Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is a lot of debate about how big a Muslim population was ever in Spain.
There is evidence that most people in Muslim controlled Spain remained Christian. They had to pay a special tax but otherwise were pretty much left alone. Same situation as occured in Ottoman occupied Eastern Europe later.
And to makes matters more fun, one reason why the Reconquista took so long was that the Christians fough among themselves constantly, and some Christian nobles had no hesistation about adapting Muslim allies against their Christian enemies. Of course,things were no better on the Muslim side.their nobles fought among themselves constantly also.
El Cid spent most of his career fighting as a Mercenary for Muslims against other Muslims. SOmething that the movie had happening off screen.
Great movie, questinable history.

All true. As a 'People of the Book', Muslims were historically very tolerant of Christians and Jews unlike the Christians. I used to show El Cid to my 8th grade Spanish students. They always loved it.
 
You moved the goalpost. That wasn't actually what you asked. You asked,

I've yet to see a Muslim country colonized by a non-Muslim country and turned into a stable democracy. Can you name one?

You didn't say it had to remain a Muslim country. That's a new condition which wasn't part of your original question. That condition may be relevant to what can be done in Afghanistan today, but you still didn't ask about that in your original question.

Oh, dear. You fail to take into consideration my previous post which indicates that I was, indeed, talking about a Muslim country that remains a Muslim country. Context, Zig, context:

We shouldn't have gone in in the first place. Our mission was to get Bin Laden. We got him and should have left then. NO COUNTRY that has EVER invaded Afghanistan was successful in changing a damn thing other than to organize them to fight against the common enemy. Once that's done, they resumed their way of life they've had for centuries: fighting among themselves.
You seem to have an idea that we could build a democratic nation from a place that was never a democratic nation and whose centuries old customs and beliefs diametrically opposed such a concept.

But nice try at spinning it.

ETA: in addition, if it didn't remain a Muslim country, then it wouldn't be an example of a Muslim country being turned into a stable democracy.
 
Last edited:
They'd be wrong. Israel was never a Muslim country. It has been officially a Jewish State since its creation. Therefore, it does not qualify as a MUSLIM country in which a colonizer successfully created a democratic government.

This is arguable. It's technically correct. "Israel has been a Jewish state since its conception." The land that it occupies, Palestine was not Jewish.

It's also arguable that it is successful since it relies on money and weapons from the US.
And it's also arguable that it is a democracy. Of course it's arguable the US is.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you can say that the United States colonized Cuba or the PI. We occupied them after the Spanish American war. But colonized them?

So which British colonies were true colonies and where colonized and which ones were just occupied? Was India ever really a colony?
 
It has everything to do with your statement implying that the is US not capable of colonizing a Muslim nation, and converting it to Democracy. As though, somehow a Muslim nation could not be colonized. Easily, easily, could be done...just not with the current climate which frowns upon such excessive force. Which I stated.

It would end up with the same result.

I am from Britain, we know all about pulling out of colonies we tried to 'civilise', we went in to Afghanistan twice on our own and again with the USA this time.

I worked with a man that was the last marine off the dockside in Aden, they ran for the ship with a mob chasing them while the ship gave covering fire. It left the harbour with bullets pinging off the hull.

USA could never have turned Afghanistan in to a model of democracy.
You would have been forced out eventually.
 
Or kill an appropriate number of them. "Occupy" would not be the goal, if we were serious.

Completely OT, at this point. I stick by my statements.

All the European Empires tried killing lots of the natives, they were all forced out in the end.

How much of a population do you think you would have to kill to make them compliant?
 
Aaash Israel. The gift that keeps on giving. We should have never recognized it as a State.

Well, a bit too late to go back to 1947 now.
And I have to disagree with you.
I am not a big fan of how the "Progressives" have gone from legtimate criticism of some of Israel's policies, to an "destroy the Zionist Entity" view. Count me strongly out. ANothe reason I am not a "Prog."
 
What is your distinction?

Good question.

I see Cuba as a Spanish Colony as I see the US, Canada, Australia as a British colonies. That the citizens of those colonies ancestry is mostly a mixture of citizens of their Colonial parents and the indigenous natives. But this is really semantics. Technically I'm wrong as the technical definition is that you grew crops.
 
Last edited:
But you don't get to write the "story".

800 years spent in my country trying to throw off the yoke of the British. 800 years.

That fervour never ceased for 800 years until we won. and the Great British Empire had to back down.

The only way your ideas would work is if you took all the natives and wiped them out. All of them. And it seems to be what you are advocating.

Isn't that what the USA did with it's own indigenous people though?
 
There is a lot of debate about how big a Muslim population was ever in Spain.
There is evidence that most people in Muslim controlled Spain remained Christian. They had to pay a special tax but otherwise were pretty much left alone. Same situation as occured in Ottoman occupied Eastern Europe later.
And to makes matters more fun, one reason why the Reconquista took so long was that the Christians fough among themselves constantly, and some Christian nobles had no hesistation about adapting Muslim allies against their Christian enemies. Of course,things were no better on the Muslim side.their nobles fought among themselves constantly also.
El Cid spent most of his career fighting as a Mercenary for Muslims against other Muslims. SOmething that the movie had happening off screen.
Great movie, questinable history.

Pretty much like Afghanistan then.
 
This is arguable. It's technically correct. "Israel has beeb a Jewish state since its conception." The land that it occupies, Palestine was not Jewish.

It's also arguable that it is successful since it relies on money and weapons from the US.
And it's also arguable that it is a democracy. Of course it's arguable the US is.

But who ran the government; the Jews or the Muslims?
 
Well, a bit too late to go back to 1947 now.
And I have to disagree with you.
I am not a big fan of how the "Progressives" have gone from legtimate criticism of some of Israel's policies, to an "destroy the Zionist Entity" view. Count me strongly out. ANothe reason I am not a "Prog."

Yes, it is too late. I'm not in favor of "destroying the Zionist Entity" either.

Let's just say that the 1947 decision has been a disaster ever since it was made. It has been followed by one foreign policy debacle after another. This is all about religion. It's about stupid Muslims fighting stupid Jews who are aided by stupid Christians helping Israel to bring about Armageddon.

Christopher Hitchens was right. Religion poisons everything.
 
Last edited:
They were when our troops were there except mostly in Kabul or another big city we were in. Once you got out of an area we had a big presence it, like rural areas, they lived exactly as they have done for centuries with women being totally controlled by men and married off for family benefit. That is part of the culture there.


Democracy has never ruled in Afghanistan. It's always been ruled by tribal leaders.


There are virtually no other religions than Islam in Afghanistan. The very, very few that were there, about 1% of the popuation, left when the Taliban took over pre-US invasion.


They already were doing that going back centuries. Sunnis overwhelmingly make up the population and the always discriminated against the Shi'a Hazars.


Never existed in Afghanistan even before the Taliban.

There is truth in what you say. I guess my point is, I see nothing to go "Hooray!" over. The whole situation is depressing, actually.


Quite possible. But the alternative was staying in Afghanistan for what? Another 20, 30, 40 years?

good point, but I just hope it is not going to be a situation where every 20 to 4o years, we have to go back to Afghanistan, go after Al Qaeda, leave when we defeat them, they again grow back because of the Taliban, and we repeat and repeat and repeat.


We shouldn't have gone in in the first place. Our mission was to get Bin Laden. We got him and should have left then.
Well, seeing as we thought Bin Laden was in Afghanistan, what would you have suggested? Sounds to me that if we wanted to get him and Al Qaeda, we had to go to Afghanistan.

NO COUNTRY that has EVER invaded Afghanistan was successful in changing a damn thing other than to organize them to fight against the common enemy. Once that's done, they resumed their way of life they've had for centuries: fighting among themselves.

True.

You seem to have an idea that we could build a democratic nation from a place that was never a democratic nation and whose centuries old customs and beliefs diametrically opposed such a concept.

You are probably right. Maybe we should have left after getting Bin Laden and Al Qaeda. I don't know. I do know I want Al Qaeda gone and Afghanistan in a situation where it wouldn't we grow back.
 
They warned them FOURTEEN TIMES TO GET THE HELL OUT AND WHY. What else do you suggest? Tell them 15, 16, 17 times because that's going to light a candle under their butts?

I only suggest that if they had known the truth about how quickly the Taliban would take over, they might have changed their minds.


Many had family there. They were dual citizens or had green cards. They didn't want to leave their families. Or, like one woman, had spent years building an animal sanctuary and didn't want to leave her life's work. They all had different reason. But to lay THEIR decisions at the feet of the government is ludicrous.

Good point.


You can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. The culture/mentality of Afghans did not lend itself to a democracy. It's as foreign to them as an absolute monarchy is to us.

True.


Don't you think Biden tried? He'd already gotten an extension once. The Taliban wanted us out and they would have started attacking our troops again.

You very well might be right and that there was no way for Biden to get more time.
 
Yes, it has. I think there are very legitimate things that politicians should be criticized about and others that are in fact unreasonable.

I agree.

I'm not convinced either way about this.


fair enough.

It's not perfect by any means. But I also don't believe it is America's responsibility to police the world. The United States are allies of dozens of countries that repress women and people that are not Muslim. We don't occupy their countries and waste trillions of dollars there. Why should Afghanistan be any different?

Good points.

There are also dozens of countries where Al Qaeda members are present besides Afghanistan.

maybe, but I think you will agree that before we invaded after 911, Afghanistan was the main base of operations and HQ of Al Qaeda. I hope it doesn't return to that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom