Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think my point, if I had a point, was that in at least the very top, it was not inherited wealth that led to or fostered their billions.

It certainly did foster their billions. Elon Musk father made a mint off apartheid, have him access to all the best schools. Bezo's parents had the $250,000 to risk on their kids crazy online book store.

These are not people who came from nothing.
 
Some TV journalists are making fun of democrats not passing stuff. After all, the GOP passed...er...one bill in 2 years. But they were unified! The problem is that even though Dems are in power, 2 of them are essentially Republicans.

The progressive democrats somehow think two bills will pass. The "radical" bills that are in fact the Biden infrastructure plan.
 
Some TV journalists are making fun of democrats not passing stuff. After all, the GOP passed...er...one bill in 2 years. But they were unified! The problem is that even though Dems are in power, 2 of them are essentially Republicans.

The progressive democrats somehow think two bills will pass. The "radical" bills that are in fact the Biden infrastructure plan.

The problem is that perpetuating the meme that government is ineffectual and powerless to actually improve material conditions for ordinary people is beneficial to the conservative political project and corrosive to the liberal project.

If the Democratic party is going to run as a meaningful alternative to right wing rule, they need to actually demonstrate that government, with the right leaders, is actually a useful social project that people should care about.

Rumors are coming out that there are talks of neutering Biden's infrastructure bill with the patented liberal means testing in order to appease the austerity hawks. If there's one thing the public loves, it's being tasked with being amateur bureaucrats in order to access social services.

Sources tell me that White House and Democrats considering attaching means test to a number of key agenda items - from EV rebates and free community college - as a way to shrink reconciliation bill and pacify spending hawks.

https://twitter.com/JarrettRenshaw/status/1442538588441354243

The problem is that while Democrats are very good at telling the public that better government is possible, they routinely fail to actually show that better government is possible.
 
That's true. The Finns I talk to or post with, in America make fun of American social programs. The working class/middle class people who are used to some of this support. "What good are free school lunches if you don't give it to all the people?"
 
Yelling just said that all the expedients that she can use to delay the effects of the default will be exhausted by Oct 18th. Then disaster will happen.
Techinically the Government will shut down on Friday because the FY 2021 runs out that day.
You could see some stop gap spending measure to keep it open,,,which is what has happened in the past,but that does not seem to be in the cards this year.
 
Very odd strategy by the Republicans: vote against the debt ceiling thing while talking about how vital it is to pass it and how bad the Democrats are for not outvoting your votes against it.
 
Last edited:
Very odd strategy by the Republicans: vote against the debt ceiling thing while talking about how vital it is to pass it and how bad the Democrats are for not outvoting your votes against it.
It's not new, they've been doing it since Reagan. This is from 2006:

 
Meanwhile, in the real world, it's becoming increasingly obvious who's responsible for gridlocking the legislative system and engaging in financial brinksmanship. Much to the chagrin of a certain pundit class, it ain't the progressives screwing things up, but rather a handful of their beloved "moderates".

Manchin, Sinema leave Dems in lurch as Biden agenda teeters
The two moderate Democrats continue to frustrate members of their party, offering few specifics on what they would support in a broad spending bill.



Democrats wanted clarity Tuesday from Sens. Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema after back-to-back meetings with President Joe Biden. They didn’t get it.

During a private meeting with the president, Sinema made clear she’s still not on board with the party’s $3.5 trillion social spending plan and is hesitant to engage on some specifics until the bipartisan infrastructure package passes the House, according to a person who spoke with her.

“This is the third time she said she has told the president, 'I’m not there,'” the person said, quoting Sinema as telling the president: “‘I’ve been very clear with you from the start.’”

Sinema has problems with both the price tag and some of the tax increases devised to pay for it. After returning from his White House meeting, Manchin said that he did not give Biden a top-line number and made “no commitments from my standpoint.”

Sinema and Manchin’s approach to the negotiations has frozen Biden’s jobs and families plan and potentially may lead to a high-profile failure of a bipartisan infrastructure bill on the House floor as progressives threaten rebellion. But without more details from the moderate duo, any hope of a bicameral agreement on Biden’s agenda is a pipe dream.

https://www.politico.com/news/2021/09/28/manchin-sinema-dems-biden-514574

I wonder how much of this is simply a messaging problem for the Democratic party. With the 2020 electoral win, all these stories were going around about how the liberals held a thin ruling majority, but really that's not the case. When you take into account conservative rouges like Sinema and Manchin, more often than not the party lacks the numbers to enact their policy agenda.

ETA: Lol

it's amazing that sinema and manchin have no specific criticism of the bill and no preferred alternatives and are left just kind of saying they aren't vibing with it so nobody really knows what to do

https://twitter.com/MattBruenig/status/1443011477418414082

It's kinda wild that there was a 420-9 vote to give Israel a billion dollars they don't really need, but it's an open question whether or not we should continue to fund our own government or if investing in our own infrastructure is "fiscally responsible" to ghouls like manchin or sinema.
 
Last edited:
The whole system by which congress operates in archaic and updated.
Roberts of "Roberts Rules Of Order" would be horrified by the mockety of parliamentary procedure the US Congress has begun.
 
The whole system by which congress operates in archaic and updated.
Roberts of "Roberts Rules Of Order" would be horrified by the mockety of parliamentary procedure the US Congress has begun.

To be honest, the whole idea of a separate legislature and executive with their own election cycles is pretty stupid, unless the goal was to have frequent deadlocked government.

The parliamentary system with a prime minister, with snap elections as an option to settle contentious matters, is much better in this specific regard.
 
To be honest, the whole idea of a separate legislature and executive with their own election cycles is pretty stupid, unless the goal was to have frequent deadlocked government.

The parliamentary system with a prime minister, with snap elections as an option to settle contentious matters, is much better in this specific regard.
It is very similar to some points in the Roman Republic. The "check" on power was other officials using their veto and term limits on executive offices. This was meant to prevent tyranny, but more often enabled it by preventing needed solutions to a status quo of gross inequality. The only counter was more vetos on ever more basic functions of government (opening the courts, allowing the treasury to conduct business, etc) in an ever-growing game of brinksmanship and dysfunction.

The Conflict of the Orders, the Gracchi and land reform, then you get to Marius, Sulla, and others being granted extraordinary purview because various crises brought popular pressure for some kind of resolution, any kind of resolution, to bear. Seeing this, it became understood that engineering a crisis could catapult one into power once the resentment gets high enough.

It's like a highly tuned, incredibly balanced, specifically timed, tight tolerance engine...with one glaring omission. There's not a single pressure relief valve (executive action vs. a vote of no confidence serving as a reset button).

Neither are perfect analogies, of course. But the same basic idea of detesting "bold, unilateral action" eventually leads to the system breaking itself apart because sometimes that really does have to happen.
 
S&M apparently haven't even said what they want, which is not the behavior of people who will soon be negotiating to take out some provisions and leave the rest intact at 2.2 trillion or something like that. That's the behavior of people who just want to prove that they're in control.

Otherwise, I'd say the rest of the party who aren't such far-right extremists should just give them whatever it takes to pass at least half of the thing (even though it's already what they agreed to before after the last time they already got it cut in half for them). As it is, though, they should just do the vote on it in whatever form is available, force S&M to show their colors, and then prepare for campaigns based on "there just weren't enough of us, but we tried; send more of us and it'll work next time".

I don't believe the criticisms of S&M from other Democrats are a good idea, though; it's less likely to get them to change their position than to get them to change their party affiliation and make McConnell the majority leader again.
 
The problem with the lists of the wealthiest individuals is that they are often very wrong. And out of curiosity don't you think the rewards of their abilities aren't really rewards for their abilities, but the people that work at Microsoft, Amazon, Tesla, Facebook, Apple, Oracle, Google etc?

Of course. And the failure of Theranos wasn't due to the visionary guidance of those at the top. It was the fault of all those employees who did what they were hired to do, as best they could. /s
 
Last edited:
To be honest, the whole idea of a separate legislature and executive with their own election cycles is pretty stupid, unless the goal was to have frequent deadlocked government.
Feature, not bug.

The parliamentary system with a prime minister, with snap elections as an option to settle contentious matters, is much better in this specific regard.
Brexit has entered the chat.
 
S&M apparently haven't even said what they want, which is not the behavior of people who will soon be negotiating to take out some provisions and leave the rest intact at 2.2 trillion or something like that. That's the behavior of people who just want to prove that they're in control.

Otherwise, I'd say the rest of the party who aren't such far-right extremists should just give them whatever it takes to pass at least half of the thing (even though it's already what they agreed to before after the last time they already got it cut in half for them). As it is, though, they should just do the vote on it in whatever form is available, force S&M to show their colors, and then prepare for campaigns based on "there just weren't enough of us, but we tried; send more of us and it'll work next time".

I don't believe the criticisms of S&M from other Democrats are a good idea, though; it's less likely to get them to change their position than to get them to change their party affiliation and make McConnell the majority leader again.
The problem with that is that is: can Democrats deliver a Republican style of governance, make a celebration of it at the signing ceremony, and expect liberal voters to reward them at the polls.

We'll run into that classic mid-term doldrums of voters bitter that sweeping their party into power "changed not a god damned thing."
 
This bill is big enough that even with significant reductions it would still not be more of the usual Republicanism.
 
Feature, not bug.


Brexit has entered the chat.

I never claimed that a parliamentary system was immune to doing stupid things.

The fact that something as complicated and controversial as Brexit was actually able to happen is a testament to the functional nature of the parliamentary system. I don't blame that system for Brexit, I blame the weirdo reactionary movement in Britain that made the call for it popular enough to seize the necessary political power. The brits got exactly what they wanted (and hard), which is how democratic systems are supposed to work.

A similar action in the US probably would have had 5 debt ceiling crisis and 2 impeachments by now or something equally stupid.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom