Terrible news from Afghanistan

I don't believe in alien spaceships, but that headline is certainly true: many of the villages are saying that the killing spree was not the work of just one guy. Indeed, Karzai even doubts that it was just one guy.
When Bales went missing from base a search party was sent out to find him. It is this search party they are confusing with perps.
 
:rolleyes:

You have no BS filter, do you?

As reported, I'm sure this story is true. The Afghan "parliamentary probe" did indeed say that up to 20 people were involved.

Whether or not their conclusion is true is another issue.

However, I think getting back to the political issue (the struggle for the hearts and minds of Afghans), the U.S. could certainly have handled this in a better way.
 
When the Taliban and AQ commit mass murder, we know why, it's usually to create chaos and for religious sectarian reasons.

The US and the Coalition want Afghanistan to be stable, and secure. There's no reason for such an attack. It goes against their interests, and puts them at risk of reprisals
 
Last edited:
***** and giggles, just like blowing up WTC7 and firing a missile at the Pentagon on 9/11.

Well the blowing up of WTC 7 was to get rid of all the "evidence" in one big swoop, and the missile at the Pentagon was because a jet plane was too "obvious", silly. ;)
 
When Bales went missing from base a search party was sent out to find him. It is this search party they are confusing with perps.

That sounds reasonable to me. But again, the villagers, the parliamentary probe, and even Karzai don't see it that way.

At the very least, the U.S. should be treating Karzai as a cooperative participant in whatever investigations they're conducting. In the first reports, I heard no mention of a search party. In fact, the U.S. military said they based their conclusions on security video of Bales sneaking back into base and turning himself in (as if this was the first they became aware of anything going on).
 
As reported, I'm sure this story is true. The Afghan "parliamentary probe" did indeed say that up to 20 people were involved.

Whether or not their conclusion is true is another issue.
I guarantee you CE thinks the story is true, and that is why I said he has no BS filter.
 
When the Taliban and AQ commit mass murder, we know why, it's usually to create chaos and for religious sectarian reasons.

The US and the Coalition want Afghanistan to be stable, and secure. There's no reason for such an attack. It goes against their interests, and puts them at risk of reprisals

I agree, but I suspect perception of the Taliban, AQ and NATO forces among the people of Afghanistan isn't quite the same as that of you and me.


Don't you think we should be concerned about how they perceive us?

The one-sided disregard for the perspective of other nations could lead to a groundswell of support for what we recognize as the "bad guys".
 
Don't you think we should be concerned about how they perceive us?


People will believe what they want to believe. How do you convince people who base their beliefs on their subjective perceptions?

Have you ever tried to convince a global warming denier that there isn't a vast conspiracy?
 
I guarantee you CE thinks the story is true, and that is why I said he has no BS filter.

I believe the story is true too, as I said above. The story was that the Afghan parliamentary probe has concluded that up to 20 Americans were involved in the shooting spree. I think their conclusion is wrong.

But I think the story is true, and it's something important that we should be very concerned with. And I don't think it's really analogous to 9/11 CTs or Apollo Hoax CTs. We actually have good reason to be concerned about the widespread perception of Americans by the people and government of Afghanistan even if--indeed especially if--those perceptions are wrong.

We needn't be at all concerned about the false beliefs of a relatively small handful of nutty 9/11 CTists blogging away.
 
People will believe what they want to believe. How do you convince people who base their beliefs on their subjective perceptions?
Good question! I think one thing you don't do is cut them out of the loop. I think you don't whisk the primary suspect out of country without at least allowing Karzai's government to question him (or at least sit in while we question him). I think you treat their concerns as important and do your best to show them the evidence to the contrary.

Have you ever tried to convince a global warming denier that there isn't a vast conspiracy?
See above. We as a country have no great concern in convincing a small minority of AGW deniers that there is no vast conspiracy.
 
You misunderstand. CE thinks there really was a large group of US soldiers involved, and not just Bales.

I understand that. I also understand that there is no evidence at all (at least not here in this thread) that CE thinks that.

In fact, I believe earlier in this thread, CE made a comment similar to mine that we need to be concerned about the struggle for the hearts and minds. I think CE is talking about what the Afghans believe and not her own belief about the massacre.
 
But I think the story is true, and it's something important that we should be very concerned with. And I don't think it's really analogous to 9/11 CTs or Apollo Hoax CTs. We actually have good reason to be concerned about the widespread perception of Americans by the people and government of Afghanistan even if--indeed especially if--those perceptions are wrong.
Do you have any idea how ignorant most Afghans are about the outside world? Many don't understand that the US and the UK are different countries. They think US soldiers are kidnapping Afghan women, taking them to Gitmo, and raping them. A majority have never even heard of the 9/11 attacks. Some still think they're fighting the Russians.

This is a largely illiterate society where information spreads by rumor and ignorance runs deep.
 
Last edited:
Good question! I think one thing you don't do is cut them out of the loop. I think you don't whisk the primary suspect out of country without at least allowing Karzai's government to question him (or at least sit in while we question him). I think you treat their concerns as important and do your best to show them the evidence to the contrary.

Good, but we already are in cooperation with the Afghans, we've been training their police and military, rebuilding their roads and vaccinating their young against polio for years, one would think we would have gained some trust by now.

See above. We as a country have no great concern in convincing a small minority of AGW deniers that there is no vast conspiracy.

And what about a country that has a majority that believes we're out to get them?
 
I understand that. I also understand that there is no evidence at all (at least not here in this thread) that CE thinks that.

In fact, I believe earlier in this thread, CE made a comment similar to mine that we need to be concerned about the struggle for the hearts and minds. I think CE is talking about what the Afghans believe and not her own belief about the massacre.
You give CE way too much credit, check out his posts in the 9/11 section.
 
Good, but we already are in cooperation with the Afghans, we've been training their police and military, rebuilding their roads and vaccinating their young against polio for years, one would think we would have gained some trust by now.
So you think we should spend the "trust" we have earned on this incident? Why? Why not continue to cooperate with them?
 
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited quote of modded post.

So you think Bales did not act alone, correct?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom