Terrible news from Afghanistan

So you're claiming that they think burning Korans is official US policy?
Is this question your way of abandoning your claim that the lack of violent protests is somehow evidence that Afghanis don't value human life?

[ETA: And no, I have claimed no such thing. However, I suspect that some Afghanis did consider the Koran burning as an official act based on official policy. In fact, the question you ducked was, "Don't you think it's even possible that there are Afghanis who value life greatly AND who understand that this killing spree wasn't official U.S. policy?" You quoted it and highlighted it in the quote, but my question is not that claim. And I note you have failed to answer the question.]

Perhaps there will yet be the large-scale riots we saw over the Koran burning, but so far there hasn't been. And this isn't the first case of US soldiers deliberately killing innocent civilians there, the previous case didn't provoke the large riots we saw over the Koran burning.

So your logic says that if they do have widespread violent protests over this incidents that lead to rioting and death it would prove that they do value human life?

And yet again, how do you distinguish your conclusion about the valuation of human life in Afghanistan from my observing that while many people in the U.S. demonstrate against even the threat of higher taxes, they didn't over recent school killing sprees? Doesn't it follow by the exact same reasoning that Americans don't value human life?
 
Last edited:
No, those aren't big enough.

By Wildcat's reasoning, to prove that they value life at least as much as they value the Koran, these public expressions of outrage should involve the killing of people.

I'm still not sure why he's unwilling to apply the same standard to U.S. expressions of outrage over the threat of raising taxes vs. the value of human life measured as expressions of outrage against school shooting sprees.
 
The problem there is that there's no target for outrage against school shootings, but there is a target when a shooter is US military.
 
OPTEMPO is I believe "Operations Tempo" - It means being busy every waking moment with things you HAVE to do to stay alive. Quite stressful.

Correct on the first part. The second part is not always true. A unit could have a very slow OPTEMPO or their OPTEMPO could be very fast. It just depends on the mission.

For the past decade, OPTEMPO within the Army itself has been very high for most units because they deploy, come back for a brief rest, train to deploy, then deploy again within a short time period. For some it has been a never ending cycle since we first invaded Afghanistan.
 
Is this question your way of abandoning your claim that the lack of violent protests is somehow evidence that Afghanis don't value human life?
I've seen no evidence that Afghan society values human life the way western societies do. In the west, for example, changing your religion is not seen as worthy of the death penalty. Nor is burning a book, or being gay. Or even murder in most countries.

[ETA: And no, I have claimed no such thing. However, I suspect that some Afghanis did consider the Koran burning as an official act based on official policy. In fact, the question you ducked was, "Don't you think it's even possible that there are Afghanis who value life greatly AND who understand that this killing spree wasn't official U.S. policy?" You quoted it and highlighted it in the quote, but my question is not that claim. And I note you have failed to answer the question.]
I'm talking about the society as a whole. I'm sure there's Afghanis who don't think apostacy should be a crime, nor burning a stupid book. But they are a minority. I think a society that has the death penalty for minor "crimes" is a society that doesn't value human life to the extent we do.

So your logic says that if they do have widespread violent protests over this incidents that lead to rioting and death it would prove that they do value human life?
I'm saying it's freaking insane that burning a book gets the reaction it does, with angry mobs calling for the heads of the book burners.

And yet again, how do you distinguish your conclusion about the valuation of human life in Afghanistan from my observing that while many people in the U.S. demonstrate against even the threat of higher taxes, they didn't over recent school killing sprees? Doesn't it follow by the exact same reasoning that Americans don't value human life?
Sorry, I'm, not seeing how this is at all analogous.
 
Last edited:
Are you sure of that? I thought most of our SOFA agreements didn't do that. (Indeed, I thought that was one reason why the U.S. refuses to sign on to the ICC.)

At any rate, it doesn't matter what the terms of most of our SOFA agreements are. It matters what the terms of our SOFA agreement with Afghanistan are.

<snip>


Do we even have a SOFA with Afghanistan? I thought that was one of the items on the agenda of the strategic partnership talks that we've been having.

I don't know if we have any formal agreements of any substance at all with them. It isn't like we were invited. For that matter, it isn't even all that clear who "they" are from one season to the next.
 
Last edited:
I've seen no evidence that Afghan society values human life the way western societies do. In the west, for example, changing your religion is not seen as worthy of the death penalty. Nor is burning a book, or being gay. Or even murder in most countries.

Ah the old "my way or the highway argument" - very noble
 
Last edited:
Why no Afghan riot after deadly rampage?

[EDIT: And this article quotes Prince Ali Seraj, the head of the National Coalition for Dialogue with the Tribes of Afghanistan, as saying basically the same thing.]

That was yesterday.

Afghanistan militants attack Kandahar killings site

Afghan protest flares over US soldier's massacre

That's today.
In the Koran instance, the first imam and first mullah to hear of it were likely quickly in the streets fomenting riots in mobs many of who agreed on the holiness of the book.

The massacre-murder of women & children in a patriarchal society takes a while for outrage to build to the riots stage; not enough Chaos-like-America-hater cheerleaders either, and fewer still outside immediate family to be enraged.

just my 2cts. ;)
 
In the Koran instance, the first imam and first mullah to hear of it were likely quickly in the streets fomenting riots in mobs many of who agreed on the holiness of the book.

The massacre-murder of women & children in a patriarchal society takes a while for outrage to build to the riots stage; not enough Chaos-like-America-hater cheerleaders either, and fewer still outside immediate family to be enraged.

just my 2cts. ;)

It is hardly as though only the immediate family are enraged. It only takes a modicum of empathy to imagine that most Afghans will be furious about an occupying soldier going on the rampage.

12.39 Abdul Rahim Ayubi, a Kandahar politician, has been speaking about the earlier attack on officials:

Today, the Kandahar governor was trying to explain to the villagers that he was only one soldier, that he was not a sane person and that he was sick.

But the people were just shouting and they were very angry. They didn't listen to the governor. They accused him of defending the Americans instead of defending the Kandahari people.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/afghanistan/9139876/Afghanistan-shooting-live.html
 
****"This latest assault was reportedly the work of a single soldier, but many Afghans won't believe or care that it was not another routine US raid. The effects are the same," said Ann Jones, author of the 2006 book Kabul in Winter and a prominent critic of US counterinsurgency tactics in Afghanistan.

"US officials miss the point entirely, insisting this massacre was a one-off tragedy, when Afghans know something like it will happen again any day."
****

[Source]
 
Last edited:
****"This latest assault was reportedly the work of a single soldier, but many Afghans won't believe or care that it was not another routine US raid. The effects are the same," said Ann Jones, author of the 2006 book Kabul in Winter and a prominent critic of US counterinsurgency tactics in Afghanistan.

"US officials miss the point entirely, insisting this massacre was a one-off tragedy, when Afghans know something like it will happen again any day."
****

[Source]

Yeah, looking around the web for the US-Afghan SOFA, I noticed that Karzai had been reluctant to agree to one unless night-time raids were ended.

It makes you wonder what kind of government Afghanistan has when it cannot prevent occupying forces from kicking in the doors of houses in the middle of the night.

Anyway, I think we can guess from this that there is a hell of a lot of resentment already there and some incidents such as drone strikes resulting in "collateral damage" (i.e killing people attending weddings) pissing on corpses, burning Korans, drunkenly blowing away a family (Hey! It's okay; the Afghans don't value human life!) are more likely to spark a major backlash.

I have to wonder how loyal the Afghan Security Forces can be considered to be and what ensures their loyalty. Anyone know?
 
Last edited:
In a civilan case establishing the persons mental state would have a high priority. In a military tribunal I am not sure if such considerations are taken into account

They are, at least in Canadian Courts Martial, and I would be surprised if they weren't in US cases. However, like civilian trials, unless the Defense is trying to establish that the accused is incapable of forming the men's rea of an offense then the accused's mental state is something that isn't considered until the sentencing phase.
 
The problem there is that there's no target for outrage against school shootings, but there is a target when a shooter is US military.

But Wildcat's claim is not about objection to US presence or US policy. It's about not valuing human life. He draws this conclusions (erroneously) from the lack of (or at least lesser degree of) public expressions of outrage.

Also, FWIW, I think there is actually a lot of cause for outrage of school shootings. There is at least as much cause for outrage there as there is for the possibility of slightly higher taxes. For example, I find it outrageous that some gun owners are so irresponsible with their weapons that kids have easy access to them. I just want to avoid going on that tangent since it's not really relevant. We're not talking about any other cause for public outcry other than how much people value human life.

My position is that you can't draw such a conclusion from the evidence of how much public outcry there is in response to various events.

Sure there are cultural difference, but it's an unreasonable assessment of cultural difference to claim that they don't value human life "over there". It's just biased thinking. We might condemn a religious zealot or a suicidal nationalist, but at the same time we say dulce et decorum est when someone in our culture makes the ultimate sacrifice for something they view as greater than their own life.
 
I've seen no evidence that Afghan society values human life the way western societies do.

"Give me liberty or give me death."

"I regret that I have but one life to give for my country."

And again, "Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori."

Indeed the dominant religion of modern Western civilization, Christianity, is based on the idea that the greatest expression of God's love for humans is to sacrifice himself (sort of) in a perverse system of justice to atone for original sin and save mankind (from its own God-given nature, I assume).

And again, your logic is flawed. You're essentially basing a conclusion on a lack of evidence.

Do you suppose something about the culture "over there" has made them less than human?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom