Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Honestly...I don't know if I'm interested in distinguishing. To me, the idea of ghosts, mediums and exorcisms are fascinating. They make the world more interesting. Part of me has always been skeptical, but another part of me wants the world to be full of mystery, and given that I am really uninterested in physical science, I need something, don't I? Because I don't connect any of this with one particular person, Sylvia or otherwise, it's difficult for me to become disillusioned (I'm also not doling out cash to any group or person).

You're so very close to an important realization here. You're basically explaining how you believe in mediums because it's interesting, and you need something mysterious. This is a perfect explanation of why people believe things that aren't true.. I can almost sense that you expect that more careful study would show these beliefs to be unreliable, and so you are avoiding that study on purpose.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiculturalism#Developing_opposition_to_multiculturalism

The 'developing opposition to multiculturalism' section outlines some common objections, and regardless of its intent, any ideology can have negative consequences. Let's not derail.


And this is a "Yikes! Personal red flag!" for me. From the Wiki,

In the United States, the cultural relativism implicit in multiculturalism attracted criticism. Often that was combined with an explicit preference for western Enlightenment values as universal values. In his 1991 work, Illiberal Education, Dinesh D'Souza argues that the entrenchment of multiculturalism in American universities undermined the universalist values that liberal education once attempted to foster. In particular, he was disturbed by the growth of ethnic studies programs (e.g., Black Studies).

Conservatives - in the US, largely Christian conservatives - tend to see multiculturalism as an attack on America's traditional Christian culture, see also Christendom. They may attribute the introduction of multiculturalism to the civil rights movement and the 1965 Immigration Act or the (Hart-Celler Act).


SR, I am giving you the benefit of the doubt in that this is not what you had intended in the post where you initially brought this up, but this topic really is a burr under my saddle. If you prefer not to go into this topic in-depth, I can certainly sympathize, but please understand that for me, this topic affects me personally fairly deeply. I will not derail this thread further regarding this, I just wanted my feelings to be made known. Thank you.

(Conspi, I'm getting a funny feeling, is there room on your bandwagon?)
 
And this is a "Yikes! Personal red flag!" for me. From the Wiki,




SR, I am giving you the benefit of the doubt in that this is not what you had intended in the post where you initially brought this up, but this topic really is a burr under my saddle. If you prefer not to go into this topic in-depth, I can certainly sympathize, but please understand that for me, this topic affects me personally fairly deeply. I will not derail this thread further regarding this, I just wanted my feelings to be made known. Thank you.

(Conspi, I'm getting a funny feeling, is there room on your bandwagon?)

You were a little too vague for me to give a real response.
 
You were a little too vague for me to give a real response.


I apologize, you touched a raw nerve with your comment on multiculturalism. You do not have to respond to my (over)reaction. However, I did have a genuine question much earlier in the thread, that was probably drowned out by the side-banter.

When you wrote the original post way back when regarding RSL's web-site, was there a particular trigger event that hit and inspired you to post, or was it something that had been building up over time?
 
SR,

Let me say that I've been reading this thread off and on for a while, and I commend you for having a civilized conversation and generally considering what people here are saying. I also want to add that I sympathize completely with the sentiment you expressed above. I grew up really interested in ghosts, aliens, psychics, and all the mysterious stories and anecdotes that float around on those topics. And I agree -- the mystery/spookiness of those phenomena make the world seem kind of exciting, mysterious, and interesting.

Today, I don't believe in any of that -- or at least, I think there is no evidence for it. But I still love reading ghost stories and horror novels/movies. I can suspend my disbelief for a long time and enjoy the same type of experience, but as a fantasy.

Like you, I was also very uninterested in science, growing up. I was good at math, but I found it horrendously boring. And I couldn't get into science without having at least some interest in math. But later on, I started reading a lot more about science from a layman's point of view: books like A Brief History of Time that explain the meaning behind all the complex theories of quantum mechanics, relativity, etc. The concepts behind science have given me the same level of mystery, awe, and excitement about the world and universe that I used to get from believing in ghosts, psychics, and the like. And they are even more exciting because they are real, or at least plausible.

Someone else here suggested The Demon Haunted World, which is a fine book. However, I would also suggest checking out A Brief History of Time, or even A Briefer History of Time, which is a bit easier of a read (the latter is a more simplified version of the former). If you like that, try reading books by Brian Greene or Lisa Randall. There are some pretty amazing things going on in science right now, some real mysteries and fascinating theories. Even with the books above which are written for laypeople, it takes a while to get your mind around some of the concepts. It's not as easy as a ghost story. But, IMHO, it's much more enriching, because you don't have to try and fool yourself to be amazed.

Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.


And here is a really cool coincidence. My old signature line on this forum was a quote from Phantoms in the Brain by VS Ramachandran that was almost exactly this sentence. (I don't remember the exact quote, and I am in an airport right now so can't look it up, will do so when I get home tomorrow). In addition to the Sagan books recommended earlier, I highly recommend this one as it is a fascinating look into human consciousness. Ramachandran is an Indian (continental) neurologist, and you would probably like it a lot. This book isn't preachy or non-preachy at all, but the work of a very curious man working with very interesting cases (phantom limbs, encounters with "God", loss of a sense of self, that kind of stuff).


ETA: And the Gould, I absolutely love Stephen J Gould.
 
Last edited:
I apologize, you touched a raw nerve with your comment on multiculturalism. You do not have to respond to my (over)reaction. However, I did have a genuine question much earlier in the thread, that was probably drowned out by the side-banter.

When you wrote the original post way back when regarding RSL's web-site, was there a particular trigger event that hit and inspired you to post, or was it something that had been building up over time?

It is not so much actual multiculturalism I object to, it is the extreme moral relativism which is often linked with multiculturalism in the bizarre world of academia.

I would say it is something that has built up over time, but not really in connection with Lancaster. It has been a general frustration with the attitudes of certain people I know in real life and online, which I found to be actively disdainful towards things I value, and I projected my anger towards them onto Lancaster and this site.
 
It is not so much actual multiculturalism I object to, it is the extreme moral relativism which is often linked with multiculturalism in the bizarre world of academia.

I would say it is something that has built up over time, but not really in connection with Lancaster. It has been a general frustration with the attitudes of certain people I know in real life and online, which I found to be actively disdainful towards things I value, and I projected my anger towards them onto Lancaster and this site.


Whoops! Sorry about the cross-posting. I can understand about the moral relativism bit, I was hoping you weren't thinking about the more extreme applications.

I am both sorry and glad that Mr. Lancaster is/was the target of your projection, as I believe it can work out well for all of us. I think if you give us all a chance, we may get somewhere after all.

(Conspi, sorry to be so wishy-washy, but maybe I will jump off your bandwagon for now. Maybe, we'll see how this goes. :) )
 
That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.
So you would prefer to believe in a fantasy of how the world is, rather than the reality?

I think the reason some people might not be terribly concerned about issues like global warming and social injustice is because they believe God will sort everything out in the end, and good people will end up in heaven. If that's not true, maybe they would feel differently--perhaps realizing that there might not be a God to right the wrongs and save the world.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.

We share a common ancestor with apes, we aren't descended from them. What's so bad about that? A human life is more important than an animal one for a variety of good reasons (the value of intelligence, sentience, simply being "one of us"), but not because we were deliberately made that way by some higher being. Likewise, what's so bad about ceasing to exist? Everything else on the planet has to die, why should humans get any special break?

I'd rather a deflated ego and the best possible assessment of what's real and true, than to live a delusion.

Most rationalists would disagree that the implications are a bad thing. In fact the more spiritual of them would revel in the idea that we are in fact "one" with other living things and the planet/universe that spawned us. "We are all made of stars", to paraphrase Carl Sagan and Moby :), and we go back to being a (non-sentient) part of that universe when we die, the natural cycle of life and existence. It horrifies you only because you are used to thinking in religious spiritual terms, but if you recognise it to be the rational approach, you ought to at least consider how it might affect you.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.

That is possibly the most depressing statement I've ever seen. "I live in a fantasy world because the real world doesn't seem as friendly." I know this is generally thought to be one of the more likely reasons for believers to believe in stuff, but I've never actually seen one of them come right out and say that they have no interest in the truth or reality and that all that is important is what they think sounds nice.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.

I don't see what is horrifying about not having consciousness. You didn't have consciousness for the first 14 billion years of the universe -- in fact, you didn't have anything because you didn't exist. It doesn't seem like this has done you much harm. When you cease to exist again, it won't be of much concern to you, because you won't have a mind to worry with. Pretty simple, really.

I also don't know that God is that much better for the human ego. After all, without God we are probably one of the most intelligent species around. At least, we are the most intelligent species on the planet, and the most intelligent species in the universe we know about so far. If God exists, we barely have the intellect of an amoeba by comparison. If God is around, we are pathetic creatures who exist at his whim, nothing more.

It's all just about how you look at it.
 
Yes, but for some of us, the mysteries of the natural world are not as compelling as they may be to others.

Please, let me lend you my copy of Cosmos on DVD. The awe and sense of majesty I feel for the universe is much greater now than it ever was when I was a 'believer'.

I strongly suggest you are selling the 'mundane world' short just because you have not been adequately introducted.

You want that religious feeling? There is no need to invent wonders, nature comes well stocked already.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.

Would seem...... I can see how it would seem that way. Wonderfully enough, when you are exposed to the details of who things really are, I have always found it amazing and uplifting.

Loosing the feeling that we are 'central' to some other purpose is not the let down everyone fears. The universe really is a marvelous thing to come to know.
 
Please, let me lend you my copy of Cosmos on DVD. The awe and sense of majesty I feel for the universe is much greater now than it ever was when I was a 'believer'.

I strongly suggest you are selling the 'mundane world' short just because you have not been adequately introducted.

You want that religious feeling? There is no need to invent wonders, nature comes well stocked already.
My thoughts exactly.

And Douglas Adams' :

Isn’t it enough to see that a garden is beautiful without having to believe that there are fairies at the bottom of it too?
 
We share a common ancestor with apes, we aren't descended from them. What's so bad about that?

Agreeing with and expanding on what Les has to say......

Or would it be more comforting to realize that you are child of the stars. This is literally true, and one of the more interesting discoveries that has been made. Virtually every atom in your body (heavier that hydrogen) was created in the supernova death of an ancient heavy star. You and I and everyone here are literally made of star stuff.

The knowledge that the building blocks of my body was assembled in the death throws of a star billions of years ago certainly fills me awe and wonder.
 
A small list books and other resource, why you read/view them, and what order.

Carl Sagan's "Demon Haunted World" - first, because what you learn in that book will help you understand every other thing better. You will get more out of every other thing on this list to read DHW first. You will get more out of everything written by Browne or Chopra as well, but not what they intended.

Sagan's "Cosmos" (on DVD or the book) (The DVD is so amazing and accessible, the book has more detail) Not only is a great intoduction to the universe as it is, it is a great introduction to our own magnificent (and sometimes discouraging) intellectual history. If this doesn't give you a 'religious feeling' you soul is made of stone. I am serious, it is glorious.

The rest, pick and choose by what is of interst to you:

Richard Dawkins, "The Blind Watchmaker" - Let me tell you, this man appreciates the argument of 'design'. He makes a better case for it (by far) than any design advocate I am familiar with. He then shows how it is utterly unecessary. This reading will replace your 'dread of being descendant from apes' with a fullfilling knowledge that we are 'brothers with every other living thing on the planet'.

Julia Sweeney's marvoulous CD "Letting Go of God". Despite anything you might think, it is not preachy (at all). It takes you through her religous upbringing, her entire suprising spiritual quest, to an incredibly touching discovery of an even more amazing world that is the world as it is, without adornment. (EVERYONE, please consider this true GEM!)

Anything Douglas Adams, its tough really explain why humor/fiction could be so valuable.... maybe someone else can help me out with that.

James Randi's "The Faith Healers" A deservedly angry book. It documents the dirty underbelly of the faith healing business. I consider it Randi's best work. Not very uplifting, granted... but it will instill in you the proper rage for what fakes and frauds are doing to their fellow human being. This is incredibly well researched and documented.

Richard Feynman's "QED" - this is a short, easy, and marvelous read. It will give you great insight into how unusual this universe really is and a great appreciation for power and accomplishment of human scientific inquest.

There are many many many more great choices, but before you condemn our world view as ego busting or boring or any other negative term, I suggest you get well aquainted as many of us have.
 
SylviaRox, a serious offer:

I will be happy to lend you my copy of the Cosmos DVDs (you'll have to mail them back), and I'll give you a copy of "Demon Haunted World" (I stock those and a few other titles specifically to give away)
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.


It is horrifying. Sometimes thinking about it keeps me awake at night.

But not so much anymore, as I've grown used to the idea. It wasn't easy though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom