Terrible news from Afghanistan

Agree. Waive SOFA. They can rend him limb from limb in public for all I care.

I would be in favor of this too if it will help mend feelings.

But, but, but Bush!

That drooling moron was the pitchman for an utterly ridiculous conspiracy which you've swallowed hook, line, and sinker.

You still don't get that most people here (including myself) hated Bush do you? We don't base what we believe off of who we happen to hate.
 
Just watching this video on the BBC here:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-17349736

Although the demonstration they are showing looks pretty small, I think it is interesting that they are burning a cross as well as an Obama effigy.

Does anyone know if there has been widespread distrust of American, British and other NATO/ISAF soldiers for any perception that they are Christian or prosyletizers?

I only wonder because I am currently reading an ... *ahem!* ... history book about the Indian Mutiny in 1857 and how a range of factors built up into a full-scale uprising against the East India Company troops.

One of the biggest grievances, as well as generally being occupied and of the native troops being told they may have to serve in places they didn't want to, was the perception that the East India Company was there to convert Hindus and Muslims to Christianity. The Company protested that it didn't intend to anything more than end a few barbaric practices such as suttee and suppress the Thugees but for the rest it merely sought to build roads, schools and hospitals.

But, a rumour got about that the bullets being distributed to the native troops were greased with pig and cow fat which seems to have been the last straw.

I can't help but see a few parallels here:

suttee = stoning of apostates
Thugees = Taliban
roads, schools and hospitals = roads, schools and hospitals
greased with pig and cow fat = burning of Korans
 
Speculating is fun, for sure........

The murderer will be tried and convicted and sentenced to at least life without parole. Alternatively, it is just barely possible the US will waive SOFA protecions and surrender him to the Afghani goverment for trial. If ever there was a situation where waiving SOFA would be appropriate, this one seems to be it.

I give crap all about his mild TBI from a vehicle accident. I give crap all about the OPTEMPO he's experienced before. I give crap all about any other excuse anyone may make for him. His actions immediately threaten the lives of US Servicemen, and death is an appropriate punishment.

Good call sarge. Thousands of us have experienced the exact same OPTEMPO as him and had TBI. Yet, you don't see thousands of us soldiers going on killing sprees. He is a lone nutcase and the punishment should be as harsh as possible.
 
Agree. Waive SOFA. They can rend him limb from limb in public for all I care.

I would be in favor of this too if it will help mend feelings.

I think it would be a disgraceful thing to do and you really need to worry if the people whose feelings you want to mend will have their feelings mended by seeing someone have his limbs torn off him in public.

It doesn't matter what he has done, sinking to the level of a barbarian would only suggest to people (even the people you may be trying to placate) that that is what you are.
 
I think it would be a disgraceful thing to do

Which part - turning him over to the democratically elected goverment under whose jurisdiction he committed the crimes, or the "tear limb from limb" part?


I personally oppose punishments that I consider cruel, and my definition of "cruel" generally matches that provided by the SCOTUS. Other nations disagree, and often refuse to return fugitives to US custody because to do so would expose them to the possibility of capital punishment. It irks me when this happens. It is hypocritical to deny the Afghani's the same measure of justice. That I find their method of punishment unacceptable is about as perfectly irrelevent as an opinion can be.

and you really need to worry if the people whose feelings you want to mend will have their feelings mended by seeing someone have his limbs torn off him in public.

The citizens of many western nations consider reprehensible the notion that a convicted murder should be returned to the US to face the possibility of execution. I don't concern myself much with their concern, and I can't imagine why an Afghani would care over much about how I feel about their method of execution.

It doesn't matter what he has done, sinking to the level of a barbarian would only suggest to people (even the people you may be trying to placate) that that is what you are.

Devoid of context, "barbaric" is a meaningless term. Much of the world considers many things we do "barbaric". He committed his crimes in Afghanistan. He was not acting as a Soldier when he committed his crimes. Had he committed exactly the same crimes in most nations where US forces are stationed, he would be subject to host-nation jurisdiction. I do not consider allowing him to avoid an unpleasant fate to be worth the effort. The greater good would be served by allowing the Afghani's to try and punish him. frankly, rending and tearing is not a realistic outcome.
 
I disagree with the idea of waiving the SOFA in this matter. The issue of criminal trials is there for a reason, and is there to broadly ensure that national sovereignty is respected.

I do believe that the member's trial needs to take place quickly, that it needs to be very well publicized in Afghanistan, and that punishment needs to be appropriate. Given that he turned himself in, it shouldn't be too difficult to convict.

On a crass note - get ready to write a lot of ex gratia cheques to the survivors.
 
We demanded that they give us ObL. When they refused, we blew up most of their infrastructure.

Give them the shooter and stop whining about the riots.
 
We demanded that they give us ObL. When they refused, we blew up most of their infrastructure.

Give them the shooter and stop whining about the riots.

I am going to go out on a limb here and say that the two situations at hand are a bit different...

But I do however see where you are coming from wanting to hand him over to the Afghanis.
 
I disagree with the idea of waiving the SOFA in this matter. The issue of criminal trials is there for a reason, and is there to broadly ensure that national sovereignty is respected.

Actually, SOFAs exist for the explicit purpose of circumventing national sovereignty. Only by waiving the SOFA may the US respect the national sovereignty of the valid goverment of Afghanistan. The entire crime was committed in A'stan and all of the victims were A'stani citizens.

I do believe that the member's trial needs to take place quickly, that it needs to be very well publicized in Afghanistan, and that punishment needs to be appropriate. Given that he turned himself in, it shouldn't be too difficult to convict.

The trial, if it is to be conducted by the US, should occur in Afghanistan under the applicable provisions of the MCM, and the punishment should occur in Afghanistan with complete transparency.
 
The essence of execution is violent. Once they try and convict him they can do it as they see fit. This will be their decision.

The essence of execution is that it is fatal. This hardly means that anything goes when proceeding from A to B. I wouldn't think that dissolving him in acid or stoning him to death would be an execution that the US could countenance even if they decided to make an exception with the SOFA in this case. If the US were to do this presumably they would make a deal that a maximum penalty can be imposed. Saying that he should be torn limb from limb before you have even had the preliminary trials is exactly what I mean when I say it is barbaric: it is arbitrary, emotional and retributive.
 
I don't know why this is shocking to anyone, decades of war make life cheap.

This conclusion still no more follows from the evidence than does the conclusion that life is cheap to Americans who demonstrate for other reasons but not over deaths (for example of school shooting sprees).

It's still false and idiotic to claim that to Afghanis (or any other group) life is cheap because they don't demonstrate or protest* over a killing spree.

*ETA: To as great an extent as they did in other protests or reactions (see Fishstick's post #99).

ETA: Don't you think it's even possible that there are Afghanis who value life greatly AND who understand that this killing spree wasn't official U.S. policy? Indeed, Afghanis aren't even homogenous on the subject of whether or not they still want the U.S. military presence in their country. Your leap of logic is not supported by any evidence.
 
Last edited:
Which part - turning him over to the democratically elected goverment under whose jurisdiction he committed the crimes, or the "tear limb from limb" part?

The "tearing limb from limb" part, obviously. As it happens, Afghanistan is about as democratic as Iran so fortunately it doesn't matter what the people think. And even if it did it is one of the most corrupt countries in the world so it still wouldn't matter what the people think. Unless, of course, the people overthrow their corrupt and authoritarian leaders and install their own corrupt and authoritarian leaders.

I personally oppose punishments that I consider cruel, and my definition of "cruel" generally matches that provided by the SCOTUS. Other nations disagree, and often refuse to return fugitives to US custody because to do so would expose them to the possibility of capital punishment. It irks me when this happens. It is hypocritical to deny the Afghani's the same measure of justice. That I find their method of punishment unacceptable is about as perfectly irrelevent as an opinion can be.

What is the method of punishment that exists in Afghanistan? As far as I know, one of them is being shot in the head with an AK-47 in a football stadium. It's rather low tech but far less obviously cruel then, say, the electric chair.

The citizens of many western nations consider reprehensible the notion that a convicted murder should be returned to the US to face the possibility of execution. I don't concern myself much with their concern, and I can't imagine why an Afghani would care over much about how I feel about their method of execution.

I think if you think something is right then you think it is right. I doubt very much that you would wish to extradict a gay Afghan man or an Afghan apostate to Afghanistan to be stoned to death.

Devoid of context, "barbaric" is a meaningless term.

Really? If I fancy a woman, follow her home, bash in her skull with a brick and rape her while she's dying and then leave her to die that would not be barbaric if devoid of context?

In my opinion, some things are barbaric or the term if the term has any meaning at all.

Much of the world considers many things we do "barbaric".

And maybe they are right.

He committed his crimes in Afghanistan. He was not acting as a Soldier when he committed his crimes. Had he committed exactly the same crimes in most nations where US forces are stationed, he would be subject to host-nation jurisdiction. I do not consider allowing him to avoid an unpleasant fate to be worth the effort. The greater good would be served by allowing the Afghani's to try and punish him. frankly, rending and tearing is not a realistic outcome.

Yes, I agree that he could and probably should be tried under Afghan law. But I am pretty sure that it would make sense for the US to prevent some gory, public, tearing and rending.

This man has committed a terrible atrocity and should indeed be punished. I think it is only human, alas, to think that only a comparably brutal and cruel form of execution can compensate for it. But human laws should not operate according to our basest feelings.

Here endeth the sermon.
 
Had he committed exactly the same crimes in most nations where US forces are stationed, he would be subject to host-nation jurisdiction.

Are you sure of that? I thought most of our SOFA agreements didn't do that. (Indeed, I thought that was one reason why the U.S. refuses to sign on to the ICC.)

At any rate, it doesn't matter what the terms of most of our SOFA agreements are. It matters what the terms of our SOFA agreement with Afghanistan are.

Sadly, I think those terms reflect the relationship between the U.S. and the host country. And in this case, it's clearly not one of two sovereign nations negotiating on equal footing.
 
This conclusion still no more follows from the evidence than does the conclusion that life is cheap to Americans who demonstrate for other reasons but not over deaths (for example of school shooting sprees).

It's still false and idiotic to claim that to Afghanis (or any other group) life is cheap because they don't demonstrate or protest* over a killing spree.

*ETA: To as great an extent as they did in other protests or reactions (see Fishstick's post #99).

ETA: Don't you think it's even possible that there are Afghanis who value life greatly AND who understand that this killing spree wasn't official U.S. policy? Indeed, Afghanis aren't even homogenous on the subject of whether or not they still want the U.S. military presence in their country. Your leap of logic is not supported by any evidence.
So you're claiming that they think burning Korans is official US policy?

Perhaps there will yet be the large-scale riots we saw over the Koran burning, but so far there hasn't been. And this isn't the first case of US soldiers deliberately killing innocent civilians there, the previous case didn't provoke the large riots we saw over the Koran burning.

And for those demanding he be turned over to the Afghans, bear in mind this may be the result of mental illness or brain trauma, something the Afghan justice system (such as it is) is poorly equipped to deal with.
 
Good call sarge. Thousands of us have experienced the exact same OPTEMPO as him and had TBI. Yet, you don't see thousands of us soldiers going on killing sprees. He is a lone nutcase and the punishment should be as harsh as possible.

I'm pretty acronym challenged at the moment.

OPTEMPO?
SOFA?
 
I'm pretty acronym challenged at the moment.

OPTEMPO?
SOFA?

SOFA is a Status of Forces Agreement. It is an agreement negotiated between the US government and a government of a country in which US forces are stationed laying out their legal status and how they will be permitted to operate by the host nation.


ETA: In this case, it depends on what the US government has agreed with the Afghan government regarding Afghan law, under which circumstances, if any, Afghanistan can get custody of the guy etc...

ETA again: This is a case study from Japan, which might help illuminate what SOFAs are. Although, as Joe the Juggler points out it may not be of much use in this case because Afghanistan may have a completely different agreement. Either way, sometimes the agreement itself may look like the host country has more jurisdiction than in practice as this case highlights.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom