Dragoonster
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Apr 11, 2008
- Messages
- 1,754
I don't see how we could ever let such a place like Afghanistan try our soldiers for crimes. What if, for example, a married soldier is convicted of raping an Afghan woman and the sentence is he has to marry her? Even with murder, it wouldn't be unusual for the survivors to accept a cash payment instead of prison or execution. And then we'd have a case of a psychopath running free.
A US military court is the proper venue in this case.
Afghanistan is not like Japan or Germany.
Those are good points, though I did include the alternative of the US trying him there, instead of overseas (for PR "hearts and minds" purposes, same reason as we should release his name soon). But I also don't trust our own courts to not let psychopaths run free.
http://www.nationaljournal.com/nationalsecurity/afghanistan-killings-not-the-first-time-20120312
some selections from that article:
The so-called “kill team” ringleader, Sgt. Calvin R. Gibbs, 25, was convicted in November of murdering the three unarmed civilians and sentenced to life in prison – although he’s eligible for parole in 8.5 years.
(...)
Behenna was initially sentenced to 25 years for unpremeditated murder in a combat zone. His term has since been reduced twice; he’s currently serving a 15-year sentence at Fort Leavenworth, Kan.
(...)
Eventually, Wuterich’s charges were reduced to manslaughter. He pleaded guilty this February to negligent dereliction of duty in the killing of the civilians in exchange for the dropping of assault and manslaughter charges and was given a general discharge from the Marine Corps under honorable conditions. According to The Los Angeles Times, Wuterich, who remained on active duty during the years of court proceedings, can still receive veteran’s benefits and won’t serve time behind bars. The others were cleared of their charges.
(...)
1st Lt. Jack Saville, an Army platoon leader involved in forcing the Iraqi civilians into the river, was sentenced in 2005 to 45 days in a military prison and given a $12,000 fine. Staff Sgt. Tracy Perkins, who gave the orders for the forced jump into the river, was acquitted of manslaughter but convicted of assault and obstruction of justice and sentenced to six months jail time.
Light sentences, plea bargains, later sentence reductions, for murdering civilians. The only life-without-parole (for now, could be reduced) sentence in that article is for the gang-rape/murder of a 14-year old after also murdering her family: [ETA: also just noticed that this was the result of a US criminal court trial, not a military court]
Green pled not guilty but was convicted of rape and murder. Though his trial was the first capital punishment case under a 2000 law allowing federal criminal courts to try crimes committed overseas by former members of the military, according to The New York Times, Green was spared the death penalty. He received a sentence in 2009 of life in prison without parole. The other four charged pleaded guilty or were convicted in military courts for their roles in the bloody raid; most received long prison terms, and all will be eligible for parole within the decade.
My "hearts and minds" reasons are probably moot since that's a war we have no chance of winning. But I also think this new psychopath deserves the death penalty, and the Afghans are far more likely to give it than the US military courts. Take away all the politics and nationalities of killers/victims, and an ******* murdered 16 innocent people. I hope the US doesn't let him run free.
Last edited:
(I just learned that the Afghani is the principle unit of currency.)