - with a large dose of dishonour and with the field left wide open for the Taliban to take control...)

Outside of dishonour, I'd agree.

The Americans weren't defeated in Afghanistan. They left and the Afghan military fell.

I do believe it demonstrates a failure of the US military and the political leaders. This clearly was a mission that could never be accomplished with guns. Or could be accomplished at all.
 
Outside of dishonour, I'd agree.

The Americans weren't defeated in Afghanistan. They left and the Afghan military fell.

I do believe it demonstrates a failure of the US military and the political leaders. This clearly was a mission that could never be accomplished with guns. Or could be accomplished at all.


Depends what is defined as "defeat". The narrow definition is along the lines of "losing a war and being forced to surrender on the enemy's terms". And of course by this measure the US (and its allies, including the UK) wasn't defeated.

But I'd use the broader definition of defeat to include "failing to achieve original stated objectives and withdrawing".

And by my definition, the US Commanders-in-Chief who were defeated in Afghanistan (and Iraq) were W and Obama. Not Biden.
 
Yeah, I would prefer that people think about the moral aspects of leaving Afghanistan like this rather than merely questions of political expedience (don’t worry! The American voters are dumb and will forget all about it by the time of the election so who cares?!)

You want to talk about how it should be. We're discussing how it is.

Don't go down this road, please!

Why? You brought it up. If you don't want to discuss something, don't bring it up in the first place.
 
Trump has called on Biden to resign in disgrace for what he has allowed to happen in Afghanistan along with the tremendous surge in Covid, the border catastrophe, the destruction of energy independence and the crippling of the economy.

"How dare you go ahead with my plan? That was a terrible idea and you knew it! Resign!"
 
Depends what is defined as "defeat". The narrow definition is along the lines of "losing a war and being forced to surrender on the enemy's terms". And of course by this measure the US (and its allies, including the UK) wasn't defeated.

But I'd use the broader definition of defeat to include "failing to achieve original stated objectives and withdrawing".

And by my definition, the US Commanders-in-Chief who were defeated in Afghanistan (and Iraq) were W and Obama. Not Biden.

All presidents since GWB got us into this mess share the blame for this, but GWB deserves the greatest share by far. The Taliban takeover was inevitable and anyone who knows anything about the history and culture of Afghanistan could have, and should have, seen it.

What we see as corruption, as I've said earlier, is part of their culture. It's always been 'family and tribal loyalty first' and anything that benefits those comes first. That's how they have learned to survive.
 
Depends what is defined as "defeat". The narrow definition is along the lines of "losing a war and being forced to surrender on the enemy's terms". And of course by this measure the US (and its allies, including the UK) wasn't defeated.

But I'd use the broader definition of defeat to include "failing to achieve original stated objectives and withdrawing".

And by my definition, the US Commanders-in-Chief who were defeated in Afghanistan (and Iraq) were W and Obama. Not Biden.

What was defined as "victory", and was it ever actually achievable?
 
What was defined as "victory", and was it ever actually achievable?
Nobody knows and no.

WaPo came out with the Afghanistan papers and revealed as much. Nobody in charge had any idea what the mission was, much less how to accomplish it. It was a zombie war, dead but undead.
 
Biden said it wouldn't end like this and then it's ending like this. He can try to blame Trump all he wants, but it's not going to work. He rescinded other plans from his predecessor; he had room to maneuver here but chose to follow Trump's timeline. Executive Abstract: Presidents only have incentives to start stupid wars, not end them. It's remarkable Biden went along with this in his first term.

What have people been saying about Afghanistan for twenty years? It's unforgiving terrain, extremely tribal, and exceedingly hostile to outsiders. "A graveyard of empires." "The invaders have the watches, but we have the time." "Me against my brother. Me and my brother against my cousin. Me, my brother, and my cousin against my neighbor. Me, my brother, my cousin, and my neighbor against the foreigner."
 
Biden said it wouldn't end like this and then it's ending like this. He can try to blame Trump all he wants, but it's not going to work. He rescinded other plans from his predecessor; he had room to maneuver here but chose to follow Trump's timeline. Executive Abstract: Presidents only have incentives to start stupid wars, not end them. It's remarkable Biden went along with this in his first term.

What have people been saying about Afghanistan for twenty years? It's unforgiving terrain, extremely tribal, and exceedingly hostile to outsiders. "A graveyard of empires." "The invaders have the watches, but we have the time." "Me against my brother. Me and my brother against my cousin. Me, my brother, and my cousin against my neighbor. Me, my brother, my cousin, and my neighbor against the foreigner."

I blame Reagan (for arming Taliban) Bush, Obama and Trump. Congress has powers to act on this too, they never did.
 
So what should Biden actually do to help these people? Winning the war, whatever that means, was clearly not possible. Continuing it forever was an option I suppose, but not a good one.

Seems like there's a moral imperative for any and all NATO nations that took part in this boondoggle to open their borders to the inevitable wave of refugees fleeing the Taliban. This will undoubtedly be very unpopular for these very xenophobic and racist countries, but is clearly the right thing to do. I'm not holding my breath.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom