Terrible news from Afghanistan

What is your evidence that we are "cutting them out of things and ignoring what they're saying'? Bear in mind some of what Afghan politicians say is for their domestic consumption. Like I said, the physical evidence gathered immediately after SSG Bales returned to his outpost is probably fairly cut and dry, and would be gathered with Afghan partners.

It seems like the two concerns you mention are not about involving the Afghans but about things you'd "like to hear more about". This is an ongoing investigation. Do the police in your town routinely announce all the details they have in the course of investigations? Why do people expect that they have a right to evidence prior to trial in public cases?

The evidence is in the form of complaints by Karzai and the Afghan parliamentary investigators who said they didn't get the cooperation they expected from the US military.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/vid...istan-killings-karzai-elders-video?intcmp=239
 
It's very simple:
If a single, or even group, of Islamic-believing people kill a lot of civilians unrelated to the conflict, they are simply anomalies

Who believes this?


If a single, or even a group, of Westerners kill some civilians, or even a number of them, it is the genocidal policy of the West, as dictated by the US.

Who believes this?
 
The evidence is in the form of complaints by Karzai and the Afghan parliamentary investigators who said they didn't get the cooperation they expected from the US military.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/vid...istan-killings-karzai-elders-video?intcmp=239

Let me bold a sentence from my reply:
Bear in mind some of what Afghan politicians say is for their domestic consumption.
If your evidence for the US not cooperating is "well, Karzai and other Afghan politicians said so" then I would submit that is no evidence at all. Look at who they are talking to and think about what their motivations might be, and you might see what I mean.
 
Bear in mind some of what Afghan politicians say is for their domestic consumption.

So the fact that Karzai and other Afghan leaders and many of the people of Afghanistan are unhappy about the way the U.S. has handled this is evidence of cooperation?


Like I said, the physical evidence gathered immediately after SSG Bales returned to his outpost is probably fairly cut and dry, and would be gathered with Afghan partners.
Probably? What is that based on? I think statements by Karzai and the Afghans complaining that they have not in fact been included in the investigations is pretty strong evidence that what you're assuming was probable didn't happen that way.

This is an ongoing investigation. Do the police in your town routinely announce all the details they have in the course of investigations? Why do people expect that they have a right to evidence prior to trial in public cases?
Police in my town seldom run into such a politically sensitive issue--especially one that goes to the very root of national sovereignty of a foreign nation.


Finally, big "recruitment drives" don't happen.
Oh right. That's why we won the battle for the hearts and minds of the Vietnamese and ended up winning that war. . . . :rolleyes:
 
So the fact that Karzai and other Afghan leaders and many of the people of Afghanistan are unhappy about the way the U.S. has handled this is evidence of cooperation?

You're conflating two issues. One is the cooperation of the investigation into the incident, the other is whether a US servicemember should be tried by the Afghan government. Karzai and some Afghan politicians are the only ones who have implied any disconnect in the investigation (for domestic political purposes, as I implied). The fact that many Afghans are unhappy that an American will not be tried in the Afghan courts is not evidence of a lack of cooperation in the investigation of the incident, or that they are even care about a cooperative investigation.

Probably? What is that based on? I think statements by Karzai and the Afghans complaining that they have not in fact been included in the investigations is pretty strong evidence that what you're assuming was probable didn't happen that way.

Common sense. Knowledge of how these things work. A little inside knowledge. When SSG Bales returned to base, the examination of his weapon and ammunition, coupled with the forensics of the sites, should be very cut and dry. Based on what his lawyer has said so far, I imagine he knows it as well.

Police in my town seldom run into such a politically sensitive issue--especially one that goes to the very root of national sovereignty of a foreign nation.

A little bit of hyperbole, but all the more reason why aspects of this investigation will be close-hold until all the information has been gathered and confirmed.

Oh right. That's why we won the battle for the hearts and minds of the Vietnamese and ended up winning that war. . . . :rolleyes:

Vietnam? We're talking about Afghanistan here. How many tours do you have?
 
Karzai and some Afghan politicians are the only ones who have implied any disconnect in the investigation (for domestic political purposes, as I implied).


You mean the Pentagon is the only party who doesn't cooperate in the investigation and spreads fairytales contradicting the facts on the ground (for domestic political purposes, as is obvious).
 
It's very simple:
If a single, or even group, of Islamic-believing people kill a lot of civilians unrelated to the conflict, they are simply anomalies
If a single, or even a group, of Westerners kill some civilians, or even a number of them, it is the genocidal policy of the West, as dictated by the US.

:hb:

In which case it would be simple to link to someone actually making this claim in relation to the latest US massacre. Please do so.

Vietnam? We're talking about Afghanistan here. How many tours do you have?

How would going on such tours enhances one's political insight?

Allen told his men that "now is not the time for revenge for the deaths of two US soldiers killed in Thursday's riots". They should, he said, "resist whatever urge they might have to strike back" after an Afghan soldier killed the two Americans. "There will be moments like this when you're searching for the meaning of this loss," Allen continued. "There will be moments like this, when your emotions are governed by anger and a desire to strike back. Now is not the time for revenge, now is the time to look deep inside your souls, remember your mission, remember your discipline, remember who you are."

Now this was an extraordinary plea to come from the US commander in Afghanistan. The top general had to tell his supposedly well-disciplined, elite, professional army not to "take vengeance" on the Afghans they are supposed to be helping/protecting/nurturing/training, etc. He had to tell his soldiers not to commit murder. I know that generals would say this kind of thing in Vietnam. But Afghanistan? Has it come to this? I rather fear it has.[/I]""""
 
An American soldier has gone on a killing spree.

This is going to explode now. Right now.

ETA: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/12/world/asia/afghanistan-civilians-killed-american-soldier-held.html

No one knows enough of this sensitive and terrible situation to make any comments on it. If you do, I mean, if you form an opinion based on the few sentences from the news media, then you are a fool and an idiot and just as senseless as the killings themselves.

There is something called a psychotic break. This guy had been in two tours in Iraq and one tour in Afganistan (where he had won just about every metal and ribbon and award available) and had seen his best friend's leg completely blown off the day before. Do not judge. American citizens who have probably never been in the military sit in their lazyboy chairs and pass judgement when if they were in the same position they would have resorted to taking out as many Afgan nationals as pay back months or years sooner.

The Afgan citizens who are so blinded by national pride and pious prejudiced hogwash that they go protest in the street cannot see that even with this event a prolonged American presence and war is far better than letting the Taliban regain power.
 
No one knows enough of this sensitive and terrible situation to make any comments on it. If you do, I mean, if you form an opinion based on the few sentences from the news media, then you are a fool and an idiot and just as senseless as the killings themselves.

There is something called a psychotic break. This guy had been in two tours in Iraq and one tour in Afganistan (where he had won just about every metal and ribbon and award available) and had seen his best friend's leg completely blown off the day before. Do not judge. American citizens who have probably never been in the military sit in their lazyboy chairs and pass judgement when if they were in the same position they would have resorted to taking out as many Afgan nationals as pay back months or years sooner.

The Afgan citizens who are so blinded by national pride and pious prejudiced hogwash that they go protest in the street cannot see that even with this event a prolonged American presence and war is far better than letting the Taliban regain power.

Most don't want either regime but, not surprisingly, hyper-violent foreign invaders and occupiers are hated more. The Taliban have proved themselves better at maintaining basic, everyday security than the tooled-up, rampaging, Americans night raiders.
 
The Taliban have proved themselves better at maintaining basic, everyday security than the tooled-up, rampaging, Americans night raiders.

Wow. You mean targeting directly civilians makes for better security? Not allowing girls to go to school makes for better lives? Discriminating people based onethnicity and religion is better?

Here they are killing 10 aid workers, unarmed doctors who were giving aid to villagers:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/08/07/AR2010080700822.html

The team members -- six Americans, one German, one Briton and four Afghans -- were returning from neighboring Nurestan province, where they had spent several days administering eye care to impoverished villagers. They were traveling unarmed and without security guards, Frans said.


And here they are recently kidnapping aid workers who were only there to help the people:

http://www.newspakistan.pk/2012/02/12/Pakistan-Taliban-holding-two-kidnapped-foreigners/

The foreigners reportedly work for an aid group, Welthungerhilfe, which helped victims of the devastating 2010 floods. They have been identified as German national Bernd Johannes, 70, and Italian national Giovanni, 24.
And that's just two examples out of hundreds.

Do you think that kind of action helps the inhabitants live better? The Taliban don't want the people to be safe and sound, they want to impose their ideology with brute force.

Your love for totalitarians is disgusting.
 
Last edited:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/mar/09/afghanistan-insurgents-civilian-victims

The annual United Nations report on civilian casualties shows that more than two-thirds of the 2,777 civilians killed last year were the victims of insurgents – a 28% increase on 2009. By contrast Nato and Afghan government forces were responsible for killing 440, a 25% decrease.

More than half of the deaths caused by the Taliban were the result of homemade bombs and suicide attacks.
How's that for security?

Here they are attacking hotels:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jun/28/afghanistan-kabul-hotel-attack-taliban

mosques:

http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Asia...tacks-two-Muslim-minority-mosques-in-Pakistan

weddings (hanging a 7 year old "spy" in the process):

http://abcnews.go.com/WN/Afghanistan/bloody-taliban-revenge-hangs-boy-attacks-
wedding/story?id=10879315#.T2heJo5rrTU

and funerals:

http://www.dawn.com/2012/03/12/tali...ity-for-suicide-blast-at-funeral-16-dead.html

Hotels, mosques, weddings and funerals, you know, real legitimate military targets...:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You seem to have a reading comprehension problem.

Some folks, apparently you included, seem to have needed someone to point out what the legitimacy of Karzai's position, in political power, is based upon. He's been criticized for quite some time, both within his country and outside of it, as being more or less the stooge of foreign powers. That's at least a partially valid critique, if not entirely.

Put another way, without the backing and presence of foreigners, he isn't in charge of much, at all. So I find it amusing that Obama's bitch is trying to apply political leverage, which he hasn't got.

I am pretty sure that he is painfully aware of the limits of his power.

I suggest you look up and read the public documents available on the current SOFA.
Ya see, Karzai and his crew signed up for that. This soldier is entitled to due process, whether your emotional reaction to that is favorable or not.

Is it your position that Karzai reneg on agreements he made on behalf of his country, or adhere to them?

How does his political legitimacy do if he backs out of deals he makes from his position as President?

No reading comprehension problem at all. I got you the first time.
 
JihadJane said:
The Taliban have proved themselves better at maintaining basic, everyday security than the tooled-up, rampaging, Americans night raiders.

OMG you haven't got a clue have you?

The overwhelming majority of civilian casualties are caused by the Taliban and the collateral damage is mostly due to the Taliban using civilians as human shields.

The Taliban are Pushtun radicals and most of the other tribes hate their guts. It's good that you've finally put it down in black & white: JihadJane supports the Taliban. You name isn't ironic, or sarcastic. You literally do support Jihad and religious fascism.
 
Last edited:
...
""""I'm getting a bit tired of the "deranged" soldier story. It was predictable, of course. The 38-year-old staff sergeant who massacred 16 Afghan civilians, including nine children, near Kandahar this week had no sooner returned to base than the defence experts and the think-tank boys and girls announced that he was "deranged". Not an evil, wicked, mindless terrorist – which he would be, of course, if he had been an Afghan, especially a Taliban – but merely a guy who went crazy.

...
It is remarkably easy to make an argument when you're arguing about what imaginary people might say and use that to make a generalization. Allied forces are killed all the time by natives and Taliban, yet no one calls them "deranged". According to you, they are the jackbooted aggressors, evil, wicked, and mindless.

The funny thing is that even that post specifically describes Allen's statement as unusual, but then promptly pretends it applies generally. Who else could turn a general urging his men not to strike back in anger into a condemnation of those same men? And why would "striking back" necessarily mean murder? That doesn't follow. Then there's the sheer hypocrisy of conjuring up about an entirely hypothetical generalization about natives and using it to make a generalization about the hypothetical people who might've made that earlier generalization.

http://www.npr.org/2012/02/24/147350141/u-s-general-calms-troops-after-afghanistan-deaths
"Afghan National Army Gen. Sher Mohammed Karimi, who traveled to the base with Allen, told the U.S. troops that their sacrifice is not wasted.

Karimi says the Americans and Afghans together are "fighting an enemy of humanity."
 
The evidence is in the form of complaints by Karzai and the Afghan parliamentary investigators who said they didn't get the cooperation they expected from the US military.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/vid...istan-killings-karzai-elders-video?intcmp=239

JihadJane, apparently, who does not, you note, deny it. Note how even her request for proof specifically limits the samples to only the killings under discussion, when the original statement was more general. She also ignored Para's post claiming what her position was, to take a shot at a more general statement.
 
OMG you haven't got a clue have you?

The overwhelming majority of civilian casualties are caused by the Taliban and the collateral damage is mostly due to the Taliban using civilians as human shields.

The Taliban are Pushtun radicals and most of the other tribes hate their guts. It's good that you've finally put it down in black & white: JihadJane supports the Taliban. You name isn't ironic, or sarcastic. You literally do support Jihad and religious fascism.

Thank goodness that's cleared up. I mean I and others asked her once what she felt about the Bali Nightclub bombings, and she never responded.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom