Terrible news from Afghanistan

Yeah, looking around the web for the US-Afghan SOFA, I noticed that Karzai had been reluctant to agree to one unless night-time raids were ended.

It makes you wonder what kind of government Afghanistan has when it cannot prevent occupying forces from kicking in the doors of houses in the middle of the night.

<snip>


One with a smaller army than the U.S.?

That's one of those funny things about being invaded and occupied by a superior force. You don't get to make a lot of rules.
 
It makes you wonder what kind of government Afghanistan has when it cannot prevent occupying forces from kicking in the doors of houses in the middle of the night.

For some reason, the word "puppet" comes to mind.

Again, what exactly is our continuing mission in Afghanistan? I thought we'd sworn off nation-building.
 
One with a smaller army than the U.S.?

That's one of those funny things about being invaded and occupied by a superior force. You don't get to make a lot of rules.

Correct!

For some reason, the word "puppet" comes to mind.

Again, what exactly is our continuing mission in Afghanistan? I thought we'd sworn off nation-building.

I don't think there is a mission as such. It is a military operation in search of an objective.
 
"Give me liberty or give me death."

"I regret that I have but one life to give for my country."

And again, "Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori."

Indeed the dominant religion of modern Western civilization, Christianity, is based on the idea that the greatest expression of God's love for humans is to sacrifice himself (sort of) in a perverse system of justice to atone for original sin and save mankind (from its own God-given nature, I assume).

And again, your logic is flawed. You're essentially basing a conclusion on a lack of evidence.

Do you suppose something about the culture "over there" has made them less than human?
"less than human"? :rolleyes:

Unfortunately, all too human:
Despite the deepening antipathy to US forces in the country, Afghanistan had largely been calm since Sunday’s killings, leaving unrealized Western fears of a repeat of the unrest that spread across the country last month after the burning of Koran by US soldiers. The only demonstration since Sunday took place Tuesday morning in the city of Jalalabad in eastern Afghanistan, where about 1,000 people burned an effigy of Obama and blocked a highway for about an hour, chanting “Death to America’’ and “Death to the Jews.’’
http://www.bostonglobe.com/news/wor...n-civilians/ryRsTsGGaLybg8KFGCgseN/story.html

Well there's the first demonstration, unfortunately they decided that the Jews must also die along with America. I guess they just throw them in for good measure, you can't go wrong blaming/killing the Jews.
 
Last edited:
But Wildcat's claim is not about objection to US presence or US policy. It's about not valuing human life. He draws this conclusions (erroneously) from the lack of (or at least lesser degree of) public expressions of outrage.

Life is cheap in Afghanistan. He's right, you're wrong.
 
Life is cheap in Afghanistan. He's right, you're wrong.

If this is true, so what ?

I suspect the value of life is something which changes according to circumstances. If "we" kill one of "them" then the the value of life is lower than in "they" kill one of "us".

Are you proposing to say to the families of those killed and their communities "quite frankly, you lot value life cheaply, so stop making such a fuss about a relatively trivial affair".

I don't think that will wash. When a member of an occupying force goes on a killing spree it tends to make waves.
 
Are you sure of that? I thought most of our SOFA agreements didn't do that. (Indeed, I thought that was one reason why the U.S. refuses to sign on to the ICC.)

I am sure that at least in practice, US Servicemembers that commit crimes not extending from military duty are subject to local jurisdiction first. Of course, in most of the nations that have a functioning SOFA with the US, the US is no longer (or never was) an occupying force.

At any rate, it doesn't matter what the terms of most of our SOFA agreements are. It matters what the terms of our SOFA agreement with Afghanistan are.

It matters to our discussion. In most other places, with a crime of this type, the host nation would get right of first refusal regardless of what the SOFA says. I agree that A'stan is not like most other nations that we have a SOFA with - and that certainly impacts our willingness to forfeit custody for most crimes. If a Soldier causes an auto accident that results in injury/death to a LN, I wouldn't expect the US to turn him over to Afghani officials - which is what would probably happen in Korea, Japan, or Germany for example.

Sadly, I think those terms reflect the relationship between the U.S. and the host country. And in this case, it's clearly not one of two sovereign nations negotiating on equal footing.

If the attached document (previous post) contains the entire SOFA, it doesn't seem to differ much from SOFAs during the first decade of our occupation of Germany/Japan/Korea. Indeed, in comparison to Japan, Afghanistan seems to have retained more authority.

Still, you are essentially correct - the US and Afghanistan do not trade as equals.
 
In most other places, with a crime of this type, the host nation would get right of first refusal regardless of what the SOFA says.

Huh? So if the SOFA said that the host nation doesn't have jurisdiction, the host nation would still get jurisdiction (based on the nature of the SOFAs the U.S. has in other countries)? The specifics of the SOFA we have with Afghanistan really are what matters.

The U.S. is not a signatory to the ICC.
 
Last edited:
So anyway..

How does the US and Afghanistan move forward from this tragedy?


I would think at the very least the U.S. needs to give a clear definition of the continuing mission it has there. If that mission has been fulfilled, we should withdraw as soon as is feasible. If not, we should figure out how to fulfill that mission.

We're definitely losing the battle for hearts and minds.
 
I'm sure it will blow over soon. It's not like he burned a Koran.

I'm not kidding. I predict that the fallout from this will be less than the fallout from the Koran burnings. Sad, but true.

WildCat said:
No big deal, no Korans were harmed. I predict no rioting Afghans over this.

The NY Times confirms this.

In Reactions to Two Incidents, a U.S.-Afghan Disconnect

KABUL, Afghanistan — The mullah was astounded and a little angered to be asked why the accidental burning of Korans last month could provoke violence nationwide, while an intentional mass murder that included nine children last Sunday did not.

“How can you compare the dishonoring of the Holy Koran with the martyrdom of innocent civilians?” said an incredulous Mullah Khaliq Dad, a member of the council of religious leaders who investigated the Koran burnings. “The whole goal of our life is religion.”

That many Americans are just as surprised that what appears to be the massacre of 16 people at the hands of an American soldier has not led to mass protests or revenge killings speaks volumes about a fundamental disconnect with their Afghan partners, one that has undermined a longstanding objective to win the hearts and minds of the population. After more than 10 years, many deaths and billions of dollars invested, Americans still fail to grasp the Afghans’ basic values. Faith is paramount and a death can be compensated with blood money.

“To Muslims, and especially to Afghans, religion is much higher a concern than civilian or human casualties,” said Hafez Abdul Qayoom, a member of Afghanistan’s highest clerical body, the Ulema Council. “When something happens to their religion, they are much more sensitive and have much stronger reaction to it.”
 
Well, the guy is not going to be tried in Afghanistan:

The soldier was held by the US military in Kandahar until Wednesday evening, when he was flown out of the country "based on legal recommendation", Pentagon spokesman Capt John Kirby said.

"We do not have appropriate detention facilities in Afghanistan," Capt Kirby said.

A Nato official later confirmed to the BBC that the suspect had been flown to Kuwait.

Members of the Afghan parliament had demanded that he should be put on trial in their country.

But the BBC's Paul Adams in Washington says this was never going to happen. The US has always insisted that charges of wrongdoing by its soldiers be dealt with within the American military legal system.

US officials say the soldier handed himself in. Mr Panetta has said that if found guilty, he could face the death penalty.

Officials said the soldier had completed several tours in Iraq but was on his first tour of duty in Afghanistan.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-17375761
 

The point the quote misses is that the massacre is not considered by Afghans to be unusual or unexpected. Every Afghan goes to bed knowing that, by morning, they may be dead from a random night raid by drug-addled, foreign soldiers of occupation. Nevertheless, the massacre is still likely speed the occupiers' departure and some more people will be killed because of it.
 
Huh? So if the SOFA said that the host nation doesn't have jurisdiction, the host nation would still get jurisdiction (based on the nature of the SOFAs the U.S. has in other countries)?

Yes, the US will often cede jurisdiction to the host nation, but not based on the nature of the SOFAs the US has with other countries. While each SOFA is a unique treaty between the US and the host nation, most of our SOFAs are essentially the same. What matters more than the actual language of the SOFA is the relationship between the US and the host nation. The closer we are to being equals, the more alike the US/host nation judicial systems are, and the more we desire/need continued good relations with the host nation, the more likely the US is to waive jurisdiction.



The specifics of the SOFA we have with Afghanistan really are what matters.

No, the relationship between the US and A'stan, the relative "power" of each nation, and the likely reaction of US citizens to "abandoning" a service member to Afghani "barbarism" are really what matters when discussing the lieklyhood that the US would waive jurisdiction. The actual SOFA itself is only important in that it provides the US with the sole decision making authority.

The U.S. is not a signatory to the ICC.

True - but why is this significant? I don't see a connection between our refusal to subject US Servicemen to the jurisdiction of the ICC and our actions under a SOFA (any SOFA).
 
The point the quote misses is that the massacre is not considered by Afghans to be unusual or unexpected. Every Afghan goes to bed knowing that, by morning, they may be dead from a random night raid by drug-addled, foreign soldiers of occupation. Nevertheless, the massacre is still likely speed the occupiers' departure and some more people will be killed because of it.

Can you source this?

I've been to Afghanistan, and in my experience, the average Afghani was more afraid of being killed in a night raid by domestic thugs than by foreign Soldiers. Indeed, to the extent that Afghani civilians were afraid of being killed by US forces, their greater fear was of a random UAV strike. I was never aware of any significant percentage of Soldiers (US, anyway) being drug-addled.
 
Well whatever the reason for the lack of deadly riots I'm glad that things are peaceful. Now if things can just remain somewhat calm until we finally get our butts out of there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom