Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Shoulda, woulda coulda. Is the government responsible to know everything?
everything? no. But I do thing they should have known Taliban was going to take over very quickly.

By the way, the Biden administration had been in office for seven months. Generally speaking, it is the same intelligence, the same military that was there before January 20th.

True.

Saying it shouldn't have happened is convenient when you're not responsible for anything. It's pretty easy to say Biden "could a" done better from the comfort of your easy chair.

Also true.

"It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat."
---Theodore Roosevelt

true again, but I bet it never stopped you from criticizing some politician, did it?


America is out of Afghanistan! Hooray!


Hooray! women there will be repressed.

Hooray! the Taliban rules instead of a democracy.

Hooray! anyone whom is of an non-Islam religion will be repressed.

Hooray! anyone whom is not a the right kind of Muslim will be repressed.

Hooray! so will be basic rights like freedom of speech and such will be repressed.

Hooray! terrorists groups like Al Qaeda will be allowed to grow and blossom again.

I do hope we won't have to go back there someday . . .
 
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
Some did, some didn't change their minds. But why was it the government's responsibility to provide more 'incentive' for them?

Okay, maybe not their responsibility, but it might have been nice to do.


You'd have to ask them. It's their lives, their families. As the saying goes: you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink.

Well, I am betting these people didn't know the Taliban would take over and do it so quickly. Otherwise how else to you explain their change of mind?

Because the Afghan army that we had supplied and trained put up almost no fight at all. They weren't getting paid by the Afghan gov't due to corruption. So they put down their guns...literally...and walked away rather than fight. Because tribal leaders in towns made secret arrangements with the Taliban not to put up any resistance in exchange for not being attacked.

Sounds like a multi administration failure in building an efficient government for Afghanistan.

Because the deadline of midnight Aug.30 had been negotiated by Biden with the Taliban rather than than the original Trump deadline of May 1. This got more Afghan allies additional time to get their special visas completed that the Trump admin. and deliberately and systematically stalled. It also gave Americans and other nationals more time. And, if we stayed past that Aug. 30 deadline, the deal with the Taliban not to attack US troops would be null and void.

true. perhaps we could have negotiated for more time, but what you say is true.

Yep, because Trump had pulled out all but 2500. That is not Biden's fault.


Yep, because Monday morning quarterbacking is always easy.

True also.
 
let's not muddy the water with facts.

It has now been established by weight of assertion by the media that Biden 'bungled' the pullout so badly that even Trump could have done better.

I never said Trump would have done better.


This belief is now a part of our collective consciousness and cannot be countered with mere facts - not just because we can't unlearn what we have been indoctrinated with, but because we don't want to.

I am open to possibility that I was wrong.

We don't want to accept that our President is just a man with limited options and abilities. We would have paradise tomorrow if only we had elected a perfect candidate who gave everyone a pony while pulling rabbits out hats and getting lions to lay down with lambs. But Biden is isn't that candidate, so we need to heap scorn on his continual failure to achieve the physically and politically impossible.

Yes, I know Biden is just a man and that there is no such thing as the perfect candidate. But I am unwilling to admit that Biden is the best this country can hope for. But no, I don't want a candidate that gives everyone a pony while pulling rabbits out of hats and getting lions to lay down with lambs.

I don't heap scorn on a failure to do the impossible, I just continue to believe that Afghanistan could have been handled better and I fear that Trump will us that to his advantage as much as possible to return to the White House. Trump back in the White House is NOT something I wish to see.

Not just regarding Afghanistan, but other issues too like children being held at the border and his awful response to the Delta virus.

I have nothing against Biden's response to covid and the Delta variant. I blame the other rside of the aisle for the rise in covid and most specifically the Delta variant. Things would be much better if Republicans didn't stand in the way of mask and vaccine mandates. I can't stand the anti-vaxxers.
 
everything? no. But I do thing they should have known Taliban was going to take over very quickly.



True.



Also true.



true again, but I bet it never stopped you from criticizing some politician, did it?





Hooray! women there will be repressed.


They were when our troops were there except mostly in Kabul or another big city we were in. Once you got out of an area we had a big presence it, like rural areas, they lived exactly as they have done for centuries with women being totally controlled by men and married off for family benefit. That is part of the culture there.

Hooray! the Taliban rules instead of a democracy.

Democracy has never ruled in Afghanistan. It's always been ruled by tribal leaders.


Hooray! anyone whom is of an non-Islam religion will be repressed.

There are virtually no other religions than Islam in Afghanistan. The very, very few that were there, about 1% of the popuation, left when the Taliban took over pre-US invasion.


Hooray! anyone whom is not a the right kind of Muslim will be repressed.

They already were doing that going back centuries. Sunnis overwhelmingly make up the population and the always discriminated against the Shi'a Hazars.

Hooray! so will be basic rights like freedom of speech and such will be repressed.

Never existed in Afghanistan even before the Taliban.

Hooray! terrorists groups like Al Qaeda will be allowed to grow and blossom again.

Quite possible. But the alternative was staying in Afghanistan for what? Another 20, 30, 40 years?


I do hope we won't have to go back there someday . . .

We shouldn't have gone in in the first place. Our mission was to get Bin Laden. We got him and should have left then. NO COUNTRY that has EVER invaded Afghanistan was successful in changing a damn thing other than to organize them to fight against the common enemy. Once that's done, they resumed their way of life they've had for centuries: fighting among themselves.

You seem to have an idea that we could build a democratic nation from a place that was never a democratic nation and whose centuries old customs and beliefs diametrically opposed such a concept.
 
Okay, maybe not their responsibility, but it might have been nice to do.

They warned them FOURTEEN TIMES TO GET THE HELL OUT AND WHY. What else do you suggest? Tell them 15, 16, 17 times because that's going to light a candle under their butts?


Well, I am betting these people didn't know the Taliban would take over and do it so quickly. Otherwise how else to you explain their change of mind?

Many had family there. They were dual citizens or had green cards. They didn't want to leave their families. Or, like one woman, had spent years building an animal sanctuary and didn't want to leave her life's work. They all had different reason. But to lay THEIR decisions at the feet of the government is ludicrous.

Sounds like a multi administration failure in building an efficient government for Afghanistan.

You can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. The culture/mentality of Afghans did not lend itself to a democracy. It's as foreign to them as an absolute monarchy is to us.

true. perhaps we could have negotiated for more time, but what you say is true.

Don't you think Biden tried? He'd already gotten an extension once. The Taliban wanted us out and they would have started attacking our troops again.
 
You seem to have an idea that we could build a democratic nation from a place that was never a democratic nation and whose centuries old customs and beliefs diametrically opposed such a concept.

We certainly could do such a thing. We just aren't allowed to do what's needed for such a transformation, anymore.
 
You seem to have an idea that we could build a democratic nation from a place that was never a democratic nation and whose centuries old customs and beliefs diametrically opposed such a concept.

We certainly could do such a thing. We just aren't allowed to do what's needed for such a transformation, anymore.

Hold on. I want to get some popcorn..............

Okay. Ready now.

How?

In the good old days, we colonized. That sort of behavior is frowned upon, today. But easily, technically possible.
 
everything? no. But I do thing they should have known Taliban was going to take over very quickly.
Maybe


true again, but I bet it never stopped you from criticizing some politician, did it?
Yes, it has. I think there are very legitimate things that politicians should be criticized about and others that are in fact unreasonable. I'm not convinced either way about this.



Hooray! women there will be repressed.

Hooray! the Taliban rules instead of a democracy.

Hooray! anyone whom is of an non-Islam religion will be repressed.

Hooray! anyone whom is not a the right kind of Muslim will be repressed.

Hooray! so will be basic rights like freedom of speech and such will be repressed.

Hooray! terrorists groups like Al Qaeda will be allowed to grow and blossom again.

I do hope we won't have to go back there someday . . .

It's not perfect by any means. But I also don't believe it is America's responsibility to police the world. The United States are allies of dozens of countries that repress women and people that are not Muslim. We don't occupy their countries and waste trillions of dollars there. Why should Afghanistan be any different? There are also dozens of countries where Al Qaeda members are present besides Afghanistan.
 
What the hell does that have to do with anything? Oh...absolutely nothing. Rolls eyes.

It has everything to do with your statement implying that the is US not capable of colonizing a Muslim nation, and converting it to Democracy. As though, somehow a Muslim nation could not be colonized. Easily, easily, could be done...just not with the current climate which frowns upon such excessive force. Which I stated.
 
Examples of the US colonizing anything but some small islands?
And no, the US didn't colonize the Philippines, though it did all the oppressor **** .
 
Last edited:
Cuz why? Them Muslims is so tuff? Give me a break. :rolleyes:

It has nothing to do with "toughness." Have you forgotten the lesson of Vietnam as well as dozens of former French, Spanish, Dutch and English colonies around the world?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom