Terra revolving round Sol question

Okay . . .

I have recorded ten different distances between the Line and Ball and (as long as the speed of sweep of the line is constant) I can use those measurements to predict where the Line and Ball will be relative to each other and the distance between them at any particular time ...

But no I’m not bothered by any of this.

Have we completed steps d) and e)?

ETA - I'm also "happy" with f)

Good. Then, modulo your dislike of my notation, you're ready for the end of the post.

This exercise is precisely what it means to live in a rotating coordinate system. "Ordinary" familiar coordinates (Cartesian coordinates are the ones you plug into Newton's Laws of Motion) are nothing more or less than than measurements of distances between (a) objects and (b) imaginary-reference-lines, conventionally labeled x, y, and z.

In the exercise above, you stated that you can construct coordinates other than "distances to inertial x,y,z lines". In particular, you constructed weird coordinates with respect to a non-inertial, rotating line. And you claimed, at least, that it's possible to write down the laws of physics in a way that handles (explains, predicts, etc.) the values of weird coordinates.

That's it. That's what I wanted to say.
 
Good. Then, modulo your dislike of my notation, you're ready for the end of the post.

This exercise is precisely what it means to live in a rotating coordinate system. "Ordinary" familiar coordinates (Cartesian coordinates are the ones you plug into Newton's Laws of Motion) are nothing more or less than than measurements of distances between (a) objects and (b) imaginary-reference-lines, conventionally labeled x, y, and z.

In the exercise above, you stated that you can construct coordinates other than "distances to inertial x,y,z lines". In particular, you constructed weird coordinates with respect to a non-inertial, rotating line. And you claimed, at least, that it's possible to write down the laws of physics in a way that handles (explains, predicts, etc.) the values of weird coordinates.

That's it. That's what I wanted to say.
I'm busy at the moment so will have to came back to it later.

I added this between posts - "I don't have an X value. Unless X means distance values then I have 10 distance values".
 
Last edited:
Gravity Probe B was basically a free-falling gyroscope. A free-falling gyroscope in flat space should point its axis to a fixed location on the sky (taking the celestial sphere to be an inertial reference system). Nonetheless, GPB's gyroscope axis was seen to rotate across the sky as though it were in a rotating system.

Maybe I'm really misunderstanding something here. My apologies if I am!
So, I put a top in motion on my table so that it is spinning and consequently standing upright. To be clear, are you saying that we can alternatively regard this (the uprightness of my top) as a consequence of the gravitomagnetism of the "shell of matter" of the universe rotating around my top?
 
This isn't true. The earth doesn't drag space along with it as it moves through space. Yes, the earth's rotation causes frame-dragging, but the space is rotated a little rather than rotating. It's twisted, like the NASA article said. And it's got nothing to do with hypothetical distant masses. If the universe contained very few distant masses, we'd still be able to detect the frame-dragging caused by the earth's rotation.

Please demonstrate the difference as it appears in the equations.
 
I'm busy at the moment so will have to came back to it later.

I added this between posts - "I don't have an X value. Unless X means distance values then I have 10 distance values".

Yes, you have 10 distance values. I used the variable X to label these distance values. This is what physicists do, Ynot. Crack open an intro physics textbook and you'll find 1000 pages of "we define x to be the height ... we solve for y ... we take the derivative of dz(t)/dt to find the velocity v_z" and so on.
 
Maybe I'm really misunderstanding something here. My apologies if I am!
So, I put a top in motion on my table so that it is spinning and consequently standing upright. To be clear, are you saying that we can alternatively regard this (the uprightness of my top) as a consequence of the gravitomagnetism of the "shell of matter" of the universe rotating around my top?
And apparently this happens for every top and every spinning thing on Earth and in the Entire Universe. The rotation of the Earth relative to the rest of the Universe doesn’t seem to interfere with this force. Or even when a gyroscope is spinning about it‘s axis as well as precessing on a different axis. Apparently the Universe acts as this shell for all spins on all axis concurrently, but force applied to a particular spinning thing doesn’t seem to effect any other. How can a force that’s strong enough to defeat gravity be focused so accurately on absolutely every single spinning thing concurrently?
 
Maybe I'm really misunderstanding something here. My apologies if I am!
So, I put a top in motion on my table so that it is spinning and consequently standing upright. To be clear, are you saying that we can alternatively regard this (the uprightness of my top) as a consequence of the gravitomagnetism of the "shell of matter" of the universe rotating around my top?

To be honest, I'm getting tired of talking about it.

There are two separate issues.

(a) Are we allowed to label the coordinates of everything in the Universe in just such a way that your top's coordinates are constants, like an object sitting still, rather than rotating? Yes we are. If we do so, do the relabeled-laws-of-physics still predict that the top stays upright, gyroscope-style? Yes they do; the relabeled laws of physics include centripetal and Coriolis forces which indeed account for the stable angle between your top and the Earth.

(b) "Well," you say, "I don't wanna deal with centripetal and Coriolis forces. I want to just look at the distant stars, pick a coordinate system in which those stars are at rest, and declare myself finished with wacky coordinates, can't I do that?" No you can't. In the presence of gravitomagnetic effects, centripetal and Coriolis forces are still there in the coordinate system in which distant stars are at rest. In the presence of gravitomagnetic effects, to find a centripetal-force-free coordinate system, you have to pick one where the distant stars are rotating.

(c) Suppose you are locked in a room with your spinning top. You've waved your arms around and determined that the room is feeling no centripetal forces. But you can't look at the mass distribution around you. Can you predict, based on this information, whether the stars are sweeping past your window (as though you were rotating) or not (as though you were still)? No you can't---a nearby spinning mass, shell-like or otherwise, would make you make the wrong prediction.

(d) You're not in a windowless room. Look into space. Is there actually a huge shell of matter out there, spinning? No. (Well, there could be one beyond the observable horizon.) Therefore there is no gravitomagnetic source-current that would make you spin. So don't worry about it.
 
Yes, you have 10 distance values. I used the variable X to label these distance values. This is what physicists do, Ynot. Crack open an intro physics textbook and you'll find 1000 pages of "we define x to be the height ... we solve for y ... we take the derivative of dz(t)/dt to find the velocity v_z" and so on.
Do you use X to somehow represent all the values at once or in a manner that any single value could be used and it doesn‘t matter which it is?
 
Do you use X to somehow represent all the values at once or in a manner that any single value could be used and it doesn‘t matter which it is?

The standard notation is x(t). x is a function of time. For a more familiar example, when you're learning how to compute the path of a cannonball, you might write "x = v*t." The position x is found by multiplying v time the time t. If you measure x at t=0, you get x=0. If you measure x at t=3, you get x=3v. And so on.
 
Is the top spinning at 1000 rpm or is the Sun orbiting the non spinning top at 1000 rpm?

If the top was on Earth and Sun was travelling at the speed of light it would take more than 50 minutes for the Sun to orbit the top once. Along way from achieving 1 rpm let alone 1000 rpm. Obviously under “normal” conditions therefore when a top is spinning at 1000 rpm it isn’t a viable alternative option to claim that the Sun could be orbiting the top at 1000 rpm.

So what’s the “special” relativity effect that makes it possible. Put simply and without explanation is it time dilation?
 
Last edited:
If the top was on Earth and Sun was travelling at the speed of light it would take more than 50 minutes for the Sun to orbit the top once. Along way from achieving 1 rpm let alone 1000 rpm. Obviously under “normal” conditions therefore when a top is spinning at 1000 rpm it isn’t a viable alternative option to claim that the Sun could be orbiting the top at 1000 rpm.

I will take a deep breath and say it again.

In a rotating coordinate system, the speed-of-light limit does not mean what you think it does.

So what’s the “special” relativity effect that makes it possible. Put simply and without explanation is it time dilation?

No. The special effect is covariance.
 
This isn't true. The earth doesn't drag space along with it as it moves through space.

Yes it does, in a very similar way to how it drags space around with it when it rotates. If the earth is moving, it imparts a kick of momentum to anything it passes by. In the limit it's moving very close to c, it drags a thin shockwave of spacetime behind it, much like a wake, that kicks anything it passes through.

If the universe contained very few distant masses, we'd still be able to detect the frame-dragging caused by the earth's rotation.

So?
 
I don't think so. I think he'd give the rotating universe short shrift. Newton said this in a letter to Dr Richard Bentley on 25 February 1692:

... I think he'd say the same about gravitomagnetism, and would be happy with the NASA article and the way the rotating gyroscope precesses because its local space is twisted.
Well, he wouldn't, would he? He's been dead for quite a while.

Look, I wasn't literally talking about the person called Isaac Newton, necessarily; I just meant "using Newtonian mechanics". Sorry if that wasn't clear.
 
You did say If Newton were to answer this. But OK, if you ask Newtonian mechanics instead, you quickly appreciate that it applies to the top. The inertia of the body is down to that body. Ditto for the moment of inertia, which used to be called "angular mass". It isn't down to some mystic distant shell of matter rotating at some mythical speed that somebody is trying to pass off as general relativity when it's nothing of the sort. In another thread Sol was trying to paint a picture of infalling space in a gravitational field, now he's trying to paint a picture of rotating space in a gravitomagnetic field, and general relativity just isn't like that. It's like the bowling ball and the "twisted dimple" on the NASA page. It's pushed down, but it isn't falling down. It's rotated, but it isn't rotating. Space emulates a rubbery solid rather than a flowing fluid.
 
You did say If Newton were to answer this. But OK, if you ask Newtonian mechanics instead, you quickly appreciate that it applies to the top. The inertia of the body is down to that body. Ditto for the moment of inertia, which used to be called "angular mass". It isn't down to some mystic distant shell of matter rotating at some mythical speed that somebody is trying to pass off as general relativity when it's nothing of the sort.
Er...
I don't understand how this addresses my question about using Newtonian mechanics to explain the bulging equator of a stationary earth in a rotating universe.

ETA: I said Newton in stead of Newtonian mechanics because the NASA article also seems to use his name in that way.
 
Last edited:
Forgive me for barging in with a question probably of no relevance to the current state of this thread but, going back to the OP, if the universe contained only terra but no sol (or vice versa) would it be possible to assign a mass to terra? I mean could it have the mass either of a humongous gas giant like Jupiter or of a grain of sand but there would be no way to tell unless you stuck something else in the universe with it?

And supposing the answer is no, would terra acquire mass, or measurable mass, if you inserted a microscopic piece of dust into the same universe at some outlandish distance away (or at any distance but it's more graphic to imagine a large one)?
 
Yes. The earth has a gravitational field, the magnitude of which depends on its "active gravitational mass" which is the same as its inertial mass. You can tell it's got a mass because you fall down.
 
Er... I don't understand how this addresses my question about using Newtonian mechanics to explain the bulging equator of a stationary earth in a rotating universe.
See what I said above. You don't use Newtonian mechanics for that, you use Newtonian mechanics to explain the bulging equator of a rotating earth. At the pole some rock is just sitting there with respect to the earth, at the equator another rock is doing 1070 miles an hour with respect to the first rock, and the velocity of a body remains constant unless the body is acted upon by an external force.
 
See what I said above. You don't use Newtonian mechanics for that, you use Newtonian mechanics to explain the bulging equator of a rotating earth. At the pole some rock is just sitting there with respect to the earth, at the equator another rock is doing 1070 miles an hour with respect to the first rock, and the velocity of a body remains constant unless the body is acted upon by an external force.
Sorry, but that still does not address anything about the question.

Let me explain:
NASA asked the question what Newton(-ian mechanics) would say about a stationary earth in a rotating universe, and assumed Newton(-ian mechanics) would say that such an earth would not bulge.
However, I don't think he/it would say that, because (barring something like sol invictus' super-strong cables solution) Newton(-ian mechanics) would have to posit some way for the universe to freely rotate around the earth that is itself consistent with Newtonian mechanics. This would result in some set of fictitious forces that would necessarily behave exactly like the fictitious forces that arise in a rotating reference frame. This would then necessarily subject the mass of the earth to internal stresses that would cause it to bulge.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom