ponderingturtle
Orthogonal Vector
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2006
- Messages
- 54,796
As you imply it is really quite ridiculous to suggest a common Jewish-Israeli _national_ character existing continuously from ancient times to the 20th century. For comparison one would be on way better footing to assert the existence of a continuous Iranian national character from Cyrus to the present day, but even that would be questionable to ridiculous, as that overarching view of continuity from the Achaemenids through the Sassanians and Islamic times only really emerged with the Mongol rulers of the Ilkhanate who saw it fit to paint Chingiis Khan as the second coming of Cyrus the Great. And of course the modern movement began in earnest only in the 19th century!
So... a continuous Israeli identity? Uh, nope.
But it is vital politically to view it that way, or they look like a European colony.
The wiki page gives a nice overview of the history of the book. When it first came out in the USA, all pro-Israel shills lapped it up. When it later came out in the UK, Norman Finkelstein, who wrote his PhD thesis on eviscerating the hoax, sent his notes to the reviewers and the book was blown out of the water by the reviewers of the Times and the London Review of Books. In Israel itself, the book was laughed out of the room by relevant academics.