Terra revolving round Sol question

Ynot, we are NOT talking about the gravitational attraction between the shell and the centrifugoscope. There is none, and it is not needed to explain why the arms lift when the shell is spinning. The effect we're talking about is called gravitomagnetism.
 
You can tell if it's spinning relative to the local inertial frame with a centrifugoscope. That's not at issue. What's at issue is what that means - is spinning relative, or not.

That seems to be the biggest problem here. One of the most valuable lessons my Chemistry professor taught us was always to ask, "compared to what?". Is an iron atom big? Compared to what? A hydrogen atom? An electron? A human being?

Spinning is relative and so you always have to ask, "relative to what?". The top, before anything happens, is spinning, but not relative to the observer's reference frame (here on Earth). We would only say it's not spinning because we too are in that reference frame. The observer applies force and the top begins to spin relative to the observer's frame of reference. As the top spins (relative to local frame), it runs into stuff and slows back down to the reference frame in which it started and now appears to be at rest again.

The reason you say that the top was spinning in that scenario is because you know the history of it: it shared the same reference frame, you applied force, then it slowed back down to that same reference frame. Now, suppose that the top wasn't spun by an observer. Instead, we first observe the top entering our solar system, on a collision course with the Earth. Is it spinning while in space? How about when it lands on Earth?
 
This thread has gone so far into la-la land it takes the breath away. And to think they're trying to appeal to the authority of GR to peddle this nonsense. Talk about cargo-cult science.

Ynot, we are NOT talking about the gravitational attraction between the shell and the centrifugoscope. There is none, and it is not needed to explain why the arms lift when the shell is spinning. The effect we're talking about is called gravitomagnetism.
You're talking through your hat. Gravitomagnetism will cause the "centrifugoscope" to precess. See NASA page re gravity probe B. And if you build a very big "centrifugoscope", the arms end up rotating at such a rapid speed that they shatter and fly away in pieces in all directions. Which is not what the moon the sun and the stars are doing. The spin overcomes electromagnbetic force but not gravity, even though the former is orders of magnitude stronger than the latter, and even though the Earth's gravitomagnetic field is extremely weak compared to its gravitational field.

Merton said:
...The reason you say that the top was spinning in that scenario is because you know the history of it: it shared the same reference frame, you applied force, then it slowed back down to that same reference frame. Now, suppose that the top wasn't spun by an observer. Instead, we first observe the top entering our solar system, on a collision course with the Earth. Is it spinning while in space? How about when it lands on Earth?
Well said Merton. The top can be spinning and moving, but then the next ridiculous hyperbole is that ah, no, the whole universe is just moving laterally relative to the top as well as spinning. Forgetting about the spinning earth, the solar rotation that varies with latitude, the rotating galaxies, etc etc etc. And forgetting about the other top coming at us from the other direction at a different speed spinning at a different rate, which we can slow down if we wish.

Here you go sol: two tops. Now try fitting your mystic fiction round that.
 
You're talking through your hat. Gravitomagnetism will cause the "centrifugoscope" to precess. See NASA page re gravity probe B.

You're very wrong. First off, the gravitomagnetic fields in the two scenarios aren't the same. The interior isn't the same as the exterior. And second, the precession described on that page occurs for a gyroscope with an axis perpendicular to the axis of rotation of the massive body. If the axis is parallel, as you would arrange them for this centrifuge meter, then there's no precession.
 
Here you go sol: two tops. Now try fitting your mystic fiction round that.

This is like objecting to Galilean relativity by suggesting a thought-experiment with TWO moving trains.

You can define a coordinate system where one train is at rest. You can define a coordinate system in which the other train is at rest. You can define a coordinate system where neither is at rest. But you can't define a system in which both trains are at rest---OH NO it's a crisis in Galilean relativity!
 
What direction is "lift" at the center of the shell?
As I said in my last post, I have been wrongly thinking of the force as being “up” as in directly opposite to gravity. It would actually be "out" as in at 90 degrees to gravity. This explains why the arms rise but the body doesn’t (my bad).
 
This thread has gone so far into la-la land it takes the breath away. And to think they're trying to appeal to the authority of GR to peddle this nonsense. Talk about cargo-cult science.
<more rant snipped>
See NASA page re gravity probe B

From a NASA page on Gravity Probe B:
NASA said:
Here is a simple experiment that almost anyone can perform on a clear night: pirouette freely around while looking up at the stars. You will notice two things: one, that the stars seem to spin around in the sky, and two, that your arms are pulled upwards by centrifugal force. Are these phenomena connected in some physical way? Not according to Newton. For him, centrifugal force is a consequence of accelerating (i.e. rotating) with respect to absolute space; it has no physical origin (and is therefore often called a "fictitious force" in elementary physics classes). It is, furthermore, a coincidence that the stars above us are at rest with respect to this same absolute space. We look upward, in effect, from two fundamentally different reference frames: one defined by our local sense of inertia, and the other defined by the global rest frame of the universe at large. Why should these two reference frames happen to coincide? Newton did not try to answer this question.
....
To put the cosmological significance of frame-dragging in concrete terms, imagine that the earth were standing still and that the rest of the universe were rotating around it: would its equator still bulge? Newton would have said "No". According to standard textbook physics the equatorial bulge is due to the rotation of the earth with respect to absolute space. On the basis of Lense and Thirring's results, however, Einstein would have had to answer "Yes"! In this respect general relativity is indeed more relativistic than its predecessors: it does not matter whether we choose to regard the earth as rotating and the heavens fixed, or the other way around: the two situations are now dynamically, as well as kinematically equivalent.

Any questions, Farsight?
 
Well said Merton. The top can be spinning and moving, but then the next ridiculous hyperbole is that ah, no, the whole universe is just moving laterally relative to the top as well as spinning. Forgetting about the spinning earth, the solar rotation that varies with latitude, the rotating galaxies, etc etc etc. And forgetting about the other top coming at us from the other direction at a different speed spinning at a different rate, which we can slow down if we wish.

I don't quite follow. I don't think anything I said would contradict viewing the whole universe as "just moving laterally relative to the top as well as spinning." My point is merely that the example of a top spinning on a table assumes a start-position and stop-position within the same frame of reference as the Earth, the room, etc. In other words, the known history is what people are seeing as the "reference frame of reality," whereas GR would not be able to claim such a thing. If the top had an unknown origin and only entered Earth's frame of reference after it had entered the solar system, it would become clear that the top, prior to its touchdown on our planet, had its own, non-special frame of reference.
 
To put the cosmological significance of frame-dragging in concrete terms, imagine that the earth were standing still and that the rest of the universe were rotating around it: would its equator still bulge? Newton would have said "No". According to standard textbook physics the equatorial bulge is due to the rotation of the earth with respect to absolute space. On the basis of Lense and Thirring's results, however, Einstein would have had to answer "Yes"! In this respect general relativity is indeed more relativistic than its predecessors: it does not matter whether we choose to regard the earth as rotating and the heavens fixed, or the other way around: the two situations are now dynamically, as well as kinematically equivalent.

For me, this is the most remarkable of all the consequences of the Theory of General Relativity. It smacks of being some kind of fantasy. In fact, it is likely the strangest and most astonishing scientific claim that I am aware of. I do find this claim so difficult to swallow that it is the reason I have embarked on a personal mission to learn more about GR.
However, to be clear, I respect the work and study done by all those in the world of physics and so trust that this claim has merit, but I do very much want to understand it for myself.
 
. So you’re saying that the entire extraterrestrial Universe is this large shell of matter spinning about the axis of the Earth?
I'm saying there's a huge (thick) shell of matter out there.
No. I'm talking about the stars (and other matter) - they form giant concentric shells of mass around us.
So can I finally conclude that the “huge (thick) shell of matter” is actually the “extraterrestrial Universe“ (from the Earth's frame)?

If so why do you say “shells” rather than “shell”? I don‘t think you‘re talking about multi-verses. As I’ve asked before, does each frame create it’s own reality and the Universe spins on one axis for one frame and a different axis for another concurrently? When two tops are spinning in opposite directions is the Universe concurrently spinning in opposing directions? When a million things are spinning about a million axis is the Universe also spinning about a million axis concurrently?

Isn’t a frame essentially merely a position of observation?
 
Last edited:
The Great Lesson of 20th Century Physics

In fact, it is likely the strangest and most astonishing scientific claim that I am aware of.


In my opinion, the single greatest, over-riding lesson of 20th century physics is that on scales of space and time far removed from our normal experience, the universe does not behave consistent with our natural, experience based intuition. On scales of the very small (quantum physics) and scales of the very large (general relativity), intuition is based not so much on physical experience as it is on the mathematical structures of the theories (although clever advances in experimental and observational technology are increasing the base of physical experience upon which a new 21st century experience-based intuition might evolve).
 
So can I finally conclude that the “huge (thick) shell of matter” is actually the “extraterrestrial Universe“ (from the Earth's frame)?

Right.

If so why do you say “shells” rather than “shell”?

Well, you can split the distribution of stars and other matter up into a series of concentric shells if you like. The case of a single shell is relatively simple, and the effect of multiple shells is cumulative (kind of, it's actually non-linear).

As I’ve asked before, does each frame create it’s own reality and the Universe spins on one axis for one frame and a different axis for another concurrently? When two tops are spinning in opposite directions the Universe is simultaneously spinning in two directions? When a million things are spinning about a million axis the Universe is also spinning about a million axis simultaneously?

What?
 
On a related note: when I'm walking, is it OK to think of myself as stationary, rolling the earth beneath my feet?

Nope. Because I'm walking past you the other way, and I'm rolling the earth beneath my feet. LOL! No I'm not, we're just walking.

Sure. In your reality, which is meaningless in my reality, in which you are being rolled around by my feet along with the rest of the earth.
 
When I look at the night sky and move my head quickly from side to side is it credible to concluded that my head might be “stationary” and the stars are moving back and forth at incredible speed (faster than light)? Wouldn’t that disprove the second postulate of SR?

If the revolutions of a spinning top were transposed to the revolutions of a shell of distant stars then the stars would have to be moving faster than light relative to the frame of the top.
 
Last edited:
When I look at the night sky and move my head quickly from side to side is it credible to concluded that my head might be “stationary” and the stars are moving back and forth at incredible speed (faster than light)? Wouldn’t that disprove the second postulate of SR?

Here's what SR says about that, Ynot.

a) Go ahead and move your head back and forth.

b) Define a collection of rulers that happen to line up with your head during this shaking process. "The x'-axis and y'-axes shall be defined with respect to the x and y axes via {x', y'} = {x cos(wt) - y sin (wt), x sin (wt) + y cos(wt)}".

c) Write down the positions of things in {x',y',z} coordinates. Your bellybutton is at {0,0,-1}. Your nose is at {0.05,0,0}. Your left hand, outstretched, is at {1m*sin(wt),1m*cos(wt),-0.3}. The star Alpha Centauri is at {(10 pc)*cos(wt), (10 pc)*sin(wt)}.

d) Write down the laws of physics in this coordinate system. What does that mean? It means you want to write down positions-vs.-time of objects. You want to write "x' of alpha centauri is some function f(t)". You want to write down laws like "F=ma". But because you're using funny coordinates these laws are complicated. There is some sort of force law, comparable to F=ma, but it is not true that a = d^2/dt^2 x'(t).

e) If you write down the actual law governing the speed of light---i.e. you track a photon and write v^2 = (dx'/dt)^2 + (dy'/dt)^2 + (dz'/dt)^2, using your own weird coordinates---you find that physics does NOT predict v^2 = (dx'/dt)^2 + (dy'/dt)^2 + (dz'/dt)^2 is a constant, nor that it's a speed limit, nor that it requires energy to get close to it, etc.

I feel like I'm repeating myself. Ynot, is any of this making sense?
 
Here's what SR says about that, Ynot.

a) Go ahead and move your head back and forth.

b) Define a collection of rulers that happen to line up with your head during this shaking process. "The x'-axis and y'-axes shall be defined with respect to the x and y axes via {x', y'} = {x cos(wt) - y sin (wt), x sin (wt) + y cos(wt)}".

c) Write down the positions of things in {x',y',z} coordinates. Your bellybutton is at {0,0,-1}. Your nose is at {0.05,0,0}. Your left hand, outstretched, is at {1m*sin(wt),1m*cos(wt),-0.3}. The star Alpha Centauri is at {(10 pc)*cos(wt), (10 pc)*sin(wt)}.

d) Write down the laws of physics in this coordinate system. What does that mean? It means you want to write down positions-vs.-time of objects. You want to write "x' of alpha centauri is some function f(t)". You want to write down laws like "F=ma". But because you're using funny coordinates these laws are complicated. There is some sort of force law, comparable to F=ma, but it is not true that a = d^2/dt^2 x'(t).

e) If you write down the actual law governing the speed of light---i.e. you track a photon and write v^2 = (dx'/dt)^2 + (dy'/dt)^2 + (dz'/dt)^2, using your own weird coordinates---you find that physics does NOT predict v^2 = (dx'/dt)^2 + (dy'/dt)^2 + (dz'/dt)^2 is a constant, nor that it's a speed limit, nor that it requires energy to get close to it, etc.

I feel like I'm repeating myself. Ynot, is any of this making sense?
Sorry but to me that just represents obfuscation by math.

Either a top is spinning at 1000 rpm or the Universe is spinning at 1000 rpm. What speed would the Sun need to be travelling to orbit a non-spinning top at 1000 rpm? What speed would a star 100 light years away?
 
Last edited:
Sorry but to me that just represents obfuscation by math.

That kind of "obfuscation" led to one of the greatest advances in the history of science. It took a true genius to make that leap, and his insight is still not understood by most people 100 years later.

Either a top is spinning at 1000 rpm or the Universe is spinning at 1000 rpm. What speed would the Sun need to be travelling to orbit a non-spinning top at 1000 rpm? What speed would a star 100 light years away?

You're just not getting the point. That red fruit over there is both an apple and une pomme, and it makes not the slightest bit of difference to reality which word you choose to use. Precisely the same is true for coordinates - they are a human convention for labeling events, and nothing more. Any coordinates will do, and the laws of physics make perfect sense (and give correct predictions) in all.
 
Sorry but to me that just represents obfuscation by math.

Either a top is spinning at 1000 rpm or the Universe is spinning at 1000 rpm. What speed would the Sun need to be travelling to orbit a non-spinning top at 1000 rpm? What speed would a star 100 light years away?

If the top is on Earth, and the Sun is 0.15 trillion meters away rotating at 1000 rpm, then it's moving at 15.7 billion m/s.

Why is this a problem? It's a problem if you try to apply the laws of physics of an inertial coordinate system. If you ever find yourself in a coordinate system where you actually feel a centrifugal+coriolis force corresponding to 1000rpm, then "moving in a circle at 15.7 Gm/s" is what you expect the Sun to do if it's obeying the laws of motion in those coordinates. In this coordinate system, it'd violate the laws of physics for the Sun to be stationary.
 
Ynot, let's step back to the beginning. Can I walk you through something?

a) We're on ordinary Earth---no weird shells or GR or anything. You're sitting on a top, spinning at 1000 rpm. You feel a crazy centrifugal force. You're obviously spinning. No laws of physics broken there.

b) Imagine a line stretching straight out in front of you. A completely imaginary straight line, which (because you're spinning) is now whipping through space at 1000 rpm. It's just a figment of geometry---nothing wrong with that. But of course the end of the line is imagined to be zipping past the Sun, etc., at speeds much greater than c. Nothing wrong with that, there's no law of physics stopping an imaginary line from moving however you want it to.

c) Look at the Sun. Look at your line. Can you state the distance between them? Call this distance X---the distance between the Sun and your line-whipping-through-space. You can do this repeatedly, write down a bunch of X'es in your notebook at various times. Nothing wrong with that. The imaginary line is somewhere, the Sun is somewhere, of course you can just write down the distance.

d) Now that you have this notebook full of X-values, you might consider making predictions. If you watch the Sun's past X values, and draw some reasonable inferences, can you predict what X will be one second from now? Of course you can. The Sun is behaving regularly, so the distance X isn't leaping unexpectedly between values.

e) Does it bother you that this quantity X changes very fast? That dX/dt is (thought of as a velocity) much faster than light? It shouldn't. Of course the distance to an imaginary line that's moving faster than light can move faster than light.

f) Does it bother you that there are other tops nearby, other than the one you're riding on and that your imaginary-line emanates from? Of course not. The other tops don't stop you from drawing your imaginary line; your imaginary line doesn't stop the Earth from having other tops on it.

Well, you know what just happened? You just described a physical phenomenon in a rotating coordinate system. Your weird distance-measurement "X" is a coordinate measured on a rotating axis. Your ability to predict future values of X---that is a law-of-physics expressed in the rotating system. That's what "laws of physics" are.

OK? That's what we mean by it's OK to write ALL of the laws of physics in rotating coordinates. Coordinates are just distances-to-imaginary-axes. It's fine if those axes are rotating. There's no way to mess up the Universe by an imaginary-line-drawing exercise like the one above.

Sorry, Ynot, that's the last explanation I have in me. If you don't get that, or at least part of it, then I doubt anything else I write will help.

The subtle thing (and the thing you'll be forgiven for not getting) is when you add GR. As it turns out, gravitomagnetism in GR will take ordinary, non-spinning observers and make them feel like they're spinning. The "feel like" is accurate in every possible detail, from "my centrifugoscope arms are up" to "my X-axis seems to have whipped past the Sun at high speed" and so on. For GR-related reasons, physicists like to take this obscure "observer thinks he's moving" effect, and lump it in with more-familiar "observer thinks he's moving" effects caused by other aspects of gravity. And the right way to describe that is to say that all frames are equally valid. It's a good thing to say; the mathematics, physics, experiments, and thought-experiments behind it are sound. It is a somewhat complicated statement, since most people aren't used to the idea of "coordinates" as used in physics.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom