Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Another non-answer.
Let's see if I can rephrase this to eliminate neutraltalk answers.

Are you especially skeptical of and/or disbelieve in any aspects of the paranormal, and if so, which ones?

Maybe I'm spouting neutraltalk because I'm neutral on some questions? Try and assume good faith rather than acting like this is some sort of police interrogation.

Yes, I don't believe homeopathy works. I also don't believe in healing touch, Reiki or similar therapies.
 
May I ask what leads you to believe certain mediumship claims are believable?

One of the reasons why I'm so hesitant to answer your questions is because I know how you're going to respond. I've read many, many accounts of mediums and séances, but I realize that sort of thing doesn't cut it for people who only care about statistics.
 
Maybe I'm spouting neutraltalk because I'm neutral on some questions? Try and assume good faith rather than acting like this is some sort of police interrogation.

Yes, I don't believe homeopathy works. I also don't believe in healing touch, Reiki or similar therapies.

Thank you.
 
SylviaRox, you've made some noise like we don't hold religion to the same standards or as harsh a standards as we are trying to hold Slyvia to.

For the record, I do. I am much more concerned with the dangers posed by religion than I am with Sylvia Browne.

(how many times have I said the following?) I would strongly suggest picking up a copy of "Demon Haunted World". It is an amazing resource for gathering the mental tools we should have gotten in school, but they failed to cover. You will be much better prepared to evalutate and rebutt the arguments you are being peppered with.
 
TruthBeTold said:
Pardon my skepticism, but is there any chance that SylviaRox keeps this thread going so that the other poignant threads about Sylvia (Lori Pleasants and Jamie Barker threads to name a few) are lost and forgotten?
SylviaRox said:
If this thread is disturbing the website, an admin may feel free to lock it, and will receive no objection from me. My experience here has been positive.
I agree. Sorry, TBT, but I think this thread is wildly popular because it's wildly popular. I usually read most of the posts about Sylvia, but only comment when something piques my interest (or outrage) or when I delude myself into thinking I know something about a topic. This thread has been robust, and sometimes a page or two goes between SR's posts, so I don't think it's even fair to say he is keeping it going.

SylviaRox said:
and the more hostile users have toned it done somewhat (although one is still very active).
Was there someone more hostile than you, SR?

Meanwhile, back to the thread:
Questioninggeller said:
I'd love to see proof that Browne, Edward, DuBios, Van Praagh, etc believe their own claims.
SylviaRox said:
We can't know, but they know. Trust me, I'm sure they know, at least in moments when they are candid with themselves. And the moral decision is up to them, and whether they believe the service is legit or not is necessary for me to answer the original question.
I mostly agree with you here, SR. There is a pretty big moral difference between a con artist like Sylvia and a self-deluded dowser, for example, or other actual believers. However, they are both doing harm, and both should be exposed as frauds.

I don't remember the context, but in some discussion, didn't Sylvia say something like, "This is something real, not something I made up psychicly"? (QG or someone have the exact quote?) I don't recall the exact words, but it sure sounded like she acknowledged that what she does is fake.

Between the two extremes (sincere believer and con artist), there are some gray areas. Plenty of people stay willfully ignorant of information that might challenge their faith. I believe there is a moral issue with that.
scotth said:
I am much more concerned with the dangers posed by religion than I am with Sylvia Browne.
Ditto. Me too.

In fact, I made a similar point earlier when the "cult" accusation popped up about NS. Conventional religions are far more dangerous than the more fringe things.
 
One of the reasons why I'm so hesitant to answer your questions is because I know how you're going to respond. I've read many, many accounts of mediums and séances, but I realize that sort of thing doesn't cut it for people who only care about statistics.

I certainly don't only care about statistics. I am however, interested in discriminating between real paranormal ability vs. imagined or faked paranormal ability. SylviaRox, what kind of criteria do you use to distinguish between actual abilities and fake/imagined ones? Are you interested in distinguishing?
 
I certainly don't only care about statistics. I am however, interested in discriminating between real paranormal ability vs. imagined or faked paranormal ability. SylviaRox, what kind of criteria do you use to distinguish between actual abilities and fake/imagined ones? Are you interested in distinguishing?

Honestly...I don't know if I'm interested in distinguishing. To me, the idea of ghosts, mediums and exorcisms are fascinating. They make the world more interesting. Part of me has always been skeptical, but another part of me wants the world to be full of mystery, and given that I am really uninterested in physical science, I need something, don't I? Because I don't connect any of this with one particular person, Sylvia or otherwise, it's difficult for me to become disillusioned (I'm also not doling out cash to any group or person).

I automatically classify something as 'fake' if the claim is that they can heal you of an ailment. Sometimes things I know are fake are still interesting to me, like L. Ron Hubbard's ideas or Gurdjieff's view of the cosmos.
 
I'd be willing to admit that even the most hardcore skeptics here at JREF would agree that the world is full of mystery--one doesn't need to believe in the paranormal to realize that.
 
I'd be willing to admit that even the most hardcore skeptics here at JREF would agree that the world is full of mystery--one doesn't need to believe in the paranormal to realize that.

Yes, but for some of us, the mysteries of the natural world are not as compelling as they may be to others.
 
Again, you need to read some Sagan to realise just how mysterious the real world is, without having to invent it yourself. In fact, the whole notions of ghosts, goblins and ghoulies is fairly paltry and trite compared to the real mysteries that confront us in this cosmos. Not just on an astronomical scale, but also right down to the atomic scale. Mysteries abound throught - much more exciting ones too. And skeptics are all for investigating these mysteries to the fullest extent!

I think the difference is that skeptics are dealing in reality and pushing the boundaries of knowledge. Whereas people like Hubbard and Sylvia are trying to peddle fantasy as reality, in exchange for money and ignorance. The problem we see is that they are succeeding all too often.
 
I'd be willing to admit that even the most hardcore skeptics here at JREF would agree that the world is full of mystery--one doesn't need to believe in the paranormal to realize that.
Bingo, Jim! Actually, take a look at my sig, the first entry. That gentleman said it best.
 
Great thread!

God bless us, everyone. :)

I'm back on lurk mode and I've climbed down from my high horse.
 
Also, we can enjoy ghosts and goblins and space aliens too--it's just that we realize they are most likely only imaginary. That doesn't mean we might not enjoy them in fiction; books and movies and stuff.
 
SylviaRox, you've made some noise like we don't hold religion to the same standards or as harsh a standards as we are trying to hold Slyvia to.

For the record, I do. I am much more concerned with the dangers posed by religion than I am with Sylvia Browne.

(how many times have I said the following?) I would strongly suggest picking up a copy of "Demon Haunted World". It is an amazing resource for gathering the mental tools we should have gotten in school, but they failed to cover. You will be much better prepared to evalutate and rebutt the arguments you are being peppered with.
I'm with ya on the religion deal, Scott. It had the potential, kept at arm's length, to be a great service to humankind. Instead - far too much of a destroyer.

Demon Haunted World by Sagan is a great one, got it. Stephen Jay Gould's The Panda's Thumb and Dinosaur In A Haystack also.
 
Evasive indeed. I have flatly said I'm not interested in debating you. Feel free to claim it as a victory for your immense personal...character.

Interesting how you considered this a "debate" and wrote:

You're actually right, I am avoiding "the hard questions": I'd rather not engage in a long, drawn out debate, which apparently is leading to no greater understanding on either side.

1. See QG's posts. Just being friendly means a lot.

Oh please. None of my posts were hostile to you. You don't want to discuss things because you don't want to address "the hard questions." Don't blame others for your issues.

You refuse condemn charlatans like Browne who take advantage of desperate people and Charles Manson, but came here libeling Robert.
 
Last edited:
Honestly...I don't know if I'm interested in distinguishing. To me, the idea of ghosts, mediums and exorcisms are fascinating. They make the world more interesting. Part of me has always been skeptical, but another part of me wants the world to be full of mystery, and given that I am really uninterested in physical science, I need something, don't I? Because I don't connect any of this with one particular person, Sylvia or otherwise, it's difficult for me to become disillusioned (I'm also not doling out cash to any group or person).

SR,

Let me say that I've been reading this thread off and on for a while, and I commend you for having a civilized conversation and generally considering what people here are saying. I also want to add that I sympathize completely with the sentiment you expressed above. I grew up really interested in ghosts, aliens, psychics, and all the mysterious stories and anecdotes that float around on those topics. And I agree -- the mystery/spookiness of those phenomena make the world seem kind of exciting, mysterious, and interesting.

Today, I don't believe in any of that -- or at least, I think there is no evidence for it. But I still love reading ghost stories and horror novels/movies. I can suspend my disbelief for a long time and enjoy the same type of experience, but as a fantasy.

Like you, I was also very uninterested in science, growing up. I was good at math, but I found it horrendously boring. And I couldn't get into science without having at least some interest in math. But later on, I started reading a lot more about science from a layman's point of view: books like A Brief History of Time that explain the meaning behind all the complex theories of quantum mechanics, relativity, etc. The concepts behind science have given me the same level of mystery, awe, and excitement about the world and universe that I used to get from believing in ghosts, psychics, and the like. And they are even more exciting because they are real, or at least plausible.

Someone else here suggested The Demon Haunted World, which is a fine book. However, I would also suggest checking out A Brief History of Time, or even A Briefer History of Time, which is a bit easier of a read (the latter is a more simplified version of the former). If you like that, try reading books by Brian Greene or Lisa Randall. There are some pretty amazing things going on in science right now, some real mysteries and fascinating theories. Even with the books above which are written for laypeople, it takes a while to get your mind around some of the concepts. It's not as easy as a ghost story. But, IMHO, it's much more enriching, because you don't have to try and fool yourself to be amazed.
 
Would you refuse to serve on a jury in a murder trial in order to not pass judgement on the defendent, even though you may have "feelings" about the defendents actions?



Again, if you are serving on a jury you are making judgements about a crime/action that has been committed (allegedly) by a person. I have outrage and downright p*ss-offedness about a lot of actions of people. That in no way negates my thought.
 
Again, if you are serving on a jury you are making judgements about a crime/action that has been committed (allegedly) by a person. I have outrage and downright p*ss-offedness about a lot of actions of people. That in no way negates my thought.

Not so sure, AB. I believe that one of the charges a jury has is to also determine the sentence in some cases. (I know that's the case in capital offenses.) In that instance, you really have to determine how much of a danger the defendant is to the community. It's an onerous task, I imagine. (I've never served on a jury as I always get weeded out.)
 
Yes, but for some of us, the mysteries of the natural world are not as compelling as they may be to others.

Hello SR, I've read this thread from start to end, but haven't really felt like I've had anything to contribute. Well done to everyone involved for keeping it civil and interesting.

Your point is valid, of course, and true of just about everything. Not everyone has the same level of interest in everything. Some people are fascinated by forensics, others by mathematics, others by gossip. If I've left your favourite category out, I apologise.

I wonder, though, about people who need to venture beyond the natural world for interest. Have they explored everything here first?

Think about the vastness of space. The utter incomprehensibility of astronomical distances. Think about time, about billions and billions of years. Think about the fact that just about everybody who was alive 120 years ago is now dead. All that humanity, all those lives, all those experiences, gone.

Think about our planet. One tiny speck in this immeasurably large universe, supporting life. Think about our fate. Is the universe going to stop expanding? Will it shrink? Where will evolution lead? Where will technology lead? What will happen to humans?

Think about why we love. Why do we care? Why do we feel? Why do we think?

Think about language. Think about different cultures. Think about food. :)

Think about disease, medicine, cures, treatment, health care.

Think about animals. Why do we appear so much more complex in our behaviour? Why do Americans not spell 'behaviour' with the 'u'?

Why do people love sunsets? Why do we love the beach and forest? Why do we love flowers and butterflies and kittens?

Why does **** stink? Why does rotting meat stink?

Why is sex the only thing I think about?

What is pi? Why do I have the ability to memorise it to so many decimal places? Why do we use decimal?

Why hearing? Why sight? Why not infrared?

What is gravity? What is electricity? What is magnetism?

Am I ever going to stop?

Why can't people spell 'definitely'?

None of these things may interest you, or anyone else, and I haven't even scratched the surface. To me, the incredible fact that all life on earth evolved over billions of years is a fascinating store of wonder, rich enough to support plundering without recourse to hobgoblins, mediums, ghosts and god.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom