Which part - turning him over to the democratically elected goverment under whose jurisdiction he committed the crimes, or the "tear limb from limb" part?
The "tearing limb from limb" part, obviously. As it happens, Afghanistan is about as democratic as Iran so fortunately it doesn't matter what the people think. And even if it did it is one of the most corrupt countries in the world so it still wouldn't matter what the people think. Unless, of course, the people overthrow their corrupt and authoritarian leaders and install their own corrupt and authoritarian leaders.
I personally oppose punishments that I consider cruel, and my definition of "cruel" generally matches that provided by the SCOTUS. Other nations disagree, and often refuse to return fugitives to US custody because to do so would expose them to the possibility of capital punishment. It irks me when this happens. It is hypocritical to deny the Afghani's the same measure of justice. That I find their method of punishment unacceptable is about as perfectly irrelevent as an opinion can be.
What is the method of punishment that exists in Afghanistan? As far as I know, one of them is being shot in the head with an AK-47 in a football stadium. It's rather low tech but far less obviously cruel then, say, the electric chair.
The citizens of many western nations consider reprehensible the notion that a convicted murder should be returned to the US to face the possibility of execution. I don't concern myself much with their concern, and I can't imagine why an Afghani would care over much about how I feel about their method of execution.
I think if you think something is right then you think it is right. I doubt very much that you would wish to extradict a gay Afghan man or an Afghan apostate to Afghanistan to be stoned to death.
Devoid of context, "barbaric" is a meaningless term.
Really? If I fancy a woman, follow her home, bash in her skull with a brick and rape her while she's dying and then leave her to die that would not be barbaric if devoid of context?
In my opinion, some things are barbaric or the term if the term has any meaning at all.
Much of the world considers many things we do "barbaric".
And maybe they are right.
He committed his crimes in Afghanistan. He was not acting as a Soldier when he committed his crimes. Had he committed exactly the same crimes in most nations where US forces are stationed, he would be subject to host-nation jurisdiction. I do not consider allowing him to avoid an unpleasant fate to be worth the effort. The greater good would be served by allowing the Afghani's to try and punish him. frankly, rending and tearing is not a realistic outcome.
Yes, I agree that he could and probably should be tried under Afghan law. But I am pretty sure that it would make sense for the US to prevent some gory, public, tearing and rending.
This man has committed a terrible atrocity and should indeed be punished. I think it is only human, alas, to think that only a comparably brutal and cruel form of execution can compensate for it. But human laws should not operate according to our basest feelings.
Here endeth the sermon.