Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
The democratic socialism model of northern European countries seems to be working out well enough for them, we could use a bit of that. That doesn't seem like the kind of shift that should really require the complete collapse of capitalism to reach, but every time elements of it are proposed (like universal health care) we're informed that the uber-wealthy running the country will see it all collapse before they part with a single red cent. Sooner or later we're going to have to call their bluff.

Good answer. I’d be on board with Capitalism, tempered with socialism where it makes sense, and other rational safeguards to avoid massive income inequality and monopolies. I think fine tuning what we have can and will head us in that direction without a collapse.
 
I think fine tuning what we have can and will head us in that direction without a collapse.
That's the problem, we can't fine tune. We can't rein in corporate overreach or even malfeasance, they're all Too Big To Fail now. You can go look in the "rich get richer" thread to see arguments that we cannot possibly levy any tax on wealth or the wealthy will cripple the economy and kick a puppy on their way out of the country. We can't even agree to fund the government we have without a doomsday clock ticking down at the end of every fiscal year. Any attempts to make any improvements or even suggest such are met by using the economy as a human shield with a gun to its temple. You don't fine tune a hostage situation.
 
Good answer. I’d be on board with Capitalism, tempered with socialism where it makes sense, and other rational safeguards to avoid massive income inequality and monopolies. I think fine tuning what we have can and will head us in that direction without a collapse.

THIS.
The problem with those who want to go all the way to A "Government controls everything and replaces market forces with government oroders" is that that system has proven a miderable failure when tried. A mixed system is much more viable.
 
That's the problem, we can't fine tune. We can't rein in corporate overreach or even malfeasance, they're all Too Big To Fail now. You can go look in the "rich get richer" thread to see arguments that we cannot possibly levy any tax on wealth or the wealthy will cripple the economy and kick a puppy on their way out of the country. We can't even agree to fund the government we have without a doomsday clock ticking down at the end of every fiscal year. Any attempts to make any improvements or even suggest such are met by using the economy as a human shield with a gun to its temple. You don't fine tune a hostage situation.

And your solution is......
 
...and their party desperately needs; for Democrats, getting nothing done is a sure way to get people not to bother voting for you. (At least this time, finally being seen at least trying for once might help, but not as much as success would.)

...not that I believe they really care about the party they claim to be in but routinely work against just like a Republican plant would...

Oh definitely. Even though getting nothing done has been how the Dems have operated for a long time, coasting on their motto of "At least we aren't the party of Trump!" and throwing some crumbs our way from time to time.

I don't think it matters too much how sincere they are, as long as we get results. I try not to let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
 
And your solution is......

Economic democracy. All private property (capital, land, etc.) will be commonly owned and managed by society as a whole.

Worker co-ops would be the norm, with businesses being democratically controlled and organized into larger workers councils with recallable delegates to help collectively decide on the economic direction of society.
 
Economic democracy. All private property (capital, land, etc.) will be commonly owned and managed by society as a whole.

Worker co-ops would be the norm, with businesses being democratically controlled and organized into larger workers councils with recallable delegates to help collectively decide on the economic direction of society.

You can call communism by a different name, but that won't make it work.
 
Communism doesn't work because it goes against human nature: greedy, selfish, and personal survival.

You certainly have an extremely low opinion of humanity.

Homo sapiens are a social and communal species by nature. Greed, selfishness, and personal survival (at the expense of others) actually explicitly go against our nature.

Capitalism goes against the natural order of our species.
 
You certainly have an extremely low opinion of humanity.

It is borne out by experience.

Homo sapiens are a social and communal species by nature. Greed, selfishness, and personal survival (at the expense of others) actually explicitly go against our nature.

You say that as if these qualities are mutually exclusive. They are not. Nor are we all the same, as you should well know. There are both angels and demons among us. A system designed for only angels will soon fall to the demons.

Capitalism goes against the natural order of our species.

The concept of ownership is quite primal. Even infants seem to have it. All you need for capitalism is ownership plus freedom to exchange with others. If you think freedom to exchange with others is against our natural order, I think you are the one who has the lower opinion of human nature.
 
You certainly have an extremely low opinion of humanity.

Yep. Sixty-seven years watching humanity kill each other over the stupidest things, lie, cheat, and steal.

Homo sapiens are a social and communal species by nature. Greed, selfishness, and personal survival (at the expense of others) actually explicitly go against our nature.

LOL! Yep, we're so social and communal by nature that our entire history consists of killing each other over the most trivial of things. Lying, cheating, stealing to get what we want.

Why do you think we have laws? HINT: Because we need negative consequences to help control our natural inclinations. And even then, they only help.

Capitalism goes against the natural order of our species.

Nope, it feeds our nature because its essentially selfish and greedy. That's why it's been so successful and Communist countries fail unless propped up by capitalism. Even the Chinese are starting to understand that.

However, humans CAN be kind, gentle, and care about others. But they're certainly not our strongest traits. But that's why a combination of capitalism and socialism works best as seen in Canada and Northern European countries.

ETA: Wow. Zigg and I agree on something. It's a miracle!
 
Last edited:
You certainly have an extremely low opinion of humanity.

Homo sapiens are a social and communal species by nature. Greed, selfishness, and personal survival (at the expense of others) actually explicitly go against our nature.

Capitalism goes against the natural order of our species.

Because virtually all human societies haven't been hiarchial? You know, full of haves, have less, and have nots. Seems to me we have to teach our children to share, it doesn't seem to be innate.

ETA: And pretty much what Stacyhs said.
 
Last edited:
Communism doesn't work because it goes against human nature: greedy, selfish, and personal survival.

You certainly have an extremely low opinion of humanity.

Homo sapiens are a social and communal species by nature. Greed, selfishness, and personal survival (at the expense of others) actually explicitly go against our nature.

Capitalism goes against the natural order of our species.

Sorry Boudicca I disagree.

There is no evidence that Communism outside of Kibbutz in Israel work. There are tons of issues associated with Capitalism, but the answer isn't a system that totally does away with self interest and markets.
 
Sorry Boudicca I disagree.

There is no evidence that Communism outside of Kibbutz in Israel work. There are tons of issues associated with Capitalism, but the answer isn't a system that totally does away with self interest and markets.

I said earlier it only works in small communities where people know each other on a personal level and have an immediate, personal benefit from working together. Kibbutzes are a good example.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom