Terrible news from Afghanistan

I don't see how we could ever let such a place like Afghanistan try our soldiers for crimes. What if, for example, a married soldier is convicted of raping an Afghan woman and the sentence is he has to marry her? Even with murder, it wouldn't be unusual for the survivors to accept a cash payment instead of prison or execution. And then we'd have a case of a psychopath running free.

A US military court is the proper venue in this case.

Afghanistan is not like Japan or Germany.

Those are good points, though I did include the alternative of the US trying him there, instead of overseas (for PR "hearts and minds" purposes, same reason as we should release his name soon). But I also don't trust our own courts to not let psychopaths run free.

http://www.nationaljournal.com/nationalsecurity/afghanistan-killings-not-the-first-time-20120312

some selections from that article:

The so-called “kill team” ringleader, Sgt. Calvin R. Gibbs, 25, was convicted in November of murdering the three unarmed civilians and sentenced to life in prison – although he’s eligible for parole in 8.5 years.

(...)

Behenna was initially sentenced to 25 years for unpremeditated murder in a combat zone. His term has since been reduced twice; he’s currently serving a 15-year sentence at Fort Leavenworth, Kan.

(...)

Eventually, Wuterich’s charges were reduced to manslaughter. He pleaded guilty this February to negligent dereliction of duty in the killing of the civilians in exchange for the dropping of assault and manslaughter charges and was given a general discharge from the Marine Corps under honorable conditions. According to The Los Angeles Times, Wuterich, who remained on active duty during the years of court proceedings, can still receive veteran’s benefits and won’t serve time behind bars. The others were cleared of their charges.

(...)

1st Lt. Jack Saville, an Army platoon leader involved in forcing the Iraqi civilians into the river, was sentenced in 2005 to 45 days in a military prison and given a $12,000 fine. Staff Sgt. Tracy Perkins, who gave the orders for the forced jump into the river, was acquitted of manslaughter but convicted of assault and obstruction of justice and sentenced to six months jail time.

Light sentences, plea bargains, later sentence reductions, for murdering civilians. The only life-without-parole (for now, could be reduced) sentence in that article is for the gang-rape/murder of a 14-year old after also murdering her family: [ETA: also just noticed that this was the result of a US criminal court trial, not a military court]

Green pled not guilty but was convicted of rape and murder. Though his trial was the first capital punishment case under a 2000 law allowing federal criminal courts to try crimes committed overseas by former members of the military, according to The New York Times, Green was spared the death penalty. He received a sentence in 2009 of life in prison without parole. The other four charged pleaded guilty or were convicted in military courts for their roles in the bloody raid; most received long prison terms, and all will be eligible for parole within the decade.

My "hearts and minds" reasons are probably moot since that's a war we have no chance of winning. But I also think this new psychopath deserves the death penalty, and the Afghans are far more likely to give it than the US military courts. Take away all the politics and nationalities of killers/victims, and an ******* murdered 16 innocent people. I hope the US doesn't let him run free.
 
Last edited:
Can you source this?

Massacre darkens Afghan outlook for US

"""""This latest assault was reportedly the work of a single soldier, but many Afghans won't believe or care that it was not another routine US raid. The effects are the same," said Ann Jones, author of the 2006 book Kabul in Winter and a prominent critic of US counterinsurgency tactics in Afghanistan.

"US officials miss the point entirely, insisting this massacre was a one-off tragedy, when Afghans know something like it will happen again any day."
""""

I've been to Afghanistan, and in my experience, the average Afghani was more afraid of being killed in a night raid by domestic thugs than by foreign Soldiers. Indeed, to the extent that Afghani civilians were afraid of being killed by US forces, their greater fear was of a random UAV strike. I was never aware of any significant percentage of Soldiers (US, anyway) being drug-addled.

Fears of different things are not mutually exclusive.

One person's experience or awareness may not be useful or authoritative in establishing the fears of "the average Afghani" or in gauging the extent of US military drug use

Who calls Afghans Afghanis?

'America's Medicated Army'

'Psychiatric drug use skyrockets in U.S. military'

Drug Use in the Military: Is it Affecting Our Troops?
 
Those are good points, though I did include the alternative of the US trying him there, instead of overseas (for PR "hearts and minds" purposes, same reason as we should release his name soon). But I also don't trust our own courts to not let psychopaths run free.

http://www.nationaljournal.com/nationalsecurity/afghanistan-killings-not-the-first-time-20120312

some selections from that article:



Light sentences, plea bargains, later sentence reductions, for murdering civilians. The only life-without-parole (for now, could be reduced) sentence in that article is for the gang-rape/murder of a 14-year old after also murdering her family: [ETA: also just noticed that this was the result of a US criminal court trial, not a military court]



My "hearts and minds" reasons are probably moot since that's a war we have no chance of winning. But I also think this new psychopath deserves the death penalty, and the Afghans are far more likely to give it than the US military courts. Take away all the politics and nationalities of killers/victims, and an ******* murdered 16 innocent people. I hope the US doesn't let him run free.

I agree with you in the bigger picture, but as for the immediate future, I think the US should follow Karzai's request: pull its troops out of the villages and return to the big US bases. I think they should mostly hole up there while waiting for the "transition" to happen, and make that happen as early as possible (Karzai wants it to be in 2013 rather than in 2014).

I think this is probably more important than the specifics of how the shooter in this incident is handled.
 
Nonsense. Wildcat's conclusion was not based on anything but the difference in degree of public expressions of outrage over two different incidents. I pointed out that exactly the same difference can be observed here in the U.S.

But your analogy is wrong. They didn't just protest the q'ran burning as you know.

Freedom or other values? I don't see any difference. If you can construe Wildcat's conclusion as being true,
I don't have to construe anything, an Afghan Mullah said the same thing.

If you don't want to take Wildcat's word for it, take his.

But we're not talking about risk, are we? We're talking about relative values as measured by expressions of public outrage.
We were talking about human life, and its value. You are the one who kept bringing up "devaluation" and misinterpreting Wildcat's poisition. Go ahead and read again our exchange if you don't believe me. Now you're trying to change the conversation.

But I insist the same thinking be applied to the difference in public expression of outrage in Afghanistan.
Insist all you want, I still think Afghans think this life is less important than the other one, and that is why they feel more compelled to express outrage at a Q'ran burning than the killing of innocent villagers. It's the same reason why Muslims don't drink, they can't enjoy this life because they have to "prepare" for the other one.

And an Afghan atheists facebook page? Please... :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Isn't that very much like saying you don't see how Afghanistan could ever be a sovereign country?

No, again you're misinterpreting what he said. Either you're doing it deliberately or you're having problems with your comprehension of English.

Wildcat said nothing about sovereignty, he talks about their justice system not being on par with his (the US).

Saudi Arabia is a sovereing country, but would you want to be tried there?
 
Last edited:
An interesting article, which basically repeats Wildcat's argument:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/15/w...t-over-2-afghan-responses.html?_r=2&ref=world

That's a Muslim cleric saying that.

Yes, I think WildCat would be right to say that most Afghans value their religion more than individual lives although he did actually say they value a stupid book more than human life. That's why I have said that it might be instructive, from a practical point of view, to look at the Indian Mutiny of 1857 and try harder to avoid making those mistakes. Because if the Afghan Security Forces, that NATO/ISAF have been building up over the last ten years were to defect, desert, mutiny (which ever word you think most fitting here) then all the fragile gains are hopelessly and irretrievably lost.


I don't see how we could ever let such a place like Afghanistan try our soldiers for crimes. What if, for example, a married soldier is convicted of raping an Afghan woman and the sentence is he has to marry her? Even with murder, it wouldn't be unusual for the survivors to accept a cash payment instead of prison or execution. And then we'd have a case of a psychopath running free.

A US military court is the proper venue in this case.

Well, I think it needn't be either one thing or another. The US government could have made a deal by which the Afghan authorities only had a maximum possible sentence, i.e not stoning to death, or dunked in a bath of acid, but something humane like...er... the electric chair or the gas chamber.

On the other hand, as it is said that "Military justice is to justice what military music is to music", why not a criminal trial in the US. If Obama is serious about treating the murders of the Afghan family as being as equal to a murder of US civilians then the defendent would have a federal criminal trial.

Well, he turned himself in, so it's not like there is any possibility of a miscarriage of justice in this case, or do you disagree?

It depends on your definition of "miscarriage of justice". If you mean, it is highly unlikely they have the wrong man, then you are almost certainly correct, but miscarriages of justice can always happen at any time of legal proceedings.

Afghans seem to value their religious text more than human life because they think blasphemy is too high a risk for their eternal life than murder. Their criteria is different than ours because to them this life is of less importance.

Yes, this is probably true.
 
I don't see how we could ever let such a place like Afghanistan try our soldiers for crimes. What if, for example, a married soldier is convicted of raping an Afghan woman and the sentence is he has to marry her? Even with murder, it wouldn't be unusual for the survivors to accept a cash payment instead of prison or execution. And then we'd have a case of a psychopath running free.

Hang on! I seem to have misread this earlier.

Are you saying that you wouldn't hand over a US soldier to Afghan authorities because they may end up being too lenient on the murderer?
 
Light sentences, plea bargains, later sentence reductions, for murdering civilians. The only life-without-parole (for now, could be reduced) sentence in that article is for the gang-rape/murder of a 14-year old after also murdering her family: (ETA: also just noticed that this was the result of a US criminal court trial, not a military court)

This happens in our civilian courts too. My uncle shot three kids because they were Mexican and he's a racist butthole. They all survived but he still only got a ten year sentence (and this was not his first time doing something like this). Turns out they can't give out long sentences much anymore because the prisons are filled with drug offenders.
 
Agree. Waive SOFA. They can rend him limb from limb in public for all I care.
Practically speaking, this is insane. Can you imagine the Republican candidates and the right wing noise machine going gonzo if Obama turned over the AMERICAN SOLDIER to the locals for trial? It would be vicious and relentless. Worse, should the guy be killed, I guarantee you that there would be articles of impeachment for treason up for a House floor vote in the next 24 hours. They would pass and impeachment might well succeed in the Senate. No matter, it wouldn't even be worthwhile for Obama to run for a second term. Even the Dems would see the futility and nominate someone else.

No, it just ain't gonna happen.
 
Well, I think it needn't be either one thing or another. The US government could have made a deal by which the Afghan authorities only had a maximum possible sentence, i.e not stoning to death, or dunked in a bath of acid, but something humane like...er... the electric chair or the gas chamber.

You can't get a fair trial in Afghanistan.
 
Practically speaking, this is insane. Can you imagine the Republican candidates and the right wing noise machine going gonzo if Obama turned over the AMERICAN SOLDIER to the locals for trial? It would be vicious and relentless. Worse, should the guy be killed, I guarantee you that there would be articles of impeachment for treason up for a House floor vote in the next 24 hours. They would pass and impeachment might well succeed in the Senate. No matter, it wouldn't even be worthwhile for Obama to run for a second term. Even the Dems would see the futility and nominate someone else.

No, it just ain't gonna happen.

As a practical matter, yes, that is true. It might be possible to conduct the trial in Afghanistan though.
 
Maybe we should just pay the custimary blood money to the families of the deceased and try the crazy SOB in Kansas so we don't have to pay to ship his ass any farther until he croaks.
 
Maybe we should just pay the custimary blood money to the families of the deceased and try the crazy SOB in Kansas so we don't have to pay to ship his ass any farther until he croaks.

What if he really is "crazy" or his if behavior was triggered by prescription drugs and/or brain damage?
 
Karzai is asking NATO to leave villages, and the Taliban have scraped talks with the US

Reuters said:
Afghanistan's President Hamid Karzai called for NATO troops to leave Afghan villages after 16 civilians died in a shooting rampage by a U.S. soldier, underscoring Afghan fury over the massacre and clouding U.S. exit plans.

In a near-simultaneous statement, the Taliban said they were suspending nascent peace talks with the United States seen as a strong chance of ending the country's decade-long war, blaming "shaky, erratic and vague" U.S. statements.

Karzai, in a statement from his office after meeting U.S. Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, said as a result of the weekend massacre, "international security forces have to be taken out of Afghan village outposts and return to (larger) bases".

The soldier accused of carrying out the shooting was based at a small special forces compound similar to others around the country which underpin NATO's counter-insurgency strategy ahead of a 2014 deadline for most Western combat forces to pull out.

Karzai said the incident had harmed relations between Afghanistan and the United States and said "all efforts have to be done to avoid such incident in the future", warning it also had hurt the trust Afghans had in foreign forces.

The killings in Kandahar province on Sunday have raised questions about Western strategy in Afghanistan and intensified calls for the withdrawal of foreign combat troops.

The Taliban statement -- delivered in English as Panetta left the country -- was another blow to NATO hopes of a negotiated settlement to the war.

"The Islamic Emirate has decided to suspend all talks with Americans taking place in Qatar from (Thursday) onwards until the Americans clarify their stance on the issues concerned and until they show willingness in carrying out their promises instead of wasting time," the group said in a statement.

The Taliban also said talks with the government of Karzai's government were pointless and none had taken place.

Furious Afghan civilians and members of parliament have demanded the staff sergeant be tried in Afghanistan over the shooting, one of the worst of its kind since U.S.-backed Afghan forces toppled the Taliban in late 2001.

It's possible this one guy just set back what little tentative negotiations there were by years. I wonder if we'll see an early exit from Afghanistan, I remember seeing Karzai was requesting a 2013 exit date rather than 2014, also related to the shooting.
 
Karzai is asking NATO to leave villages, and the Taliban have scraped talks with the US



It's possible this one guy just set back what little tentative negotiations there were by years. I wonder if we'll see an early exit from Afghanistan, I remember seeing Karzai was requesting a 2013 exit date rather than 2014, also related to the shooting.

The Taliban's suspensions of negotiations is not, as far as I know, connected to the latest US massacre. I'm not sure that labeling the talks "little tentative negotiations" is accurate, either.
 
So again, my statement that the terms of other SOFAs are irrelevant to this incident. What matters are the terms of the U.S.'s SOFA with Afghanistan.

The terms of other SOFAs are irrelevent to this incident, but the terms of the US/A'stan SOFA are not all that matters in this case.


I disagree. We're bound by the SOFA. The language of the SOFA the result of the relationship between the US and the host nation, but we're legally bound by the terms of the SOFA.

We are not bound to follow the letter of the SOFA, and we often waive our jurisdiction under other SOFAs. It is our relationship with the host nation and our perception of the 'fairness' of the host nation legal system that determines our willingness to do so.


OK, I see your point now. If the SOFA gives jurisdiction to the US, the US could still waive that jurisdiction and let the guy be tried in Afghanistan if they chose to. But again, if the SOFA reserved jurisdiction to the host country, even though the US has the upper hand in the relationship, it would not have the authority to take jurisdiction. So the terms of the SOFA matter most (or at least first).

So far as I am aware, our SOFAs very rarely give the host nation jurisdiction to prosecute crimes of this nature - but the US does occasionally waive jurisdiction. The SOFA matters first, but our relationship with the host nation (more accurately, how much we care about our relationship with the host nation) matters most.


Again, as you pointed out, most of our SOFAs reserves jurisdiction for criminal matters like this to the host nation. Those terms are irrelevant. What matters is that the SOFA we have with Afghanistan gives jurisdiction to the US.

If I actually wrote that, I did so in error. Most (all that I know of) our SOFAs are essentially identical to the one we have with A'stan.


That's a pretty big thing, isn't it? In fact, that's pretty much the entire question. If the US didn't have jurisdiction, there would be no question of the US waiving its jurisdiction.

The US almost always has jurisdiction - and often waives jurisdiction. that is relevent. If the US has virtually identical SOFAs with most nations (it does), yet decides to waive jurisdiction to some host nations but not to others (it does), then it is not the language of the SOFA that is most important in determining whether or not to waive jurisdiction.




I was trying to figure out how other international law might come into play and perhaps trump our SOFA with Afghanistan.

I believe that the US takes the stance that its servicemembers will never be subject to international tribunals. I favor this approach, so long as the US treats its Soldier/criminals appropriately.
 
Afghanistan President Hamid Karzai Blasts U.S. Over Probe Into Shootings: 'It Is By All Means The End Of The Rope Here'
:

***... Afghanistan's president angrily accused the U.S. on Friday of not sharing information about how an American soldier allegedly shot and killed 16 Afghans in two villages.

...

In an emotional meeting with relatives of the shooting victims, Karzai said the villagers' accounts of the massacre were widely different from the scenario depicted by U.S. military officials. The relatives and villagers insisted that it was impossible for one gunmen to kill nine children, four men and three women in three houses of two villages near a U.S. combat outpost in southern Afghanistan.

Karzai pointed to one of the villagers from Panjwai district of Kandahar province and said:

"In his family, in four rooms people were killed – children and women were killed – and then they were all brought together in one room and then set on fire. That, one man cannot do."
***
 
Soldier identified

U.S. officials told NBC News on Friday that the soldier suspected of shooting 16 civilians in Afghanistan is Army Staff Sgt. Robert Bales.

Bales, 38, was deployed to Afghanistan in December with the 3rd Stryker Brigade, based out of Joint Base Lewis-McChord, south of Tacoma, Wash., the officials said.

Somebody should owe me ten dollars, but I will forgive this due to the recession.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom