Terrible news from Afghanistan

Who said we'll stop?

See above. The US has done all those uncooperative things I just mentioned (taking Bales out of the country without letting Afghan authorities question him, etc.). So when you said that we have been cooperating with Afghanistan in other regards and that we should have built up some degree of trust by now, it sure seemed as if your implication was that we continue not cooperating with them about the Bales massacre.
 
Follow-up: Probe team: Women sexually assaulted before killing in Panjwai

US soldiers were alleged to have sexually assaulted two female victims before they were killed in the Panjwai massacre in southern Kandahar last Sunday, a high-level Afghan probe team revealed. [...]

The Wolesi Jirga members jointly probing the Panjwai episode, along with a government team, on Saturday presented their chilling findings to the general session of the Parliament.

MP Hamidzai Lali, representing Kandahar province and a delegation member, said before the gun attack, US soldiers physically manhandled the two women and later turned their weapons on the helpless residents.

Shakiba Hashami, another delegation member, confirmed the vicious attack, adding about 15 to 20 American soldiers were involved in the killings and even helicopters were seen hovering the areas. [...]
 
See above. The US has done all those uncooperative things I just mentioned (taking Bales out of the country without letting Afghan authorities question him, etc.). So when you said that we have been cooperating with Afghanistan in other regards and that we should have built up some degree of trust by now, it sure seemed as if your implication was that we continue not cooperating with them about the Bales massacre.

SSG Bales had lawyered up almost immediately after saying he did it. (A prudent move on his part, should have done it three words earlier.) What would be the point of allowing him to refuse to answer questions from Afghan officials? Keeping him either at Kandahar or Bagram where protests could take place outside the gates every day while he pleads the fifth to Afghan officials? (While the right against self-incrimination is in the Afghan constitution, I would not say that it is well-entrenched in Afghan culture.)

We have video. We have his weapons seized immediately upon return to base. We have his kit and his ammunition (i.e. whatever was left of his basic load). There should be some damning evidence in there (i.e. weapons fired, number of rounds missing) to correlate with forensics from the villages (gunshot wounds, ballistics). To think that we are not sharing this with the Afghans is ridiculous. Also, Afghans were at this outpost; the Afghan officials can question them and the villagers probably far more effectively than we can.
 
An interesting observation from Robert Fisk:

"Robert Fisk: Madness is not the reason for this massacre"

""""I'm getting a bit tired of the "deranged" soldier story. It was predictable, of course. The 38-year-old staff sergeant who massacred 16 Afghan civilians, including nine children, near Kandahar this week had no sooner returned to base than the defence experts and the think-tank boys and girls announced that he was "deranged". Not an evil, wicked, mindless terrorist – which he would be, of course, if he had been an Afghan, especially a Taliban – but merely a guy who went crazy.

...

...a remarkable and highly significant statement from the US army's top commander in Afghanistan, General John Allen, exactly 22 days ago. Indeed, it was so unusual a statement that I clipped the report of Allen's words from my morning paper and placed it inside my briefcase for future reference.

Allen told his men that "now is not the time for revenge for the deaths of two US soldiers killed in Thursday's riots". They should, he said, "resist whatever urge they might have to strike back" after an Afghan soldier killed the two Americans. "There will be moments like this when you're searching for the meaning of this loss," Allen continued. "There will be moments like this, when your emotions are governed by anger and a desire to strike back. Now is not the time for revenge, now is the time to look deep inside your souls, remember your mission, remember your discipline, remember who you are."

Now this was an extraordinary plea to come from the US commander in Afghanistan. The top general had to tell his supposedly well-disciplined, elite, professional army not to "take vengeance" on the Afghans they are supposed to be helping/protecting/nurturing/training, etc. He had to tell his soldiers not to commit murder. I know that generals would say this kind of thing in Vietnam. But Afghanistan? Has it come to this? I rather fear it has.
""""
 
An interesting observation from Robert Fisk

Another truther, predictable as usual.

"But there are a lot of things we don’t know, a lot of things we’re not going to be told [...] perhaps the plane was hit by a missile, we still don’t know."

Yeah, keep talking Fisk, nobody is listening to kooks.
 
Last edited:
Funny, the very people who were whining that KSM should have a fair trial are the same asking for Bales to be handed over to Afghan tribal justice...

I can't speak for those who want to hand over Bales to Afghan tribal justice but I think it is a little surprising that you consider demands for fair trials as whining. Is this similar to people who whine about wanting the vote, or who whine about wanting free speech or who whine about ending slavery etc...? If you characterize demands for fair trials as whining then it suggests you think fair trials/and/or correct judicial proceedings are over-rated.

Anyway, unless you are referring to BenBurch's impression of judge, jury and executioner and his call to have him torn limb from limb then I think the most important point has been made by JoeTheJuggler who is pointing out that there is more to it then just punishing the culprit. What needs to be done - and/or to be seen to be done - is taking the Afghan government's complaint seriously and investigating the crime in tandem with Afghan authorities including interviewing witnesses and the suspect and establishing what happened together.

This is not a call for Afghan "tribal justice" to prevail - I would certainly be against that.

You can't get a fair trial in Afghanistan.

What do suppose are the prospects for Afghanistan one day getting a decent legal system?

I certainly hope that they get a decent legal system one day
 
An interesting observation from Robert Fisk:


According to details in another article about the Afghan Parliamentary Inquiry's findings, it may well have been revenge.

Kurz vor der Tragödie war ein amerikanischer Schützenpanzerwagen auf eine Sprengladung aufgefahren. Die ganze Besatzung kam dabei ums Leben. Laut Augenzeugen sollen die Militärs dafür Rache an den Einwohnern der nahe gelegenen Siedlung geschworen haben.


Paraphrased: Shortly before the tragedy, a US military vehicle was blown up by a payload and the crew all died. Eyewitnesses report soldiers swearing revenge to the residents of the nearby village.

The link to the Pajhwok article i've posted above doesn't work anymore, it's now here.
 
Last edited:
""""I'm getting a bit tired of the "deranged" soldier story. It was predictable, of course. The 38-year-old staff sergeant who massacred 16 Afghan civilians, including nine children, near Kandahar this week had no sooner returned to base than the defence experts and the think-tank boys and girls announced that he was "deranged". Not an evil, wicked, mindless terrorist – which he would be, of course, if he had been an Afghan, especially a Taliban – but merely a guy who went crazy.


Gratuitous hair-splitting.
 
What would be the point of allowing him to refuse to answer questions from Afghan officials?

The point would be cooperating with Afghanistan rather than cutting them out of things and ignoring what they're saying.

I would also like to hear more details about this squad of men who were sent to search for Bales that Afghan witnesses wrongfully claim were involved in the killing.

I'd also like to hear more about the physical evidence at the scene and to what extent the US military investigation is considering it. (Were all the bodies moved after being killed and set on fire?)

Again, my main concern is not so much whoddunnit or the disposition of Bales, but trying not to turn this into a huge Taliban/Al Qaeda recruitment drive--that is, my concern is over the war for the hearts and minds of Afghans.
 
The point would be cooperating with Afghanistan rather than cutting them out of things and ignoring what they're saying.

I would also like to hear more details about this squad of men who were sent to search for Bales that Afghan witnesses wrongfully claim were involved in the killing.

I'd also like to hear more about the physical evidence at the scene and to what extent the US military investigation is considering it. (Were all the bodies moved after being killed and set on fire?)

Again, my main concern is not so much whoddunnit or the disposition of Bales, but trying not to turn this into a huge Taliban/Al Qaeda recruitment drive--that is, my concern is over the war for the hearts and minds of Afghans.

What is your evidence that we are "cutting them out of things and ignoring what they're saying'? Bear in mind some of what Afghan politicians say is for their domestic consumption. Like I said, the physical evidence gathered immediately after SSG Bales returned to his outpost is probably fairly cut and dry, and would be gathered with Afghan partners.

It seems like the two concerns you mention are not about involving the Afghans but about things you'd "like to hear more about". This is an ongoing investigation. Do the police in your town routinely announce all the details they have in the course of investigations? Why do people expect that they have a right to evidence prior to trial in public cases?

(BTW, the whole moving bodies is ludicrous as evidence of conspiracy. SSG Bales played football, victims included children, and even the adult Afghan male typically weighs a buck and a quarter sopping wet.)

Finally, big "recruitment drives" don't happen. Talking heads like to talk about them, but they don't happen like that. Local response is important and I can guarantee that's happening, and trial and punishment is important and that will happen fairly swiftly as well.
 
Last edited:
Oh good, shall we start referring to the Taliban merely as "guys who went crazy", then, and drop all this "terrorist" nonsense?

Aren't you one of those who defended their actions?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5938026#post5938026

Well yes you are! You are defending their attacks as being legitimate responses to an occupation.

According to you, attacking civilians directly, as a matter of policy like attacking weddings and funerals (in Pakistan no less, which is not "occupied") and attacking foreign aid workers (you know who are only there to HELP) are legitimate ways of fighting a war...

What happened in Afghanistan was a fluke, it wasn't intentional on the part of the Coalition, and it will never be policy to attack civilians, unlike the Taliban who intentionally target them. And you have the gull to compare that to the Taliban. Just when I thought you couldn't sink any lower...
 
Last edited:
It's very simple:
If a single, or even group, of Islamic-believing people kill a lot of civilians unrelated to the conflict, they are simply anomalies
If a single, or even a group, of Westerners kill some civilians, or even a number of them, it is the genocidal policy of the West, as dictated by the US.

:hb:
 
That's the spirit. No reference to what it is morally correct, just a gung-ho statement that might makes right.

You seem to have a reading comprehension problem.

Some folks, apparently you included, seem to have needed someone to point out what the legitimacy of Karzai's position, in political power, is based upon. He's been criticized for quite some time, both within his country and outside of it, as being more or less the stooge of foreign powers. That's at least a partially valid critique, if not entirely.

Put another way, without the backing and presence of foreigners, he isn't in charge of much, at all. So I find it amusing that Obama's bitch is trying to apply political leverage, which he hasn't got.

I am pretty sure that he is painfully aware of the limits of his power.

I suggest you look up and read the public documents available on the current SOFA.
Ya see, Karzai and his crew signed up for that. This soldier is entitled to due process, whether your emotional reaction to that is favorable or not.

Is it your position that Karzai reneg on agreements he made on behalf of his country, or adhere to them?

How does his political legitimacy do if he backs out of deals he makes from his position as President?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom