sol invictus
Philosopher
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2007
- Messages
- 8,613
1. GR states that there are no inertial frames.
Right - although you can always choose a frame that's close to inertial in some finite region. The degree of "non-inertialness" depends on how curved the spacetime is, which in turn depends on how much matter and energy there is nearby, whether there are gravity waves passing through, etc.
2. GR recognizes gravity as a consequence of the curvature of spacetime rather than a "force" in the newtonian sense. Gravity is a fictitious force?
Yes.
3. An inertial frame is an approximation of reality. To presume an inertial frame is to disregard (not recognize) the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.
Yes.
4. A non-inertial frame is an accurate depiction of reality. Choosing a non-inertial frame is an attempt to recognize the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.
It's more quantitative and specific than that, but yes.
5. If we choose to recognize the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime (= non-inertial frame), we need to invent fictitious forces.
Einstein's equations let us calculate the curvature of spacetime given the matter and energy content. Once we know the spacetime, we can describe it using various choices of coordinates - those are frames. Since the spacetime is curved, none of the coordinates will be inertial (inertial coordinates can't describe a curved space, any more than you can make a map of the surface of the earth that's both flat and not distorted).
One you have the spacetime and the coordinates, you can predict the motion of particles. Those equations of motion will look approximately like ma=0 unless either (a) the spacetime is curved, in which case you cannot use inertial coordinates, or (b) it's not (very) curved but you choose to use non-inertial coordinates, in which case there are "fictitious forces".