Stacyhs
Penultimate Amazing
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
Some did, some didn't change their minds. But why was it the government's responsibility to provide more 'incentive' for them?
The question wasn't whether the US gov't should have known the Taliban's capability for taking over so quick but whether they should have "provided more incentive" for Americans to leave. They told them to get out FOURTEEN TIMES because our troops were leaving. What more incentive did they need? US supplied moving vans and first class tickets on the airline of their choice?
You'd have to ask them. It's their lives, their families.
Because the Afghan army that we had supplied and trained put up almost no fight at all. They weren't getting paid by the Afghan gov't due to corruption. So they put down their guns...literally...and walked away rather than fight. Because tribal leaders in towns made secret arrangements with the Taliban not to put up any resistance in exchange for not being attacked.
Because the deadline of midnight Aug.30 had been negotiated by Biden with the Taliban rather than than the original Trump deadline of May 1. This got more Afghan allies additional time to get their special visas completed that the Trump admin. and deliberately and systematically stalled. It also gave Americans and other nationals more time. And, if we stayed past that Aug. 30 deadline, the deal with the Taliban not to attack US troops would be null and void.
Yep, because Trump had pulled out all but 2500. That is not Biden's fault.
Yep, because Monday morning quarterbacking is always easy.
Some did, some didn't change their minds. But why was it the government's responsibility to provide more 'incentive' for them?
I think it was the government's responsible know the Taliban's capabilities and do the due diligence and intelligence and know Taliban was going to quickly take over and make sure that the American citizens there and our Afghan allies knew the truth about the situation. Lets face it: Taliban's two week takeover caught Biden Administration off guard, and that shouldn't have happened.
The question wasn't whether the US gov't should have known the Taliban's capability for taking over so quick but whether they should have "provided more incentive" for Americans to leave. They told them to get out FOURTEEN TIMES because our troops were leaving. What more incentive did they need? US supplied moving vans and first class tickets on the airline of their choice?
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
They live there, they know the lie of the land more than most..
But did they really know that the Taliban was going to take over and do it so quickly?
You'd have to ask them. It's their lives, their families.
As the saying goes: you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink.Therefore it was their responsibility to follow and heed the US govt's warning to get out.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
It was obvious the Taliban was going to take over eventually.
If that was the case, why were we so unprepared for the Taliban takeover?
Because the Afghan army that we had supplied and trained put up almost no fight at all. They weren't getting paid by the Afghan gov't due to corruption. So they put down their guns...literally...and walked away rather than fight. Because tribal leaders in towns made secret arrangements with the Taliban not to put up any resistance in exchange for not being attacked.
Why did that evacuation need to be put together on the quick?
Because the deadline of midnight Aug.30 had been negotiated by Biden with the Taliban rather than than the original Trump deadline of May 1. This got more Afghan allies additional time to get their special visas completed that the Trump admin. and deliberately and systematically stalled. It also gave Americans and other nationals more time. And, if we stayed past that Aug. 30 deadline, the deal with the Taliban not to attack US troops would be null and void.
Biden even had to bring Troops back to Afghanistan to do the evacuation.
Yep, because Trump had pulled out all but 2500. That is not Biden's fault.
Just seems to be me, it could have been better done instead in a rush with the Taliban surrounding the airport.
Yep, because Monday morning quarterbacking is always easy.