Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Despite their pretense, nothing about Marx and Engels is actually scientific. And history has proven them completely wrong. They thought industrial capitalism would evolve into communism. But the way communists actually gained power was through violent revolution in decidedly non-capitalist, often agrarian societies. They also couldn't conceive of the rapid growth of worker productivity in capitalist industrial societies which allowed an unprecedented increase in standard of living across the board, not just for the rich.

Lol, what? Marx and his contemporaries didn't think industrial capitalism would "evolve" into communism. That's impossible. A socialist revolution is necessary to eventually bring about communism. Marxism 101.

You are right that people like Lenin and Mao decided to wage socialist revolutions in countries that were so far from the requirement of fully-developed industrial capitalism that it was impossible for them to fully succeed.

The US and other first world countries however are ready at this point.
 
Lol, what? Marx and his contemporaries didn't think industrial capitalism would "evolve" into communism. That's impossible. A socialist revolution is necessary to eventually bring about communism. Marxism 101.

Perhaps I'm not making myself clear.

Marx thought capitalism would inevitably change into communism. He called this a revolution, but it's more in the sense that the industrial revolution was a revolution, an inevitable historical process which is called a revolution because it introduces radical change. Actual violent political revolutions are not inevitable processes, they are peculiar processes that don't have to happen, they can fail, and oddly enough even when successful they don't necessarily produce much change beyond who's in charge.

But capitalism doesn't turn into communism, ever. It is only non-capitalist countries which turn to communism. And it is never democratic, as Marx believed it would be.

In other words, Marx was fundamentally wrong about how history works.

You are right that people like Lenin and Mao decided to wage socialist revolutions in countries that were so far from the requirement of fully-developed industrial capitalism that it was impossible for them to fully succeed.

The US and other first world countries however are ready at this point.

Yeah, no. This is basically just the same sort of rationalization that cult members do when their prophet's predicted doomsday fails to materialize.
 
Last edited:
Biden is getting his booster shot. I bet there will be a lot of right-wing prayer on this one. ;)
 
Last edited:
When I was a small child I was extremely selfish, and jealous of people who had more than me. If that had been encouraged I might have become a raging capitalist. But then my brother arrived, and my mother insisted that we share everything equally (how unfair is that? I was 18 months older than him, and bigger and smarter, so I should have gotten more!). She also told me about Jesus and made me read the Bible - which was my first exposure to Communism.

I lapped it up. "The meek shall inherit the Earth", it said. "A rich man has less chance of getting into Heaven than a camel has of squeezing through the eye of a needle!". The righteous would ask "When did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink? And when did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you? And when did we see you sick or in prison and visit you?" And Jesus would reply "As you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.".

Yes, if it wasn't for that childhood indoctrination I might have kept my capitalist instincts and become rich beyond my wildest dreams, and not have had to deal with all this guilt!

But one thing puzzles me. Republicans are more likely to be strong believers in the 'literal' truth of the Bible, yet they are also more likely to embrace capitalist rather than communist ideas - exactly the opposite of what Jesus taught! Why is it that democrats - who profess to favor science and logic over religious dogma - are more open to sharing their wealth and caring for the less fortunate? It's a mystery for sure, and shows how little we know about how people are influenced by culture during early social development.
Christian (evangelical/Southern Baptist) doctrine, as I experienced it, had a strong undercurrent of greed. They merely channel it to "rewards in heaven" for the most part (so, like an investment with future returns). A long history of "prosperity doctrine/puritan work ethic" is baked in, at this point.
 
Lol, what? Marx and his contemporaries didn't think industrial capitalism would "evolve" into communism. That's impossible. A socialist revolution is necessary to eventually bring about communism. Marxism 101.



You are right that people like Lenin and Mao decided to wage socialist revolutions in countries that were so far from the requirement of fully-developed industrial capitalism that it was impossible for them to fully succeed.



The US and other first world countries however are ready at this point.
"Evolve" is probably not the right term.

But they produced a lot of literature saying political reforms would need to happen to "bring about the conditions necessary" for even further social reforms. They were echoing/expanding on similar themes from the French Revolution and the (largely unsuccessful) movements in mid-1800s across Europe, concluding those earlier examples all failed to take these next steps.
 
Biden is getting his booster shot. I bet there will be a lot of right-wing prayer on this one. ;)

Good thing the vaccines are safe.

Well, except for the cons, who will be wishing harm upon the President, in accordance with their religious beliefs.
 
Biden getting the Booster is an obvious trick to make Republicans refuse their first dose.
Clearly, Biden wouldn't do it to set a good example.
 
Lol, what? Marx and his contemporaries didn't think industrial capitalism would "evolve" into communism. That's impossible. A socialist revolution is necessary to eventually bring about communism. Marxism 101.

You are right that people like Lenin and Mao decided to wage socialist revolutions in countries that were so far from the requirement of fully-developed industrial capitalism that it was impossible for them to fully succeed.

The US and other first world countries however are ready at this point.

AH, the old "Communism is Wonderful Idea, only the right people have not tried it yet" theory.
 
Marxism is like a religion; the true beleivers are undettered by facts and evidence when it conflicts with the Word of Their All Wise, All Knowing Leader.
The Glorious People's Revolution is always just around the corner...like the Second Coming of Christ.
And the real kicker is that many Marxist consider themselves to be "rational thinkers".
 
Economic democracy. All private property (capital, land, etc.) will be commonly owned and managed by society as a whole.

Worker co-ops would be the norm, with businesses being democratically controlled and organized into larger workers councils with recallable delegates to help collectively decide on the economic direction of society.

So no one will be able to own their own home or their own farm or their own small business? That will really be popular.
Your system has been tried and failed time and time again.
And your view of Human Nature is ..well,,just plain wrong.
 
Despite their pretense, nothing about Marx and Engels is actually scientific. And history has proven them completely wrong. They thought industrial capitalism would evolve into communism. But the way communists actually gained power was through violent revolution in decidedly non-capitalist, often agrarian societies. They also couldn't conceive of the rapid growth of worker productivity in capitalist industrial societies which allowed an unprecedented increase in standard of living across the board, not just for the rich.

No, not across the board. Standards of living have been decreasing in the US for the last 40 years. Homelessness in the US is at an all time high.

And btw, almost nothing about how Communist nations were actually run is taken from Karl Marx's work.

Now, I don't think Marx was right, but there is little doubt unfettered Capitalism is a disaster for a substantial percentage of the population and workforce.
 
Because virtually all human societies haven't been hiarchial? You know, full of haves, have less, and have nots. Seems to me we have to teach our children to share, it doesn't seem to be innate.

ETA: And pretty much what Stacyhs said.

And no society has been more hiarchial then the countries where Marxsim has been tried. The Soviet Union, where the upper levels of the Party became basically a new aristoricacy is a good example. Same thing happened in CHina and every other "Marxist" country.
 
No, not across the board. Standards of living have been decreasing in the US for the last 40 years. Homelessness in the US is at an all time high.

And btw, almost nothing about how Communist nations were actually run is taken from Karl Marx's work.

Now, I don't think Marx was right, but there is little doubt unfettered Capitalism is a disaster for a substantial percentage of the population and workforce.

Question becomes if we are not going through another period of rapid economic change brought about by new technologies..in this case computers and other forms of AI....programmed machings replacing most assembly line workers, for instance.
Same as happened in the 19th Century Industrial Revolution..it took a long time for that to settle down also.
 
Question becomes if we are not going through another period of rapid economic change brought about by new technologies..in this case computers and other forms of AI....programmed machings replacing most assembly line workers, for instance.
Same as happened in the 19th Century Industrial Revolution..it took a long time for that to settle down also.

Of course we are. We have been in a steady transition from manufacturing and agriculture to service employment for the last 50 years. Computers have only added to that steady transition. But we don't pay service workers well and the GOP has managed to destroy the unions.

Capitalism with all its negatives has led to the greatest expansion of wealth that one could imagine. Capitalism is efficient. Marx said this in Das Kapital

But it at the same time it has led to the greatest division of wealth. And this is a problem.
 
Real problem I have with Marxism is in the end it's a Utopian system dedicated to building Paradise on Earth...a perfect society. It never happens because you can't build a perfect society with
imperfect people. And when in power, Utopians blame people for the failure of their schemes rather then reality, and often decide the way forward is to try to coerce people into being perfect through "social engineering" projects that often boils down to treating people like the dirt in an engineering project..to be moved around and thrown aside as necessary.
I give you Stalin's five year plans and Mao's Great Leap Forward as examples.
At best total failures, at worst murder machiines as bad as anything Hitler came up with.

From Each according to his ablity,to each according to his need will never work with Human Beings. The people with the ability, will get tired of sacricing evenrything to the people with needs.
 
Last edited:
Marxism is like a religion; the true beleivers are undettered by facts and evidence when it conflicts with the Word of Their All Wise, All Knowing Leader.
The Glorious People's Revolution is always just around the corner...like the Second Coming of Christ.
And the real kicker is that many Marxist consider themselves to be "rational thinkers".
That's probably true of Marxism.

The problem with Marxism often being it bares little resemblance to anything Marx ever wrote or said.
 
Real problem I have with Marxism is in the end it's a Utopian system dedicated to building Paradise on Earth...a perfect society. It never happens because you can't build a perfect society with
imperfect people. And when in power, Utopians blame people for the failure of their schemes rather then reality, and often decide the way forward is to try to coerce people into being perfect through "social engineering" projects that often boils down to treating people like the dirt in an engineering project..to be moved around and thrown aside as necessary.
I give you Stalin's five year plans and Mao's Great Leap Forward as examples.
At best total failures, at worst murder machiines as bad as anything Hitler came up with.

From Each according to his ablity,to each according to his need will never work with Human Beings. The people with the ability, will get tired of sacricing evenrything to the people with needs.

Yeah, but the reality is that we don't necessarily reward those with ability. Most wealth today is inherited and not created from scratch. Capitalism rewards ability, but mostly it rewards the offspring of ability.
 
And no society has been more hiarchial then the countries where Marxsim has been tried. The Soviet Union, where the upper levels of the Party became basically a new aristoricacy is a good example. Same thing happened in CHina and every other "Marxist" country.

True. That's because it goes against our nature. Once someone gets something, they want to hang onto it. And that goes for power, too. It's why people tend to get more conservative as they get older; they've got something they want to keep. Young people tend to be more idealistic because they haven't really accumulated anything of worth yet.

I was watching a program about abandoned buildings and they were showing the ruins of a once huge spa in the former Yugoslavia or Romania, I forget which. But it was built in secret because it was only open to the ruling Communist elite.

Communism is a lovely idea but so are flying unicorns.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom