Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's a strategic disaste whose effects will be felt wel beyond Afghanistan's borders.
Possibly.

I am angry because I thought Biden was smarter then to mess this up, I was wrong.
There had better be some firing in State and DOD over the next few days.

How should he have done this? Not at all? This seems to be the military's answer to everything.

You never answered my question Dud. When should we leave? Twenty years from now? Would that have made a difference?
 
two lefties think a total humilation of the US is not a big deal. What a surprise.
Making up a "humiliation" that isn't there is just plain desperate. For what happens in a given place after any particular country leaves that place to be an actual humiliation for that country just isn't even possible. Humiliation would need to be about something that happened while that country's forces are still there, by definition. You're pointing out problems at one restaurant and trying to tell people they're ignoring what a "humiliation" it is for some other restaurant miles away.

All polls/surveys on the subject have shown that getting out of Afghanistan has been very popular among the American populace, including those who've been expecting the Taliban to rule afterward, including when the poll is framed in that light. Biden's overall numbers have dropped recently, but that began before this, and, when his approval/disapproval is separated subject-by-subject, lo and behold, it turns out to be pretty high on the subject of leaving Afghanistan and low on domestic issues.

Shock of all shocks: do popular stuff, be popular on those items; do unpopular stuff, be unpopular on those items. Your desire for Democrats to keep choosing the second option as much as possible doesn't make what's popular popular, or make what's unpopular unpopular, or reverse the political effects thereof.

this will enerzize Islamic Extermist all over the Mid East
The consistency with which you manage to assert the exact opposite of reality on every topic in your reach is impressive. The #1 complaint about the USA among foreign Muslims has long been its presence & interference in other countries, particularly theirs. Leaving one obviously reduces that, so of course you just had to say it would do the opposite.

Of course your probably don't see Islamic Militants as any kind of a threat. Guess 9/11 went into a black hole in your memory.
Again with the posting from Opposite World. If anybody here is forgetting about the day the Muslim terrorists targeted symbols of excessive American influence & imposition around the globe because they wanted America to back off & mind its own business, it's anybody who claims that those same groups will be riled up by getting what they want.
 
Possibly.



How should he have done this? Not at all? This seems to be the military's answer to everything.

You never answered my question Dud. When should we leave? Twenty years from now? Would that have made a difference?

A few more months would probably have allowed a lot more Afghanis to have gotten out.
But your contempt for the Militaryis noted,
And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it.

Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake.
 
A few more months would probably have allowed a lot more Afghanis to have gotten out.
But your contempt for the Militaryis noted,
And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it.
Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake.


Which military? It's turning out that Afghan army and police units were making deals with the Taliban a year ago. How much more support should the U.S. give to a corrupt government that won't fight for itself? There's an argument to be made that the Taliban, like the Viet Cong, couldn't survive without broader support from the populace. I don't think too many Americans will consider this a defeat for us.
KABUL — The spectacular collapse of Afghanistan’s military that allowed Taliban fighters to reach the gates of Kabul on Sunday despite twenty years of training and billions of dollars in American aid began with a series of deals brokered in rural villages between the militant group and some of the Afghan government’s lowest-ranking officials.
The deals, initially offered early last year, were often described by Afghan officials as cease-fires, but Taliban leaders were in fact offering money in exchange for government forces to hand over their weapons, according to an Afghan officer and a U.S. official.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/08/15/afghanistan-military-collapse-taliban/
 
We've spent 20 years in Afghanistan building their army, having them set up a government and then supporting that government, and if it's already down, Afghanis didn't want it. And if Afghanis didn't want it, the government was going down the second we left whether it was last year when Trump wanted out, now, or 50 years from now.
 
As I, and others, have been saying, you can't force others to fight when the will isn't there. The Afghan Army had no will to fight as they so quickly demonstrated. The Taliban could not, and would not, have overrun the entirety of the government controlled areas if the Afghan Army had fought. They just didn't. That is not Biden's fault. That is the fault of the Afghans' own corrupt government and their own culture and history. Nothing, nor any amount of reasonable time, was or is going to change that.
 
A few more months would probably have allowed a lot more Afghanis to have gotten out.
Maybe. Is that something we wanted to do?
But your contempt for the Military is noted,And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it.

Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake.

How many times have you said I have contempt for the military? This is patently false. I have a tremendous amount of respect for the military.

But this doesn't mean I'm ignorant of its flaws. I believe the military is prone to certain kinds of mistakes. And not being willing to pull back seems to be number one on their hit list.

As for this being a mistake. Maybe you're right. But I still don't think it has much of an effect on US elections.
 
As I, and others, have been saying, you can't force others to fight when the will isn't there. The Afghan Army had no will to fight as they so quickly demonstrated. The Taliban could not, and would not, have overrun the entirety of the government controlled areas if the Afghan Army had fought. They just didn't. That is not Biden's fault. That is the fault of the Afghans' own corrupt government and their own culture and history. Nothing, nor any amount of reasonable time, was or is going to change that.

It's much easier to stand up to the playground bully when you know your big brother is right there and has your back.
 
Last edited:
We've spent 20 years in Afghanistan building their army, having them set up a government and then supporting that government, and if it's already down, Afghanis didn't want it. And if Afghanis didn't want it, the government was going down the second we left whether it was last year when Trump wanted out, now, or 50 years from now.

I keep saying the following, and here we see a supporting example:

A People gets the government it deserves.
 
We've spent 20 years in Afghanistan building their army, having them set up a government and then supporting that government, and if it's already down, Afghanis didn't want it. And if Afghanis didn't want it, the government was going down the second we left whether it was last year when Trump wanted out, now, or 50 years from now.

:thumbsup:

The GOP is already placing all the blame on Biden. Pompeo, conveniently forgetting that he was all for Trump's plan of withdrawing by May 31, is now opening his blow hole and criticizing Biden for "blame shifting". Oh, sweet Jesus...the irony!

Rep. Mike Waltz (R) is also blaming Biden calling the withdrawal the 'worst foreign policy disaster in modern American history' again conveniently forgetting that it was GWB who got us into both Iraq and Afghanistan in the first place. THOSE were the worst foreign policy decisions, not getting us out. He also said Ukraine and Hong Kong must be feeling terrified about how we abandoned our allies. Amnesia strikes again as he forgets to have a 'broken heart' for our Kurd allies that Trump abandoned and were 'hunted down'. And let's not forget Trump's "perfect" phone call with Ukraine's Pres. Zelensky whom he was attempting to extort for his own political gain.

The GOP's hypocrisy, although completely expected, is still mind blowing. But their base will eat it up like candy.
 
It's much easier to stand up to the playground bully when you know your big brother is right there and has your back.

A bully is almost always bigger and stronger than his victim. In this case, the bigger and stronger army was the Afghan Army with over 300,000 troops and US supplied equipment, not the 80,000 Taliban.
 
A few more months would probably have allowed a lot more Afghanis to have gotten out.
But your contempt for the Militaryis noted,
And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it.

Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake.

You're adopting a knee-jerk reaction and attitude when you take offense at any displeasure expressed by progressives where the military is concerned. If there's a lack of respect being directed by any thinking progs, it would be more toward the civilian leadership under whom the military serve. (Fools who might think the military is an autonomous branch of government calling its own shots can be dismissed without taking their drivel seriously.)
 
Bush managed to get elected a second time on the back of going to Iraq and other things.

Voters have a short memory, dudalb.

That. When Bush invaded Iraq, I thought "There goes his chances of a second term." Boy, was I wrong. Never underestimate the stupidity of a large portion of the electorate.

The difference is that the invasion of Iraq was widely considered at the time of Bush’s second election to be a big success.

It was only in his second term that it started really obviously falling apart.
 
:thumbsup:

The GOP is already placing all the blame on Biden. Pompeo, conveniently forgetting that he was all for Trump's plan of withdrawing by May 31, is now opening his blow hole and criticizing Biden for "blame shifting". Oh, sweet Jesus...the irony!

Rep. Mike Waltz (R) is also blaming Biden calling the withdrawal the 'worst foreign policy disaster in modern American history' again conveniently forgetting that it was GWB who got us into both Iraq and Afghanistan in the first place. THOSE were the worst foreign policy decisions, not getting us out. He also said Ukraine and Hong Kong must be feeling terrified about how we abandoned our allies. Amnesia strikes again as he forgets to have a 'broken heart' for our Kurd allies that Trump abandoned and were 'hunted down'. And let's not forget Trump's "perfect" phone call with Ukraine's Pres. Zelensky whom he was attempting to extort for his own political gain.

The GOP's hypocrisy, although completely expected, is still mind blowing. But their base will eat it up like candy.
And in other breaking news: water turns out to be wet. :thumbsup:

Still worth pointing out to some people I suppose.
 
I think the idea that Biden is above criticism for this is really no better then what I get from the GOP.
The bad thing about Partisan,ideilogical blinders is that people are totally unaware they are wearing them.
I guess trying to see things without blinders is not very popular here..andother eason why this site is pretty much dying.
 
Yeah, I would prefer that people think about the moral aspects of leaving Afghanistan like this rather than merely questions of political expedience (don’t worry! The American voters are dumb and will forget all about it by the time of the election so who cares?!)
 
A few more months would probably have allowed a lot more Afghanis to have gotten out.
But your contempt for the Militaryis noted,
And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it.

You tend to take any criticism of the military as contempt for the entire military. That is just not true. You also tend to see military action as a go to resolution for a lot of things. Your admiration and love of the military and its history is very apparent in your posts. I'm not saying that's a bad thing; I just think it tends to cloud how you look at most things.

Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake.

No one is ignoring anything. We are seeing it from a broader perspective than you do. Nor is it a 'fact' that he 'messed up badly'. That is an opinion.
 
Apparently the only possible reason why I'm saying this isn't a catastrophe is because I'm such a dedicated Biden fan. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom