Stupid question about Palestine

Jews (Israeli settlers) who live in those areas are Israeli citizens, with all the protections that entails. They get to vote in Israeli elections.

Everyone else who lives in those areas are not Israeli citizens, they don't get to vote in Israeli elections.

The amount of control over one area or another by the Israeli or Palestinian governments in the West Bank is shown in a map here: Maps: The occupation of the West Bank

Gaza is under internal Palestinian Control, there are no Israeli settlements or military installations there, although Israel still maintains full control of coastal and aerial access to Gaza.

Within areas annexed by Israel there are "Arab Israelis", many of whom self identify as Palestinian, mostly Muslim but some Christians as well. Those people are Israeli citizens, I think they make up about 10% of the population.

There remains significant dispute as to what makes up the "recognized state of Israel". Israel has "annexed" some areas such as the Golan Heights and parts of Jerusalem, they consider those to part of Israel proper, but most other nations still dispute that. Syria, for example, still considers the Golan Heights to be part of Syria, albeit under Israeli occupation.

My only question would be "Did Israel start the fight or did the other side?" Side who successfully pretty much controls the land at the end of any such owns the land. and **** the other side if they cannot get over the stupidity !!! No religion is worth any of this ******!! Or anything else, if the truth be told!!!!
 
Reckless along with delusions of grandeur is a very bad combination for a POTUS.

Notice he was sniffling again as he read this announcement. I do wonder what drugs he is on.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rule 9
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Except for Jordan, which offered the Palestinians citizenship, the surrounding Arab nations treat them as trash, and certainly don't offer them citizenship. Also, the current refugees are the children or grandchildren of those who fled in 1948 and later in 1967, and they're also granted refugee status by the UN.

And yes, the Palestinians were booted out.
Some fled for the atrocities of the approaching Israeli forces, such as the Deir Yassin massacre, a joint operation of the two terrorist groups Irgun, led by Menachem Begin, and Lehi alias the Stern Gang, led by Yitzhak Shamir - yes, Israel had two terrorists as PM. Others were ethnically cleansed, such as the inhabitants of Lydda and Ramle, who were force-marched over the green line, under the direction of Yitzhak Rabin. Oh ****, another PM who was a war criminal.

However, it's part of the Israeli national myth that the Palestinians went all of their free will. It's also part of the Israeli national myth that the neighbouring Arab states made radio broadcasts that the Palestinians should leave their towns. Patently false, as "New Historians" in the 1980s showed.

Oh, and those hundreds of empty Palestinian villages and towns have been thoroughly razed to the ground.

And Israeli terrorists under Irgun and Stern murdered British citizens. For the time, I would have expected and supported British heavy bomber raids in retaliation. It is amazingly educational!!! Note I support Israel - as long as they leave the big boys alone and concentrate on the terrorists. Those are always my choice to be victims - preferably alive and in parts.
 
I agree that historically the Jews were treated abominably in Russia by the Tsars.

I was listening the other day to a BBC radio 4 archive by the BBC TV Daily Politics presenter Jo Coburn, who I did not know is a member of the Jewish race. Some interesting points were made, including that some Jews support Corbyn. Those Jews don't agree with the Israeli government, though most British Jews support a Tory capitalist state. Jews don't think Miliband was Prime Minister material even though he is Jewish.

There is a bit about all this in a book published in 1951 by E.S.P Haynes called The Lawyer A Conversation Piece:

The appearance of this book is timely just when the Nazi fury of anti-Semitism has broken out in Germany. No doubt every country gets the Jew it deserves, and the Germany of my youth had no reason to complain of those Jews nor has Great Britain to-day. The defects of the Jew are on the surface and his qualities are usually buried. Seen en masse, Jews may be disagreeable; but this is equally true of women or chimney-sweeps or even lawyers! The really intelligent Jew may only be one out of five thousand; but is this proportion much better among Gentiles? The stupid Gentile is perhaps less flamboyant and sparrow-minded than the stupid Jew; but that scarcely gives the stupid Gentile much cause for boasting.

Real intimacy with a Jew may not be easy, for the Jew is by temperament usually as secretive as he is often sensitive; but although the Jew is a bad enemy, he is also the most loyal friend. If he never forgets an injury he never forgets a good turn. I have never come across an ungrateful Jew.
 
Last edited:
I thought there was a thread about the Jews which now seems to have been suddenly vanished by the forum management. This one seems the most relevant with regard to the troubles in Palestine at the moment.

At the time of the Balfour declaration in about 1917 Rothschild proposed a homeland for the Jewish race which he then crossed out to a homeland for the Jewish people. The definition of a Jew comes down from the family history maternal line. That would make Murdoch a Jew. Personally, I think there is now a lack of gaiety in Europe due to the Holocaust, which wiped out many actors and musicians and composers, and even comedians, who were alive before the Second World War.

This is from a Wikipedia about the matter:

Israel's Law of Return stipulates that a Jew is someone with a Jewish mother or someone who has converted to Judaism.[8] The Israeli Chief Rabbinate requires documents proving the Jewishness of one’s mother, grandmother, great-grandmother and great-great-grandmother when applying for marriage.[9] The Office of the Chief Rabbi (OCR) has underlined the basic principle that a child is not recognised by the OCR and other bodies as Jewish unless his or her mother is Jewish.[10]
 
Again, wtf does that have to do with:

I recognise that they would not see them as such, but are people in areas of Palestine like Gaza and the West Bank still technically Israelis? Are those areas still technically a part of the recognised nation state of Israel?

I am well aware how Jewish lineage works, my son is technically Jewish via my evil ex. (Because she is an evil *********** witch, nothing to do with her religion). He even has an Israeli passport, amongst other more useful ones.
Fortunately he has a brain and is an atheist.

But once again, Jewish is not a race. Neither is Israeli.

ps. WWII or not, they'd pretty much all be dead by now from old age anyway by now.

pps. You think all sorts of randomly nonsensical things it appears.

ppps. I'm sure the mods didn't 'vanish' a thread.

pppps. Why don't you start a thread for your xyz is/was Jewish and I didn't even know stuff?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom