Stupid question about Palestine

So if I spend the next ten years wishing I lived in your house, does that mean I deserve it more than you because your only connection to it is that you live there already?

Dave
The Jewish National Funds thinks so, as already noted.
The JNF is not the trustee of the general public in Israel. Its loyalty is given to the Jewish people in the Diaspora and in the state of Israel... The JNF, in relation to being an owner of land, is not a public body that works for the benefit of all citizens of the state.​
it provides land for Jewish tenants whether they live in the area or not, and not for others, whether they live there or not. This is the fundamental principle of Zionism. That is why people who support that ideology give more weight to Biblical mythology than to current legal tenure. As if I had to have a real ethnicity to have the right to occupy my home in the city of my birth.
 
So if I spend the next ten years wishing I lived in your house, does that mean I deserve it more than you because your only connection to it is that you live there already?

Dave

To make the analogy work, you need to buy the house.
 
The Israeli's do have a cultural tie with the region that reaches back into ancient history. For a thousand years, the Passover and Yom Kippur ceremonies have ended with the phrase "next year... in Jerusalem". Whether that counts as a national identity is another matter.

The Palestinians do not. Perhaps they might in the future, but as thinks stand currently they are a manufactured nationality with a manufactured claim on the land in general, and Jerusalem in particular.

To quote Zuheir Mohsen,


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zuheir_Mohsen
Manufactured identity is just as important as non manufactured identity.
 
The Palestinians do not. Perhaps they might in the future, but as thinks stand currently they are a manufactured nationality with a manufactured claim on the land in general, and Jerusalem in particular.

To quote Zuheir Mohsen,

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zuheir_Mohsen
And what are Mohsen's credentials as an ethnographer? His bio is that of a politician who wanted a "Greater Syria". I could also dig up plenty of quotes from Dutch or Flemish (wannabe) politicians with an agenda who claim we're really one people and advocate a "Greater Netherlands".
 
The Israeli's do have a cultural tie with the region that reaches back into ancient history. For a thousand years, the Passover and Yom Kippur ceremonies have ended with the phrase "next year... in Jerusalem". Whether that counts as a national identity is another matter.

The Palestinians do not. Perhaps they might in the future, but as thinks stand currently they are a manufactured nationality with a manufactured claim on the land in general, and Jerusalem in particular.

To quote Zuheir Mohsen,


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zuheir_Mohsen

If manufactured identity is a disqualifier, we've got a lot of putting our own house in order to do. What national identity isn't "manufactured" in the same sense?

This is where the tapatalk signature that annoys people used to be
 
To make the analogy work, you need to buy the house seize the house through eminent domain and gentrify the neighborhood by making generous grants and tax incentives to out of town developers.

Better.

This is where the tapatalk signature that annoys people used to be
 
Last edited:
Then you guys are shamefully promoting a characterization of the conflict that's purposefully distorted to be inflammatory.

In your characterisation, then, in what sense did Israel "buy" the house?

Like any analogy it's flawed, and the reality is far more complex; but any representation that results in the appearance of people who have lived in an area for centuries having no right to continue living there is hardly undistorted either.

Dave
 
Then you guys are shamefully promoting a characterization of the conflict that's purposefully distorted to be inflammatory.
Unilateral assertion of one's own position being superior or another's inferior is about the most useless contribution to a discussion one can make.

This is where the tapatalk signature that annoys people used to be
 
To make the analogy work, you need to buy the house.

More precisely, buy your neighbourhood from your unscrupulous landlord and evict you because you are of the wrong ethnicity.

Owning so much property that the livelihood and shelter of other people is entirely dependent on land and real estate you own gives you the power to do profoundly immoral things. Quelle surprise.
 
Americans seem to understand Black nationalism but not Arab nationalism. Netanyahu doesn't want peace, he wants war with Iran. That's very unfair on British hostages of the mad mullahs in Iran I hope that's civil enough.
 
Last edited:
In your characterisation, then, in what sense did Israel "buy" the house?

Because Zionist immigrants from the very beginning to today needed to acquire their lands and residences by legally purchasing or leasing them. Just like any other immigrant in any other nation of the world. The characterization that Jews just show up, kick Arabic peoples out of their homes and lands and move in is false, inflammatory, and frankly bigoted.

Now, having said that, it is also true that during the Israeli war of independence (called the "Nakba" by some) Arabs who fled, voluntarily or by force, were not allowed back (with some exceptions) and their lands were ultimately taken by the state. In addition in subsequent years there have also been incidences where security zones and buffers have also displaced Palestinians from their lands. I am not defending these actions, but am pointing out that they are a tiny percentage of the whole, and to characterize it as typical rather than exceptional is not correct.

Like any analogy it's flawed, and the reality is far more complex; but any representation that results in the appearance of people who have lived in an area for centuries having no right to continue living there is hardly undistorted either.

Dave

The conflict can be characterized as a civil war, but it needs to be brought to an end. A two state solution, albeit imperfect, puts an end to the violence and lets everyone have self determination.
 
More precisely, buy your neighbourhood from your unscrupulous landlord and evict you because you are of the wrong ethnicity.

While that may have happened on an individual basis, the JNF, which was the agency who acquired lands to facilitate immigration specifically targeted unused lands for the specific purpose of not creating resentment among local Arab populations who would have been displaced.

Owning so much property that the livelihood and shelter of other people is entirely dependent on land and real estate you own gives you the power to do profoundly immoral things. Quelle surprise.

In theory this is true, but I don't see how it applies to this conflict. I humbly suggest you may have formed opinions based on incomplete information.
 
Unilateral assertion of one's own position being superior or another's inferior is about the most useless contribution to a discussion one can make.

My unilateral assertion was a critique of your statement alone, and not a comparison. If you want to provide evidence demonstrating your analogy is true, feel free to do so.
 
I have no idea if any of the Jewish people who lived in the area in 1947 refused Israeli citizenship, or if there are any Jewish people living in West Bank or Gaza who have not sought out nor want Israeli citizenship.

I can assure you there are no Jews living in Gaza.
 
While that may have happened on an individual basis, the JNF, which was the agency who acquired lands to facilitate immigration specifically targeted unused lands for the specific purpose of not creating resentment among local Arab populations who would have been displaced.
You're selectively quoting from the history of the JNF?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_National_Fund:
By 1948, the JNF owned 54% of the land held by Jews in the region,[16] or a bit less than 4% of the land in what was then known as the British Madate of Palestine.[17] By the eve of statehood, the JNF had acquired a total of 936,000 dunums of land;[18] another 800,000 dunums had been acquired by other Jewish organizations or individuals.
But after Israel's establishment:
After Israel's establishment in 1948, the government began to sell absentee lands to the JNF. On January 27, 1949, 1,000 km² of land (from a total of about 3,500 km²) was sold to the JNF for the price of I£11 million. Another 1,000 km² of land was sold to the JNF in October 1950. Over the years questions about the legitimacy of these transactions have been raised but Israeli legislation has generally supported the JNF's land claims.
One dunum is around 900 m2, so the 2,000 km2 the JNF acquired in 1948/1950 equals 2,222,222 dunum, i.e., more than twice what she had acquired by buying it from Arab landlords.

The land that Israel sold to the JNF in 1948 and 1950 was confiscated from "absentee" landlords. However, "absentee" does not even mean they were out of the country:
As a result, two million dunams were confiscated and given to the custodian, who later transferred the land to the development authority. This law created the novel citizenship category of "present absentees" (nifkadim nohahim), persons present at the time but considered absent for the purpose of the law. These Israeli Arabs enjoyed all civil rights-including the right to vote in the Knesset elections-except one: the right to use and dispose of their property. About 30,000-35,000 Palestinians became "present absentees".
When Robert Fisk interviewed the Custodian of Absentee Property, he said that maybe up to 70% of Israeli territory had been confiscated from "absentees".

In theory this is true, but I don't see how it applies to this conflict. I humbly suggest you may have formed opinions based on incomplete information.
What an ironic statement given the above. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom