Stupid question about Palestine

Wouldn't the simplest thing just be to forget about dividing the country and make it one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights? That would seem the most rational solution to me. Give it some funky name that doesn't favour either.
Why don't you first try to get everlasting peace and a unified country in that island to the west of yours?
Ireland for those who don't know UW's locale

I faintly remember you had a psychopathic politician who actually succeeded quite a long way in that. One of his best achievements actually. After his national career, he became the special envoy for the Quartet (UN / USA / EU / Russia) to try to get peace in the Israel/Palestine question. How did he succeed? :rolleyes:

Prestige: I see what you're saying, but I'm a bit flummoxed as to why the default position is that it is the State of Israel that claims dominion over these lands. By what right?
Israel always touts that they accepted the 1947 UN partition plan, and the Arabs didn't. However, the Green Line which is the de facto recognized border of Israel gives them quite a bit more of the former Mandate Palestine than the partition plan. They've never formally claimed the West Bank, nor Gaza.

It is not the case that the Palestinians have carved out ghettos there. The Israelis have carved up the place in various bantustans that are separated by the wall, by road blocks and check points. Getting from one town to the next in the West Bank can be a tedious, time consuming and humiliating affair if you're Palestinian. Of course, the Jewish settlers in the settlements have no such problems and they can use special roads that are exclusively open for them.

As I said before, Israel has ultimate control over both West Bank and Gaza. And viewed as such, Israel is an apartheid state.
 
Is this the case? I can't say Israeli 20th century history is an area I have really been able to wrap my head around, but the reading I have done (which admittedly has been written by friends of Israel, though not utter jingoists) gave the impression that there were broadcasts that did play a role,
IIRC, Benny Morris found half a dozen such broadcasts that only were aimed at a single town in the front line. But it's part of the national myth that this was massive.

but that violence and the generally coercive/unfriendly environment Palestinians now found themselves in were the ultimate reasons for why Palestinians left. That is, that it was not exactly forcible, but not exactly voluntary either.
You missed the part about Lydda and Ramle? The expulsion of those two cities accounted for 10% of the total refugees.
 
Marriage is weird. I think a state can be broadly secular, and still make concessions to the religious sensibilities of its citizens.

As for the default position, you may want to read up on the history of the region and the origin of Israel as a state. Basically the entire region was part of the British Empire until the 20th century. The British, as sovereigns there, ultimately granted independence to the various territories. In a nutshell: it was Britain's land and they could do with it what they wanted. All of Arabia was already an Arabian homeland. It's not like Arabs scattered around the world were lacking a place in the Middle East they could call their own.

The only people who were inconvenienced by this arrangement were Arabs living in Palestine, who a) didn't want to live in Jewish homeland, and b) didn't want to move over the border.
The British had a mandate from the League of Nations, which went over to a UN mandate, so no, the British could not do as they saw fit.

And they couldn't even control the situation, despite having more military in Palestine than in the whole of India, what with zionist terrorists like Begin's Irgun who blew up the British HQ of the King David Hotel, and Shamir's Stern Gang who murdered Lord Moyne, the British High Commissioner in Cairo and later UN envoy Bernadotte.

But really, what it boils down to is that a huge spate of recent immigrants displaced those who had lived there for centuries. Now, I understand that Jews wanted a state of their own after the Holocaust. But that was not the Palestinians' doing. They should have founded a Jewish state in Pomerania or Silesia, after all, it was the Germans who perpetrated the Holocaust.
 
IIRC, Benny Morris found half a dozen such broadcasts that only were aimed at a single town in the front line. But it's part of the national myth that this was massive.
OK, that makes sense.

You missed the part about Lydda and Ramle? The expulsion of those two cities accounted for 10% of the total refugees.

No, I stated it sloppily, I didn't mean that physical violence was nonexistent or insignificant. My point was rather that even though one might say that a majority (I think?) left "voluntarily", it wasn't really voluntary as much as due to massive social pressure and the apparent threat of violence in the immediate future.
 
The British had a mandate from the League of Nations, which went over to a UN mandate, so no, the British could not do as they saw fit.

Moreover, I believe by FAR the most widely supported option by the people living there was for a "pan-Arabic" "Greater Syria".
 
Basically the entire region was part of the British Empire until the 20th century.

I... think the one who needs to read up on history here is you. It was part of the Ottoman Empire who annexed it from the Mamluks and the Akkoyonlu in the 16th century. Those parts came under British and French mandates in, 1920, I believe?
 
So essentially, boiled down to it, based on all you say, the areas of the West Bank and Gaza are contested territory between Israel and the Palestinian authority? As there are Jewish citizens in the West Bank with all the rights of Israelis, then does the Israeli government consider these areas to belong to Israel? All of the West Bank? What is their end target, to take all of the West Bank?
There is no unified Israeli policy goal, and the peace question is the overriding question in Israeli politics.

If you look back to the 1920s, the Zionist Labour Movement (the precursor of the nowadays Labour party) wanted to claim the whole of Mandate Palestine, extended to the north in Lebanon up to the Litani river - that's the area that Israel controlled in the 1980s and 1990s in the fallout of the Lebanese civil war until Hezbollah made the price too high to keep controlling it. Nowadays, Labour would be most inclined to compromise with the Palestinians for peace. But they're not a shadow of their former self under Ben Gurion or Golda Meir, when they were by far away the largest party and controlled government.

The religiously-inclined point to the Bible verse where God promised Abraham all the territory from the Nile to the Euphrates.

Likud, the party founded by the aforementioned terrorists Begin and Shamir, and currently led by Netanyahu, is quite clear in its program of principles. They advocate annexing the West Bank, which they call "Judea and Samaria".

However, even if the main party in power was willing to compromise they have to face internal opposition in the government. Both main parties need smaller coalition parties to top up a majority, and those are typically religious nutbars who are not willing to compromise. Oh, and Likud is allied with Lieberman who even advocates expulsion of Arab Israelis, i.e., of Israeli citizens.

And a major roadblock against peace are the settlements, i.e., the "facts on the ground". There are large settlement blocks in the West Bank that provide cheap housing to Israelis. No Israeli politician will be able to sell that those settlements will be handed over to the Palestinians. That is why building yet another settlement is such a crucial issue; each settlement means yet another part of the West Bank that will not be ceded to the Palestinian state.
 
Wouldn't the simplest thing just be to forget about dividing the country and make it one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights? That would seem the most rational solution to me. Give it some funky name that doesn't favour either.

When I suggest that I'm called an anti-Semite.
 
When I suggest that I'm called an anti-Semite.

Well duh. That would be denying Israelis their national identity, which is basically genocide, unlike denying Palestinians their national identity, which is totally cool.
 
Marriage is weird. I think a state can be broadly secular, and still make concessions to the religious sensibilities of its citizens.

As for the default position, you may want to read up on the history of the region and the origin of Israel as a state. Basically the entire region was part of the British Empire until the 20th century. The British, as sovereigns there, ultimately granted independence to the various territories. In a nutshell: it was Britain's land and they could do with it what they wanted.
I want to challenge these assertions, as my reading of that history has produced conclusions entirely different from yours, in terms of simple facts.

The region was not part of the British Empire until the 20th century, but part of the Ottoman Empire from the sixteenth century until 1917, when it was occupied by Britain during WW1. So it came under U.K. control only towards the end of the second decade of the 20th century.

You state that it was Britain's land that the Empire could do with as it pleased? I find otherwise. Britain governed the land under a League of Nations Mandate, defined thus:
... the Mandate is granted to Britain "for the purpose of giving effect to the provisions of Article 22 of the Covenant of the League of Nations". That article, which concerns entrusting "tutelage" of colonies formerly under German and Turkish sovereignty to "advanced nations" with specific regard to "[c]ommunities formerly belonging to the Turkish Empire" that they "have reached a stage of development where their existence as independent nations can be provisionally recognised subject to the rendering of administrative advice and assistance by a Mandatory until such time as they are able to stand alone."​
Can you give me a link to your dissenting source of information that tells you that the UK was unlimited suzerain of the entire area prior to the twentieth century?
 
Wouldn't the simplest thing just be to forget about dividing the country and make it one secular nation state where Palestinians and Israelis have the same rights? That would seem the most rational solution to me. Give it some funky name that doesn't favour either.

Not going to happen, Israel has way to much focused on being an jewish ethno religious nationalist state. How would you reconcile the right of return with being a secular nation?
 
Marriage is weird. I think a state can be broadly secular, and still make concessions to the religious sensibilities of its citizens.

As for the default position, you may want to read up on the history of the region and the origin of Israel as a state. Basically the entire region was part of the British Empire until the 20th century. The British, as sovereigns there, ultimately granted independence to the various territories. In a nutshell: it was Britain's land and they could do with it what they wanted. All of Arabia was already an Arabian homeland. It's not like Arabs scattered around the world were lacking a place in the Middle East they could call their own.

The only people who were inconvenienced by this arrangement were Arabs living in Palestine, who a) didn't want to live in Jewish homeland, and b) didn't want to move over the border.

And the jews down't want them to have any real political voice, because how can it be a jewish homeland if muslims have any significant political power?
 
Sounds good to me. Let's go with what you said.
...and...?
Why did you not start going? E.g. by retracting in full your uninformed post, including, explicitly, all the stupid conclusions you drew from your bizarrely false premises?
 
Well duh. That would be denying Israelis their national identity, which is basically genocide, unlike denying Palestinians their national identity, which is totally cool.
A Palestinian national identity arose only fairly recently as a result of the way borders were forcibly drawn after WWs 1+2. It is essentially negatively defined as those Arabs caught in limbo between Israel on one side, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt on the other. With Jordan playing a low-key, special role. In fact, it has long been said by some sypathetic to Israel's territorial claims that a recognized Palestinian state already exists, and its name is Jordan.

Prior to the establishment of Israel and the invention of Jordan, Iraq etc, indeed the whole region was merely called "Palestine" as a historic geographic term referencing an ancient Roman province named after a Kanaanite tribe, the Philistines, if memory serves (I am slightly unsure about the "Kanaanite" designation), but it was inhabited mostly by Arabs identifying as Arabs and muslims. Hence the locally prefered option in the early and mid 20th century to create a greater Syria as an Arab state, which could have included modern Syria, Jordan, Lebanon and parts of Iraq. Had an Israel been wedged into such a greater Syria, there would have been a place for displaced Palestinians to go and have rights as full citizens of a recognized, strong state.

Israel, in contrast, has indeed had a rather clear identity, both ethnically and territorially, all the time since at least the Maccabean time.

The problem is that we can't roll back time and implement better solutions that might have been feasible before lots of **** hit multiple fans. We have to deal with a Palestinian identity, even though that has emerged rather recently and we' d perhaps be collectively better of if we could all forget about it.
 
A Palestinian national identity arose only fairly recently as a result of the way borders were forcibly drawn after WWs 1+2. It is essentially negatively defined as those Arabs caught in limbo between Israel on one side, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt on the other. With Jordan playing a low-key, special role. In fact, it has long been said by some sypathetic to Israel's territorial claims that a recognized Palestinian state already exists, and its name is Jordan.

Prior to the establishment of Israel and the invention of Jordan, Iraq etc, indeed the whole region was merely called "Palestine" as a historic geographic term referencing an ancient Roman province named after a Kanaanite tribe, the Philistines, if memory serves (I am slightly unsure about the "Kanaanite" designation), but it was inhabited mostly by Arabs identifying as Arabs and muslims. Hence the locally prefered option in the early and mid 20th century to create a greater Syria as an Arab state, which could have included modern Syria, Jordan, Lebanon and parts of Iraq. Had an Israel been wedged into such a greater Syria, there would have been a place for displaced Palestinians to go and have rights as full citizens of a recognized, strong state.

Israel, in contrast, has indeed had a rather clear identity, both ethnically and territorially, all the time since at least the Maccabean time.

The problem is that we can't roll back time and implement better solutions that might have been feasible before lots of **** hit multiple fans. We have to deal with a Palestinian identity, even though that has emerged rather recently and we' d perhaps be collectively better of if we could all forget about it.

What do you think is the best plan today?

I guess a better question is what is the goal.
 
Last edited:
Prior to the establishment of Israel and the invention of Jordan, Iraq etc, indeed the whole region was merely called "Palestine" as a historic geographic term referencing an ancient Roman province named after a Kanaanite tribe, the Philistines, if memory serves (I am slightly unsure about the "Kanaanite" designation),
The Philistines were one of the "Sea Peoples", who invaded the area and then settled on the coast, not indigenous Kanaanites.

but it was inhabited mostly by Arabs identifying as Arabs and muslims.
"Arabs" only in a cultural sense. Genetically, Palestinians are the descendants of the local population, so of Jews and Samarians, who over the centuries converted to Christianity and/or Islam.

Israel, in contrast, has indeed had a rather clear identity, both ethnically and territorially, all the time since at least the Maccabean time.
Not really. There were big cultural differences between the three strands of diaspora Jews - Ashkenazim who lived from the Rhineland to Western Russia, and spoke Yiddish, Sephardim who lived in Southern Europe and spoke Ladino, and the Mizrahim who lived in the Arab world from Morocco to Iraq. Hebrew was a dead language that was only used in liturgy. The ZIonist movement has managed to revive Hebrew as a living and primary language of all three and managed to unify them under a national myth of the founding of the state of Israel.
 
In addition to ddt's astute comments, the Ottomans definitely recognized Palestine as distinct, not least due to Jerusalem. They actually did their best to NOT have Jews move there.

Palestinian national identity arose as part of the anti-Ottoman movements and certainly existed within a pan-Arabic movement, with most favouring a Greater Syria occupying most of Mashriq. It's very Orientalist to just see them as a foil to the Israeli nationalist movements, which are absolutely nothing like ancient and quite diverse. The Palestinians too desired self-determination, they opposed the British probably as much as or more than the settlers, etc. Although (to Amin al-Hosseini's chagrin) nothing like a remotely unified Palestinian movement ever materialized, that doesn't mean they, as a people, should be denied their unique identity.
 
Not really. There were big cultural differences between the three strands of diaspora Jews - Ashkenazim who lived from the Rhineland to Western Russia, and spoke Yiddish, Sephardim who lived in Southern Europe and spoke Ladino, and the Mizrahim who lived in the Arab world from Morocco to Iraq. Hebrew was a dead language that was only used in liturgy. The ZIonist movement has managed to revive Hebrew as a living and primary language of all three and managed to unify them under a national myth of the founding of the state of Israel.

As you imply it is really quite ridiculous to suggest a common Jewish-Israeli _national_ character existing continuously from ancient times to the 20th century. For comparison one would be on way better footing to assert the existence of a continuous Iranian national character from Cyrus to the present day, but even that would be questionable to ridiculous, as that overarching view of continuity from the Achaemenids through the Sassanians and Islamic times only really emerged with the Mongol rulers of the Ilkhanate who saw it fit to paint Chingiis Khan as the second coming of Cyrus the Great. And of course the modern movement began in earnest only in the 19th century!

So... a continuous Israeli identity? Uh, nope.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom