Terra revolving round Sol question

Does the distant shell of rotating mass theory hold up when there's a stack of tops spinning in different directions at different speeds? By "stack" I mean tops on on top of each other so they all share the same axis. I was just in a toy store and saw a product called "Totem Tops" that does this. If two "shells" share the same axis and rotate in different directions why don't their opposing forces cancel each other out?

Ynot, I have no idea what mental picture you're analyzing here.

a) Start with empty space. Do you know how the laws of physics work? Is it OK to play with multiple tops, according to these laws of physics? Do you need gravity to help you spin them? No you don't.
b) Add a distant, spinning mass shell.
c) The space inside the shell is identical to case (a) in every possible way, except that if you point a telescope at the stars outside the shell, they are rotating. Other than that, all of the laws of physics are the same, so---can you still use the same tops? Can you spin them, stop them, etc., however you want? Of course you can.
 
Ynot, I have no idea what mental picture you're analyzing here.

a) Start with empty space. Do you know how the laws of physics work? Is it OK to play with multiple tops, according to these laws of physics? Do you need gravity to help you spin them? No you don't.
b) Add a distant, spinning mass shell.
c) The space inside the shell is identical to case (a) in every possible way, except that if you point a telescope at the stars outside the shell, they are rotating. Other than that, all of the laws of physics are the same, so---can you still use the same tops? Can you spin them, stop them, etc., however you want? Of course you can.
It’s not a matter if I can use and spin the top or not or whether there’s gravity or not and I have no idea why you mention such things. It seems to be a form of obfuscation. It’s purely whether I can tell if a top is spinning or not. The claim is that when I think I’m spinning a top I could actually be stopping it as it may have been previously spinning in unison with a very distant shell of spinning matter. It’s also claimed that when I think I’m observing properties created by a spinning top I could equally be observing identical properties caused by the spinning shell. I can’t see in a practical sense how several tops could be concurrently spinning in two direction and at different speeds on the same axis and all be non-spinning let alone a shell or shells causing them to appear as if they’re spinning when they aren‘t.
 
It’s purely whether I can tell if a top is spinning or not.
But that's easy enough to do: Simply pick a reference frame, and check to see if the top is spinning relative to that reference frame.

Do you have a table handy? So pick a reference frame in which the table is stationary. This shouldn't be difficult; most of us do it all the time without even thinking about it. Is the top spinning relative to the frame of the stationary table? The answer is probably obvious.

A different question is whether the frame of the stationary table is more important or "real" than other frames. The answer to that question depends on whether you're checking to see if tops are spinning relative to the table. If you are, then yes, the frame of the stationary table is extremely important. If you're not, then there's no reason to prefer that frame over any other frame.

In fact, the physics of spinning tops--along with the physics of everything else--are all the same regardless of which frame you choose.
 
It’s not a matter if I can use and spin the top or not or whether there’s gravity or not and I have no idea why you mention such things. It seems to be a form of obfuscation. It’s purely whether I can tell if a top is spinning or not. The claim is that when I think I’m spinning a top I could actually be stopping it as it may have been previously spinning in unison with a very distant shell of spinning matter. It’s also claimed that when I think I’m observing properties created by a spinning top I could equally be observing identical properties caused by the spinning shell. I can’t see in a practical sense how several tops could be concurrently spinning in two direction and at different speeds on the same axis and all be non-spinning let alone a shell or shells causing them to appear as if they’re spinning when they aren‘t.

The tops are obviously spinning with respect to each other---that's something you can measure, using local rulers, and no coordinate-system trick can obscure this. If they're spinning with respect to the table, no coordinate-system trick can obscure this. The only remaining question is: can you can find one solid reference which is absolutely not spinning?

You might think "Aha, using my centrifugoscope I have found that the table is really not spinning". You might think, "Aha, I will point my telescope at a distant star, and if the telescope is fixed on the star, and the star is not moving faster than light, then the telescope is not spinning." These are two *alternative* definitions for "what reference frame is not spinning". The point of the shells-discussion: gravitomagnetism, if present, might make these two things disagree with each other.
 
:confused: Er, do you even remember what we are discussing, or why? Let me remind you:

"...imagine that the earth were standing still and that the rest of the universe were rotating around it: would its equator still bulge? Newton would have said "No".

So in this thought experiment the earth is not rotating, but universe is rotating around it. That is given. All I wanted to point out is that Newton would not have said "No", in the case that this rotating universe is anything like the one we have.
Fine. But remember this: "In the case of Gravity Probe B this is sometimes referred to as the 'missing inch' argument because space curvature shortens the circumference of the spacecraft's orbital path around the earth by 1.1 inches". Hypothetical distant shells of rotating mass twist space. The Earth's equator gets shorter, not longer. Rotating the whole of space is something different.
 
Fine. But remember this: "In the case of Gravity Probe B this is sometimes referred to as the 'missing inch' argument because space curvature shortens the circumference of the spacecraft's orbital path around the earth by 1.1 inches". Hypothetical distant shells of rotating mass twist space. The Earth's equator gets shorter, not longer. Rotating the whole of space is something different.

You've confused de Sitter precession and Lense-Thirring precession I think.
 
Fine. But remember this: "In the case of Gravity Probe B this is sometimes referred to as the 'missing inch' argument because space curvature shortens the circumference of the spacecraft's orbital path around the earth by 1.1 inches". Hypothetical distant shells of rotating mass twist space. The Earth's equator gets shorter, not longer. Rotating the whole of space is something different.
Yet rotating the whole of space is what NASA is talking about in that sentence. I can't say I really understand why, but there it is.
 
Yet rotating the whole of space is what NASA is talking about in that sentence. I can't say I really understand why, but there it is.

It's worth rereading that page in full, as it's a remarkably clear description ( http://einstein.stanford.edu/SPACETIME/spacetime4.html to save you looking back for the link).

The missing inch bit is not related to the Earth's rotation - watch the video of Kip Thorne as well as that's helpful in understanding it.

The de Sitter (geodetic) precession comes about from the test particle moving round the Earth, not anything to do with the Earth rotating once every 24 hours.

The frame dragging (Lense-Thirring) effect is the bit under discussion in this thread. It's impressive that Farsight managed to confuse the two given how clearly separated they are in that text, how clear the explanation is, and given Farsight seems to think he's an expert on the subject.
 
It’s also claimed that when I think I’m observing properties created by a spinning top I could equally be observing identical properties caused by the spinning shell.

No one has ever made any such claim. There are no "properties created by a spinning top".

The spinning or not-spinning top has essentially no effect on anything else, including the shell. because the top is very small and light.

The spinning or non-spinning shell of matter can have a very large effect on everything else, including the top, because the shell is huge and very massive.

Adding multiple tops to the story doesn't change it in the slightest, which is why none of us can understand the questions you keep asking about them.
 
Last edited:
Yet rotating the whole of space is what NASA is talking about in that sentence. I can't say I really understand why, but there it is.
It's like space is a thin flat rubber sheet. We drop a bowling ball in the middle, then you walk underneath and grab it through the rubber. Then you either twist it round, or hold it steady while I get hold of the rim of the sheet and twist that round instead. You get the same effect either way - gravitomagnetism. Space is frame-dragged, like the NASA picture. It is rotated, but not rotating. Rotating space is like me getting rid of the cannonball and getting out the marbles instead. Then I mount the rubber sheet on a turntable, press the on button, and we start flicking marbles across it. An object's path in this universe is now curved instead of linear. However inertia still resists your attempt to change that path. And it's the inertia of the object, not that of some distant mass that does it. When the earth is spinning, inertia makes it tough to bend the path, so the equator bulges. When the universe is spinning instead, inertia makes it tough to straighten the path, so the equator bulges. But there's no twist, it's different to gravitomagnetism. A gravitomagnetic field is like an electromagnetic field. The rotating universe is like a magnetic monopole.
 
I can’t see in a practical sense how several tops could be concurrently spinning in two direction and at different speeds on the same axis and all be non-spinning let alone a shell or shells causing them to appear as if they’re spinning when they aren‘t.

Nobody has suggested that this is valid. In your scenario, two tops are stacked on a common axis and rotating in opposite directions at 1000 RPM each relative to the table. That's a valid statement in the reference frame where the table is non-rotating. If I understand correctly, all reference frames should describe Top A moving relative to top B at 2000 RPM. Nobody has proposed a single reference frame where both tops are non-rotating. You can define a reference frame where one top is non-rotating, but in that frame, the other is spinning twice as fast. Additionally, in that reference frame, the distant shell is spinning (distant galaxies revolving around the stationary top) at 1000 RPM.

Basically, you can define a reference frame where top A is not spinning, or define one where top B is not spinning, but there is not a reference frame where neither top is spinning.
 
...
It’s also claimed that when I think I’m observing properties created by a spinning top I could equally be observing identical properties caused by the spinning shell. I can’t see in a practical sense how several tops could be concurrently spinning in two direction and at different speeds on the same axis and all be non-spinning let alone a shell or shells causing them to appear as if they’re spinning when they aren‘t.
I'm on very thin ice trying to say anything about this stuff, but I think I am beginning to imagine that a sliver of light might be breaking through.
It appears that the mathematics of GR allows one to regard the top as spinning or not depending on what one wants to examine and how. By having the top not spin, the GR equations provide the forces needed to maintain reality by having the rest of the universe act as a spinning shell -- either perspective will produce the same results -- specifically, the top will not fall over because of the resulting forces.
I think I have fallen into the same trap of trying to look at multiple tops spinning resulting in contradictory spinning shells. That will not work because you must choose only one frame of reference at a time. One cannot expect two different frames of reference to provide the same explanation simultaneously. Another spinning top (going in a different direction) cannot simultaneously be regarded as stationary at the same time the first one is stationary. Those result in two different frames of reference with different results in the GR equations.
GR is a mathematical tool (a model) that provides these perspectives, but I still don't understand how all this relates to reality -- but I'm working on it.
 
I'm on very thin ice trying to say anything about this stuff, but I think I am beginning to imagine that a sliver of light might be breaking through.
It appears that the mathematics of GR allows one to regard the top as spinning or not depending on what one wants to examine and how. By having the top not spin, the GR equations provide the forces needed to maintain reality by having the rest of the universe act as a spinning shell -- either perspective will produce the same results -- specifically, the top will not fall over because of the resulting forces.
I think I have fallen into the same trap of trying to look at multiple tops spinning resulting in contradictory spinning shells. That will not work because you must choose only one frame of reference at a time. One cannot expect two different frames of reference to provide the same explanation simultaneously. Another spinning top (going in a different direction) cannot simultaneously be regarded as stationary at the same time the first one is stationary. Those result in two different frames of reference with different results in the GR equations.
GR is a mathematical tool (a model) that provides these perspectives, but I still don't understand how all this relates to reality -- but I'm working on it.
Hope you don’t get blinded by the light ;). Perhaps the real “trap” is not looking at multiple tops spinning concurrently from a Universal frame. I don’t understand how any limited, single perspective observation can correctly represent a complete actual reality
 
Last edited:
Nobody has suggested that this is valid. In your scenario, two tops are stacked on a common axis and rotating in opposite directions at 1000 RPM each relative to the table. That's a valid statement in the reference frame where the table is non-rotating. If I understand correctly, all reference frames should describe Top A moving relative to top B at 2000 RPM. Nobody has proposed a single reference frame where both tops are non-rotating. You can define a reference frame where one top is non-rotating, but in that frame, the other is spinning twice as fast. Additionally, in that reference frame, the distant shell is spinning (distant galaxies revolving around the stationary top) at 1000 RPM.

Basically, you can define a reference frame where top A is not spinning, or define one where top B is not spinning, but there is not a reference frame where neither top is spinning.
I understood the claim to be that you can’t tell if anything is spinning period, not just a particular top. So if two tops are spinning in opposite directions I take it you agree that we can say at least one top is spinning?
 
Last edited:
I understood the claim to be that you can’t tell if anything is spinning period, not just a particular top. So if two tops are spinning in opposite directions I take it you agree that we can say at least one top is spinning?

Yes.
 
Hope you don’t get blinded by the light ;). Perhaps the real “trap” is not looking at multiple tops spinning concurrently from a Universal frame. I don’t understand how any limited, single perspective observation can correctly represent a complete actual reality

I'm sure they'll correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that is exactly what they're trying to explain to us here.:) You get to choose any perspective that you find useful, because there is no single absolute perspective.

General relativity, our current best theory of gravity and a massive conceptual advance (one that has still not been fully appreciated by most people) allows us to choose any coordinate system we like. Its predictions for all physical experiments are independent of coordinate choice, and - unlike in Newtonian theories - there is nothing that prefers one coordinate system over another apart from convenience. There are no inertial frames, and all gravitational "forces" are "fictitious" in the sense of Newton.

As a result, you're perfectly free to choose coordinates in which the sun goes around the earth, or in which the earth isn't rotating and all the stars go around it once/24 hours. Do those coordinates "require many novel forces and assumptions"? Nope, not in the slightest - no assumptions are necessary, nor are there any new forces. Are they more complex? Not really - calculations can be done in whatever coordinates are the most convenient, and the results transformed to any other, so on that basis it's very hard to argue that one set of coordinates are more complex than another.

But come on - doesn't the earth really go around the sun? Well, people used to think that there was an absolute rest frame, and really things at rest with respect to the earth and air where at rest. Galileo and Newton overturned that notion by making it clear that "at rest" is a meaningless statement, one that only has relative meaning. General relativity to a large degree overturned even the notion that acceleration or rotation is absolute, because it allows one to use any coordinates whatsoever, and proves that all physical predictions are unchanged.

I'm only piping in because I'm going through the same process as you. Personally, I'll never understand the specifics, but I'm striving to understand the concepts. I'll appreciate if the experts will correct me where I will almost certainly go wrong.

I think the trap is that we want to hold on to that absolute reference frame. We abandoned our geocentric view of the world and took an "outside-looking-in" perspective and noticed that the planets were revolving around the sun. We zoomed out further and saw that the stars in our galaxy were revolving around a center. We want to keep zooming out to get the "big picture" view of reality.

Somehow GR tells us that this "absolute big picture" inertial perspective does not exist. I've been reading this wiki link on inertial frames (minus the math) and trying to really understand conceptually why there are no inertial frames. That seems to be due to the curvature of spacetime in the presence of massive objects. Apparently, massive objects distort and drag (and even rotate?) spacetime. Therefore, an inertial perspective of the universe is an inaccurate approximation.

Einstein’s general theory modifies the distinction between nominally "inertial" and "noninertial" effects by replacing special relativity's "flat" Euclidean geometry with a curved metric. In general relativity, the principle of inertia is replaced with the principle of geodesic motion, whereby objects move in a way dictated by the curvature of spacetime. As a consequence of this curvature, it is not a given in general relativity that inertial objects moving at a particular rate with respect to each other will continue to do so. This phenomenon of geodesic deviation means that inertial frames of reference do not exist globally as they do in Newtonian mechanics and special relativity.
 
I'm really confused about inertial vs non-inertial frames and fictitious forces.

Conceptually, I've been thinking of inertial reference frames as "approximations of reality", and non-inertial frames as "reality". It seems counterintuitive that if we choose a realistic model (non-inertial frame), we need to introduce fictitious forces to explain how objects behave. However, if we choose an unrealistic model (inertial frame), we don't.

Can someone please point out my logical failure(s) and correct my understanding?

1. GR states that there are no inertial frames.

2. GR recognizes gravity as a consequence of the curvature of spacetime rather than a "force" in the newtonian sense. Gravity is a fictitious force?

3. An inertial frame is an approximation of reality. To presume an inertial frame is to disregard (not recognize) the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.

4. A non-inertial frame is an accurate depiction of reality. Choosing a non-inertial frame is an attempt to recognize the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.

5. If we choose to recognize the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime (= non-inertial frame), we need to invent fictitious forces.

If I'm understanding 1 thru 4 correctly, then number 5 makes no sense to me.
 
I'm really confused about inertial vs non-inertial frames and fictitious forces. (...)

First of all, let me clarify something that Ynot had trouble with. GR can tell you what *would* happen in various counterfactual worlds. GR can tell you what an utterly-empty, finite-size Universe would be like---even though we don't happen to live in such a Universe.

By analogy, SR can tell you what *would* happen if you had a relativistic racecar on a relativistic spaceship full of identical twins, even though we don't have such a thing; and questions about "what does SR mean" can be answered in terms of what it says about the spaceship.

1. GR states that there are no inertial frames.

No. In space with masses in it, there's no global inertial frame.

2. GR recognizes gravity as a consequence of the curvature of spacetime rather than a "force" in the newtonian sense. Gravity is a fictitious force?

Yes. The funny laws-of-motion seen under gravity ("this cannonball's coordinates describe a parabola") come from the exact same GR terms as the funny laws-of-motion ("things get pulled right off the carousel") seen by accelerating observers. There is no identifiable theoretical or experimental distinction that lets you label one as a "force" and one as "fictitious".

Mass/energy causes spacetime curvature, that's a real thing, but feeling a force due to curved space is, in some sense, a fictitious force.

3. An inertial frame is an approximation of reality. To presume an inertial frame is to disregard (not recognize) the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.

4. A non-inertial frame is an accurate depiction of reality. Choosing a non-inertial frame is an attempt to recognize the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.

No. If you're looking at a small, finite region of space, your choice of frame can fully take into account a nearby gravity/mass/curvature. That's true whether you pick an inertial or non-inertial frame.

The only inaccuracy that comes in is if you try to extend your frame over a large region. Then, the thing you're ignoring is tidal forces, i.e. gravity gradients, i.e. curvature.

Examples: near Earth, an astronaut in a free-falling space capsule will think of his walls as an inertial frame. A person in an elevator on the Earth's surface will think of his walls as a non-inertial frame. Both of these are perfectly "taking into account" the presence of gravity/curvature. Both are limited, in the same way, by the finite size of the space considered---if you have a hundred-mile-wide box, you might measure that gravity points in a different direction at the left edge of the box vs. the right edge, but that's a tidal force---there's no frame-transformation you can do, inertial or otherwise, to prevent that difference from being there.

A better place to start would be: free-falling observers are, by definition, in inertial frames. Gravity/curvature tells us that sometimes a free-falling observer doesn't move in a straight line (or, equivalently, that an observer moving in a straight line---like one standing on the Earth's surface---is not inertial). If you wish to represent all non-straight-line motion as though due to a force---as though straight-line motion was the default, and only F=ma could violate it---then you can invent an explanation along these lines.
 
First of all, let me clarify something that Ynot had trouble with. GR can tell you what *would* happen in various counterfactual worlds. GR can tell you what an utterly-empty, finite-size Universe would be like---even though we don't happen to live in such a Universe.

By analogy, SR can tell you what *would* happen if you had a relativistic racecar on a relativistic spaceship full of identical twins, even though we don't have such a thing; and questions about "what does SR mean" can be answered in terms of what it says about the spaceship.



No. In space with masses in it, there's no global inertial frame.



Yes. The funny laws-of-motion seen under gravity ("this cannonball's coordinates describe a parabola") come from the exact same GR terms as the funny laws-of-motion ("things get pulled right off the carousel") seen by accelerating observers. There is no identifiable theoretical or experimental distinction that lets you label one as a "force" and one as "fictitious".

Mass/energy causes spacetime curvature, that's a real thing, but feeling a force due to curved space is, in some sense, a fictitious force.



No. If you're looking at a small, finite region of space, your choice of frame can fully take into account a nearby gravity/mass/curvature. That's true whether you pick an inertial or non-inertial frame.

The only inaccuracy that comes in is if you try to extend your frame over a large region. Then, the thing you're ignoring is tidal forces, i.e. gravity gradients, i.e. curvature.

Examples: near Earth, an astronaut in a free-falling space capsule will think of his walls as an inertial frame. A person in an elevator on the Earth's surface will think of his walls as a non-inertial frame. Both of these are perfectly "taking into account" the presence of gravity/curvature. Both are limited, in the same way, by the finite size of the space considered---if you have a hundred-mile-wide box, you might measure that gravity points in a different direction at the left edge of the box vs. the right edge, but that's a tidal force---there's no frame-transformation you can do, inertial or otherwise, to prevent that difference from being there.

A better place to start would be: free-falling observers are, by definition, in inertial frames. Gravity/curvature tells us that sometimes a free-falling observer doesn't move in a straight line (or, equivalently, that an observer moving in a straight line---like one standing on the Earth's surface---is not inertial). If you wish to represent all non-straight-line motion as though due to a force---as though straight-line motion was the default, and only F=ma could violate it---then you can invent an explanation along these lines.

Thanks for the response. I need to try to digest all of this. However, can you please rephrase the last sentence. I'm especially not understanding the highlighted portion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom