Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Most wealth today is inherited and not created from scratch. Capitalism rewards ability, but mostly it rewards the offspring of ability.

That may be true overall.

Still, I looked up the richest folks on the planet, and for the most part at those lofty heights it doesn’t hold.

51513253938_a6d370217a_z.jpg
 
Trump is going to be very unhappy as he's only #339 out of 400 in the US and only #1438 on the World's richest people. Maybe he can cheat and get his numbers up like he did before.
 
Yeah, but the reality is that we don't necessarily reward those with ability. Most wealth today is inherited and not created from scratch. Capitalism rewards ability, but mostly it rewards the offspring of ability.

It also doesn't reward those with the best innovations, ideas or work ethic. Much of the wealth goes to those who game the system or inherit from that system.
 
I don't quite buy that since Marx was wrong on so many things I don't think he is a reliable guide to much.
Uh, non sequitur.

Marx's views being right or wrong has nothing to do with whether people are accurately describing his views.

In fact Marx (and Engels, as well) derided many socialists as utopian.

ETA: Marx's impact is mostly as a sociologist more than political theorist. "Marxism" in fact, is not a prescription for a government model, but a form of socioeconomic analysis.

But Marx was popular in some circles and so people aspiring to power would say "we're Marxists" to borrow on his legacy.

Sorry to say, but you sound like you're regurgitating all kinds of decades-old tropes from the cold War that have little to nothing to do with the actual human person that existed.
 
Last edited:
That may be true overall.

Still, I looked up the richest folks on the planet, and for the most part at those lofty heights it doesn’t hold.

[qimg]https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51513253938_a6d370217a_z.jpg[/qimg]

The problem with the lists of the wealthiest individuals is that they are often very wrong. And out of curiosity don't you think the rewards of their abilities aren't really rewards for their abilities, but the people that work at Microsoft, Amazon, Tesla, Facebook, Apple, Oracle, Google etc?

Still, there are millions of heirs living off the wealth created by their great grandparents, grandparents, and parents. Here are just a few. I give you the Walmart clan.the Ford family, the Kennedys, the Vanderbilts, the Rockefellers, the Kochs, the Rothschilds

Oh, and did I forget President Trump and his children?
 
Perhaps I'm not making myself clear.

Marx thought capitalism would inevitably change into communism. He called this a revolution, but it's more in the sense that the industrial revolution was a revolution, an inevitable historical process which is called a revolution because it introduces radical change. Actual violent political revolutions are not inevitable processes, they are peculiar processes that don't have to happen, they can fail, and oddly enough even when successful they don't necessarily produce much change beyond who's in charge.

But capitalism doesn't turn into communism, ever. It is only non-capitalist countries which turn to communism. And it is never democratic, as Marx believed it would be.

In other words, Marx was fundamentally wrong about how history works.

No, he was very right. You act like the transition from feudalism to capitalism wasn't rocky as well.

Revolution doesn't have to be especially violent, and doesn't always refer to actual physical action. Throwing out our Constitution and ratifying a new one that emphasizes socialist ideals and goals would be a revolutionary act. And one I support.

He's also right that the conditions in society need to be right for any radical action to happen, which is why I work within mainstream politics despite my disgust in doing so sometimes.

"Evolve" is probably not the right term.

But they produced a lot of literature saying political reforms would need to happen to "bring about the conditions necessary" for even further social reforms. They were echoing/expanding on similar themes from the French Revolution and the (largely unsuccessful) movements in mid-1800s across Europe, concluding those earlier examples all failed to take these next steps.

Yep. Political revolution doesn't happen without social revolution, and vice-versa. If you can't get people to agree with you, no way you can get them to fight with you. That's why the main goal should be to move society farther and farther to the left, so people would be more amenable to agreement with socialist and communist views.
 
Last edited:
And out of curiosity don't you think the rewards of their abilities aren't really rewards for their abilities, but the people that work at Microsoft, Amazon, Tesla, Facebook, Apple, Oracle, Google etc?

I think my point, if I had a point, was that in at least the very top, it was not inherited wealth that led to or fostered their billions.
 
How was he right, if none of his predictions have ever come to pass?

This is pure cult member doomsday rationalization.

For once we agree.
I find the encless excuses Marxist have for the total failure of Marxism (which is different then other more moderate forms of Socialism) total failure whenever it has been tried.
THen there is the huge body count Marxism has managed to rack up....any system that produces people like Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot has got to be suspect.
And the whole "Ths state will wither away" theory is just plain laughable.
i repeat, Marxism is just like religion;In the ne it's based on total faith in a all knowing infalible
divine being (Marx) and his sacred scriptures.
 
It's odd to use a computer game series as a source of political wisdom, but the first two "Bioshock" games make the point about how both left and right extremes lead to a very bad place.
In the first game, the villian (for most of the game) is Andrew Ryan whose philosohy is based on that of Ayn Rand, and an attempt to create a real life "Galt's Gulch" under the sea leads to disaster, and in the second it's Sofia Lamb who thinks that any form of self interest and any attempt to improve one lot individually is evil,and also leads to disaster.
 
The problem with the lists of the wealthiest individuals is that they are often very wrong. And out of curiosity don't you think the rewards of their abilities aren't really rewards for their abilities, but the people that work at Microsoft, Amazon, Tesla, Facebook, Apple, Oracle, Google etc?

Still, there are millions of heirs living off the wealth created by their great grandparents, grandparents, and parents. Here are just a few. I give you the Walmart clan.the Ford family, the Kennedys, the Vanderbilts, the Rockefellers, the Kochs, the Rothschilds

Oh, and did I forget President Trump and his children?

Well not everyone can start a pizzeria in a gold Field and Charge gold for pie,
No Pizza Gate jokes now please.
 
I think my point, if I had a point, was that in at least the very top, it was not inherited wealth that led to or fostered their billions.

It's a good point.

I'm not saying that we shouldn't reward people for their abilities. We should.

But the system today is obscene and frankly is counterproductive. How the wealthy use their wealth is what makes it bad. The more income and wealth is amassed with fewer individuals the more the economy is geared towards that reality. Look at the business that thrive in our economy. Luxury items for the wealthy are manufactured instead of commodity items for the poor and middle class.
 
Uh, non sequitur.

Marx's views being right or wrong has nothing to do with whether people are accurately describing his views.

In fact Marx (and Engels, as well) derided many socialists as utopian.

ETA: Marx's impact is mostly as a sociologist more than political theorist. "Marxism" in fact, is not a prescription for a government model, but a form of socioeconomic analysis.

But Marx was popular in some circles and so people aspiring to power would say "we're Marxists" to borrow on his legacy.

Sorry to say, but you sound like you're regurgitating all kinds of decades-old tropes from the cold War that have little to nothing to do with the actual human person that existed.

This is pretty accurate.

The utopian socialists who preceded them like Saint-Simon, Fourier, and Owen were considered by Marx and Engels to have the right basic concept, but they were utopian in their thinking that we can all just put our differences aside and come together for the common good.

The scientific socialists knew based on historical materialism that the ruling class never gives up their power easily, and therefore to achieve socialism, the bourgeoisie need to be supplanted and suppressed by the proletariat.

And yep, I ended up learning the most about Marxism initially in my sociology studies, where he is considered much more influential. Much like with many other Millennials, Gen Z, and whatever the current young generation is called I had an affinity for the concept of socialism growing up. And we also didn't have the Cold War propaganda of previous generations brainwashing us into believing that socialism and communism is evil.

My generation has grown up in a world that is rapidly falling apart and we see older generations doing nothing to stop it. The system I grew up believing in, and enlisted to protect, has failed us. We realize that radical action is needed.
 
Please return to discussing the Biden Presidency. If you want to discuss, compare or analyse economic systems, please do so in an appropriate thread.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
From notable far-left rag The Atlantic:

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/09/democrats-free-pass-on-immigration-is-over/620208/

Democrats’ Free Pass on Immigration Is Over
As he extends Trump-era policies, President Biden discovers that many voters are no longer willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.


Up until recently, the Biden administration seemed to have been banking on the persistence of this double standard, whereby the left-leaning parts of the public assume general goodwill on the part of Democratic politicians and therefore give them a pass. The administration has taken up court battles to protect some of Trump’s harshest asylum policies and commenced flying multiple planeloads of migrants back to Haiti. Now-viral images show that, in recent days, Border Patrol agents have been charging at—and in some cases verbally assaulting—Haitian migrants marooned at the Mexican border across from Del Rio, Texas.

But the assumption that these tactics would go unchallenged when deployed by a Democratic administration, as was often the case in the past, appears to have been a serious miscalculation. The spotlight that Trump shined on the southern border for four years is still plugged in. The public is still paying attention. And images that evoke the era of slavery—with fair-skinned men on horseback rushing Black migrants, whiplike reins flailing behind them—have added to a long-simmering push from the left to consider immigration policy not simply in terms of economics or national security, but also in terms of race.
 
No, not across the board. Standards of living have been decreasing in the US for the last 40 years. Homelessness in the US is at an all time high.

Feature of capitalism, look how much more wealth billionaires have than they did 40 years ago. The system works exactly as designed. You have to understand that this isn't a bug in capitalism but a feature. We should be celebrating this as good capitalists.
 
The problem with the lists of the wealthiest individuals is that they are often very wrong. And out of curiosity don't you think the rewards of their abilities aren't really rewards for their abilities, but the people that work at Microsoft, Amazon, Tesla, Facebook, Apple, Oracle, Google etc?

Still, there are millions of heirs living off the wealth created by their great grandparents, grandparents, and parents. Here are just a few. I give you the Walmart clan.the Ford family, the Kennedys, the Vanderbilts, the Rockefellers, the Kochs, the Rothschilds

Oh, and did I forget President Trump and his children?

And of course those "self made" billionares are not exactly starting off in low ecconomic status either. They have the family wealth to start their businesses, even if that was not in the .01% wealth it was certainly in the top 5%.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom