Terrible news from Afghanistan

Hang on! I seem to have misread this earlier.

Are you saying that you wouldn't hand over a US soldier to Afghan authorities because they may end up being too lenient on the murderer?
It's certainly possible. I don't know what the justice system is like with the current Afghan government but traditionally there if a murder victim's family is willing to accept a cash payment for the death that's the end of it. Alternatively, members of the family can opt to personally kill the accused instead.
 
Soldier identified



Somebody should owe me ten dollars, but I will forgive this due to the recession.

Well, your bet was that his name would be revealed once charges were officially filed. His name was revealed before then, which was what I was hoping and advocating for. Don't see why I should send you ten bucks!
 
JEEZE, GET A CLUE!

The guy flipped out. he is CRAZY! NUTS Whacko!

And there is NO damn "Cover Up"

Nasty Neil

101st Airborne Div.
 
And there is NO damn "Cover Up"

Karzhai did raise an interesting question the other day. He mentions that all the dead were gathered in one place to be burned. They were killed in different houses. Seems a little strange that one drunk person with a part of his foot blown off in an earlier fight would go to this trouble.

There havebeen conflicting reports as to how many shooters there were. It is concieveable that only one man did the shooting and others helped gather the bodies.

Bear in mind that the shooter is from a unit which, in the past had a case of several soldiers going on a rampage as a group.

Possibility exists that the shooter is covering for the clean-up detail.
 
JEEZE, GET A CLUE!

The guy flipped out. he is CRAZY! NUTS Whacko!

And there is NO damn "Cover Up"

I'm not sure anyone is claiming there is a cover-up. There is definitely a problem in the struggle to win the hearts and minds of the people of Afghanistan with whisking him out of country quickly and not even allowing Afghan authorities to conduct any independent investigation.

U.S. authorities aren't even claiming to have any evidence of what happened other than the statement of the "CRAZY! NUTS Whacko!" guy, and the video of his return to the base. The fact that Afghanistan has found evidence (witness testimony and apparently some physical evidence--Karzai says the people were killed in 4 different rooms, then all the bodies moved to one room where they were set afire) that conflicts with the theory of the case that the U.S. has is a pretty big deal.

Even without surrendering the guy for prosecution by Afghanistan, the US could have been a lot more cooperative.
 
Detailed service

The truth will come out; I'm not going to indulge conspiracy theories or claims of systemic problems at this point.

Bear in mind that the shooter is from a unit which, in the past had a case of several soldiers going on a rampage as a group.

Sergeant, I'm disappointed in this claim. If you're referring to SSG Gibbs and the "Kill Team", they were in separate BCTs within 2d ID. For a soldier, being in different platoons in different companies in different battalions in different BCTs is a significant degree of separation; it's like a different world.
 
Yeah, the story I hear about Bales seems a bit contradictory. Everyone says he's a nice guy, but he has a record of some incident with a woman where he was sentenced to anger management. I realize there's a huge leap from something like that to a massacre like this, but then again there's a huge distance from Seattle to a small village in Afghanistan.
 
Well, your bet was that his name would be revealed once charges were officially filed. His name was revealed before then, which was what I was hoping and advocating for. Don't see why I should send you ten bucks!

Too late - I preemptively forgave the debt, so you have no standing to challenge its veracity!
 
It's certainly possible. I don't know what the justice system is like with the current Afghan government but traditionally there if a murder victim's family is willing to accept a cash payment for the death that's the end of it.

I guess anything is "possible" but I'd rate this possibility at as near to zero as makes any difference. One of the village elders said, "We don't want money and we want justice and we want them to be tried in Afghanistan."

Karzai said, "We asked for justice rather than compensation."

And Bales' lawyer is dead set against a trial in Afghanistan (even a U.S. military trial conducted there)--and I presume that position is in the best interest of his client.
 
They probably heard of My Lai and Abu Ghraib. They know that the American won´t give this guy anything but a slap on a wrist.
They know no such thing, unless you believe in Woo and Sylvia Browne being truthful.

I'm willing to see what the courts decide, though I already note that the "PTSD defense" issue has already leaped onto the pages of American media sources.

Whatever you think will happen, you have no crystal ball. Guy is eligible for the death penalty, under the UCMJ.

We'll see. And it will take a year or so, I expect. Maybe more.
 
Maybe we should just pay the custimary blood money to the families of the deceased and try the crazy SOB in Kansas so we don't have to pay to ship his ass any farther until he croaks.

Not a bad idea. *tips cap*

EDIT:

Note to Mr Karzai.

You owe your position to the foreign powers in Afghanistan. I find it rather funny that you are whinging about what you want.

You don't get what you want, since you have little power.
Your path to power leaves you with severe limits on your ability to act, or to get any leverage.

You
Have
No
Leverage


Best wishes in getting what you want, bitch.

You were Bush's bitch, and you are now Obama's bitch.
 
Last edited:
Funny, the very people who were whining that KSM should have a fair trial are the same asking for Bales to be handed over to Afghan tribal justice...
 
Not a bad idea. *tips cap*

EDIT:

Note to Mr Karzai.

You owe your position to the foreign powers in Afghanistan. I find it rather funny that you are whinging about what you want.

You don't get what you want, since you have little power.
Your path to power leaves you with severe limits on your ability to act, or to get any leverage.

You
Have
No
Leverage


Best wishes in getting what you want, bitch.

You were Bush's bitch, and you are now Obama's bitch.



That's the spirit. No reference to what it is morally correct, just a gung-ho statement that might makes right.


We should send you as an envoy
 
Up to 20 US troops executed Panjwai massacre: probe

A parliamentary probe team on Thursday said up to 20 American troops were involved in Sunday’s killing of 16 civilians in southern Kandahar province.

The probing delegation includes lawmakers Hamidzai Lali, Abdul Rahim Ayubi, Shakiba Hashimi, Syed Mohammad Akhund and Bismillah Afghanmal, all representing Kandahar province at the Wolesi Jirga and Abdul Latif Padram, a lawmaker from northern Badakhshan province, Mirbat Mangal, Khost province, Muhammad Sarwar Usmani, Farah province.

The team spent two days in the province, interviewing the bereaved families, tribal elders, survivors and collecting evidences at the site in Panjwai district. [...]
 
You owe your position to the foreign powers in Afghanistan. I find it rather funny that you are whinging about what you want.

You don't get what you want, since you have little power.
Your path to power leaves you with severe limits on your ability to act, or to get any leverage.

You
Have
No
Leverage


Best wishes in getting what you want, bitch.

You were Bush's bitch, and you are now Obama's bitch.

Don't you hate it when those uppity puppets act like they actually have their own sovereign nation?

But I find it deeply problematic that if your position is actually that of NATO and the U.S. (and even the U.N.) that none of them will say so publicly.
 
That site claims the earth is visited by alien spaceships.

Do you believe in alien spaceships Jane?

I don't believe in alien spaceships, but that headline is certainly true: many of the villages are saying that the killing spree was not the work of just one guy. Indeed, Karzai even doubts that it was just one guy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom