Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
2500 US lives, lol. People really forget what a real war looks like, it seems. We've lost WAY more than that in a day, due to COVID.

Anyway, sure. Whatever you want to believe. :thumbsup:

Or kill an appropriate number of them. "Occupy" would not be the goal, if we were serious.

Completely OT, at this point. I stick by my statements.

I disagree. Especially if it involves free land. This whole thing would make a good topic, tbh. Sort of an "alternate reality" scenario. Entertaining.

Not the way I write the story, you wouldn't. ;)

 
Sure you could. You would have to make it worth their while. I'm sure Afghanistan has minerals that are worth a lot of money. Get rid of the indigenous tribes and somebody could get rich.

I knew getting rid of smallpox would come back to haunt us.
 
Sigh. I said we had never colonized a Muslim nation; I did not say we were not capable of doing so. I did say that no one had ever been successful in invading Afghanistan and changing their inherent way of life. That is historical fact. Colonizing a nation is not the same thing as changing their inherent way of life, customs, and belief. Sometimes it does but I've yet to see a Muslim country colonized by a non-Muslim country and turned into a stable democracy. Can you name one?

Well people would make that argument for Israel.
 
Ah...you see the Confederates as rebelling against an "oppressive force" do you? Interesting and revealing.
It does sort of match. The oppressive force was, essentially, the unrealized threat that the growing majority of those opposed to slavery would at some future time over-ride the minority and abolish slavery as the Northern population grew and the ability of the slave states to control territorial expansion weakened. The current R. issue seems to be similar - calling for rebellion on the grounds that unless the evolution of the electorate is interrupted their minority policies will no longer rule the nation. The Confederate rebellion was one of anti-democratic hatred, and that's what its symbol will always represent.
 
You wouldn't be able to find Americans willing to live there.
Of course, we could forcefully relocate them in good old Soviet style.


There was a recurring MadTV sketch featuring a 1950s science fiction serial set decades in the future. One of the characters was black (and never allowed to actually deliver any lines), and it was frequently mentioned that he was from the Separate But Equal Continent of Antarctica. I'm sure something similar could be done with Afghanistan and various "undesirables".
 
Is this where I am supposed to shout "Godwinning!"?

I'm not endorsing such behavior, just saying it is feasible to install a Democracy in Afghanistan, if not for current societal limitations.

Saying it's possible but only with mass murder isn't a useful rebuttal to saying it's not really an option. Yes, technically it is possible if we kill enough people. Now that the obvious is stated, what would you have anyone do with that information?
 
Not the way I write the story, you wouldn't. ;)
But you don't get to write the "story".

800 years spent in my country trying to throw off the yoke of the British. 800 years.

That fervour never ceased for 800 years until we won. and the Great British Empire had to back down.

The only way your ideas would work is if you took all the natives and wiped them out. All of them. And it seems to be what you are advocating.
 
But you don't get to write the "story".

800 years spent in my country trying to throw off the yoke of the British. 800 years.

That fervour never ceased for 800 years until we won. and the Great British Empire had to back down.

The only way your ideas would work is if you took all the natives and wiped them out. All of them. And it seems to be what you are advocating.

We would have to conquer a city in Afganistan, and bring in a great number of Americans to settle. Try to take over the entire country in this way would be difficult, even if conservatives had their way and deported the natives for being 'illegals'.

Though if my experience is to judge, the captured cities would lose loyalty quickly, and flip back to Afghanistan, or a neighboring country.
 
The idea that a firmer hand would have lead to different result is ahistorical.

The Soviets failed in their occupation and they committed all the war crimes even the most ghoulish war hawks could ask for, and more. It was a gloves-off bloodbath, old-fashioned imperialism and they still failed.
 
Last edited:

Nope. Learn your history. Muslim Spain was re-conquered by Christian monarchies between the 13th and 15th centuries. Muslims were driven into the southern part of Spain (Granada) where they were finally defeated in 1492 by Isabella, Queen of Castile and her husband Ferdinand, King of Aragon. Ten years later, Muslims were either forced to convert to Christianity or live only in one small area of Spain. In the next 100 years, almost all Muslims had either left or converted (or had pretended to convert) and Islam was forbidden in any area of Spain. By the beginning of the 17th century, virtually no Muslims remained in Spain. Spain remained a monarchy until the 20th century. In no way was Spain, as a MUSLIM country, ever governed by a democracy. Spain is not an example.
 
Nope. Learn your history. Muslim Spain was re-conquered by Christian monarchies between the 13th and 15th centuries. Muslims were driven into the southern part of Spain (Granada) where they were finally defeated in 1492 by Isabella, Queen of Castile and her husband Ferdinand, King of Aragon. Ten years later, Muslims were either forced to convert to Christianity or live only in one small area of Spain. In the next 100 years, almost all Muslims had either left or converted (or had pretended to convert) and Islam was forbidden in any area of Spain. By the beginning of the 17th century, virtually no Muslims remained in Spain. Spain remained a monarchy until the 20th century. In no way was Spain, as a MUSLIM country, ever governed by a democracy. Spain is not an example.

I thought it was more about how the inquisition treated Muslims and Jews was what was needed in Afghanistan. A few centuries of forced conversions to Catholicism under threat of torture and then maybe they can be ready.
 
In no way was Spain, as a MUSLIM country, ever governed by a democracy.

You moved the goalpost. That wasn't actually what you asked. You asked,

I've yet to see a Muslim country colonized by a non-Muslim country and turned into a stable democracy. Can you name one?

You didn't say it had to remain a Muslim country. That's a new condition which wasn't part of your original question. That condition may be relevant to what can be done in Afghanistan today, but you still didn't ask about that in your original question.
 
Well people would make that argument for Israel.

They'd be wrong. Israel was never a Muslim country. It has been officially a Jewish State since its creation. Therefore, it does not qualify as a MUSLIM country in which a colonizer successfully created a democratic government.
 
Nope. Learn your history. Muslim Spain was re-conquered by Christian monarchies between the 13th and 15th centuries. Muslims were driven into the southern part of Spain (Granada) where they were finally defeated in 1492 by Isabella, Queen of Castile and her husband Ferdinand, King of Aragon. Ten years later, Muslims were either forced to convert to Christianity or live only in one small area of Spain. In the next 100 years, almost all Muslims had either left or converted (or had pretended to convert) and Islam was forbidden in any area of Spain. By the beginning of the 17th century, virtually no Muslims remained in Spain. Spain remained a monarchy until the 20th century. In no way was Spain, as a MUSLIM country, ever governed by a democracy. Spain is not an example.


There is a lot of debate about how big a Muslim population was ever in Spain.
There is evidence that most people in Muslim controlled Spain remained Christian. They had to pay a special tax but otherwise were pretty much left alone. Same situation as occured in Ottoman occupied Eastern Europe later.
And to makes matters more fun, one reason why the Reconquista took so long was that the Christians fough among themselves constantly, and some Christian nobles had no hesistation about adapting Muslim allies against their Christian enemies. Of course,things were no better on the Muslim side.their nobles fought among themselves constantly also.
El Cid spent most of his career fighting as a Mercenary for Muslims against other Muslims. SOmething that the movie had happening off screen.
Great movie, questinable history.
 
I see the Dems are back to forming circluler firing squads.....something they are , sadly, very good at.
Apparently funds for Israel's Iron dome is holding up the whole budget process.....
 
I see the Dems are back to forming circluler firing squads.....something they are , sadly, very good at.
Apparently funds for Israel's Iron dome is holding up the whole budget process.....

Aaash Israel. The gift that keeps on giving. We should have never recognized it as a State.
 
They'd be wrong. Israel was never a Muslim country. It has been officially a Jewish State since its creation. Therefore, it does not qualify as a MUSLIM country in which a colonizer successfully created a democratic government.

Got it, we just need to rename Afghanistan to something else that would be a properly Christian state and just have basic forced conversion. That is how you get democracy.

But I guess you are right about Israel it is a Jewish state and not a democracy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom