Stupid question about Palestine

As you imply it is really quite ridiculous to suggest a common Jewish-Israeli _national_ character existing continuously from ancient times to the 20th century. For comparison one would be on way better footing to assert the existence of a continuous Iranian national character from Cyrus to the present day, but even that would be questionable to ridiculous, as that overarching view of continuity from the Achaemenids through the Sassanians and Islamic times only really emerged with the Mongol rulers of the Ilkhanate who saw it fit to paint Chingiis Khan as the second coming of Cyrus the Great. And of course the modern movement began in earnest only in the 19th century!

So... a continuous Israeli identity? Uh, nope.

But it is vital politically to view it that way, or they look like a European colony.
 
To be fair, European colonies are typically, at least at some point in their history, ruled by a European country, which is clearly not true of the present day nation of Israel.

Dave

Just by people from European countries :rolleyes:
 
Not in dispute. I'm not saying that Israel is better or worse, by whatever means you want to define, than a European colony; just that it's significantly different to one in rather a fundamental way.

Dave

Yes indeed. The parallels are striking though.
 
A Palestinian national identity arose only fairly recently as a result of the way borders were forcibly drawn after WWs 1+2. It is essentially negatively defined as those Arabs caught in limbo between Israel on one side, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt on the other. With Jordan playing a low-key, special role. In fact, it has long been said by some sypathetic to Israel's territorial claims that a recognized Palestinian state already exists, and its name is Jordan.

Prior to the establishment of Israel and the invention of Jordan, Iraq etc, indeed the whole region was merely called "Palestine" as a historic geographic term referencing an ancient Roman province named after a Kanaanite tribe, the Philistines, if memory serves (I am slightly unsure about the "Kanaanite" designation), but it was inhabited mostly by Arabs identifying as Arabs and muslims. Hence the locally prefered option in the early and mid 20th century to create a greater Syria as an Arab state, which could have included modern Syria, Jordan, Lebanon and parts of Iraq. Had an Israel been wedged into such a greater Syria, there would have been a place for displaced Palestinians to go and have rights as full citizens of a recognized, strong state.

Israel, in contrast, has indeed had a rather clear identity, both ethnically and territorially, all the time since at least the Maccabean time.

The problem is that we can't roll back time and implement better solutions that might have been feasible before lots of **** hit multiple fans. We have to deal with a Palestinian identity, even though that has emerged rather recently and we' d perhaps be collectively better of if we could all forget about it.

A "national" identity as you describe isn't much older than the idea of a Palestinian national identity.

Various administrative structures dating back to Roman times have borne that name, however. This is also the case for many places we know today and readily accept as the names of regions and the inhabitants therein.

The Ottoman administrative divisions used more the old Satrapy/City-State style of naming (and Eastern names, ex. Halab rather than Aleppo).

I'm not sure whether the old regional names survived through the ages or whether, when offered a semi-autonomous rule with hopes for independence, they wisely chose not to balk at what word was used to describe it. In either case, there are numerous parallels of regional identities complete with unique ethno-linguistic quirks that we all readily accept as authentic.

I mean is Germany really Germany, then? The people we call Germans migrated there from somewhere else! Hell, half of them live in a place called "France" and the ones actually in Germany were trying for 7-800 some-odd years to convince us all they were actually Romans (and Holy...and an Empire). Meanwhile, France was actually part of Rome while Germany wasn't for crying out loud!

Just sayin' :9.

ETA: Do I need to que up a certain They Might Be Giants song?
 
Last edited:
Yes indeed. The parallels are striking though.

Hence the need to firmly establish the idea that there was either continuous presence of the Jewish people there and that it was a barren wasteland. Being viewed as primarily european people moving in and taking land from the people who live there would be politically unacceptable no matter how accurate it is.

And of course non european jews are not exactly treated all that well.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-32813056
 
Not in dispute. I'm not saying that Israel is better or worse, by whatever means you want to define, than a European colony; just that it's significantly different to one in rather a fundamental way.

Dave

Well, there's inherently two kinds of colonies is probably more accurate. One is where a diffuse population is displaced by mass migration (Americas, Australia) and the other is a thin administrative apparatus directing a subjugated population (Africa, India). The protectorate model picked up a lot of its DNA from the latter (having similar developed infrastructure, social institutions, and regional proximity). The proper modern term would be more akin to "occupied territory"

Then the script changes and suddenly there's a lot of mass migration. The other North African and India colonies to one degree or another saw local populations enter the bureaucracy and take control. Generally speaking, there's a rough correlation between the peaceful and structured transition and positive relations with the West. To my mind, the unique thing about Israel is the entirely questionable transition alongside its top-tier status among former colonies. A sudden mass migration parallel to a transition to "local" rule with frequently positive benefits for the former host country and its allies/power bloc raises a few yellow flags for me.

ETA: this would also not be an unprecedented event. A certain Babylonian king once gave the Israeli people right of return. There was a resurgent Egypt at the time and he saw that spinning Israel off as an autonomous dependent would give him a nice buffer state.
 
Last edited:
Is this the case? I can't say Israeli 20th century history is an area I have really been able to wrap my head around, but the reading I have done (which admittedly has been written by friends of Israel, though not utter jingoists) gave the impression that there were broadcasts that did play a role, but that violence and the generally coercive/unfriendly environment Palestinians now found themselves in were the ultimate reasons for why Palestinians left. That is, that it was not exactly forcible, but not exactly voluntary either.

Some left voluntarily and some were forced out. Some kind of a combination. Both sides have incentive to exaggerate that which better supports their narrative, and they do.
 
To be fair, European colonies are typically, at least at some point in their history, ruled by a European country, which is clearly not true of the present day nation of Israel.

Dave
Ask any Mizrahim or Beta Israel in Israel and they'll say the place is run by Ashkenazim.
 
Hence the need to firmly establish the idea that there was either continuous presence of the Jewish people there and that it was a barren wasteland. Being viewed as primarily european people moving in and taking land from the people who live there would be politically unacceptable no matter how accurate it is.
Exhibit A in this category is Joan Peters' book "From Time Immemorial", which argued this on basis of forged and invented statistics and selective quoting, like a Mark Twain quote with an ellipsis in it... that spanned over 300 pages. :boggled: The wiki page gives a nice overview of the history of the book. When it first came out in the USA, all pro-Israel shills lapped it up. When it later came out in the UK, Norman Finkelstein, who wrote his PhD thesis on eviscerating the hoax, sent his notes to the reviewers and the book was blown out of the water by the reviewers of the Times and the London Review of Books. In Israel itself, the book was laughed out of the room by relevant academics.

Undaunted by this, Alan Dershowitz later copied and pasted significant parts of the book for his own book "The Case for Israel", including the aforementioned Mark Twain quote. When Finkelstein called him out on this, he suddenly didn't get tenure at DePaul.
 
Some left voluntarily and some were forced out. Some kind of a combination. Both sides have incentive to exaggerate that which better supports their narrative, and they do.

Yeah, but that's a pretty weak narrative as far as understanding the events go.
 
After the failed UN partition plan, in 1948 war broke out between Israel and its neighbours and in 1949 an armistice was signed with the "Green Line" delineating Israel. Pending a final peace resolution, the "Green Line" is the recognized border of Israel. Egypt occupied and militarily administered the Gaza Strip. Jordan annexed the West Bank and East Jerusalem; no other country save the UK recognized this annexation.

Fun fact: All the parties that signed the 1949 armistice agreed the "green line" was NOT Israel's border, that it was just an armistice line and that a permanent border would be agreed upon (or fought over) later.
 
Wouldn't the simplest thing just be to forget about dividing the country and make it one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights? That would seem the most rational solution to me. Give it some funky name that doesn't favour either.

The problem with that is baby making. The Palestinians who have no interest in being Israelis will eventually grow more voters than Israeli Jews. Your proposal would mean the end of the Jewish state.
 
The problem with that is baby making. The Palestinians who have no interest in being Israelis will eventually grow more voters than Israeli Jews. Your proposal would mean the end of the Jewish state.
Of course it would mean that. Undesired Walrus is saying exactly so. A Jewish state would end and
one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights​
would replace it. That is the essence of this position.

Would you object, if I suggested that Catholics and Protestants should have the same rights in a United Ireland: that would end the Protestant ascendancy in part of that partitioned island? (These Catholics breed like rabbits, don't you know?)

Of course it would! It should be ended. States should belong to the generality of their population, not to any defined religious or ethnic sub group.

Zionism has unintentionally perpetuated the now outdated assumptions of the late nineteenth century imperialist milieu in which it was founded.

Here is the 1916 Irish Republic proclamation of Independence
The Irish Republic is entitled to, and hereby claims, the allegiance of every Irishman and Irish woman. The Republic guarantees religious and civil liberty, equal rights and equal opportunities of all its citizens, and declares its resolve to pursue the happiness and prosperity of the whole nation and of all its parts, cherishing all the children of the nation equally, and oblivious of the differences carefully fostered by an alien government, which have divided a minority in the past.​

Here is a self justification from the Jewish National FundWP.
The JNF is not the trustee of the general public in Israel. Its loyalty is given to the Jewish people in the Diaspora and in the state of Israel... The JNF, in relation to being an owner of land, is not a public body that works for the benefit of all citizens of the state. The loyalty of the JNF is given to the Jewish people and only to them is the JNF obligated. The JNF, as the owner of the JNF land, does not have a duty to practice equality towards all citizens of the state.​
 
The problem with that is baby making. The Palestinians who have no interest in being Israelis will eventually grow more voters than Israeli Jews.
[ citation required ]
Shall we play a game? You provide a reference that argues that "demographic threat", and then I'll provide a reference that demolishes the numbers.

Your proposal would mean the end of the Jewish state.
Given that from the beginning, over 20% of the Israeli population have been Palestinians, not Jews, don't you think that's a bit insulting to a large minority?
 
Well duh. That would be denying Israelis their national identity, which is basically genocide, unlike denying Palestinians their national identity, which is totally cool.

The Israeli's do have a cultural tie with the region that reaches back into ancient history. For a thousand years, the Passover and Yom Kippur ceremonies have ended with the phrase "next year... in Jerusalem". Whether that counts as a national identity is another matter.

The Palestinians do not. Perhaps they might in the future, but as thinks stand currently they are a manufactured nationality with a manufactured claim on the land in general, and Jerusalem in particular.

To quote Zuheir Mohsen,

Zuheir Mohsen said:
...Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new tool to continue the fight against Israel and for Arab unity.

........Once we have accomplished all of our rights in all of Palestine, we shouldn't postpone the unification of Jordan and Palestine for one second....
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zuheir_Mohsen
 
The Israeli's do have a cultural tie with the region that reaches back into ancient history. For a thousand years, the Passover and Yom Kippur ceremonies have ended with the phrase "next year... in Jerusalem". Whether that counts as a national identity is another matter.

The Palestinians do not. Perhaps they might in the future, but as thinks stand currently they are a manufactured nationality with a manufactured claim on the land in general, and Jerusalem in particular.

So if I spend the next ten years wishing I lived in your house, does that mean I deserve it more than you because your only connection to it is that you live there already?

Dave
 
Honestly... so? Aren't strictly maintained ethno-states kind of out of fashion?

So it's a part of the world where being an ethnic minority really sucks. To the north in Syria Yazidi women have been traded back and forth as sex slaves, their men simply murdered. To the southwest, Egypt, Coptic Christians face regular attack in addition to the governmental discrimination against them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom