Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, I would prefer that people think about the moral aspects of leaving Afghanistan like this rather than merely questions of political expedience (don’t worry! The American voters are dumb and will forget all about it by the time of the election so who cares?!)

Moral questions resolved! I'm free to discuss politics now.
 
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
That. When Bush invaded Iraq, I thought "There goes his chances of a second term." Boy, was I wrong. Never underestimate the stupidity of a large portion of the electorate.
The difference is that the invasion of Iraq was widely considered at the time of Bush’s second election to be a big success.

It was only in his second term that it started really obviously falling apart.

True. It wasn't until after he was elected in 2004 that we discovered we had been lied to about the WMD. But I was still against it from day one and I didn't think Americans would be happy about another foreign war. Like I said, I was wrong.
 
I think the idea that Biden is above criticism for this is really no better then what I get from the GOP.
The bad thing about Partisan,ideilogical blinders is that people are totally unaware they are wearing them.
I guess trying to see things without blinders is not very popular here..andother eason why this site is pretty much dying.

Who has said Biden is above criticism? I certainly didn't. He was obviously wrong about the chances of the Taliban taking over. But trying to claim he is responsible for their quick takeover is not looking at the facts of what happened and why. If anyone is wearing blinders restricting their view, it's not us.
 
I think the idea that Biden is above criticism for this is really no better then what I get from the GOP.
The bad thing about Partisan,ideilogical blinders is that people are totally unaware they are wearing them.
I guess trying to see things without blinders is not very popular here..andother eason why this site is pretty much dying.

He is not above criticism. Criticize away.

But I think you're 100 percent wrong in thinking this makes a difference in US elections.
 
Yeah, I would prefer that people think about the moral aspects of leaving Afghanistan like this rather than merely questions of political expedience (don’t worry! The American voters are dumb and will forget all about it by the time of the election so who cares?!)

You want to talk about how it should be. We're discussing how it is.
 
Yeah, I would prefer that people think about the moral aspects of leaving Afghanistan like this rather than merely questions of political expedience (don’t worry! The American voters are dumb and will forget all about it by the time of the election so who cares?!)

Moral aspects? The Afghanistan government and military had more troops and more weapons than the Taliban yet they crumbled pretty much without a fight.

Is America prepared to fight and protect them indefinitely? Isn't two decades enough?
 
Moral aspects? The Afghanistan government and military had more troops and more weapons than the Taliban yet they crumbled pretty much without a fight.

Is America prepared to fight and protect them indefinitely? Isn't two decades enough?

I'm going to agree with dudalb on something. A month or two more of performing a smooth evacuation of those who should have been evacuated would have been useful. No need for decades for that.
 
I thinkk a withdrawl from Afghansitan was probably inevitable....it's turned into just a bad postion to hold from a military point of view...but the withdrawal was incredibly badly handled,and, frankly, I want to see some heads role at State and DOD over this.
I also am hearing reports that Agfhans who were allies to the US are being truned away from the Airport.That is an outrage and a shame.Same think as happened in VIetnam. Like to hear somebody defend doing this.
 
I thinkk a withdrawl from Afghansitan was probably inevitable....it's turned into just a bad postion to hold from a military point of view...but the withdrawal was incredibly badly handled,and, frankly, I want to see some heads role at State and DOD over this.
I also am hearing reports that Agfhans who were allies to the US are being truned away from the Airport.That is an outrage and a shame.Same think as happened in VIetnam. Like to hear somebody defend doing this.

Guardian ran part of a story of a hotel employee's SIV application being in review since 2018. The program has an 18,000 application backlog. The best option they could think of was trying to find a third party nation to host these people while they completed the process. And that was only going through the congressional process in July.

I think the program may have been more myth than reality, and accomplishing what you think may be more of a multi year project still remaining. The US has always had a bad system for processing refugees and similar visa requests.
 
I thinkk a withdrawl from Afghansitan was probably inevitable....it's turned into just a bad postion to hold from a military point of view...but the withdrawal was incredibly badly handled,and, frankly, I want to see some heads role at State and DOD over this.
I also am hearing reports that Agfhans who were allies to the US are being truned away from the Airport.That is an outrage and a shame.Same think as happened in VIetnam. Like to hear somebody defend doing this.

The Afghan people who helped the US such as the language translators should have been taken care of. Apparently, many of them are being hunted and executed. At least the mainstream media isn't asking Biden what his favorite ice cream flavor is right now.
 
The Afghan people who helped the US such as the language translators should have been taken care of. Apparently, many of them are being hunted and executed. At least the mainstream media isn't asking Biden what his favorite ice cream flavor is right now.

At least he isn't bragging about how he gets two scoops while everyone else only gets one.
 
You want to talk about how it should be. We're discussing how it is.

Don't go down this road, please!

Moral aspects? The Afghanistan government and military had more troops and more weapons than the Taliban yet they crumbled pretty much without a fight.

Is America prepared to fight and protect them indefinitely? Isn't two decades enough?

There's going to be a humanitarian disaster, I'm afraid.
 
Don't forget people the Major failure is on the Afgan Military forces refusal to fight, and that is mainly a Cultural issue that has faced every Army in Afghanistan, we see a simular Tribal Rivalry system building in the United States.
People loyal to the Small Group not to the Country.
Where there is no will there is no defense.
 
The real problem:
But perhaps the biggest hardship was having to teach virtually every recruit how to read. Kem estimated that only 2 to 5 percent of Afghan recruits could read at a third-grade level despite efforts by the United States to enroll millions of Afghan children in school over the previous decade.

“The literacy was just insurmountable,” he said in an Army oral-history interview. Some Afghans also had to learn their colors, or had to be taught how to count. “I mean, you’d ask an Afghan soldier how many brothers and sisters they had and they couldn’t tell you it was four. They could tell you their names, but they couldn’t go ‘one, two, three, four.’ ”

Making everything harder was the Obama administration’s decision to rapidly expand the size of the Afghan security forces from 200,000 soldiers and police to 350,000. With recruits at a premium, Afghans were rushed through boot camp, even if they couldn’t shoot or perform other basic tasks.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/inve...2a45e2-fdc7-11eb-a664-4f6de3e17ff0_story.html
 
Hmmm...looks to be the case.

This is an article from 2016:

With an estimated 25,000 troops officially based in Helmand, the government should have enough muscle to confront the Taliban.

The problem is many of those troops don’t exist.
Across Afghanistan, lists of troops and police officers are filled with fake names, or the names of men killed in the fighting, but not officially declared dead. Captain Wali and his men are in Babaji to fill the void of these “ghost soldiers”.

A recent investigation by Helmand’s provincial council found that approximately 40% of enlisted troops did not exist. The authors of an analysis commissioned by the Afghan government – and obtained by the Guardian – said the share might be even higher.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/may/17/afghanistan-ghost-soldiers-taliban-babaji

Ghost troops are emblematic of an adversary possibly even more damaging than the militants: corruption. Toofan Waziri, a political analyst who recently visited Helmand as part of a government appointed delegation, said he found one base where the commander had ordered half of his 100 soldiers to leave, without notifying his superiors, only to pocket their salaries.
 
Last edited:
We had not invested 20 years and many lives in Lebanon. Comparing the two is, frankly, stupid. You are really streching to convince yoursel this is not a disaster to the Biden Presidency.

That is just the sunk cost fallacy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom