Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, it is too late. I'm not in favor of "destroying the Zionist Entity" either.

Let's just say that the 1947 decision has been a disaster ever since it was made. It has been followed by one foreign policy debacle after another. This is all about religion. It's about stupid Muslims fighting stupid Jews who are aided by stupid Christians helping Israel to bring about Armageddon.

Christopher Hitchens was right. Religion poisons everything.

I wrote my dissertation on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Religion is just the window dressing, not for once the cause..
 
maybe, but I think you will agree that before we invaded after 911, Afghanistan was the main base of operations and HQ of Al Qaeda. I hope it doesn't return to that.

I'm not sure that it was. However let's say that was. That was two decades ago when Al Qaeda was very different than it is today. It was loosely run by Osama bin Laden who was driven out of Afghanistan almost twenty years ago and operated out of Pakistan. And is dead now.

It also should be noted that not a single terrorist hijacker on 9-11 was from Afghanistan. They were almost all from Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Yemen. Many lived and trained in the United States.

It just seems to me that occupying Kabul and Kandahar does little to prevent terrorism since there are lots of places these people can and do set up shop.

I also want to compliment you. You're thoughtful and reasonable. It's refreshing to have an intelligent discussion that doesn't involve obstinacy.
 
I wrote my dissertation on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Religion is just the window dressing, not for once the cause..

I'd love to read it. But at the moment. I don't necessarily agree with that conclusion. I believe it is what it is always about...money and power. But religion is the framework and how the state actions are sold.
 
Let's move this discussion to the dedicated Israel Palestine thread before the mods do it for us.....
 
I wrote my dissertation on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Religion is just the window dressing, not for once the cause..
Once, when asked what the role of religious Jews would be in his projected Jewish nation state, Herzl rather chillingly replied "We shall know how to keep them in their synagogues". And he said it in German, so it probably sounded even more chilling.
 
I'm not sure that it was. However let's say that was. That was two decades ago when Al Qaeda was very different than it is today.

Well, I was around two decades ago and if you asked anyone back then, they would have said they thought Al Qaeda HQ was in Afghanistan. Pretty sure that is what the CIA and other intelligence services thought as well.


It was loosely run by Osama bin Laden who was driven out of Afghanistan almost twenty years ago and operated out of Pakistan. And is dead now.
do we know for certain when Bin Laden left Afghanistan. Maybe it had something to do with the US forces coming into Afghanistan?

It also should be noted that not a single terrorist hijacker on 9-11 was from Afghanistan. They were almost all from Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Yemen. Many lived and trained in the United States.
True, but the people that planned, and ordered the attack were in Afghanistan. Certainly, their leader was, until he left for Pakistan.

It just seems to me that occupying Kabul and Kandahar does little to prevent terrorism since there are lots of places these people can and do set up shop.

Maybe, but Al Qaeda isn't anything like it was before we got to Afghanistan. I hope it doesn't grow back.


I also want to compliment you. You're thoughtful and reasonable. It's refreshing to have an intelligent discussion that doesn't involve obstinacy.

thanks!

Thanks also for debating me with evidence, facts, and logic and not going the personal attack route. It seems to many these days like to go down the path of Ad Hominem. I have been the victim of that on many other forums.
 
SOrry I ever brough the Iron Dome topic up. I wanted to show a very minor issue is bringing the US to the edge of economic Catastrophe, but I should have seen it would become another Israeli/Palestinian dust up.
 
do we know for certain when Bin Laden left Afghanistan. Maybe it had something to do with the US forces coming into Afghanistan?
It absolutely did.

According to one of his wives, bin Laden was reunited with his family for first time after the 9/11 attacks in the second half of 2002 in Peshawar, the capital city of the Tribal Areas, where they lived for five months in another safe house.[7] After this, in September 2002, bin Laden took his family into the rural mountain areas of northwest Pakistan (and very notably, not in the tribal belt where main US attention was focused.) First they stayed in the Shangla district in the Swat valley, where they stayed in two safe houses for eight to nine months. In May 2003, bin Laden and his family moved to Haripur, a small town close to Islamabad, where they stayed in a rented house for two years. In June 2005, bin Laden and his family moved to Abbottabad.

True, but the people that planned, and ordered the attack were in Afghanistan. Certainly, their leader was, until he left for Pakistan.

Yes,

Maybe, but Al Qaeda isn't anything like it was before we got to Afghanistan. I hope it doesn't grow back.
Me too, but I think terrorists can and do set up their HQ in pretty much any nation.
 
I'm not sure that it was. However let's say that was. That was two decades ago when Al Qaeda was very different than it is today. It was loosely run by Osama bin Laden who was driven out of Afghanistan almost twenty years ago and operated out of Pakistan. And is dead now.

It also should be noted that not a single terrorist hijacker on 9-11 was from Afghanistan. They were almost all from Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Yemen. Many lived and trained in the United States.

It just seems to me that occupying Kabul and Kandahar does little to prevent terrorism since there are lots of places these people can and do set up shop.

I also want to compliment you. You're thoughtful and reasonable. It's refreshing to have an intelligent discussion that doesn't involve obstinacy.

I'll second that!
 
The only way your ideas would work is if you took all the natives and wiped them out. All of them.
That's not accurate. Historically, it's quite common for people who survive an invasion to adopt much or all of the invaders' culture. France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, and Romania are full of descendants of non-Romans who speak modern versions of Latin and participate in a modern version of the Romans' religion (imposed on even the Romans by a past Emperor). Britain & Ireland are full of descendants of Celts who speak English (and have fought over which version of the Romans' religion they should follow). Africa has numerous communities that aren't descended from the Bantu but speak Bantu languages after getting overrun in the Bantu Expansion. Iran still speaks its own language but writes it in a past invader's alphabet and follows that same invader's religion. China was originally at least a half-dozen different major entities which became one only by conquest a few millennia ago. Prehistorically, when farming cultures have invaded areas previously populated by hunters & gatherers, the population afterward sometimes remains genetically the same afterward but always ends up as farmers. Afghanistan is another example; the dominant religion and most common languages were brought in by Iran and have stuck since then even though Iran is out now. I'm sure there are examples that don't work like this (and Afghanistan is an example on that side too, since they don't retain the cultural fingerprints of their other past conquerors like the Mongolians or the Greeks or the Yuezhi). The point is that there isn't a reliable law of nature pointing us one way or the other on this. It's a variable determined by other variables.

We would have to conquer a city in Afganistan, and bring in a great number of Americans to settle.
A big challenge with that is the fact that past colonies have been founded in places where people wanted to settle, and Afghanistan, like most of the rest of Muslim lands, is on some of the world's most horribly bleak worthless miserable wasteland.

(BTW on American colonialism: one could consider the western states colonies of the eastern ones.)
 
Oh, man. Wow. We've got a new -gate, and it's a doozy.

Fox News slams Biden for riding a bicycle: 'Just compare it to President Donald Trump'

Bicyclegate!

So he doesn't have the physical stamina to be president, but he can do something that has physical intensity of riding a bike for exercise...

That's logic.

Also, can people cool it with playing doctors on TV? You're not qualified to say if someone is in declining physical/mental health by reading articles or watching things from a distance. Knock it off.
 
Biden getting a lot of use out of Trump's pretextual anti-covid measure to deny asylum seekers their rights under international law.

Pres. Biden is using Title 42 to expel asylum seekers without their right to hearings.

Ex-Pres. Trump invoked Title 42 citing #COVID19, but health experts say it has no medical basis. Per
@CNBC
, it was used to expel:

▪️ 440,000+ people under Trump
▪️ 690,000+ people under Biden

https://twitter.com/ajplus/status/1440337774628917249
 
Biden getting a lot of use out of Trump's pretextual anti-covid measure to deny asylum seekers their rights under international law.



https://twitter.com/ajplus/status/1440337774628917249

Yeah, no defense of the Biden Admin on that for me, at this point. The main justification that likely could be offered in the first place would be the backlog and sabotage of the relevant government departments needed to process the load, but that defense is not an indefinite one.
 
Whatever happened to "build bridges, not walls"? The majority of those being expelled are brown people.

I'm sure that most of the posters on ISF are now of the opinion that Biden is a racist. Right?

I am sorry. But you seem to live in some odd world where absolute conformation and loyalty to someone is considered to be the norm
 
Meanwhile, we are hanging on the edge of economic catastrophe.
And no, This is not hypebole. If the US defaults, it is going to be much much worse then the previous government shutdowns.
And, make no mistake, Biden and the Dems will get the blame. They might not deserve it,...I think both parties will be guilty, but anybody who thinks that the GOP will get the blame is living another reality
IMHO, the Progressive wing of the Democrats are irresponsible in their refusal to cmpromise with the centrists wing. They have become just like the Tea Party in the GOP...a bunch of ideologues who demand ideoloival purity above all else.
I know the Progs here will blast me, but that is to be expected. People wearing blinders never see they are wearin them.
 
Meanwhile, we are hanging on the edge of economic catastrophe.
And no, This is not hypebole. If the US defaults, it is going to be much much worse then the previous government shutdowns.
And, make no mistake, Biden and the Dems will get the blame. They might not deserve it,...I think both parties will be guilty, but anybody who thinks that the GOP will get the blame is living another reality
IMHO, the Progressive wing of the Democrats are irresponsible in their refusal to cmpromise with the centrists wing. They have become just like the Tea Party in the GOP...a bunch of ideologues who demand ideoloival purity above all else.
I know the Progs here will blast me, but that is to be expected. People wearing blinders never see they are wearin them.

Why is the progressive wing responsible? They're the ones insisting on passing Biden's agenda.

There is absolutely a minority caucus that is endangering the political agenda of the Democratic party, but it's not the progressives. It's the handful of "moderates" that are deliberately undermining the agenda set out by Biden and the D Congress.

The 3.5 trillion bill is Joe Biden's idea. Progressives are backing him, and have support of all but a handful of holdouts. The austerity "centrists" are the holdouts here, not the progressives.

We should be asking why a handful of supposed Democratic congress members are using the Republican obstructionist tactics rather than toeing the party line.

ETA: "Build Back Better" is Biden's centerpiece domestic agenda item for Christ's sake. The moderates are trying to poison the party's electoral chances with pointless austerity.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom