Terrible news from Afghanistan

I'm sure that Padmé will be very understanding and will still love him despite this massacre.

vadersees-1.jpg
 
Interesting how smoothly the usual suspects have steered the discussion from "Americans commit a terrible crime" to "look how primitive those Muslims are".

Americans (plural) did not commit a terrible crime. It is neither fair, honest nor accurate to say that.

You should be careful where you out the letter "S". Just one of them could accidentally expose your personal prejudices.
 
our Real American Patriots are too busy attacking the Afghans to find anything bad about this guy.

Ahem...

Yet the mullahs and the media will do their part to ensure that this one traitor and burnt Korans are the public face of the Afghan mission.
Fallacy of the excluded middle.

You left out "summarily tossed into a pit of punji sticks".
That's not what I said. I said that allied forces in Afghanistan have done a lot of good work that is going to be overshadowed by the insanity of one man.

I can't speak for any others, but all of my above quoted comments were posted prior to yours.

Where I come from, calling someone "insane", "a traitor" and half-jokingly suggesting they should be stabbed to death with sharpened wooden sticks is saying really bad things about them.

Now do you really believe that it is fair to the tens of thousands of US and allied servicemen who have done good things over there to let this one lunatics (look, I just said something bad about him again!) actions overshadow them?
 
I'm sure it will blow over soon. It's not like he burned a Koran.

I'm not kidding. I predict that the fallout from this will be less than the fallout from the Koran burnings. Sad, but true.


The US Embassy in Kabul has warned US nationals of growing anti-American sentiment and the threat of protest action in Afghanistan following the killing of Afghan civilians by a US serviceman:

'EMERGENCY MESSAGE FOR U.S. CITIZENS'


Ahem...





I can't speak for any others, but all of my above quoted comments were posted prior to yours.

Where I come from, calling someone "insane", "a traitor" and half-jokingly suggesting they should be stabbed to death with sharpened wooden sticks is saying really bad things about them.

Now do you really believe that it is fair to the tens of thousands of US and allied servicemen who have done good things over there to let this one lunatics (look, I just said something bad about him again!) actions overshadow them?

Yes, how unfair that the mass murder of civilians, (men, woman and children) in their homes, by a foreign, occupying soldier creates bad PR!
 
Last edited:
At least you've changed from a statement that refers to the values of everyone "over there" to "a good percentage". So what percentage of Afghans think death or rape is an appropriate punishment for a girl getting an education or getting a job?


All of them? Or are you just making the trivial observation that some Afghanis have different values than some Americans? Isn't it also true that some Americans have different values than others?
From WaPo:
The public response to the shootings so far has been calmer than the six days of riots and attacks after Qurans were burned at Bagram Air Field, leaving 30 people dead including six U.S. soldiers.
I don't know why this is shocking to anyone, decades of war make life cheap.
 
From WaPo:

I don't know why this is shocking to anyone, decades of war make life cheap.

What's the metric for measuring public outrage? Is it the amount of people that show up at your gate? Is it protests in the street? Is it national (Afghani) or foreign press picking it up?

Edit:
Apparently the guy was on his fourth tour, after suffering brain trauma. The institution is very much at fault here too.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, with OBL feeding fishes, I care less and less about what happens when we leave.

Vandals rarely do care about the destruction and misery they leave behind.

Information from the Stratfor email dump suggests that OBL's body was not, in fact, dumped in the sea.

Edit:
Apparently the guy was on his fourth tour, after suffering brain trauma. The institution is very much at fault here too.

In 2009, Pentagon officials estimated that up to 360,000 Iraq and Afghanistan veterans may have suffered brain injuries. Many will have been returned to the battlefield.

One U.S. veteran attempts suicide every 80 minutes.
 
Last edited:
Can you take this stupid OBL derail somewhere else, please?

More on topic, outrage in Afghanistan

Protests, attacks hit Afghanistan in wake of massacre

Thousands of people took to the streets in eastern Afghanistan on Tuesday to protest the killing of 16 civilians by a U.S. soldier, burning an effigy of Barak Obama and calling for the killer to be tried in Afghanistan.
Demonstrators in the city of Jalalabad chanted "Death to America -- Death to Obama" and blocked the main highway to Afghanistan's capital, Kabul, Britain's Daily Telegraph reported.
"Jihad (holy war) is the only way to get the invading Americans out of Afghanistan," one banner read, according to the newspaper.

The demonstrators also demanded that President Hamid Karzai reject plans to sign a strategic pact with Washington that would allow U.S. advisers and possibly special forces to remain beyond a 2014 deadline for foreign combat troops to leave Afghanistan.

And in the South, too:

The attack came as hundreds of students took to the streets of the eastern city of Jalalabad, as anger over Sunday's killings by the unnamed US soldier prompted more anti-US protests.

About 400 university students shouted "Death to America -- Death to Obama", burning the US president in effigy and blocking the main highway to Kabul before dispersing after about two hours.

Abdul Rahim Ayoubi, a member of the Afghan parliament from Kandahar, told Al Jazeera that many locals were still deciding how to respond to the attacks.
 
Last edited:
Speculating is fun, for sure........

The murderer will be tried and convicted and sentenced to at least life without parole. Alternatively, it is just barely possible the US will waive SOFA protecions and surrender him to the Afghani goverment for trial. If ever there was a situation where waiving SOFA would be appropriate, this one seems to be it.

I give crap all about his mild TBI from a vehicle accident. I give crap all about the OPTEMPO he's experienced before. I give crap all about any other excuse anyone may make for him. His actions immediately threaten the lives of US Servicemen, and death is an appropriate punishment.
 
Speculating is fun, for sure........

The murderer will be tried and convicted and sentenced to at least life without parole. Alternatively, it is just barely possible the US will waive SOFA protecions and surrender him to the Afghani goverment for trial. If ever there was a situation where waiving SOFA would be appropriate, this one seems to be it.

I give crap all about his mild TBI from a vehicle accident. I give crap all about the OPTEMPO he's experienced before. I give crap all about any other excuse anyone may make for him. His actions immediately threaten the lives of US Servicemen, and death is an appropriate punishment.

Agree. Waive SOFA. They can rend him limb from limb in public for all I care.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom