JoeTheJuggler
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2006
- Messages
- 27,766
So again, my statement that the terms of other SOFAs are irrelevant to this incident. What matters are the terms of the U.S.'s SOFA with Afghanistan.Yes, the US will often cede jurisdiction to the host nation, but not based on the nature of the SOFAs the US has with other countries.
I disagree. We're bound by the SOFA. The language of the SOFA the result of the relationship between the US and the host nation, but we're legally bound by the terms of the SOFA.What matters more than the actual language of the SOFA is the relationship between the US and the host nation.
OK, I see your point now. If the SOFA gives jurisdiction to the US, the US could still waive that jurisdiction and let the guy be tried in Afghanistan if they chose to. But again, if the SOFA reserved jurisdiction to the host country, even though the US has the upper hand in the relationship, it would not have the authority to take jurisdiction. So the terms of the SOFA matter most (or at least first).The closer we are to being equals, the more alike the US/host nation judicial systems are, and the more we desire/need continued good relations with the host nation, the more likely the US is to waive jurisdiction.
The nature of our SOFAs with other countries is, as I said, irrelevant here.
Again, as you pointed out, most of our SOFAs reserves jurisdiction for criminal matters like this to the host nation. Those terms are irrelevant. What matters is that the SOFA we have with Afghanistan gives jurisdiction to the US.No, the relationship between the US and A'stan, the relative "power" of each nation, and the likely reaction of US citizens to "abandoning" a service member to Afghani "barbarism" are really what matters when discussing the lieklyhood that the US would waive jurisdiction.
That's a pretty big thing, isn't it? In fact, that's pretty much the entire question. If the US didn't have jurisdiction, there would be no question of the US waiving its jurisdiction.The actual SOFA itself is only important in that it provides the US with the sole decision making authority.
I was trying to figure out how other international law might come into play and perhaps trump our SOFA with Afghanistan.True - but why is this significant? I don't see a connection between our refusal to subject US Servicemen to the jurisdiction of the ICC and our actions under a SOFA (any SOFA).