Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
Some did, some didn't change their minds. But why was it the government's responsibility to provide more 'incentive' for them?
I think it was the government's responsible know the Taliban's capabilities and do the due diligence and intelligence and know Taliban was going to quickly take over and make sure that the American citizens there and our Afghan allies knew the truth about the situation. Lets face it: Taliban's two week takeover caught Biden Administration off guard, and that shouldn't have happened.

The question wasn't whether the US gov't should have known the Taliban's capability for taking over so quick but whether they should have "provided more incentive" for Americans to leave. They told them to get out FOURTEEN TIMES because our troops were leaving. What more incentive did they need? US supplied moving vans and first class tickets on the airline of their choice?


Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
They live there, they know the lie of the land more than most..
But did they really know that the Taliban was going to take over and do it so quickly?

You'd have to ask them. It's their lives, their families.
Therefore it was their responsibility to follow and heed the US govt's warning to get out.
As the saying goes: you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink.


Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
It was obvious the Taliban was going to take over eventually.
If that was the case, why were we so unprepared for the Taliban takeover?

Because the Afghan army that we had supplied and trained put up almost no fight at all. They weren't getting paid by the Afghan gov't due to corruption. So they put down their guns...literally...and walked away rather than fight. Because tribal leaders in towns made secret arrangements with the Taliban not to put up any resistance in exchange for not being attacked.

Why did that evacuation need to be put together on the quick?

Because the deadline of midnight Aug.30 had been negotiated by Biden with the Taliban rather than than the original Trump deadline of May 1. This got more Afghan allies additional time to get their special visas completed that the Trump admin. and deliberately and systematically stalled. It also gave Americans and other nationals more time. And, if we stayed past that Aug. 30 deadline, the deal with the Taliban not to attack US troops would be null and void.

Biden even had to bring Troops back to Afghanistan to do the evacuation.

Yep, because Trump had pulled out all but 2500. That is not Biden's fault.

Just seems to be me, it could have been better done instead in a rush with the Taliban surrounding the airport.

Yep, because Monday morning quarterbacking is always easy.
 
The problem is, with so many Republicans holding seats in Congress, and controlling so many State governments, such changes will be almost impossible, because to fix things, we'd need the assistance of the very people who are the problem.



It's not just the Federal level of the Republican Party that needs to be burned down, it's the entire organization, at every level of government.



Like I said, it's not going to be an easy job, nor a quick one.
This was a redistricting year, as well. Searches show a lot local coverage. A lot of slow process stories, a few court challenges. I don't hear it brought up much by leadership. Aside from the doomed bill in the Senate, there's little on that topic at all in terms of party priorities. And the machinery of elections are state controlled and locally operated, anyways.
 
The question wasn't whether the US gov't should have known the Taliban's capability for taking over so quick but whether they should have "provided more incentive" for Americans to leave. They told them to get out FOURTEEN TIMES because our troops were leaving. What more incentive did they need? US supplied moving vans and first class tickets on the airline of their choice?
let's not muddy the water with facts.

It has now been established by weight of assertion by the media that Biden 'bungled' the pullout so badly that even Trump could have done better. This belief is now a part of our collective consciousness and cannot be countered with mere facts - not just because we can't unlearn what we have been indoctrinated with, but because we don't want to.

We don't want to accept that our President is just a man with limited options and abilities. We would have paradise tomorrow if only we had elected a perfect candidate who gave everyone a pony while pulling rabbits out hats and getting lions to lay down with lambs. But Biden is isn't that candidate, so we need to heap scorn on his continual failure to achieve the physically and politically impossible. Not just regarding Afghanistan, but other issues too like children being held at the border and his awful response to the Delta virus.

I feel for those poor Americans in Afghanistan that Biden let down. Here I am lying in this ventilator gasping for breath and wondering if I will make it through the day, and it's all Biden's fault. You see, if only he had told me FIFTEEN TIMES to wear a damn mask I would have listened for sure!
 
Last edited:
let's not muddy the water with facts.

It has now been established by weight of assertion by the media that Biden 'bungled' the pullout so badly that even Trump could have done better. This belief is now a part of our collective consciousness and cannot be countered with mere facts - not just because we can't unlearn what we have been indoctrinated with, but because we don't want to.

We don't want to accept that our President is just a man with limited options and abilities. We would have paradise tomorrow if only we had elected a perfect candidate who gave everyone a pony while pulling rabbits out hats and getting lions to lay down with lambs. But Biden is isn't that candidate, so we need to heap scorn on his continual failure to achieve the physically and politically impossible. Not just regarding Afghanistan, but other issues too like children being held at the border and his awful response to the Delta virus.

I feel for those poor Americans in Afghanistan that Biden let down. Here I am lying in this ventilator gasping for breath and wondering if I will make it through the day, and it's all Biden's fault. You see, if only he had told me FIFTEEN TIMES to wear a damn mask I would have listened for sure!

One of your best posts yet.

I dunno...maybe they would have been more incentivized if they'd been offered free scratch off lottery tickets or a free chicken sandwich at Chick- Fil- A.
 
Last edited:
Mounted border patrol agents whipping Haitian refugees at the border.

Border patrol is mounted on horseback rounding up Haitian refugees with whips.

This is unfathomable cruelty towards people fleeing disaster and political ruin. The administration must stop this.

https://twitter.com/SawyerHackett/status/1439976012188692496

ETA: News article

A mounted U.S. Border Patrol agent shouted commands in a tense encounter with Haitian migrants wading through the Rio Grande near Del Rio, Texas.

As the Haitians tried to climb onto the U.S. side of the river Sunday afternoon, the agent shouted: "Let's go! Get out now! Back to Mexico!"

The agent swung his whip menacingly, charging his horse toward the men in the river who were trying to return to an encampment under the international bridge in Del Rio after buying food and water in Ciudad Acuña, Mexico.

One migrant fell as he tried to dodge, others shielded their heads with their hands.

After a few minutes the agents retreated, allowing the migrants to return to the camp, where over 10,000 are waiting for the chance to open an asylum claim in the United States.

https://www.elpasotimes.com/story/news/immigration/2021/09/19/haitian-migrants-tough-choices-crackdown-del-rio-texas-border/8411152002/

While international law protects the right to seek asylum, public health ordinance Title 42, adopted by former President Donald Trump during the COVID-19 pandemic and continued by President Joe Biden, allows for rapid expulsions without the opportunity to seek asylum.

I guess it's different if it's not Trump doing it.
 
Last edited:
Mounted border patrol agents whipping Haitian refugees at the border.

https://twitter.com/SawyerHackett/status/1439976012188692496

ETA: News article

https://www.elpasotimes.com/story/news/immigration/2021/09/19/haitian-migrants-tough-choices-crackdown-del-rio-texas-border/8411152002/

I guess it's different if it's not Trump doing it.


Yeah, it's all a tragic mess. But not everybody in the world who lives in a bad place can move to the U.S. And according to press reports, most of these Haitians are not new refugees; they have been living for years, even decades, in Chile and other countries, and swallowed false claims that President Joe would let'em all in. What do you really think Biden should do?
In August, U.S. border officials stopped Haitian migrants more than 7,500 times, a 37% increase from July. Many of the Haitians reaching U.S. soil are believed to have lived in Brazil, Chile and other South American countries before deciding to trek north during the coronavirus pandemic, which has ravaged the region's economies.
 
Yeah, it's all a tragic mess. But not everybody in the world who lives in a bad place can move to the U.S. And according to press reports, most of these Haitians are not new refugees; they have been living for years, even decades, in Chile and other countries, and swallowed false claims that President Joe would let'em all in. What do you really think Biden should do?

He should order them not to whip these people. I agree that the US shouldn't be a haven for everyone who wants to come here. That said we don't treat humans as animals. EVER!
 
He should order them not to whip these people. I agree that the US shouldn't be a haven for everyone who wants to come here. That said we don't treat humans as animals. EVER!

I'm pretty sure that that tactic was not approved by anybody in authority, and I suspect that there will be consequences.
 
And Debt Ceiling crisis , here we come.
Sick and tired of this.
Why the hell do BOTH sides wait until the last minute before dealing with this?
We got a disfunctinal congress, and anybody with any brains or not wearing huge partisan blinders should see that both parties are to blame.
 
And Debt Ceiling crisis , here we come.
Sick and tired of this.
Why the hell do BOTH sides wait until the last minute before dealing with this?
We got a disfunctinal congress, and anybody with any brains or not wearing huge partisan blinders should see that both parties are to blame.

There's certainly enough blame to go around.
 
And Debt Ceiling crisis , here we come.
Sick and tired of this.
Why the hell do BOTH sides wait until the last minute before dealing with this?
We got a disfunctinal congress, and anybody with any brains or not wearing huge partisan blinders should see that both parties are to blame.

Because they have to pass it then. Bring it up earlier and people play games.

What should be done is to take the political element out of the equation.
 
There's certainly enough blame to go around.

The congress's way of doing business is antiquated beyond belief. For one thing, the budget should be the FIRST thing done ever year, and, except for real emergencies, no other major bills done until that is in place. But both parties seem to like to dealy it so they can play stupid political games.

And I see neither party really anxious to make changes, which they could easily do.
 
Because they have to pass it then. Bring it up earlier and people play games.

What should be done is to take the political element out of the equation.


That makes no sense. You are always going to have politics involved with the budget. How much is spent and what it is spent on is a political issue if every there was one.
I have a sick feeling what you want is a system where permanent bureaucrats hold the real power, and the Congress just does their bidding.
Funny, the is the way the Soviet Union ran:the government made all the spending decisions and the Soviet COngress just rubber stamped their decisions. DId not work out too well.
 
The congress's way of doing business is antiquated beyond belief. For one thing, the budget should be the FIRST thing done ever year, and, except for real emergencies, no other major bills done until that is in place. But both parties seem to like to dealy it so they can play stupid political games. And I see neither party really anxious to make changes, which they could easily do.
No that's why they delay this to the last moment. No one wants to be the party that shot a bullet into the American economy.
 
That makes no sense. You are always going to have politics involved with the budget. How much is spent and what it is spent on is a political issue if every there was one.
I have a sick feeling what you want is a system where permanent bureaucrats hold the real power, and the Congress just does their bidding.
Funny, the is the way the Soviet Union ran:the government made all the spending decisions and the Soviet COngress just rubber stamped their decisions. DId not work out too well.

There have been bills on this before that takes this process out of the hands of Congress. That raising the debt limit would be done automatically.

Raising the debt ceiling for 40 years was basically a nothinburger. I don't seem to remember it being used as political gamesmanship until the 90s.
 
That makes no sense. You are always going to have politics involved with the budget. How much is spent and what it is spent on is a political issue if every there was one.

I'm struggling with this one too. How is determining policy not political? It is by definition.

I think we may be seeing a definition of "political" that is a little different. I found this article very expressive on the point.

https://www.cracked.com/blog/3-things-that-make-political-discussions-nearly-impossible

Christina H. said:
A lot of people use "politics" to mean "stuff that doesn't affect real life." They think of it as nothing but abstract ****, like economics and laws about lawyers and declaring National Low-Flow Toilet Day and not discriminating against some group you don't know any people from. I mean, most of those actually do affect real life (especially toilet holidays), but depending on who you are, there's a large swath of political issues that feel really non-urgent, if not completely unnecessary.

Everyone has different ideas of which issues fall into what bucket. Some white business owner who's never met any black people might think racism is mostly about mean words celebrities say sometimes, and that therefore addressing racism is not super important to anyone's lives, black or white. On the flip side, raising taxes on small businesses is "real-life important" because it affects whether he can afford to keep Martha and Kevin on or has to fire them. It affects real, hard-working people's livelihoods! People with names! Meanwhile, a Sikh guy who got pulled out of his car and beaten up for being a "Muslim terrorist" might think racism is a very urgent problem, while small business taxes are something you discuss academically in a living room conversation over pumpkin spice lattes.
 
That makes no sense. You are always going to have politics involved with the budget. How much is spent and what it is spent on is a political issue if every there was one.
I have a sick feeling what you want is a system where permanent bureaucrats hold the real power, and the Congress just does their bidding.
Funny, the is the way the Soviet Union ran:the government made all the spending decisions and the Soviet COngress just rubber stamped their decisions. DId not work out too well.

The budget and the debt ceiling are two different things, The debt ceiling has to be raised to pay for items already appropriated. It's to pay for last year's budget.
 
The budget and the debt ceiling are two different things, The debt ceiling has to be raised to pay for items already appropriated. It's to pay for last year's budget.

I know.
And I think coupling them is a very dangerous tactic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom