Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Examples of the US colonizing anything but some small islands?
And no, the US didn't colonize the Philippines, though it did all the oppressor **** m

Interesting, other than Hawaii, English is a second, third, fourth lor fifth anguage in all of them.
 
It has everything to do with your statement implying that the is US not capable of colonizing a Muslim nation, and converting it to Democracy. As though, somehow a Muslim nation could not be colonized. Easily, easily, could be done...just not with the current climate which frowns upon such excessive force. Which I stated.

No no no to it could be easily be done. You are talking out your ass.

We spent more than a Trillion US dollars in Afghanistan. Thousands of American lives were lost. Two decades in Afghanistan and we couldn't do it. We couldn't do it in Vietnam despite more than a decade there and 160,000 casualties.

Sure if America wanted to bankrupt itself and sacrifice lots of American lives we could maybe occupy a few Muslim nations for a few decades. But would it be worth it?
 
No no no to it could be easily be done. You are talking out your ass.

We spent more than a Trillion US dollars in Afghanistan. Thousands of American lives were lost. Two decades in Afghanistan and we couldn't do it. We couldn't do it in Vietnam despite more than a decade there and 160,000 casualties.

Sure if America wanted to bankrupt itself and sacrifice lots of American lives we could maybe occupy a few Muslim nations for a few decades. But would it be worth it?

2500 US lives, lol. People really forget what a real war looks like, it seems. We've lost WAY more than that in a day, due to COVID.

Anyway, sure. Whatever you want to believe. :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
2500 US lives, lol. People really forget what a real war looks like, it seems. We've lost WAY more than that in a day, due to COVID.

Anyway, sure. Whatever you want to believe. :thumbsup:

So? Do you think we would have been successful if we lost 50,000 lives and spent 5 trillion dollars?

To be successful you have to not only occupy a country you have to win the hearts and minds.
 
To be successful you have to not only occupy a country you have to win the hearts and minds.

Or kill an appropriate number of them. "Occupy" would not be the goal, if we were serious.

Completely OT, at this point. I stick by my statements.
 
Or kill an appropriate number of them. "Occupy" would not be the goal, if we were serious.

Completely OT, at this point. I stick by my statements.

No, it's hearts and minds.
Napoleon did annihilate the Russian Czarist forces, and by all logic should have been hailed by the serfs as a liberator, as he promised them freedom and land.
But he was a foreign invaders, so they instead fought for the government that enslaved them.
If Force was enough, Russia would be a protectorate of France
 
Last edited:
Or kill an appropriate number of them. "Occupy" would not be the goal, if we were serious.

Completely OT, at this point. I stick by my statements.

WOW! Hitler has got nothing on you.

Are you really this inhuman?
 
No, it's hearts and minds.
Napoleon did annihilate the Russian Czarist forces, and by all logic should have been hailed by the serfs as a liberator, as he promised them freedom and land.
But he was a foreign invaders, so they instead fought for the government that enslaved them.
If Force was enough, Russia would be a protectorate of France

Hmm. Let's see, if we kill most of them and populate the land with Americans we will have effectively colonized Afghanistan. Let's see just how brutal and bloodthirsty we can be.
 
Hmm. Let's see, if we kill most of them and populate the land with Americans we will have effectively colonized Afghanistan. Let's see just how brutal and bloodthirsty we can be.

You wouldn't be able to find Americans willing to live there.
Of course, we could forcefully relocate them in good old Soviet style.
 
WOW! Hitler has got nothing on you.

Are you really this inhuman?

Is this where I am supposed to shout "Godwinning!"?

I'm not endorsing such behavior, just saying it is feasible to install a Democracy in Afghanistan, if not for current societal limitations.
 
You wouldn't be able to find Americans willing to live there.
Of course, we could forcefully relocate them in good old Soviet style.

Sure you could. You would have to make it worth their while. I'm sure Afghanistan has minerals that are worth a lot of money. Get rid of the indigenous tribes and somebody could get rich.
 
I disagree. Especially if it involves free land. This whole thing would make a good topic, tbh. Sort of an "alternate reality" scenario. Entertaining.

Dream on.
At the very, very best you would get an Apartheid situation like South Africa, but with way fewer Whites.
 
Sure you could. You would have to make it worth their while. I'm sure Afghanistan has minerals that are worth a lot of money. Get rid of the indigenous tribes and somebody could get rich.

That's what the Chinese are doing, or going to do. But company compounds for wealth extraction are not the same as settling in.
 
Is this where I am supposed to shout "Godwinning!"?

I'm not endorsing such behavior, just saying it is feasible to install a Democracy in Afghanistan, if not for current societal limitations.

No, this is the time you look in the mirror.

What you are suggesting that if America is willing to sacrifice its humanity and commit genocide, we could turn Afghanistan into a democracy.

Funny, a democracy means the people of Afghanistan will vote for American friendly individuals with American values. Would you "vote" for a government that murdered millions of your fellow citizens?

Out of curiosity, have you studied Vietnam, Iran even the American Revolution? Your plan has proven far more often than not to be a failure.
 
We shouldn't have gone in in the first place. Our mission was to get Bin Laden. We got him and should have left then. NO COUNTRY that has EVER invaded Afghanistan was successful in changing a damn thing other than to organize them to fight against the common enemy. Once that's done, they resumed their way of life they've had for centuries: fighting among themselves.
You seem to have an idea that we could build a democratic nation from a place that was never a democratic nation and whose centuries old customs and beliefs diametrically opposed such a concept.

In the good old days, we colonized. That sort of behavior is frowned upon, today. But easily, technically possible.

LOL. We never colonized a Muslim country with the culture of tribalism. Ya got nuthin'.

Cuz why? Them Muslims is so tuff? Give me a break. :rolleyes:

What the hell does that have to do with anything? Oh...absolutely nothing. Rolls eyes.

It has everything to do with your statement implying that the is US not capable of colonizing a Muslim nation, and converting it to Democracy. As though, somehow a Muslim nation could not be colonized. Easily, easily, could be done...just not with the current climate which frowns upon such excessive force. Which I stated.


Sigh. I said we had never colonized a Muslim nation; I did not say we were not capable of doing so. I did say that no one had ever been successful in invading Afghanistan and changing their inherent way of life. That is historical fact. Colonizing a nation is not the same thing as changing their inherent way of life, customs, and belief. Sometimes it does but I've yet to see a Muslim country colonized by a non-Muslim country and turned into a stable democracy. Can you name one?
 
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
Cuba, Guam, the Philippines, Puerto Rico, Hawaii.
I don't think you can say that the United States colonized Cuba or the PI. We occupied them after the Spanish American war. But colonized them?

Colony may be too loose a term as Cuba was technically a protectorate but we occupied it and had an outsize influence and control over them for years. On the other hand, the Philippines were a colony according to this:

Meanwhile, American opposition to U.S. colonial rule of the Philippines came in many forms, ranging from those who thought it morally wrong for the United States to be engaged in colonialism, to those who feared that annexation might eventually permit the non-white Filipinos to have a role in American national government.
When it became clear that U.S. forces were intent on imposing American colonial control over the islands, the early clashes between the two sides in 1899 swelled into an all-out war. Americans tended to refer to the ensuing conflict as an “insurrection” rather than acknowledge the Filipinos’ contention that they were fighting to ward off a foreign invader.

https://history.state.gov/milestones/1899-1913/war
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom