Stupid question about Palestine

Undesired Walrus

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Apr 10, 2007
Messages
11,691
I recognise that they would not see them as such, but are people in areas of Palestine like Gaza and the West Bank still technically Israelis? Are those areas still technically a part of the recognised nation state of Israel?
 
I recognise that they would not see them as such, but are people in areas of Palestine like Gaza and the West Bank still technically Israelis? Are those areas still technically a part of the recognised nation state of Israel?

Jews (Israeli settlers) who live in those areas are Israeli citizens, with all the protections that entails. They get to vote in Israeli elections.

Everyone else who lives in those areas are not Israeli citizens, they don't get to vote in Israeli elections.

The amount of control over one area or another by the Israeli or Palestinian governments in the West Bank is shown in a map here: Maps: The occupation of the West Bank

Gaza is under internal Palestinian Control, there are no Israeli settlements or military installations there, although Israel still maintains full control of coastal and aerial access to Gaza.

Within areas annexed by Israel there are "Arab Israelis", many of whom self identify as Palestinian, mostly Muslim but some Christians as well. Those people are Israeli citizens, I think they make up about 10% of the population.

There remains significant dispute as to what makes up the "recognized state of Israel". Israel has "annexed" some areas such as the Golan Heights and parts of Jerusalem, they consider those to part of Israel proper, but most other nations still dispute that. Syria, for example, still considers the Golan Heights to be part of Syria, albeit under Israeli occupation.
 
Last edited:
Well Trump is about to make yet another of his ill-advised moves by officially recognizing Jerusalem as the Capital of Israel.

This man is a dickwad!! He creates trouble every time he opens his gob.
 
Reckless along with delusions of grandeur is a very bad combination for a POTUS.

Notice he was sniffling again as he read this announcement. I do wonder what drugs he is on.
 
Jews (Israeli settlers) who live in those areas are Israeli citizens, with all the protections that entails. They get to vote in Israeli elections.

Everyone else who lives in those areas are not Israeli citizens, they don't get to vote in Israeli elections.

The amount of control over one area or another by the Israeli or Palestinian governments in the West Bank is shown in a map here: Maps: The occupation of the West Bank

Gaza is under internal Palestinian Control, there are no Israeli settlements or military installations there, although Israel still maintains full control of coastal and aerial access to Gaza.

Within areas annexed by Israel there are "Arab Israelis", many of whom self identify as Palestinian, mostly Muslim but some Christians as well. Those people are Israeli citizens, I think they make up about 10% of the population.

There remains significant dispute as to what makes up the "recognized state of Israel". Israel has "annexed" some areas such as the Golan Heights and parts of Jerusalem, they consider those to part of Israel proper, but most other nations still dispute that. Syria, for example, still considers the Golan Heights to be part of Syria, albeit under Israeli occupation.

Thanks. But if I am a Palestinian in the West Bank or Gaza, what is my nationality proper? As I understand it Palestine isn't recognised as a state by much of the international community so what is my passport, for example?

Israel really defines its citizens by whether they are Jewish? So if my parents are a Palestinian and an Israeli Jew, am I then Israeli?
 
I recognise that they would not see them as such, but are people in areas of Palestine like Gaza and the West Bank still technically Israelis? Are those areas still technically a part of the recognised nation state of Israel?
No, they're not Israelis and they've never been. The Palestinians that live in Gaza and the West Bank (and East Jerusalem) are citizens of the State of Palestine, but that's not a universally recognized state (oh, Israel is neither but has wider recognition).

After the failed UN partition plan, in 1948 war broke out between Israel and its neighbours and in 1949 an armistice was signed with the "Green Line" delineating Israel. Pending a final peace resolution, the "Green Line" is the recognized border of Israel. Egypt occupied and militarily administered the Gaza Strip. Jordan annexed the West Bank and East Jerusalem; no other country save the UK recognized this annexation.

In 1967, Israel conquered the Gaza Strip as well as the West Bank and East Jerusalem, as well as the Syrian territory of the Golan Heights.

Within Israel proper, i.e., within the Green Line, approx. 80% of the population are Jewish Israelis and 20% are Arab Israelis, the latter mainly in the Galilee, and some very small groups (Bedouins, Circassians), all Israeli citizens. Until the 1970s, the Arab Israelis lived under military administration. They've gradually gotten nearly the same rights as Jewish Israelis, mainly due to various court cases. Every election cycle, routinely the government outlaws Arab political parties who then have to go to court to get on the ballot.

The Golan Heights have been annexed by Israel somewhere in the 1990s; nobody recognizes this annexation. Its inhabitants are Israeli settlers - only Jewish ones, of course.

The West Bank has been divided into three areas A, B, and C. Area "A" is under Palestinian administration, except for security issues, i.e., the Israeli army can barge in at any moment under any pretext. Area "B" is mixed administration, and area "C" is under Israeli administration, i.e., it consists of Israeli settlements for Jewish Israeli settlers. Of course, area "A" is not one contiguous area but consists of four or five disjoint areas that are separated by road blocks and checks and walls.

East Jerusalem is separate from the West Bank and has been annexed by Israel right away in 1967. This annexation is recognized by no country, except now apparently by the USA as it recognizes "Jerusalem" as the Israeli capital, not "West Jerusalem". Its borders have been widely expanded from the British/Jordanian borders and Israel builds large Jewish settlements on its eastern borders. The Palestinian inhabitants of East Jerusalem have "permanent resident" status but Israel pulls all kind of tricks to make their life difficult. For instance, if you're born and raised there, and then decide to go a year abroad to study, you'll find that you won't get back your resident status.

The Gaza Strip only had six small Jewish settlements when Sharon evacuated it in 2002. Gaza is now administered by Hamas, but Israel still controls its airspace, its sea shore and all of its land borders except for the Rafa border crossing with Egypt.
 
Thanks. But if I am a Palestinian in the West Bank or Gaza, what is my nationality proper? As I understand it Palestine isn't recognised as a state by much of the international community so what is my passport, for example?

Israel really defines its citizens by whether they are Jewish? So if my parents are a Palestinian and an Israeli Jew, am I then Israeli?

I am not the expert on this, but here is my understanding....

Palestinians are Palestinians, they travel under Palestinian passports. Israel does not recognize Palestine as a nation, but still recognizes Palestine's ability to do some things done by nation states, subject to Israeli oversight. Many other nations do recognize Palestine as an independent nation state.

Israel seems to recognize the right of anyone with Jewish ancestry to become Israeli, if they live in Israel, at least for a time - they call it the Right of Return.

I have no idea if any of the Jewish people who lived in the area in 1947 refused Israeli citizenship, or if there are any Jewish people living in West Bank or Gaza who have not sought out nor want Israeli citizenship.


ETA: I see that ddt posted a really good answer while I was typing. That's good, and more informative than mine. It can be very hard to find actual answers to questions about Israel and Palestine, as many people jump straight into the political/cultural/religious conflict. Hopefully other forum members can help with that, as I am far from the expert on this subject.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. But if I am a Palestinian in the West Bank or Gaza, what is my nationality proper? As I understand it Palestine isn't recognised as a state by much of the international community so what is my passport, for example?
There is a Palestinian passport, issuance subject to Israeli oversight.

Until 1988, Jordan gave Jordanian citizenship to all inhabitants of the West Bank.

Israel really defines its citizens by whether they are Jewish? So if my parents are a Palestinian and an Israeli Jew, am I then Israeli?
When it comes to marriage law, Israel is a theocratic state. I presume your first parent is a Muslim? Or a Christian - never mind, the Rabbis who rule over Jewish marriage would never perform such a marriage. Your parents got married in Cyprus? Or in Berlin?
 
There is a Palestinian passport, issuance subject to Israeli oversight.

Until 1988, Jordan gave Jordanian citizenship to all inhabitants of the West Bank.


When it comes to marriage law, Israel is a theocratic state. I presume your first parent is a Muslim? Or a Christian - never mind, the Rabbis who rule over Jewish marriage would never perform such a marriage. Your parents got married in Cyprus? Or in Berlin?

Thank you very much for all these comprehensive answers. It's a lot to understand.

So essentially, boiled down to it, based on all you say, the areas of the West Bank and Gaza are contested territory between Israel and the Palestinian authority? As there are Jewish citizens in the West Bank with all the rights of Israelis, then does the Israeli government consider these areas to belong to Israel? All of the West Bank? What is their end target, to take all of the West Bank?

On the issue of the parents issue, you are saying that a Palestinian Muslim and Israeli Jew are not allowed to marry? There is no recognition of a marriage anywhere? If I were born in Berlin to these parents, would I be an automatic citizen of Israel?
 
Also, why are there Palestinian refugee camps even today? Am I right in thinking that the Palestinians are there because they were booted out of Israel back in the 40s or whatever? Are they still there because there is nowhere for them to go?
 
So essentially, boiled down to it, based on all you say, the areas of the West Bank and Gaza are contested territory between Israel and the Palestinian authority? As there are Jewish citizens in the West Bank with all the rights of Israelis, then does the Israeli government consider these areas to belong to Israel? All of the West Bank? What is their end target, to take all of the West Bank?

I don't know what end result the Israelis are looking for. I get the impression that there is no unified "Target". Many Israelis object to the settlements, many don't care, and many are very supportive of expanding the settlements. Some Israelis want to pull back from most of the West Bank, other Israelis want to expel the Palestinians from West Bank and annex the whole thing.

In the absence of a clear political or cultural mandate, the Israelis just keep muddling along. Existing settlements, especially those in or near Jerusalem or Hebron keep growing, but there is less establishment of new settlements than there used to be. Many of the settlers are Jewish immigrants, especially from the old USSR, they live there in part due to financial incentives and nationalism

Also, why are there Palestinian refugee camps even today? Am I right in thinking that the Palestinians are there because they were booted out of Israel back in the 40s or whatever? Are they still there because there is nowhere for them to go?

I don't know about the camps in Palestine itself, but many of the surrounding nations never allowed the Palestinian refugees citizenship or property rights. They kind of forced the Palestinians to behave as if leaving Palestine were a temporary thing. Israel would not let them return to Palestine, not even West Bank or Gaza, but the nations that hosted the camps would not allow them to live as citizens of those host nations.
 
Wouldn't the simplest thing just be to forget about dividing the country and make it one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights? That would seem the most rational solution to me. Give it some funky name that doesn't favour either.
 
Wouldn't the simplest thing just be to forget about dividing the country and make it one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights? That would seem the most rational solution to me. Give it some funky name that doesn't favour either.

Now you're being sensible, that will never happen.....sadly
 
Wouldn't the simplest thing just be to forget about dividing the country and make it one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights? That would seem the most rational solution to me. Give it some funky name that doesn't favour either.

Israel is already a secular nation where Jews and Palestinians (both Israelis) have the same rights. The only places Palestinians don't have the same rights as Jews is where by intransigence, violence, and an enabling international community they have carved out Palestinian ghettos in which they reject Israeli sovereignty. To the extent that Israel tolerates those ghettos, rather than imposing its sovereignty, the Palestinians living there necessarily do not enjoy the same rights as peaceful Israeli citizens living outside the ghettos.

Aside from the name of the country, your solution is what we have already today. The problem is that Palestinians don't want to share a secular state with equal rights for Jews. The simplest solution would be for Palestinians to get over it.
 
On the issue of the parents issue, you are saying that a Palestinian Muslim and Israeli Jew are not allowed to marry? There is no recognition of a marriage anywhere? If I were born in Berlin to these parents, would I be an automatic citizen of Israel?
They can't get married in Israel. There is no secular marriage, only religious marriage that is recognized by the state. So you'll have to find a Rabbi, an Imam or a Priest who will perform that marriage. Good luck with that. Oh, and the Jewish marriage is controlled by the Orthodox Chief Rabbinate, so also many atheist or liberallly-religious Jews are unhappy with it and go to Cyprus to get married. That's a bone that Ben Gurion threw the religious to get them on board with founding Israel.

And yes, foreign marriages are recognized.

I don't know if in your hypothetical case, the child would be an automatic citizen, but they would be entitled to Israeli citizenship. The Law of Return entitles anyone to citizenship who was classed a Jew or half-Jew under the Nazi Nuremberg Laws. That's not a Godwin, that is the actual rationale.
 
Last edited:
Prestige: I see what you're saying, but I'm a bit flummoxed as to why the default position is that it is the State of Israel that claims dominion over these lands. By what right?

Also, you said that Israel is a secular state. I can only go on what others here say as they know better, but it appears to be the case that an Arab and a Jew cannot get married, and the state does not provide for secular weddings to allow this. That does not sound secular.
 
Last edited:
Also, why are there Palestinian refugee camps even today? Am I right in thinking that the Palestinians are there because they were booted out of Israel back in the 40s or whatever? Are they still there because there is nowhere for them to go?
Except for Jordan, which offered the Palestinians citizenship, the surrounding Arab nations treat them as trash, and certainly don't offer them citizenship. Also, the current refugees are the children or grandchildren of those who fled in 1948 and later in 1967, and they're also granted refugee status by the UN.

And yes, the Palestinians were booted out.
Some fled for the atrocities of the approaching Israeli forces, such as the Deir Yassin massacre, a joint operation of the two terrorist groups Irgun, led by Menachem Begin, and Lehi alias the Stern Gang, led by Yitzhak Shamir - yes, Israel had two terrorists as PM. Others were ethnically cleansed, such as the inhabitants of Lydda and Ramle, who were force-marched over the green line, under the direction of Yitzhak Rabin. Oh ****, another PM who was a war criminal.

However, it's part of the Israeli national myth that the Palestinians went all of their free will. It's also part of the Israeli national myth that the neighbouring Arab states made radio broadcasts that the Palestinians should leave their towns. Patently false, as "New Historians" in the 1980s showed.

Oh, and those hundreds of empty Palestinian villages and towns have been thoroughly razed to the ground.
 
Last edited:
Prestige: I see what you're saying, but I'm a bit flummoxed as to why the default position is that it is the State of Israel that claims dominion over these lands. By what right?

Also, you said that Israel is a secular state. I can only go on what others here say as they know better, but it appears to be the case that an Arab and a Jew cannot get married, and the state does not provide for secular weddings to allow this. That does not sound secular.

Marriage is weird. I think a state can be broadly secular, and still make concessions to the religious sensibilities of its citizens.

As for the default position, you may want to read up on the history of the region and the origin of Israel as a state. Basically the entire region was part of the British Empire until the 20th century. The British, as sovereigns there, ultimately granted independence to the various territories. In a nutshell: it was Britain's land and they could do with it what they wanted. All of Arabia was already an Arabian homeland. It's not like Arabs scattered around the world were lacking a place in the Middle East they could call their own.

The only people who were inconvenienced by this arrangement were Arabs living in Palestine, who a) didn't want to live in Jewish homeland, and b) didn't want to move over the border.
 
Last edited:
It's also part of the Israeli national myth that the neighbouring Arab states made radio broadcasts that the Palestinians should leave their towns. Patently false, as "New Historians" in the 1980s showed.

Is this the case? I can't say Israeli 20th century history is an area I have really been able to wrap my head around, but the reading I have done (which admittedly has been written by friends of Israel, though not utter jingoists) gave the impression that there were broadcasts that did play a role, but that violence and the generally coercive/unfriendly environment Palestinians now found themselves in were the ultimate reasons for why Palestinians left. That is, that it was not exactly forcible, but not exactly voluntary either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom