Terra revolving round Sol question

If a centrifugoscope has it’s arms extended either by itself spinning or by a distant shell of spinning matter when it’s not spinning, how can the arms ever be unextended?
 
Last edited:
If a centrifugoscope has it’s arms extended either by itself spinning or by a distant shell of spinning matter when it’s not spinning. How can the centrifugoscope ever have it’s arms not extended?

Um? If it's not spinning, for one. If it's in a giant rotating shell, then corotating with that shell will cancel out the shell's gravitomagnetic effect.
 
Um? If it's not spinning, for one. If it's in a giant rotating shell, then corotating with that shell will cancel out the shell's gravitomagnetic effect.
Um? If the arms aren’t extended it isn’t spinning and there isn’t a distant shell spinning relative to it. It also can’t be corotating with a distant shell because corotating would cause the arms to extend. Please don’t claim that corotating with a distant shell cancels out the centrifugal effects of rotation.

Therefore - If there was a distant spinning shell that created a force that extended the arms of the centrifugoscope then it would do so regardless of whether the centrifugoscope was spinning or not and the arms would never be unextended. That the arms can be and usually are unextended proves this shell doesn't actually exist. To suggest that when you think you are spinning something you are actually spinning a large, distant shell would be ludicrous in the extreme.
 
Last edited:
um? If the arms aren’t extended it isn’t spinning and there isn’t a distant shell spinning relative to it. It also can’t be corotating with a distant shell because corotating would cause the arms to extend. Please don’t claim that corotating with a distant shell cancels out the centrifugal effects of rotation.

do you realize that the device i described above will extend its arms if you put it inside a very large shell of matter, and spin the shell (but keep the centrifugoscope fixed in place)?

hth. Hand!
 
Please don’t claim that corotating with a distant shell cancels out the centrifugal effects of rotation.

Sorry, that's exactly what I'm going to claim. (IIRC, it's not exactly co-rotating, you don't have to match speeds with the shell.)

Why is that surprising? It's exactly what would happen on a merry-go-round, right? The merry-go-round is going (to a grounded observer) clockwise at 1 rpm. You're corotating with it, so to you the merry-go-round is at rest ... but you're holding a "stationary" centrifugometer, and you notice its arms are extended. If you spin your centrifugometer counterclockwise at 1rpm, its arms fall down.

In your own frame, you explain this as (a) my local laws of physics seem to include a centrifugal force, and (b) if I spin coutnerclockwise, I can make a centripetal force that cancels the spacetime force.
 
hth. Hand!
I can't make any sense of such a stupid post. What Sol said has nothing to do with co-rotation - "do you realize that the device i described above will extend its arms if you put it inside a very large shell of matter, and spin the shell (but keep the centrifugoscope fixed in place)?"
 
I can't make any sense of such a stupid post. What Sol said has nothing to do with co-rotation - "do you realize that the device i described above will extend its arms if you put it inside a very large shell of matter, and spin the shell (but keep the centrifugoscope fixed in place)?"

Sol's post is correct. Inside a spinning shell of matter, due to the effects of gravitomagnetism, the laws of motion are exactly the same as those in a spinning coordinate system. One of those laws makes the centrifugoscope arms rise.

One feature of the laws of motion in a spinning coordinate system is that you can counterrotate and cancel the spin-dependent effects.
 
Sorry, that's exactly what I'm going to claim. (IIRC, it's not exactly co-rotating, you don't have to match speeds with the shell.)

Why is that surprising? It's exactly what would happen on a merry-go-round, right? The merry-go-round is going (to a grounded observer) clockwise at 1 rpm. You're corotating with it, so to you the merry-go-round is at rest ... but you're holding a "stationary" centrifugometer, and you notice its arms are extended. If you spin your centrifugometer counterclockwise at 1rpm, its arms fall down.

In your own frame, you explain this as (a) my local laws of physics seem to include a centrifugal force, and (b) if I spin coutnerclockwise, I can make a centripetal force that cancels the spacetime force.

Sorry, wrong. Counter-rotation isn’t co-rotation. Cancelling rotation with equal counter-rotation is effectively stopping rotation. This is confirmed by the unextended arms.
 
Sorry, wrong. Counter-rotation isn’t co-rotation. Cancelling rotation with equal counter-rotation is effectively stopping rotation. This is confirmed by the unextended arms.

If you co-rotate with the motion of the *massive shell*, that's counter-rotating against the rotation you "feel" when stationary inside the shell.
 
Sol's post is correct. Inside a spinning shell of matter, due to the effects of gravitomagnetism, the laws of motion are exactly the same as those in a spinning coordinate system. One of those laws makes the centrifugoscope arms rise.

One feature of the laws of motion in a spinning coordinate system is that you can counterrotate and cancel the spin-dependent effects.
But we’re talking specifically about co-rotation. Sol isn’t.
Um? If it's in a giant rotating shell, then corotating with that shell will cancel out the shell's gravitomagnetic effect.

Here is what Sol said again. Hope the bold and red helps.
Do you realize that the device I described above will extend its arms if you put it inside a very large shell of matter, and spin the shell (but keep the centrifugoscope fixed in place)?

 
Yes I frequently look at the night sky. It’s something I like to do. When I do it appears that the Universe is spinning. So you’re saying that the entire extraterrestrial Universe is this large shell of matter spinning about the axis of the Earth?

I'm saying there's a huge (thick) shell of matter out there. Further, the state of "zero rotation", in which the arms of the centrifugoscope hang down, is the one in which the stars aren't rotating. Why is that? Is it a coincidence?

Even when off center or not aligned by 90 degrees (at the equator)?
Are there are multiple shells? Or does the same shell simultaneously spin about infinite axis to suit infinite frames? Do all planets and all things have their own large shell of matter?

If there are many shells, the effects combine in a way you can work out. If there's just one and you're off-center, the centrifugoscope will extend its arms, but not equally on each side.

Why does this force created by the shell cause the arms of the centrifugoscope to rise and extend against the force of gravity but the body of the centrifugoscope doesn’t even get any lighter?

It affects the body too. The point of the arms is to make that effect more apparent.

By “not spinning” I mean not displaying the known properties of spinning (evidence of spinning).

The whole point of the cetrifugoscope is to define and measure that (or rather, one aspect of it).

The big “and” is that clearly this doesn’t happen in practice. Any loose material thrown from a spinning thing doesn’t rise to a distant shell, it falls to the Earth. Centrifugal force threw it off then gravity pulled it down. Obviously it therefore wasn’t pulled off by some distant spinning shell of matter.

You seem to be confusing two things there. Sure, the earth pulls on things. But forget the earth, it's irrelevant to this conversation. We're talking about rotation and whether or not it's relative, and the gravity of the earth isn't particularly relevant. In outer space, does material thrown from a spinning thing rise to the distant shell? Yep.
 
But we’re talking specifically about co-rotation. Sol isn’t.


Here is what Sol said again. Hope the bold and red helps.

[/FONT]

I have no idea what you think the disagreement is.

Centrifugoscope stationary* + spinning shell = arms up. (Sol's post)

Centrifugoscope stationary* + stationary (or absent) shell = arms down. (ordinary Newtonian universe)

Centrifugoscope spinning + spinning shell = arms down (my post)

Centrifugoscope spinning + stationary (or absent) shell = arms up (ordinary Newtonian universe)
 
You seem to be confusing two things there. Sure, the earth pulls on things. But forget the earth, it's irrelevant to this conversation. We're talking about rotation and whether or not it's relative, and the gravity of the earth isn't particularly relevant. In outer space, does material thrown from a spinning thing rise to the distant shell? Yep.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]I'm struggling to understand why you would make such statements. Either we're talkng about completetly different things or you seem to be cherry-picking the most ideal conditions to support your case at the expense of credibility. [/FONT][FONT=Verdana, sans-serif][FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]I'm not talking about whether spinning is relative. I'm talking about whether it can be known whether a thing is spinning or not.[/FONT][/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]We can't decide which force causes the arms to extend if no force prevents them from extending in the first place. We therefore absolutely need gravity to keep the arms unextended before some other force extends them. The question is whether that force is created by the spinning of the [FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]c[/FONT][FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]entrifugoscope or a spinning distant shell. [/FONT][/FONT]
 
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]
It affects the body too. The point of the arms is to make that effect more apparent.
[/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Why would it affect the arms any more than the body? Gravity wouldn't. If the force of a distant spinning shell is strong enough to lift the arms against the force of gravity then it's also strong enough to lift the whole centrifugoscope and other things. Please explain why it wouldn't do this.[/FONT]
 
Last edited:
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]We can't decide which force causes the arms to extend if no force prevents them from extending in the first place. We therefore absolutely need gravity to keep the arms unextended before some other force extends them. The question is whether that force is created by the spinning of the [FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]c[/FONT][FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]entrifugoscope or a spinning distant shell. [/FONT][/FONT]

Perhaps the following will help.

In an inertial reference frame, Newton's 2nd law holds: we only get acceleration when we apply a force. In non-inertial reference frames, Newton's 2nd law only holds if we add in fictitious forces, which are forces that are always proportional to mass (and often are position-dependent too). So for example, if we rotate with respect to an inertial reference frame, then this rotation causes centrifugal and coriolis forces. In Newtonian mechanics, inertial reference frames can move with respect to each other, but they can never accelerate with respect to each other. If two frames are accelerating (including rotating) with respect to each other, at least one and maybe both are not inertial.

The difficulty is that in general relativity, there are no universal inertial reference frames. A reference frame can only be locally inertial. This is easy enough to understand in the case of linear acceleration: a falling reference frame is inertial, but a frame at rest in a gravitational field experiences forces (gravity) which are always proportional to mass. But if we take two reference frames on opposite sides of the earth, each of which is locally inertial (ie, falling), they are accelerating with respect to each other. That's very non-Newtonian.

But it gets weirder: gravitomagnetic effects mean that locally inertial reference frames can also rotate relative to each other. The simplest case is the interior of a rotating massive shell. The locally inertial reference frame rotates with respect to reference frames far away from the mass. This inertial reference frame will rotate in the same direction as the surrounding shell (again, relative to a distant inertial reference frame), but not at the same speed. So if we put out centrifugal device inside the shell, what it will measure is the rotation relative to this locally inertial reference frame, and NOT relative to any sort of absolute inertial reference frame (which we can't define) or to a distant inertial reference frame (which we can define, and is probably the next best thing). Spin it faster or slower than (or backwards from) the local inertial reference frame, it will measure rotation. Spin it with the local inertial reference frame, and it won't.
 
Last edited:
I'm saying there's a huge (thick) shell of matter out there.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]If there was then we couldn't see through it to see if the Universe continues beyond it. Effectively it would be the edge boundry of the Universe and that would mean the Universe has a centre and a Universally stationary orientation. It could also mean the the Universe is expanding by being pulled toward the shell rather then by expansion. [/FONT]

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]You're pulling my leg - right?[/FONT]
 
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Why would it affect the arms any more than the body? Gravity wouldn't. If the force of a distant spinning shell is strong enough to lift the arms against the force of gravity then it's also strong enough to lift the whole centrifugoscope and other things. Please explain why it wouldn't do this.[/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Even if the lifting force of the shell was somehow weight effected then what are the incredible odds that any particular centrifugoscope has arms that are light enough to be lifted against the force of gravity but a body that's too heavy? What if the body is lighter than each arm? Do overall lighter centrifugoscopes float off in to space? Do heavier arms on other centrifugoscopes not extend because they're too heavy? . . .[/FONT]

ETA - [FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Have just realised that the shell force would prolly be “out” not “up”. Perhaps what I've said above is wrong. [/FONT]
 
Last edited:
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]I'm not talking about whether spinning is relative. I'm talking about whether it can be known whether a thing is spinning or not.[/FONT]

You can tell if it's spinning relative to the local inertial frame with a centrifugoscope. That's not at issue. What's at issue is what that means - is spinning relative, or not.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]We can't decide which force causes the arms to extend if no force prevents them from extending in the first place. We therefore absolutely need gravity to keep the arms unextended before some other force extends them. The question is whether that force is created by the spinning of the [FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]c[/FONT][FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]entrifugoscope or a spinning distant shell. [/FONT][/FONT]

I really don't know what you mean. There's no reason we can't use our centrifuguscope to detect spinning out in space. The earth's gravity is unnecessary and a distraction.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif][/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Why would it affect the arms any more than the body? Gravity wouldn't. If the force of a distant spinning shell is strong enough to lift the arms against the force of gravity then it's also strong enough to lift the whole centrifugoscope and other things. Please explain why it wouldn't do this.[/FONT]

What direction is "lift" at the center of the shell?


By gravity - a form of gravity you're not very familiar with.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]If there was then we couldn't see through it to see if the Universe continues beyond it. Effectively it would be the edge boundry of the Universe and that would mean the Universe has a centre and a Universally stationary orientation. It could also mean the the Universe is expanding by being pulled toward the shell rather then by expansion. [/FONT]

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]You're pulling my leg - right?[/FONT]

No. I'm talking about the stars (and other matter) - they form giant concentric shells of mass around us.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom