Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, I'd prefer a system that at least tries to temper or mitigate our worst traits rather than embrace and amplify them.

There is no system of pure capitalism on this planet, because such a system would be pure hell. We live in a mixed system. What we're haggling over is that exact mix.
 
Sorry Boudicca I disagree.

There is no evidence that Communism outside of Kibbutz in Israel work. There are tons of issues associated with Capitalism, but the answer isn't a system that totally does away with self interest and markets.

Self-interest and markets would still exist under my proposed system.

You can't eliminate all self-interest, we aren't the Borg after all, but through democratic ownership of capital a consensus would need to be reached among the interests of everybody who controls that capital. Rather than one person or a board of directors calling the shots for everybody.

I also don't want to eliminate markets, since a centralized authority has no way to determine the wants and needs of an entire population successfully, as long as scarcity is still a factor anyway. Which is why councils would be formed for the needs of individual industries. Markets and competition would still exist to a certain degree, they just wouldn't be the make or break risk they are in a capitalist society since you wouldn't be alone in that initial investment.
 
There is no system of pure capitalism on this planet, because such a system would be pure hell. We live in a mixed system. What we're haggling over is that exact mix.

Yes exactly. I strongly feel that Capitalism and the rules of it should be reformed. But self interest is too strong a component of a good economic system to throw out. The problem with Capitalism today is that it is more aristocracy than meritocracy.

Far too many people's success is based on their heritage as opposed to work ethic or ingenuity.
 
The problem with capitalism is that it dehumanizes everyone.
Work just becomes an interchangeable good, people are expected to function like a machine.
The current solution is to carve out enough spare time for people to feel human in. But that is pretty wasteful, when half the time you do things that for the other half of the time you need to recover from.
 
SuburbanTurkey said:
Communism doesn't work because it goes against human nature: greedy, selfish, and personal survival.

As opposed to capitalism, which brings out humanity's better natures

Quip I saw from Soviet Russia: "Under capitalism, man exploits man. Communism is the reverse."

As SuburbanTurkey said, most countries are trying to determine the best mix. I'll add that there are both good and bad actors working on how to adjust the mix. The good ones want to extend the benefits of the system to as many as possible, while the bad ones want to grab as much as they can get away with. Unfortunately each plays by a different set of rules that seems to put the good ones at a disadvantage.
 
And waht, pary tell, would you replace Captialism with?

I didn't realize it was a binary world. Capitalism or socialism and nothing in between....


Nm.. I see you've clarified that you don't either.
 
Last edited:
To poke at a couple things in this discussion -

Communism doesn't work because it goes against human nature: greedy, selfish, and personal survival.

Greed, selfishness, and personal survival (at the expense of others) actually explicitly go against our nature.

Both of these are off. Human nature is a pretty complex subject, after all. To take this a little further -

You say that as if these qualities are mutually exclusive. They are not. Nor are we all the same, as you should well know. There are both angels and demons among us. A system designed for only angels will soon fall to the demons.

It might be much more accurate to say that we all have angels and demons within us. Very few people are solely "good" or "bad," and how people act frequently varies quite significantly based on the situation that they find themselves in. With that said, I'm of the camp that thinks that communism won't work (on a larger scale, at least, because immediate community bonds can be fairly powerful stabilizers) specifically because of the complexities of human nature - not even solely the obviously problematic parts like greed.

Of course communism and capitalism don't work. You need a combination of the two.

Quibble - actual communism is sufficiently different from the core from capitalism that "combination" is probably a bad way to put it. Compromise between the two should work, though.
 
As opposed to capitalism, which brings out humanity's better natures


Odd how you infer that from what I said. Saying that communism goes against human nature in no way means that capitalism brings out our 'better nature". One has zero to do with the other. However, unlike communism, capitalism play well with some of our worst nature: greed and selfishness. Greed and selfishness are often what make a successful capitalist.
 
Yeah, I'd prefer a system that at least tries to temper or mitigate our worst traits rather than embrace and amplify them.

So do I which is why I also said:

Nope, it feeds our nature because its essentially selfish and greedy. That's why it's been so successful and Communist countries fail unless propped up by capitalism. Even the Chinese are starting to understand that.

However, humans CAN be kind, gentle, and care about others. But they're certainly not our strongest traits. But that's why a combination of capitalism and socialism works best as seen in Canada and Northern European countries.
 
Yeah, I'd prefer a system that at least tries to temper or mitigate our worst traits rather than embrace and amplify them.

So do I which is why I also said:

Nope, it feeds our nature because its essentially selfish and greedy. That's why it's been so successful and Communist countries fail unless propped up by capitalism. Even the Chinese are starting to understand that.

However, humans CAN be kind, gentle, and care about others. But they're certainly not our strongest traits. But that's why a combination of capitalism and socialism works best as seen in Canada and Northern European countries.

Aridas, this is also in response to your post. Please note that I also said:

Wow. Zigg and I agree on something. It's a miracle!
 
So do I which is why I also said:







Aridas, this is also in response to your post. Please note that I also said:
I'm in agreement. I think most of us are saying similar things in different words, and so vague and brief (with dashes of tongue-in-cheek/satire spices) that confusion is rampant.

I think which traits come to the fore in a person (and by way of shared culture, society as well) is heavily influenced during early social development. Add in a layer of people exuding traits a culture reveres being more likely to produce offspring (and impart those same social values).

But this isn't the thread for a treatise on epigenetic theories, so I'll digress :9.
 
Aridas, this is also in response to your post. Please note that I also said:

Fair enough. When I wrote it, I admit to having assumed that you already understood that general principle anyways, though. However, I think that we may disagree a bit about the balance from your characterization, much as "it's complex and usually strongly related to the conditions at hand" probably works just fine on the topic of my opinion about what the balance is when it comes to the balance of more self-centered and not self-centered traits, rather than simply characterizing those not so self-centered traits as weaker.
 
I'm in agreement. I think most of us are saying similar things in different words, and so vague and brief (with dashes of tongue-in-cheek/satire spices) that confusion is rampant.

I think which traits come to the fore in a person (and by way of shared culture, society as well) is heavily influenced during early social development. Add in a layer of people exuding traits a culture reveres being more likely to produce offspring (and impart those same social values).

When I was a small child I was extremely selfish, and jealous of people who had more than me. If that had been encouraged I might have become a raging capitalist. But then my brother arrived, and my mother insisted that we share everything equally (how unfair is that? I was 18 months older than him, and bigger and smarter, so I should have gotten more!). She also told me about Jesus and made me read the Bible - which was my first exposure to Communism.

I lapped it up. "The meek shall inherit the Earth", it said. "A rich man has less chance of getting into Heaven than a camel has of squeezing through the eye of a needle!". The righteous would ask "When did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink? And when did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you? And when did we see you sick or in prison and visit you?" And Jesus would reply "As you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.".

Yes, if it wasn't for that childhood indoctrination I might have kept my capitalist instincts and become rich beyond my wildest dreams, and not have had to deal with all this guilt!

But one thing puzzles me. Republicans are more likely to be strong believers in the 'literal' truth of the Bible, yet they are also more likely to embrace capitalist rather than communist ideas - exactly the opposite of what Jesus taught! Why is it that democrats - who profess to favor science and logic over religious dogma - are more open to sharing their wealth and caring for the less fortunate? It's a mystery for sure, and shows how little we know about how people are influenced by culture during early social development.
 
When I was a small child I was extremely selfish, and jealous of people who had more than me. If that had been encouraged I might have become a raging capitalist. But then my brother arrived, and my mother insisted that we share everything equally (how unfair is that? I was 18 months older than him, and bigger and smarter, so I should have gotten more!). She also told me about Jesus and made me read the Bible - which was my first exposure to Communism.

I lapped it up. "The meek shall inherit the Earth", it said. "A rich man has less chance of getting into Heaven than a camel has of squeezing through the eye of a needle!". The righteous would ask "When did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink? And when did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you? And when did we see you sick or in prison and visit you?" And Jesus would reply "As you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.".

Yes, if it wasn't for that childhood indoctrination I might have kept my capitalist instincts and become rich beyond my wildest dreams, and not have had to deal with all this guilt!

But one thing puzzles me. Republicans are more likely to be strong believers in the 'literal' truth of the Bible, yet they are also more likely to embrace capitalist rather than communist ideas - exactly the opposite of what Jesus taught! Why is it that democrats - who profess to favor science and logic over religious dogma - are more open to sharing their wealth and caring for the less fortunate? It's a mystery for sure, and shows how little we know about how people are influenced by culture during early social development.

Good points and good questions, Roger R.

I'm also of the opinion that our personality traits are about 50-50 nature vs nurture. Like clay and play-doh, we can be shaped and molded but clay is never going to be play-doh and play-doh is never going to be clay.
 
I'm in agreement. I think most of us are saying similar things in different words, and so vague and brief (with dashes of tongue-in-cheek/satire spices) that confusion is rampant.

I think which traits come to the fore in a person (and by way of shared culture, society as well) is heavily influenced during early social development. Add in a layer of people exuding traits a culture reveres being more likely to produce offspring (and impart those same social values).

But this isn't the thread for a treatise on epigenetic theories, so I'll digress :9.

I agree, it's never entirely nature or nurture. We are all the sum total of our parts.
 
Are you positioning yourself with Manchin and Sinema? They are the ones ST is talking about.

Not strictly true. They often had more ammunition available than the army in remote locations and were using repeating rifles whereas the army stuck with single shot rifles.

Logistics did it though, being able to fortify on captured ground and effectively unlimited numbers of men to replace those lost is what decided it in the end as much as ammunition.
 
When I was a small child I was extremely selfish, and jealous of people who had more than me. If that had been encouraged I might have become a raging capitalist. But then my brother arrived, and my mother insisted that we share everything equally (how unfair is that? I was 18 months older than him, and bigger and smarter, so I should have gotten more!). She also told me about Jesus and made me read the Bible - which was my first exposure to Communism.

I lapped it up. "The meek shall inherit the Earth", it said. "A rich man has less chance of getting into Heaven than a camel has of squeezing through the eye of a needle!". The righteous would ask "When did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink? And when did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you? And when did we see you sick or in prison and visit you?" And Jesus would reply "As you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.".

Yes, if it wasn't for that childhood indoctrination I might have kept my capitalist instincts and become rich beyond my wildest dreams, and not have had to deal with all this guilt!

But one thing puzzles me. Republicans are more likely to be strong believers in the 'literal' truth of the Bible, yet they are also more likely to embrace capitalist rather than communist ideas - exactly the opposite of what Jesus taught! Why is it that democrats - who profess to favor science and logic over religious dogma - are more open to sharing their wealth and caring for the less fortunate? It's a mystery for sure, and shows how little we know about how people are influenced by culture during early social development.

I think you are onto something here.

Even though I'm an atheist, I was brought up much the same way as you, though I didn't have any siblings. My parents were Catholic and emphasized and made sure to practice Jesus's selfless and giving nature, rather than focus on sin and hellfire like other parents. And that's what I still basically believe in today, even if I don't believe in God or Jesus.

Marx and Engels in developing the concept of scientific socialism would often compare their beliefs to the utopian socialists who preceded them. Often the earlier utopian socialists were more influenced by religious beliefs like Christianity, but still had some good ideas that Marx would incorporate into his own work.
 
Marx and Engels in developing the concept of scientific socialism would often compare their beliefs to the utopian socialists who preceded them. Often the earlier utopian socialists were more influenced by religious beliefs like Christianity, but still had some good ideas that Marx would incorporate into his own work.

Despite their pretense, nothing about Marx and Engels is actually scientific. And history has proven them completely wrong. They thought industrial capitalism would evolve into communism. But the way communists actually gained power was through violent revolution in decidedly non-capitalist, often agrarian societies. They also couldn't conceive of the rapid growth of worker productivity in capitalist industrial societies which allowed an unprecedented increase in standard of living across the board, not just for the rich.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom