Terra revolving round Sol question

1. GR states that there are no inertial frames.

Right - although you can always choose a frame that's close to inertial in some finite region. The degree of "non-inertialness" depends on how curved the spacetime is, which in turn depends on how much matter and energy there is nearby, whether there are gravity waves passing through, etc.

2. GR recognizes gravity as a consequence of the curvature of spacetime rather than a "force" in the newtonian sense. Gravity is a fictitious force?

Yes.

3. An inertial frame is an approximation of reality. To presume an inertial frame is to disregard (not recognize) the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.

Yes.

4. A non-inertial frame is an accurate depiction of reality. Choosing a non-inertial frame is an attempt to recognize the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime.

It's more quantitative and specific than that, but yes.

5. If we choose to recognize the effects of massive objects on the geometry of spacetime (= non-inertial frame), we need to invent fictitious forces.

Einstein's equations let us calculate the curvature of spacetime given the matter and energy content. Once we know the spacetime, we can describe it using various choices of coordinates - those are frames. Since the spacetime is curved, none of the coordinates will be inertial (inertial coordinates can't describe a curved space, any more than you can make a map of the surface of the earth that's both flat and not distorted).

One you have the spacetime and the coordinates, you can predict the motion of particles. Those equations of motion will look approximately like ma=0 unless either (a) the spacetime is curved, in which case you cannot use inertial coordinates, or (b) it's not (very) curved but you choose to use non-inertial coordinates, in which case there are "fictitious forces".
 
I'm sure they'll correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that is exactly what they're trying to explain to us here.:) You get to choose any perspective that you find useful, because there is no single absolute perspective.
Yes, and I think I understand what they’re saying but I don’t accept it. If someone can explain how limitations of observation from a limited perspective can have any effect on actual reality (or accurately represent total reality) them I might believe them. Observations from different perspectives provide different information but so what? Reality is what it is, it’s not how it’s perceived to be from limited observation. The invention of microscopes and telescopes didn’t create a new reality they just created means by which we can better observe the reality that always existed. Observation has no magical qualities that create or destroy anything.
 
If someone can explain how limitations of observation from a limited perspective can have any effect on actual reality (or accurately represent total reality) them I might believe them.

But they don't.

Observations from different perspectives provide different information but so what? Reality is what it is, it’s not how it’s perceived to be from limited observation. The invention of microscopes and telescopes didn’t create a new reality they just created means by which we can better observe the reality that always existed. Observation has no magical qualities that create or destroy anything.

That's true. So what?

Yes, and I think I understand what they’re saying but I don’t accept it.

No, I don't think you do.

In a sense, the whole point of relativity is to figure out what isn't relative. The results of physical experiments aren't relative, but statements like "object A is moving" are. People have great difficulty understanding that, because they're used to thinking of absolute motion as real - when in fact it's only relative motion that means anything.
 
Yes, and I think I understand what they’re saying but I don’t accept it. If someone can explain how limitations of observation from a limited perspective can have any effect on actual reality (or accurately represent total reality) them I might believe them.
I don't understand what you mean by this.
Do you mean that no one has explained to your satisfaction how from a "limited perspective" the sun can be said to revolve around the earth, thereby "having an effect on the "actual reality" that the earth revolves around the sun?

Would that be a fair description?
 
I might regret this, but I'm very curious as to what you mean here.
See the NASA page on gravity probe B. The gravitomagnetic field is twisted space or a "twist field". The electromagnetic field is similar. If you move through it, you turn, and in that respect a magnetic field is a "turn field". That's why Maxwell talked about a screw mechanism, and don't forget the torque on a compass needle. For a pure magnetic field or "rotation field", a region of space has to be rotating like a rotor running free and disconnected from the surrounding space. Space doesn't let this happen, it makes as much sense as a disc of the rubber sheet in the bowling-ball analogy rotating like a turntable. But the nature of space doesn't stop you giving a rotation to the whole rubber sheet.

I thought this was interesting by the way.
 
See the NASA page on gravity probe B. The gravitomagnetic field is twisted space or a "twist field". The electromagnetic field is similar. If you move through it, you turn, and in that respect a magnetic field is a "turn field". That's why Maxwell talked about a screw mechanism, and don't forget the torque on a compass needle. For a pure magnetic field or "rotation field", a region of space has to be rotating like a rotor running free and disconnected from the surrounding space. Space doesn't let this happen, it makes as much sense as a disc of the rubber sheet in the bowling-ball analogy rotating like a turntable. But the nature of space doesn't stop you giving a rotation to the whole rubber sheet.

I thought this was interesting by the way.
Could you demonstrate using the equations for gravity and magnetic monopoles?
 
But they don't.
That's true. So what?

No, I don't think you do.

In a sense, the whole point of relativity is to figure out what isn't relative. The results of physical experiments aren't relative, but statements like "object A is moving" are. People have great difficulty understanding that, because they're used to thinking of absolute motion as real - when in fact it's only relative motion that means anything.
I continue to think that absolute motion is real and that all things are constantly in Universal motion. Relative motion is different Universal motions and relatively stationary motion is same Universal motions. Inertial (non-accelerating) Universal motion can only be observed compared to a different Universal motion (relatively). Accelerating Universal motion can be observed by the observable effects of acceleration. Acceleration could be described as being non-relative or very locally relative. Accelerating can only be observed if there is a lag within the accelerating thing. Gravity accelerates everything equally so there is no lag to observe. Acceleration is a change in Universal speed or direction. Whether a thing can be observed or not doesn’t establish whether a thing exists or not. Relative motion only “means anything” and Universal motion “isn‘t real” only because The Theory of Relativity says so. If you’re only going to ask Relativity you’re only going to get Relativity answers.

ETA - All motion is relative in the sense that all motion is not Universally the same and all things are always moving relative to something else. This doesn’t mean that motion per se is or has to be relative.

All this is merely my current opinions and conclusions.
 
Last edited:
Right - although you can always choose a frame that's close to inertial in some finite region. The degree of "non-inertialness" depends on how curved the spacetime is, which in turn depends on how much matter and energy there is nearby, whether there are gravity waves passing through, etc.



Yes.



Yes.



It's more quantitative and specific than that, but yes.



Einstein's equations let us calculate the curvature of spacetime given the matter and energy content. Once we know the spacetime, we can describe it using various choices of coordinates - those are frames. Since the spacetime is curved, none of the coordinates will be inertial (inertial coordinates can't describe a curved space, any more than you can make a map of the surface of the earth that's both flat and not distorted).

One you have the spacetime and the coordinates, you can predict the motion of particles. Those equations of motion will look approximately like ma=0 unless either (a) the spacetime is curved, in which case you cannot use inertial coordinates, or (b) it's not (very) curved but you choose to use non-inertial coordinates, in which case there are "fictitious forces".

Thanks for the reply. I'll try to do some more reading on the subject. Did you mean ma=0 above or did you intend f=ma? If its not a typo then I'm confused.

Also, in (b) you specified that it wasn't very curved. What if (c) it was very curved and you chose non-inertial coordinates? Would you still need fictitious forces?

I'm really trying to appreciate what "causes" the fictitious forces. Are they similar to gravity and just a consequence of the geometry of spacetime as well? Or, are they more like a property of the chosen reference frame?
 
Yes, and I think I understand what they’re saying but I don’t accept it. If someone can explain how limitations of observation from a limited perspective can have any effect on actual reality (or accurately represent total reality) them I might believe them. Observations from different perspectives provide different information but so what? Reality is what it is, it’s not how it’s perceived to be from limited observation. The invention of microscopes and telescopes didn’t create a new reality they just created means by which we can better observe the reality that always existed. Observation has no magical qualities that create or destroy anything.

I'm not sure that you are understanding. As far as I can tell, you seem to be arguing against ideas that have not been suggested in this thread.
 
ETA - All motion is relative in the sense that all motion is not Universally the same and all things are always moving relative to something else. This doesn’t mean that motion per se is or has to be relative.
How would one go about testing or falsifying this claim?
How does one test if something is absolutely moving or standing still?
 
How would one go about testing or falsifying this claim?
How does one test if something is absolutely moving or standing still?
Let's see what James Clerk Maxwell said about this in Matter and Motion.

Maxwell said:
Section 18. ABSOLUTE SPACE

Absolute space is conceived as remaining always similar to itself and immovable. The arrangement of the parts of space can no more be altered than the order of the portions of time. To conceive them to move from their places is to conceive a place to move away from itself.

But as there is nothing to distinguish one portion of time from another except the different events which occur in them, so there is nothing to distinguish one part of space from another except its relation to the place of material bodies. We cannot describe the time of an event except by reference to some other event, or the place of a body except by reference to some other body. All our knowledge, both of time and place, is essentially relative. When a man has acquired the habit of putting words together, without troubling himself to form the thoughts which ought to correspond to them, it is easy for him to frame an antithesis between this relative knowledge and a so-called absolute knowledge, and to point out our ignorance of the absolute position of a point as an instance of the limitation of our faculties. Any one, however, who will try to imagine the state of a mind conscious of knowing the absolute position of a point will ever after be content with our relative knowledge.
 
Yep. Regretting it.
Why? Go look at that NASA page again. See where it says Einstein was right again. There is a space-time vortex around Earth. And see where it says But if space is twisted, the direction of the gyroscope's axis should drift over time. Then take a look at On Physical Lines of Force where on page 53 Maxwell says this:

Maxwell said:
"A motion of translation along an axis cannot produce a rotation about that axis unless it meets with some special mechanism, like that of a screw".
Also see the title. He's talking about vortices. Now go do your own research and start thinking for yourself. Stop being a smart-alec ignorant naysayer who dismisses Einstein and Maxwell and anything else that doesn't square with your piss-poor physics education.
 
How would one go about testing or falsifying this claim? How does one test if something is absolutely moving or standing still?
You compare its motion with the CMBR dipole anisotropy. The CMBR allows you to gauge motion relative to the universe, and since the universe is absolutely everything, you say that this motion is absolute.

Note however that if you were the something, and if you were inside a black box, you wouldn't be able to detect this motion, so it isn't "abolute motion" in the relativity sense.
 
You compare its motion with the CMBR dipole anisotropy. The CMBR allows you to gauge motion relative to the universe, and since the universe is absolutely everything, you say that this motion is absolute.
Well it's the part we can see, anyway. More importantly, it's still as arbitrary as any, depending on where you put your origin and how space is curved there.
 
Now go do your own research and start thinking for yourself.


For quite some time now, edd and many others here have been thinking for ourselves instead of letting Farsight tell us how to think.

Stop being a smart-alec ignorant naysayer who dismisses Einstein and Maxwell and anything else that doesn't square with your piss-poor physics education.


The person who wrote that sentence has been unable to follow discussions of Einstein and Maxwell because he does not understand first-year calculus and electromagnetism. He doesn't even understand Einstein's algebra: Farsight got lost at equation (3) of Einstein's Die Grundlage der allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie.

Although Farsight pretends to champion Einstein, he's been disagreeing with Einstein for years, notably by denying the two fundamental principles of Einstein's general theory of relativity: the equivalence principle, and the admissibility of all coordinate transformations allowed by differential geometry.
 
Why? Go look at that NASA page again. See where it says Einstein was right again. There is a space-time vortex around Earth. And see where it says But if space is twisted, the direction of the gyroscope's axis should drift over time. Then take a look at On Physical Lines of Force where on page 53 Maxwell says this:


Also see the title. He's talking about vortices. Now go do your own research and start thinking for yourself. Stop being a smart-alec ignorant naysayer who dismisses Einstein and Maxwell and anything else that doesn't square with your piss-poor physics education.

Funny, I was about to raise Maxwell here. What in Maxwell's equations (modified from the standard form to permit a magnetic monopole) suggests anything 'twisty' about magnetic monopoles?

edit to add: I don't think attacking the level of other peoples physics education is going to be a successful line of argument for you.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the reply. I'll try to do some more reading on the subject. Did you mean ma=0 above or did you intend f=ma? If its not a typo then I'm confused.

If by "f" you mean all forces other than gravity, then yes, that's what I meant. I was referring to a situation in which no external forces are acting except perhaps gravity - but in GR as you know, gravity is just geometry.

Also, in (b) you specified that it wasn't very curved. What if (c) it was very curved and you chose non-inertial coordinates? Would you still need fictitious forces?

If it's very curved you must choose non-inertial coordinates, because inertial coordinates cannot describe curved space. Whether or not you regard the gravitational/non-inertial/curvature "forces" in such a situation as "fictitious" is a matter of taste. But what is clear is that in such a curved spacetime, gravity cannot be separated from centrifugal-type forces.

I'm really trying to appreciate what "causes" the fictitious forces. Are they similar to gravity and just a consequence of the geometry of spacetime as well? Or, are they more like a property of the chosen reference frame?

They're a combination. In flat spacetime you can eliminate them by choosing an inertial frame. In a curved spacetime all frames necessarily have them.
 
Last edited:
How would one go about testing or falsifying this claim?
How does one test if something is absolutely moving or standing still?
It’s not a claim it’s part of “my current opinions and conclusions”.

As I see it there are two possibilities . . .

1) If there is a Universal stationary then everything that moves relative to that orientation has Universal motion.

2) If there is no Universal stationary then everything has Universal motion.

That there is no known evidence of a Universal stationary doesn’t mean it absolutely can’t and doesn’t exist. It does mean however that there is absolutely no reason to assume or conclude that it can or does exist (no more than a god). My default conclusion must be therefore that everything has Universal motion. You conclusion can be whatever you choose.
 
Last edited:
It’s not a claim it’s part of “my current opinions and conclusions”.

As I see it there are two possibilities . . .

1) If there is a Universal stationary then everything that moves relative to that orientation has Universal motion.

2) If there is no Universal stationary then everything has Universal motion.

That there is no evidence of a Universal stationary doesn’t absolutely mean it can’t and doesn’t exist. It does mean however that there is absolutely no reason to assume it can or does exist (no more than a god). My default conclusion must be therefore that everything has Universal motion. You conclusion can be whatever you choose.

Does your idea of "Universal motion" have any physical significance? Does it make any physical predictions?

ETA: Because as far as I can tell, all your "Universal motion" really means is, "stuff is moving relative to other stuff, which may or may not be in absolute motion".
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom