Terra revolving round Sol question

Things are either moving or they’re not. If there’s a third option please explain what it is.

There is a third option - that a thing is either moving or not moving depending entirely on which arbitrary choice of coordinates you choose to use to describe it. In other words, that "moving" and "not moving" are meaningless when applied to an object, unless you relate its state of motion to that of some other object.

This by the way has been understood since the time of Galileo, 300 years or so before Einstein, and 400 years before now.
 
Things are either moving or they’re not. If there’s a third option please explain what it is.

Try telling an astronaut: "You are either right-side-up or upside-down. If there's a third option please explain what it is."
 
ynot, is it fair to summarize your idea like this: You want to assert that a top is spinning or not spinning, without having to observe or measure the motion of the top in relation to anything else.

Is that a correct summary of your idea?
 
If Universal motion exists as I currently think it does then it would only be observable and practically measurable when it was observed relative to another Universal motion or when it was accelerating. But so what? Being observable and measurable confirms things exists but not being observable and measurable doesn’t confirm things don‘t exist.

Do you want to buy the dragon in my garage? I really don't have the time to walk it these days. $1000 and I'll throw in the feeding bowls and litter box.
 
Ah, this helps. I see I did understand you correctly.

This, to me, means that you would say:
"It is impossible, in principle, to tell the velocity of the sun."
But also
"It is absolutely certain that the velocity of the sun is not zero."

Or, in the extreme case, that seems to imply we'd have to say:

"It's impossible to say if the sun is going 567 km/s, 12 mm/s, or 35.7 nm/s, but it's certainly not 0 m/s."

I'm sure I don't know how that would work.
Requiring a thing to “work” seems to be humanising something that doesn’t “care” about humans. The Universe existed long before humans worried about whether it “worked” or not. We can’t observe or measure that the Sun (or anything) has autonomous Universal motion but because we can’t say it’s Universally stationary we can conclude it has. If things don’t have autonomous motion where do the motions of relative motion come from? What does acceleration change? We can observe and measure the relative motion of the Sun and other things and that’s what we do.
 
Last edited:
We can’t observe or measure that the Sun (or anything) has autonomous Universal motion but because we can’t say it’s Universally stationary we can conclude it has. If things don’t have autonomous motion where do the motions of relative motion come from?

"Because the astronaut can't conclude that he's horizontal, we conclude that he's definitely either right-side-up or upside-down. If things don't have an orientation, where do somersaults come from?"

Ynot, please note that physicists who claim that there's no absolute motion have no problem accepting, defining, observing, and writing equations for relative motion and acceleration.

(a) Pick a reference frame, recognizing that this choice is arbitrary.
(b) Measure the velocity VA of Object A relative to this arbitrary frame.
(c) Measure the velocity VB of Object B relative to this same frame.
(c) Wait a millisecond, then re-measure the velocity VB' of Object B.
(d) If VA is not equal to VB, that's relative motion.
(e) If VB' is not equal to VB, that's acceleration.

And it's still the case that the choice of reference frame was completely arbitrary, and it doesn't make sense to ask whether it's "absolutely" at rest or moving.
 
Requiring a thing to “work” seems to be humanising something that doesn’t “care” about humans. The Universe existed long before humans worried about whether it “worked” or not. We can’t observe or measure that the Sun (or anything) has autonomous Universal motion but because we can’t say it’s Universally stationary we can conclude it has. If things don’t have autonomous motion where do the motions of relative motion come from? What does acceleration change? We can observe and measure the relative motion of the Sun and other things and that’s what we do.

"Just because we haven't found an absolute frame of reference doesn't mean there isn't one." Is that it?

Of course, what we have found is tons of evidence that an absolute frame of reference isn't necessary, probably wouldn't work, and probably doesn't exist.

So far, we haven't found any evidence that an absolute frame of reference is necessary, would work, or does exist.

If the sum total of your idea is that Relativity doesn't conclusively prove the non-existence of an absolute frame of reference, I'll leave it to the actual physicists in the thread to say whether or not that's really the case.

For my part, so what? Assuming that there's no absolute frame of reference explains a lot of things we observe, really well. Assuming there's no absolute frame of reference makes a lot of really accurate and correct predictions about the physical world.

Does the possible (but so far undetected, and so far nonsensical) existence of an absolute frame of reference give us a better explanation for what we observe? Does it make more or better predictions about physical reality?
 
If the sum total of your idea is that Relativity doesn't conclusively prove the non-existence of an absolute frame of reference, I'll leave it to the actual physicists in the thread to say whether or not that's really the case.

Yes, Relativity doesn't prove the non-existence of an absolute reference frame, in the sense that you can never conclusively prove the non-existence of anything. But by the same token, the lack of a disproof s also essentially irrelevant.
 
I will try to explain once again - I’m simply saying that because we can’t say anything is ever actually stationary we can conclude that everything is actually continuously moving. Whether this motion is inertial or accelerating is not important. Whether this motion is stationary or moving relative to other motions is not important. Everything has it’s own independent, autonomous motion. Nominating that something is stationary may be fine for the convenience of math but it doesn’t make anything actually stationery.
 
I will try to explain once again - I’m simply saying that because we can’t say anything is ever actually stationary we can conclude that everything is actually continuously moving. Whether this motion is inertial or accelerating is not important. Whether this motion is stationary or moving relative to other motions is not important. Everything has it’s own independent, autonomous motion. Nominating that something is stationary may be fine for the convenience of math but it doesn’t make anything actually stationery.

What you are saying amounts to saying that because we can't assign any particular absolute value to the motion of anything, we can thus rule out one particular absolute value for the motion of everything (that is, zero).

Your argument works for any value: 0 m/s (stationary), 10 m/s, whatever value you choose. Thus, not only is nothing stationary (and thus everything is moving), nothing is moving at exactly 10 m/s.
But this argument works for 11 m/s as well. And 12. And 13...

Therefore nothing has any particular absolute motion.
 
I will try to explain once again - I’m simply saying that because we can’t say anything is ever actually stationary we can conclude that everything is actually continuously moving. Whether this motion is inertial or accelerating is not important. Whether this motion is stationary or moving relative to other motions is not important. Everything has it’s own independent, autonomous motion. Nominating that something is stationary may be fine for the convenience of math but it doesn’t make anything actually stationery.
Consider the fact that if there were only one object in the universe, there would be no way to know if it were in inertial motion. Since it follows that there does not appear to be anyting like absolute space, it takes at least one more object to determine something is moving; all we really have is relative motion. So, I believe it's meaningless to say anything is "actually" moving.
 
Yes, Relativity doesn't prove the non-existence of an absolute reference frame, in the sense that you can never conclusively prove the non-existence of anything. But by the same token, the lack of a disproof s also essentially irrelevant.
That seems to contradict what some physicists have said, specifically, that General Relativity would be contradicted by the existence of an absolute frame of reference.
 
Requiring a thing to “work” seems to be humanising something that doesn’t “care” about humans.
You misunderstand. I meant to say I do not know how coming to this conclusion would work.

The Universe existed long before humans worried about whether it “worked” or not. We can’t observe or measure that the Sun (or anything) has autonomous Universal motion but because we can’t say it’s Universally stationary we can conclude it has. If things don’t have autonomous motion where do the motions of relative motion come from? What does acceleration change? We can observe and measure the relative motion of the Sun and other things and that’s what we do.
Yes, I understand what you are saying.
My problem with it is that your notion of "universal motion" is essentially a concept without content. It does not add anything to how things are or behave, it just adds a tag to an object that says "this object is on the move." It does not alter the fact that we can only work with relative motion.
The second problem I have is that the logic you use to get to your conclusion is not quite rigorous, as has been pointed out by several people.
 
Consider the fact that if there were only one object in the universe, there would be no way to know if it were in inertial motion. Since it follows that there does not appear to be anyting like absolute space, it takes at least one more object to determine something is moving; all we really have is relative motion. So, I believe it's meaningless to say anything is "actually" moving.
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]If there was only one thing in the Universe then the Universe would only be that one thing. Don't think a thing can move beyond it's own existence (not even relatively).[/FONT]

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]I will try another explanation that might be more agreeable and acceptable. . . .[/FONT]

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Nothing can ever be said to be actually stationary. All things are constantly moving relative to other things. All things are therefore constantly moving.[/FONT]
 
Nothing can ever be said to be actually stationary. All things are constantly moving relative to other things. All things are therefore constantly moving.
It's simpler than that.

Nothing can be said to be absolutely stationary, therefore anything may be taken to be stationary.
 
It's simpler than that.

Nothing can be said to be absolutely stationary, therefore anything may be taken to be stationary.
It's even simpler than that.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Stationary cannot be said to exist. Therefore only motion can be said to exist . . . Your turn . . .[/FONT]
 
It's even simpler than that.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Stationary cannot be said to exist. Therefore only motion can be said to exist . . . Your turn . . .[/FONT]

"Stationary" is just a particular value for motion. By ruling out "stationary", as I said, your argument rules out all values of motion, thus, by your argument, motion does not exist.
 
"Stationary" is just a particular value for motion. By ruling out "stationary", as I said, your argument rules out all values of motion, thus, by your argument, motion does not exist.
When I stop laughing I might be able to reply.

Stationary is a value for NO motion.

ETA - [FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]All that laughter makes me want to be more agreeable so I will agree - “Stationary is just a particular value for motion”. That value is none, nil, zero, 0, nada, non-existent, completely lacking motion, without motion, still, motionless, no motion . . . [/FONT]
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom