Terra revolving round Sol question

Well it's the part we can see, anyway. More importantly, it's still as arbitrary as any, depending on where you put your origin and how space is curved there.
Check out WMAP, which suggests that the universe is flat, and that space isn't curved at all. As for how big it is, who knows?

If I might digress a moment, in some articles you'll read something to the effect that "if the universe is flat it must be infinite", but this isn't actually true. If you were some kind of flatworm living on a sphere, you could work out the size of your world from the curvature. But if you can't measure any curvature, you can't work out that your world is infinite. For all you know you could be living on a disc. By that I mean a mathematical disc rather than a flat round plate where you can crawl over the edge to the underside. It's just a surface, when you get to the edge there's nowhere else to go. To scale it back up a dimension, I think an interesting analogy is a globule of water coupled with the wave nature of matter. When a wave meets the edge it suffers total internal reflection. You wouldn't be able to see an edge, you'd see reflections. Hence I amuse myself looking at the Hubble deep field, picking some galaxy and then looking to the right and asking myself is that the same galaxy? All good fun.
 
Does your idea of "Universal motion" have any physical significance? Does it make any physical predictions?

ETA: Because as far as I can tell, all your "Universal motion" really means is, "stuff is moving relative to other stuff, which may or may not be in absolute motion".
No, “Universal motion” means (in “my idea”) that things have motion that isn’t merely relative. Relative motion is just a way of observing Universal motions. Relative motion is a consequence of different Universal motions.

What credible evidence do you have that it’s even possible that a thing “may not be in absolute motion“? If there’s absolutely no evidence that such a state can and does exist why do assume or conclude it possibly can and does?
 
Last edited:
Funny, I was about to raise Maxwell here. What in Maxwell's equations (modified from the standard form to permit a magnetic monopole) suggests anything 'twisty' about magnetic monopoles?

edit to add: I don't think attacking the level of other peoples physics education is going to be a successful line of argument for you.
Sigh. And yet again edd digs up some specious smart-ass reason to ignore Einstein and Maxwell and what gravitomagnetism and electromagnetism is all about. Timewaster.
 
Sigh. And yet again edd digs up some specious smart-ass reason to ignore Einstein and Maxwell and what gravitomagnetism and electromagnetism is all about. Timewaster.

How am I ignoring Maxwell by suggesting you use Maxwell's equations to explain how a magnetic monopole on its own gives rise to any sort of twisting field?
 
Check out WMAP, which suggests that the universe is flat, and that space isn't curved at all. As for how big it is, who knows?

If I might digress a moment, in some articles you'll read something to the effect that "if the universe is flat it must be infinite", but this isn't actually true. If you were some kind of flatworm living on a sphere, you could work out the size of your world from the curvature. But if you can't measure any curvature, you can't work out that your world is infinite. For all you know you could be living on a disc. By that I mean a mathematical disc rather than a flat round plate where you can crawl over the edge to the underside. It's just a surface, when you get to the edge there's nowhere else to go. To scale it back up a dimension, I think an interesting analogy is a globule of water coupled with the wave nature of matter. When a wave meets the edge it suffers total internal reflection. You wouldn't be able to see an edge, you'd see reflections. Hence I amuse myself looking at the Hubble deep field, picking some galaxy and then looking to the right and asking myself is that the same galaxy? All good fun.

A better example of a flat but finite space that avoids any issues with edges would be a flat torus.
 
No, “Universal motion” means (in “my idea”) that things have motion that isn’t merely relative. Relative motion is just a way of observing Universal motions. Relative motion is a consequence of different Universal motions.

So your idea is that Universal motion is an absolute motion? And that everything has an absolute motion?

What credible evidence do you have that it’s even possible that a thing “may not be in absolute motion“? If there’s absolutely no evidence that such a state can and does exist why do assume or conclude it possibly can and does?

I'm pretty sure there's tons of evidence that it's possible that a thing "may not be in absolute motion".

For example, the theory of General Relativity makes predictions based (in part) on the assumption that things are not in absolute motion, and those predictions invariably come true. Every time GR predicts an experimental result, and the experiment confirms the prediction, that's more evidence that it's possible that a thing "may not be in absolute motion".

In fact, GR is so good at making true predictions based on the assumption that it's possible for things to not be in absolute motion, that it is by far the best explanation for the physical universe that we have ever had. It is demonstrably, unquestionably, better than any previous explanation that did not allow for the possibility that things may not be in absolute motion.

So when I ask if your idea of Universal motion has any physical significance, what I'm actually asking is, does your idea of Universal motion successfully predict everything that GR successfully predicts? And does it offer a better explanation of the physical reality we observe, than GR does?

Do you even know whether it is possible to produce a sensible explanation of physical reality, that includes an absolute frame of reference? NOTE: I'm not asking if you have any evidence that such a frame of reference exists--I'm asking if you think it's possible to describe an absolute frame of reference that makes sense of what we observe.
 
So your idea is that Universal motion is an absolute motion? And that everything has an absolute motion?
Yes, if “Universal motion” and “Absolute motion” essentially mean the same thing (which I think they do). I prefer to use “Universal motion” and “Universal stationary” and will continue to do so (after all it‘s “my idea“).

I'm pretty sure there's tons of evidence that it's possible that a thing "may not be in absolute motion".

For example, the theory of General Relativity makes predictions based (in part) on the assumption that things are not in absolute motion, and those predictions invariably come true. Every time GR predicts an experimental result, and the experiment confirms the prediction, that's more evidence that it's possible that a thing "may not be in absolute motion".

In fact, GR is so good at making true predictions based on the assumption that it's possible for things to not be in absolute motion, that it is by far the best explanation for the physical universe that we have ever had. It is demonstrably, unquestionably, better than any previous explanation that did not allow for the possibility that things may not be in absolute motion.

So when I ask if your idea of Universal motion has any physical significance, what I'm actually asking is, does your idea of Universal motion successfully predict everything that GR successfully predicts? And does it offer a better explanation of the physical reality we observe, than GR does?

Do you even know whether it is possible to produce a sensible explanation of physical reality, that includes an absolute frame of reference? NOTE: I'm not asking if you have any evidence that such a frame of reference exists--I'm asking if you think it's possible to describe an absolute frame of reference that makes sense of what we observe.
So this “tons of evidence” only comes from a single source (Relativity)? Can you give a single piece of credible evidence for a Universally stationary without asking Relativity?
 
Last edited:
So this “tons of evidence” only comes from a single source (Relativity)? Can you give a single piece of credible evidence for a Universally stationary without asking Relativity?

This is like asking how a refrigerator works, getting the answer, and replying "But that's just thermodynamics! Can't you explain it without using thermodynamics?"

If you don't want answers that use relativity---the one and only known and tested theory of space, time, and matter---what do you propose we use?
 
So this “tons of evidence” only comes from a single source (Relativity)? Can you give a single piece of credible evidence for a Universally stationary without asking Relativity?
Evidence comes from actual experiments. Relativity explains those experiments. Your question is ill-formed.

Though if you want to be more explicit, these experiments fit into a very general framework that covers more than a score of proposed different theories of gravity, is capable of describing those experiments under nigh-arbitrary theories, of which GTR is but one. The extent to which preferred frames make a measurable difference is actually quantified, and those quantities turn out to be not measurably different from zero. For more information, look up the parametrized post-Newtonian formalism.
 
Yes, if “Universal motion” and “Absolute motion” essentially mean the same thing (which I think they do). I prefer to use “Universal motion” and “Universal stationary” and will continue to do so (after all it‘s “my idea“).
Fair enough. Just making sure I understand what you mean by "Universal"

So this “tons of evidence” only comes from a single source (Relativity)?
The "tons of evidence" comes from tons of observations that match what Relativity predicts. It's not my fault that Relativity makes predictions that turn out to be true tons of times, and never turn out to be false.

Can you give a single piece of credible evidence for a Universally stationary without asking Relativity?
Probably not, since Relativity says there isn't one. You are the one with the idea of Universal motion and Universal stationary. You are the one that should be giving credible evidence for these things. Relativity says they probably don't exist, and that you're probably wrong if you think they do. And Relativity has tons of correct predictions about reality, to back it up.

If you can tell me an idea that makes more and better predictions about reality than Relativity, and that is proven right more often than Relativity, then I'll happily ask that idea about Universal motion and Universal stationary. In the mean time, based on what has actually been observed and tested, I'm going to conclude that you're probably wrong, and that Universal motion and Universal stationary probably don't exist.
 
This is like asking how a refrigerator works, getting the answer, and replying "But that's just thermodynamics! Can't you explain it without using thermodynamics?"

If you don't want answers that use relativity---the one and only known and tested theory of space, time, and matter---what do you propose we use?
I’m not asking how anything works. I’m asking for a single piece of credible evidence for the existence of a Universally stationary without “asking” Relativity. That a refrigerator exists is self-evident by the observable fact it does. I don’t need to know or accept thermodynamics to know refrigerators exist.

If I was questioning the validity of thermodynamics I would ask for proof of how a refrigerator works without referring to thermodynamics. This could be simply done by demonstrating how an expanding gas causes a drop in temperature. If Relativity is as robust and accepted as thermodynamics is why is it still called a theory?
 
If I was questioning the validity of thermodynamics I would ask for proof of how a refrigerator works without referring to thermodynamics. This could be simply done by demonstrating how an expanding gas causes a drop in temperature. If Relativity is as robust and accepted as thermodynamics is why is it still called a theory?

Demonstrating thermodynamics without using thermodynamics?

Re "still called a theory"...

Please note: "theory" in common language and "Theory" in scientific parlance mean very different things.

Relativity is accepted as (provisionally pending evidence to the contrary) a scientific "Theory" because it agrees with all tests thus far performed, with the measurements and mathematical predictions agreeing with each other not just well, but spectacularly precisely.

Fact is we can't seem to find an absolute background everything else is relative to, and when we treat the observations of the universe as being relative to each other the maths and predictions it provides prove to be accurate.

This doesn't mean there isn't an absolute motion that all motion is relative to, and therefore there is potentially an absolute "still". It means that when we do the maths to see if treating the earth as going around the sun or the sun going around the earth in their respective different reference frames, the maths makes the same predictions.

And if you can't distinguish between the two observationally or mathematically, is there a difference?
 
.This doesn't mean there isn't an absolute motion that all motion is relative to, and therefore there is potentially an absolute "still". It means that when we do the maths to see if treating the earth as going around the sun or the sun going around the earth in their respective different reference frames, the maths makes the same predictions.
By "Universal motion" I don’t mean "an absolute motion that all motion is relative to". I mean that all things are in constant motion and that motion doesn’t need to be realtive to anything (it is Universal).
 
I'm a little confused. How do you define a motion if not in comparison (relative) to something else?

"Object a has gone x distance in y time" only makes sense if you compare the motion to something else. Hence the concept of frames of reference. You're referencing something as "still" (only in an abstract sense, because the thing you're referencing to could be and probably is moving itself, but for the purposes of measurement) and then measuring against this point/object to determine the distance moved. All motion is only practically measurable as motion if it is relative to something else. Otherwise you can't know it's motion can you?

I may be missing your point though.
 
I'm confused, ynot.

Nothing can be said to be universally stationary, therefore everything is universally in motion?
If I use these words as I know them, this either becomes self-contradictory, or the notion of universal motion is an untestable redundant entity.

ETA: For instance, I understand motion to imply a certain measurable velocity. How would you measure the universal velocity of something?
 
Last edited:
I'm a little confused. How do you define a motion if not in comparison (relative) to something else?

"Object a has gone x distance in y time" only makes sense if you compare the motion to something else. Hence the concept of frames of reference. You're referencing something as "still" (only in an abstract sense, because the thing you're referencing to could be and probably is moving itself, but for the purposes of measurement) and then measuring against this point/object to determine the distance moved. All motion is only practically measurable as motion if it is relative to something else. Otherwise you can't know it's motion can you?

I may be missing your point though.
If Universal motion exists as I currently think it does then it would only be observable and practically measurable when it was observed relative to another Universal motion or when it was accelerating. But so what? Being observable and measurable confirms things exists but not being observable and measurable doesn’t confirm things don‘t exist.
 
Last edited:
I'm confused, ynot.

Nothing can be said to be universally stationary, therefore everything is universally in motion?
If I use these words as I know them, this either becomes self-contradictory, or the notion of universal motion is an untestable redundant entity.

ETA: For instance, I understand motion to imply a certain measurable velocity. How would you measure the universal velocity of something?
Things are either moving or they’re not. If there’s a third option please explain what it is. Perhaps my use of the word “Universal” is complicating things. Does this read any better? - Nothing can be said to be universally stationary, therefore everything is can be concluded to be universally in motion.

I explained what I mean by “Universal motion” in post #333. I've also explained why I don't think observablity and measurability is relevant to what I'm saying.
 
Things are either moving or they’re not. If there’s a third option please explain what it is. Perhaps my use of the word “Universal” is complicating things. Does this read any better? - Nothing can be said to be universally stationary, therefore everything is can be concluded to be universally in motion.

I explained what I mean by “Universal motion” in post #333. I've also explained why I don't think observablity and measurability is relevant to what I'm saying.
I'm still confused. What you are saying just doesn't make sense to me, but I want to try to at least understand your position.

You seem to be saying that absolutely everything must be said to be in motion, but that it is not necessarily possible to quantify this universal motion. Is that correct?
 
If Universal motion exists as I currently think it does then it would only be observable and practically measurable when it was observed relative to another Universal motion or when it was accelerating. But so what? Being observable and measurable confirms things exists but not being observable and measurable doesn’t confirm things don‘t exist.
Ah, this helps. I see I did understand you correctly.

This, to me, means that you would say:
"It is impossible, in principle, to tell the velocity of the sun."
But also
"It is absolutely certain that the velocity of the sun is not zero."

Or, in the extreme case, that seems to imply we'd have to say:

"It's impossible to say if the sun is going 567 km/s, 12 mm/s, or 35.7 nm/s, but it's certainly not 0 m/s."

I'm sure I don't know how that would work.
 
Sigh. And yet again edd digs up some specious smart-ass reason to ignore Einstein and Maxwell and what gravitomagnetism and electromagnetism is all about. Timewaster.
That's clearly a lie. He asked you for specifics about what they said. You are clearly attacking him rather than providing the specifics.

We know why: you don't know anything about this subject.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom