Terra revolving round Sol question

It's even simpler than that.

[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Stationary cannot be said to exist. Therefore only motion can be said to exist . . . Your turn . . .[/FONT]
Now you're moving into weird territory.
This "simple" argument only works if you equivocate 'stationary' and 'absolutely stationary'. The premise is only true for 'absolutely stationary' and the conclusion only follows if the premise would have been about both kinds of stationary. So no, it's not that simple.
 
Now you're moving into weird territory.
This "simple" argument only works if you equivocate 'stationary' and 'absolutely stationary'. The premise is only true for 'absolutely stationary' and the conclusion only follows if the premise would have been about both kinds of stationary. So no, it's not that simple.
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Stationary is no more or less stationary with or without the word “absolute”. Relative stationary is an abstract construct that isn't actually stationary. [/FONT]
 
Last edited:
When I stop laughing I might be able to reply.

Stationary is a value for NO motion.

ETA - [FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]All that laughter makes me want to be more agreeable so I will agree - “Stationary is just a particular value for motion”. That value is none, nil, zero, 0, nada, non-existent, completely lacking motion, without motion, still, motionless, no motion . . . [/FONT]

That's right, and zero is just another number.
 
Are you claiming that nothing is the same as something?

Here's what I'm saying:

According to relativity we can say that something is stationary. In fact, we can choose anything and call it stationary. In that reference frame other objects will have particular values to their motion.
If we choose a different object and say that it is stationary, other objects will have different values for the motion than in that first frame, but if we know the relative motion between object 1 and object 2 we can conveniently transform between frames.

Thus your claim that we can't say anything is stationary is identical to a claim saying that we can't say anything has any particular value for it's motion. There's nothing special about "stationary", as should be obvious from the above.
 
This thread has descended into farce. If you come across an object in space that's spinning, you don't start thinking that the whole universe is spinning around it. Because hey look, there's another spinning object over there, and another, and another. What kind of logic starts postulating distant masses rotating at some hyperlight speed and magical mysterious forces? It isn't physics, it isn't cosmology, it's posturing geocentric quackery, peddled by people who ignore the CMBR dipole anisotropy, and who don't have a clue about gravitomagnetism or inertia. They try to pass off the nonsense they're pushing as relativity, and then the next breath say it doesn't matter what Einstein said. Talk about Emperor's New Clothes.
 
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Stationary is no more or less stationary with or without the word “absolute”.
It is if you conflate the two, yes.
To me, not so much. One of them does not exist in any meaningful way, the other one is useful. That is, in my head, stationary always means "declared stationary".

Relative stationary is an abstract construct that isn't actually stationary. [/FONT]
Perhaps, but absolutely stationary is an even more abstract concept that doesn't actually refer to anything in the physical world.
The same thing goes for its "opposite", which you call universal motion, which can take any real value except zero, and cannot be quantified for any given object.

Most importantly, this whole conundrum goes away when you just ignore absolute stationarity, because it does not meaningfully exist. Then forget about the opposite of this non-existent thing, and accept that velocity is a quantity that can exclusively be described relative to something declared to be stationary.
 
You're forgetting about light.

ETA: and absolutely stationary is meaningful when an object has no motion relative to the CMBR. It is stationary with respect to the universe, and that's as absolute as it gets.
 
Last edited:
sorry to ask but...how can you tell the difference between a universe that is spinning around an object verses a stationary universe where the object is spinning? If you can't then does it matter which one you choose?
 
This thread has descended into farce. If you come across an object in space that's spinning, you don't start thinking that the whole universe is spinning around it. Because hey look, there's another spinning object over there, and another, and another. What kind of logic starts postulating distant masses rotating at some hyperlight speed and magical mysterious forces?
It's not postulating. It's just a coordinate transformation. The fact that you think the resulting picture is strange is because your ancestors did not evolve to deal with a world that is significantly rotating.
Yet they did evolve to deal with significantly curved spacetime, so that nobody bats an eye when an object thrown does not continue on a straight path. See how that works? It's just a question of what perspective makes most intuitive sense to you. To ask which perspective describes reality more truly is meaningless. They are perfectly equivalent descriptions.
 
You're forgetting about light.
What about light?

ETA: and absolutely stationary is meaningful when an object has no motion relative to the CMBR. It is stationary with respect to the universe, and that's as absolute as it gets.
Yes, and as it turns out, it doesn't actually get all that absolute. For instance, I read that the CMB is constant to within 1 part in 100,000 or so. What would be the corresponding error margin on velocities?

ETA: Also, Humanzee makes a good point.
 
Last edited:
The way you get a rest frame from the CMB is to work out how you'd have to move relative to our position in order to get its dipole to zero. The primordial anisotropies that are about one part in 100,000 are after the much larger dipole we see due to our motion has been subtracted.
That dipole is off the top of my head equivalent to about 600-700km/s towards Leo, roughly.
There's actually probably a very small primordial dipole not due to our motion relative to the average of the rest of the universe - but it can't be disentangled and is likely to be a couple of orders of magnitude smaller - equivalent to probably no more than 10km/s error.
 
The way you get a rest frame from the CMB is to work out how you'd have to move relative to our position in order to get its dipole to zero. The primordial anisotropies that are about one part in 100,000 are after the much larger dipole we see due to our motion has been subtracted.
That dipole is off the top of my head equivalent to about 600-700km/s towards Leo, roughly.
There's actually probably a very small primordial dipole not due to our motion relative to the average of the rest of the universe - but it can't be disentangled and is likely to be a couple of orders of magnitude smaller - equivalent to probably no more than 10km/s error.
Cool, thanks. So if I understand you correctly, declaring something "absolutely stationary" the way Farsight wants would imply saying that its stationary to within 10 km/s?

And this is due to anisotropy, not measurement errors, correct?
 
Last edited:
Yes. We would have the same error even if we made perfect measurements of the CMB. It's a kind of cosmic variance (googleable term there) - we are limited by only being able to see the one CMB and so can't use it alone to narrow things down further.

This doesn't change the theoretical existence of the ideal frame in discussion either.
 
If we could measure a cosmic neutrino background would that make a difference in the error or identification of such an "ideal" reference frame?
 
The neutrinos would come from a different surface to the CMB and so would in principle provide an extra measurement you could use to reduce the effect of cosmic variance, yes.

Aside from the practical difficulties I'm a bit worried there's something I've not thought of about that, but I think it's alright in principle.
 
ETA - [FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]All that laughter makes me want to be more agreeable so I will agree - “Stationary is just a particular value for motion”. That value is none, nil, zero, 0, nada, non-existent, completely lacking motion, without motion, still, motionless, no motion . . . [/FONT]
Yes, and it is something that has no application outside of a particular choice of what is stationary. As Maxwell said, if you take the time to think about the issue, you will find no reason to try to find absolute motion.
 
Last edited:
I will try to explain once again - I’m simply saying that because we can’t say anything is ever actually stationary we can conclude that everything is actually continuously moving.

No we can't - not using logic, at least.

A murder was committed last night. We don't have any evidence so we can't conclude that ynot didn't do it. Therefore, we can conclude that ynot committed the murder, and so did everyone else. :confused:

ynot said:
Roboramma said:
"Stationary" is just a particular value for motion. By ruling out "stationary", as I said, your argument rules out all values of motion, thus, by your argument, motion does not exist.
When I stop laughing I might be able to reply.

Stationary is a value for NO motion.

ETA - All that laughter makes me want to be more agreeable so I will agree - “Stationary is just a particular value for motion”. That value is none, nil, zero, 0, nada, non-existent, completely lacking motion, without motion, still, motionless, no motion . . .

You are aware that zero is a number and "stationary" means "velocity=0" - right?
 
You're forgetting about light.

ETA: and absolutely stationary is meaningful when an object has no motion relative to the CMBR. It is stationary with respect to the universe, and that's as absolute as it gets.
The CMB is made up of photons. There is no meaningful reference frame for photons.

The photons that make up the CMB clearly did not originate from a completely homogenous collection. How do you pick out the particles that were at rest when the CMB was emitted?
 
The CMB is made up of photons. There is no meaningful reference frame for photons.

The photons that make up the CMB clearly did not originate from a completely homogenous collection. How do you pick out the particles that were at rest when the CMB was emitted?

An individual CMB photon of course doesn't define a frame. But the collection of them does (approximately) - it's the frame in which the temperature (CMB photons have a black body spectrum) looks uniform in all directions, or rather uniform up to fluctuations of about 1 part in 100,000. An observer moving with respect to that frame will see a higher temperature in front of her and a lower temperature behind, due to Doppler shift.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom