When I look at the night sky and move my head quickly from side to side is it credible to concluded that my head might be “stationary” and the stars are moving back and forth at incredible speed (faster than light)? Wouldn’t that disprove the second postulate of SR?
Here's what SR says about that, Ynot.
a) Go ahead and move your head back and forth.
b)
Define a collection of rulers that happen to line up with your head during this shaking process. "The x'-axis and y'-axes shall be defined with respect to the x and y axes via {x', y'} = {x cos(wt) - y sin (wt), x sin (wt) + y cos(wt)}".
c) Write down the positions of things in {x',y',z} coordinates. Your bellybutton is at {0,0,-1}. Your nose is at {0.05,0,0}. Your left hand, outstretched, is at {1m*sin(wt),1m*cos(wt),-0.3}. The star Alpha Centauri is at {(10 pc)*cos(wt), (10 pc)*sin(wt)}.
d) Write down the laws of physics
in this coordinate system. What does that mean? It means you want to write down positions-vs.-time of objects. You want to write "x' of alpha centauri is some function f(t)". You want to write down laws like "F=ma". But
because you're using funny coordinates these laws are complicated. There is some sort of force law, comparable to F=ma, but it is not true that a = d^2/dt^2 x'(t).
e) If you write down the
actual law governing the speed of light---i.e. you track a photon and write v^2 = (dx'/dt)^2 + (dy'/dt)^2 + (dz'/dt)^2, using your own weird coordinates---you find that physics does NOT predict v^2 = (dx'/dt)^2 + (dy'/dt)^2 + (dz'/dt)^2 is a constant, nor that it's a speed limit, nor that it requires energy to get close to it, etc.
I feel like I'm repeating myself. Ynot, is any of this making sense?