Terrible news from Afghanistan

Yes, the US will often cede jurisdiction to the host nation, but not based on the nature of the SOFAs the US has with other countries.
So again, my statement that the terms of other SOFAs are irrelevant to this incident. What matters are the terms of the U.S.'s SOFA with Afghanistan.

What matters more than the actual language of the SOFA is the relationship between the US and the host nation.
I disagree. We're bound by the SOFA. The language of the SOFA the result of the relationship between the US and the host nation, but we're legally bound by the terms of the SOFA.

The closer we are to being equals, the more alike the US/host nation judicial systems are, and the more we desire/need continued good relations with the host nation, the more likely the US is to waive jurisdiction.
OK, I see your point now. If the SOFA gives jurisdiction to the US, the US could still waive that jurisdiction and let the guy be tried in Afghanistan if they chose to. But again, if the SOFA reserved jurisdiction to the host country, even though the US has the upper hand in the relationship, it would not have the authority to take jurisdiction. So the terms of the SOFA matter most (or at least first).

The nature of our SOFAs with other countries is, as I said, irrelevant here.

No, the relationship between the US and A'stan, the relative "power" of each nation, and the likely reaction of US citizens to "abandoning" a service member to Afghani "barbarism" are really what matters when discussing the lieklyhood that the US would waive jurisdiction.
Again, as you pointed out, most of our SOFAs reserves jurisdiction for criminal matters like this to the host nation. Those terms are irrelevant. What matters is that the SOFA we have with Afghanistan gives jurisdiction to the US.

The actual SOFA itself is only important in that it provides the US with the sole decision making authority.
That's a pretty big thing, isn't it? In fact, that's pretty much the entire question. If the US didn't have jurisdiction, there would be no question of the US waiving its jurisdiction.



True - but why is this significant? I don't see a connection between our refusal to subject US Servicemen to the jurisdiction of the ICC and our actions under a SOFA (any SOFA).
I was trying to figure out how other international law might come into play and perhaps trump our SOFA with Afghanistan.
 
Well whatever the reason for the lack of deadly riots I'm glad that things are peaceful. Now if things can just remain somewhat calm until we finally get our butts out of there.

I think it is simply a case what are you going to protest against - No nation or people are immune to seemly random acts of violence. Those that died clearly didn't deserve what happened and the man responsible was not acting in any formalized way or representing a government, or social grouping
 
Last edited:
Since he's in U.S. custody, I think it's safe to say that that won't happen.

However, I think the issue of how our SOFA handles crimes like this is an important one in winning the "hearts and minds". While the reaction to the Koran burning thing might have been unjustified, it would be difficult for any country to suffer a massacre like this and not be allowed to participate in the administration of justice without stirring up greater resentment against the ongoing U.S. military presence.

BTW, what exactly is our continuing mission there?

Yep, and now we whisk him out of the country and are not going to have anything to do with a trial in Afghanistan, whether held by us or the Afghans.

Obama said: "The United States takes this as seriously as if it was our own citizens and our own children who were murdered."

Yet in addition to whisking him away, we haven't even revealed his name? So if a foreign soldier massacred 16 Americans, we wouldn't expect the foreign nation to name the soldier, or to allow us to try him? That's how seriously we'd take it?

The US strategy in many ways seem to be designed to LOSE "hearts and minds". Stuff like this, the laughable sentence for that Iraqi massacrer and some of the Abu Ghraib guys, night raids, drones attacking funerals, burning korans...what an absolutely inept occupier we are.
 
Yep, and now we whisk him out of the country and are not going to have anything to do with a trial in Afghanistan, whether held by us or the Afghans.

Obama said: "The United States takes this as seriously as if it was our own citizens and our own children who were murdered."

Yet in addition to whisking him away, we haven't even revealed his name? So if a foreign soldier massacred 16 Americans, we wouldn't expect the foreign nation to name the soldier, or to allow us to try him? That's how seriously we'd take it?

Ten dollars says that the soldier will be publicly named once charges are officially filed.
 
Ten dollars says that the soldier will be publicly named once charges are officially filed.

I think you're right. I would imagine measure will need to be taken to protect his family. (Identifying the shooter identifies them as well.)
 
An interesting article, which basically repeats Wildcat's argument:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/15/w...t-over-2-afghan-responses.html?_r=2&ref=world

“To Muslims, and especially to Afghans, religion is much higher a concern than civilian or human casualties,” said Hafez Abdul Qayoom, a member of Afghanistan’s highest clerical body, the Ulema Council. “When something happens to their religion, they are much more sensitive and have much stronger reaction to it.

[...]

Mullah Qayoom is surprised that anyone is surprised.
“Humans were sent here to worship and protect religion,” he said. “That is what the purpose of a Muslim’s life is.”
That's a Muslim cleric saying that.
 
Last edited:
That's a Muslim cleric and a mullah saying that.

I still don't buy the argument. I guarantee you there are Afghans who value human life very highly.

And logically the relative violence of public expressions of outrage over the two events in question does not support the conclusion that everyone "over there" values the Koran higher than human life. (Again, by that same logic, we would conclude that Americans value human life lower than they do tax policy.)

FWIW, saying one is "a higher concern" than the other might be accurate (and is not the same as a statement about devaluing human life.)

Similarly, I'll bet it's true that more Americans are more concerned about tax policy than they are school shootings. Does it follow that they value human life less than they do their money (or even more generally, economic prosperity)?
 
I still don't buy the argument. I guarantee you there are Afghans who value human life very highly.

And again, nobody is saying that they don't.

FWIW, saying one is "a higher concern" than the other might be accurate (and is not the same as a statement about devaluing human life.)
I think it is the same argument. They value their religion higher than human life (again, I'm not saying they don't value human life), so by definition they value human life less, so there is devaluation.
 
And again, nobody is saying that they don't.


A stupid book is more important than human life over there.



Pardalis said:
I think it is the same argument. They value their religion higher than human life (again, I'm not saying they don't value human life), so by definition they value human life less, so there is devaluation.

So does that mean that Americans also devalue human life since there aren't protests over things like school shooting sprees but there are over even the threat of increased taxes?

If we're talking about people having beliefs in things they value so strongly that they'd be willing to give up their own life for them, I earlier cited several examples of that in Western culture. It's also not a sign that the sacrifice means life is devalued. In fact, that life is dear is exactly why it's seen as such a tremendous (sometimes heroic or saintly or even godly) sacrifice.
 
Wildcat said more important, he didn't say life wasn't important.

The mullah agrees with him.
 
Last edited:
Wildcat said more important, he didn't say life wasn't important.

The mullah agrees with him.

But didn't you just say that claiming something is more important than life is the same thing as devaluing human life?

And again, even if it's just an observation about other values relative to human life, can't the same thing be said about Americans?

Another good example, few countries tolerate the number of traffic fatalities and gun-related fatalities (slightly over half of which are suicides) that we in the U.S. do as an acceptable trade off to some idea or another of "freedom". Doesn't it follow that we value these other things more highly than human life?
 
But didn't you just say that claiming something is more important than life is the same thing as devaluing human life?

sigh

devaluating

To lessen or cancel the value of.

If they value religion more this means life is valued less.

And again, even if it's just an observation about other values relative to human life, can't the same thing be said about Americans?
Apples and oranges. Americans don't sacrifice their lives and threaten other people's lives in violent protests over taxes.

Another good example, few countries tolerate the number of traffic fatalities and gun-related fatalities (slightly over half of which are suicides) that we in the U.S. do as an acceptable trade off to some idea or another of "freedom". Doesn't it follow that we value these other things more highly than human life?
Yes, some people value freedom more than human life. I think it can be at times a legitimate point of view.

Plus the risk involved in these fatalities is a relative one, and acceptable.
 
Last edited:
Take for example smokers, it could be said they value pleasure and the freedom to enjoy pleasure over their own life expectancy.

This doesn't mean they don't value life at all, they just assess the risk as being acceptable, just like we assess the risk of having a car crash as being acceptable when we start the car.

Afghans seem to value their religious text more than human life because they think blasphemy is too high a risk for their eternal life than murder. Their criteria is different than ours because to them this life is of less importance.
 
Last edited:
A better way of putting it is would be that they value the afterlife more than actual life.
 
I don't see how we could ever let such a place like Afghanistan try our soldiers for crimes. What if, for example, a married soldier is convicted of raping an Afghan woman and the sentence is he has to marry her? Even with murder, it wouldn't be unusual for the survivors to accept a cash payment instead of prison or execution. And then we'd have a case of a psychopath running free.

A US military court is the proper venue in this case.

Afghanistan is not like Japan or Germany.
 
Apples and oranges. Americans don't sacrifice their lives and threaten other people's lives in violent protests over taxes.
Nonsense. Wildcat's conclusion was not based on anything but the difference in degree of public expressions of outrage over two different incidents. I pointed out that exactly the same difference can be observed here in the U.S.

If you want to include as evidence about the relative value of human life cases of suicide bombing or other sacrificing of life for a greater cause, as I mentioned above, this is not a concept that is foreign to the West. Indeed, it is not spun as devaluing human life at all. Precisely because human life is dear, such sacrifices are held to be more noble or whatever.

Yes, some people value freedom more than human life. I think it can be at times a legitimate point of view.
Freedom or other values? I don't see any difference. If you can construe Wildcat's conclusion as being true, it's only true in a very trivial way--one that doesn't say anything about the people "over there" that is unique or fundamentally different from anyone else. So if it's true, it's still an idiotic thing to say.

Plus the risk involved in these fatalities is a relative one, and acceptable.
But we're not talking about risk, are we? We're talking about relative values as measured by expressions of public outrage.

In fact, I think there are a great number of factors that could explain why people might engage in public expressions of outrage in response to one thing but not another (or to a greater or lesser degree) without saying anything about how they value human life.

When I point out that Americans do the same thing (more or less quietly acquiesce to great loss of human life, while spending a lot of energy expressing outrage over things that do not involve loss of human life), we can talk about any number of reasons for this difference such that the difference does not lead to any conclusion at all about how we value human life (even relatively). I agree.

But I insist the same thinking be applied to the difference in public expression of outrage in Afghanistan.
 
I don't see how we could ever let such a place like Afghanistan try our soldiers for crimes. What if, for example, a married soldier is convicted of raping an Afghan woman and the sentence is he has to marry her? Even with murder, it wouldn't be unusual for the survivors to accept a cash payment instead of prison or execution. And then we'd have a case of a psychopath running free.

A US military court is the proper venue in this case.

Afghanistan is not like Japan or Germany.

Well, he turned himself in, so it's not like there is any possibility of a miscarriage of justice in this case, or do you disagree?
 
I don't see how we could ever let such a place like Afghanistan try our soldiers for crimes.

Isn't that very much like saying you don't see how Afghanistan could ever be a sovereign country?

If that's the case, then yet again, what exactly is our continuing mission there?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom