Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

"New age philosophy is nothing new"

I'm sure the irony in that statement was intended...but the New Age movement as we know it can be traced back mainly to the Theosophical Society, which I believe was founded in the 1880s (that's new to me, at least in religious terms).

Certainly, notions that you would consider nonsense existed before that, but Theosophy had a different flavor than anything that came before.

Theosophy goes back to Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite. The Aryan vs.Semitic comparisons in the writings of Madame Blavatsky was nothing new either and not very peaceful.
 
Exactly. Someone needed to say, "your actions have hurt society, therefore you must go to prison for the rest of your life". The previous statement does not morally judge the perpretator, it judges the effect of his actions on society.

That's not the same as saying, "You're an EVIL man, and you are morally disgusting to me. Because of this, you must stay in prison." Only God and Manson (or just Manson, for most of you) know whether he knew he was doing evil.

Remember: this all stemmed from a question asked to me by QG (I believe QG). He basically asked whether it is wrong to offer a service to someone which does not exist (i.e., cleansing money). I said I needed to know whether the offerer of the service knew what they were doing wasn't legit. If they knew, it's morally wrong. If they didn't know, it's not morally wrong, but we still have to fix it.

Your interpretation of my posts and responses are rather evasive. For example, I asked many questions including:

So in your moral understanding, Randi should just shut his mouth, and let Browne continue without anyone in the world questioning her?
 
Theosophy goes back to Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite. The Aryan vs.Semitic comparisons in the writings of Madame Blavatsky was nothing new either and not very peaceful.

You're quite flattering to Theosophy to include it in such a lineage. I thought the claim was that Madame got most of her ideas from Edward Bulwer-Lytton and plagiarized the rest?
 
Your interpretation of my posts and responses are rather evasive. For example, I asked many questions including:

Evasive indeed. I have flatly said I'm not interested in debating you. Feel free to claim it as a victory for your immense personal...character.
 
Manson is clearly schizophrenic. We could get into all sorts of interesting discussions about the morals of the severely deranged, such as what if we treated him and he realized he was wrong and repented, but I suggest we do so elsewhere.

Neither Sylvia Browne nor Robert Lancaster appears to be schizophrenic, although you could make a decent argument that Browne exhibits sociopathic tendencies. I don't believe it's fair to compare SR's opinion of Manson and Lancaster, especially now that he's moderated his opinion of the latter.
 
[leading protion snipped]
Also, I would say that the fact scientists have found no explanation for psychic powers does not make them less, or more, likely to exist. It just means we can't explain them, if they do exist.
Like gravity? We're still looking for a decent explanation of how that works. But the big difference there is we know it exists. Its effects are easily seen and can be quantified; that is, reduced to a set of equations that describe its behaviour and can make accurate predictions. That's why we're able to throw a space probe off our planet and get it into orbit around Saturn.

The same cannot be said for "psychic" powers.

I would disagree with this. Science hasn't tried to explain psychic powers because they can't be SHOWN to exist at all. That, to me, makes them less likely to exist.
I think that is far more true than those who believe in any form of the supernatural would care to admit. From auras to cryptozoology, all attempts by scientists to verify, under controlled conditions, even the existence of a broad set of "unexplainable" phenomena have failed even to show they exist.

Auras? Can't be seen
Dowsing? Fails every time
Fortune telling? (Sylvia's domain) Results are easily replicable by people versed in cold reading
Ganzfeld? So close to 50/50 one can safely conclude there is no effect
Ghosts? Lots of rational explanations for the apparent effects of ghosts
God? (Warning: argument from personal incredulity coming up) To me, he gets smaller as our knowledge of the universe expands
Homeopathy? No better than placebos
Sasquatch, yeti, and the Loch Ness Monster? Most of the evidence consists of unreliable eyewitness accounts and forged pictures--not to mention a lack of bodies and a viable mechanism for maintaining the species
Tarot and tea leaves? See fortune telling above
Telepathy? No better than 50/50
Yin and Qi energy? No instrument known to science can detect it

Getting back to science: the Standard Model of particle physics does an amazing job describing how particles and energy in the universe interact with each other. I see nothing in it that even comes close to describing how psychics are supposed to be able to accomplish what they claim they can do.

Going deeper, string theory and M-theory are the latest attempts by scientists to bring the theories of relativity and quantum physics together. Yet I have heard of no theorist in that realm who claims it also helps explain supernatural phenomena.

It's also a safe bet that anyone who invokes quantum theory to explain how his miracle device works is at best a quack and worse (and more usually) a fraud. Randi's commentaries are full to bursting at the seams with that sort of stuff. And for the most part, people posting on this forum believe that is the company Sylvia Browne keeps.
 
Can you give me the specific questions you want me to answer? I'm not going to answer hostile questions, or questions which are designed to force me to concede points which I'm not willing to concede.
I have questions, but first I need to know:
1. What is your definition of a "hostile question"? and
2. What are the points you are not willing to concede?
 
I have questions, but first I need to know:
1. What is your definition of a "hostile question"? and
2. What are the points you are not willing to concede?

1. See QG's posts. Just being friendly means a lot.
2. Any point which is purely speculative or philosophical ("why can't psychics be right all the time?")
 
You're quite flattering to Theosophy to include it in such a lineage. I thought the claim was that Madame got most of her ideas from Edward Bulwer-Lytton and plagiarized the rest?

As she was yet another charlatan, I fail to see your point.
 
You're quite flattering to Theosophy to include it in such a lineage. I thought the claim was that Madame got most of her ideas from Edward Bulwer-Lytton and plagiarized the rest?

En Francais: "I say old chap, you're getting a little off topic, what?"
 
I don't believe it's fair to compare SR's opinion of Manson and Lancaster, especially now that he's moderated his opinion of the latter.

I'm not comparing his opinions of Manson. I'm comparing SR's statement of this:

I just refuse to pass judgement on people on a moral level, I try to assume good faith and think about the possible reasons for them committing bizarre and evil acts and how they can be stopped (prison)

and his OP on this thread.

I have praised his turnaround from the OP repeatedly. However, there is a valid contradiction.
 
I'm not comparing his opinions of Manson. I'm comparing SR's statement of this:

I just refuse to pass judgement on people on a moral level, I try to assume good faith and think about the possible reasons for them committing bizarre and evil acts and how they can be stopped (prison)

and his OP on this thread.
I have praised his turnaround from the OP repeatedly. However, there is a valid contradiction.

Not only valid, but enough fuel for another conspiracy thread.
 
En Francais: "I say old chap, you're getting a little off topic, what?"
Sacre merde!, you are not a French person type, you English pigdog! Je me'n fout, you maked me lose my temperature. Je suis triste, you pomargranet tete. IL pleure dans mon couer.
 
...

That's not the same as saying, "You're an EVIL man, and you are morally disgusting to me. Because of this, you must stay in prison." Only God and Manson (or just Manson, for most of you) know whether he knew he was doing evil.

Remember: this all stemmed from a question asked to me by QG (I believe QG). He basically asked whether it is wrong to offer a service to someone which does not exist (i.e., cleansing money). I said I needed to know whether the offerer of the service knew what they were doing wasn't legit. If they knew, it's morally wrong. If they didn't know, it's not morally wrong, but we still have to fix it.
(bolding mine)

Manson knew. Oh man did he know. Manson was the very very dark side of woo. He did NOT commit the Tate-LaBianca murders directly. He used his power of persuasion - driven by evil intention - to get others to carry out the murders instead. I read Bugliosi's Helter-Skelter in the late 70s. I live 4 miles from the site of the murders. There's a lot to this case. All of it swirled around the evil thoughts and intentions of one man. You're entitled to exonerate Manson of such a label as evil. But after digging into it, if you ever plan to, you may alter your assessment. In fact I'd lay odds on it.

It's important as a corollary to Browne, because although I am not comparing what Browne does to what Manson did, there is this: I believe Browne knows, at some level, that she is hoodwinking people. That to stay in business, she must appeal to the fragile elements of human nature as a method to generate income. A predator-prey situation. The establishment and maintenance of moral guidelines is critical to society. We need to know the boundaries. Browne deserves every withering bit of scrutiny being aimed at her.
 
1. See QG's posts. Just being friendly means a lot.
2. Any point which is purely speculative or philosophical ("why can't psychics be right all the time?")
I hope you are half as tolerant with abruptness from others as you expect us to be with you, considering the wild accusations you've made previously in this thread.
First question: Are there any paranormal fields you are skeptical of(i.e. telepathy, psychokinesis, talking with the dead, teleportation, spirit guides, dowsing etc.)?
 
The program showed how a guest ought to behave at his girlfriend's friend's party, when discovering that the hostess was drunk.
 
Last edited:
I hope you are half as tolerant with abruptness from others as you expect us to be with you, considering the wild accusations you've made previously in this thread.
First question: Are there any paranormal fields you are skeptical of(i.e. telepathy, psychokinesis, talking with the dead, teleportation, spirit guides, dowsing etc.)?

I'm skeptical of all supernatural claims you mentioned, but I do believe some exist, mainly in the realm of mediumship.
 
I'm skeptical of all supernatural claims you mentioned, but I do believe some exist, mainly in the realm of mediumship.
Another non-answer.
Let's see if I can rephrase this to eliminate neutraltalk answers.

Are you especially skeptical of and/or disbelieve in any aspects of the paranormal, and if so, which ones?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom