Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Pretty childish, are we humans, at times. Every other species on the planet is perfectly fine with the cycle of birth, life, procreation, death. Except us.

Just because your consciousness ceases when you die, does not mean consciousness of you ceases. And there's the beauty, to me anyway. You'll "live" for decades afterwards. Maybe generations. Longer? I've got a picture of my grandfather and grandmother, both born in the late 1800s. And here we are into the 21st century and they are still, in a sense, "alive".

And what about offspring? That's the best answer to "eternal life" that Nature was able to devise. Works for me. I don't have kiddies yet, but some of my brothers and sisters do. They'll carry on our "line".

It's that unbroken string, that link-in-the-chain mindset of which you can indulge, to dispel the notion that when you die, it's all over. It is not.

Great point. In essence, this is my job. I help to preserve and interpret what's left of people's lives; making them relevant to people today and keeping alive both snapshots of individual lives, and the general continuity and shared experiences that humans have had over thousands of years. I think that's why when I tell people that I work in a museum, most of them say "that must be great". I have no religion, and so I choose to play a small part in this particular way for humans to have what many want most; some kind of "afterlife". It's like they say about the ancient Egyptian mummies; some see their display as grotesque and disrespectful. Others see it as the people of today giving them want they wanted - for a part of them to live on.

Between the sciences and the arts, I have all the "religion" I could possibly need.
 
Well, one thing is certain. When we leave our bodies...some of us will be surprised and some of us won't and the rest won't give a darn!
 
I really hope that's not the case. Otherwise Sylvia is digging herself into a deeper hole that will ruin what's left of her reputation. Suppose Randi found out.
What reputation would that be? The reputation as a foul, repellant mass?
The reputation as a lying, money-grubbing fiend? The reputation as something that builds up peoples hope/or dashes them based on nothing except (apparently) her whim or her mouth running too fast for the brain stem? (Note for the concerned, I can't say that any of these are true - I only refer ,as noted, to reputation - I have not met Browne and have no desire to do so but have read in various places things that indicate that these fairly represent her reputation .)
 
No offense, but that's a pretty big assumption, isn't it? :)
Actually, it isn't - just to use the Xtian example:
if goes heaven or hell, not surprised; if wakes in a tent with 72 virgins or in Cthulhus' belly, surprised; no afterlife, won't care. (OR- if no afterlife, won't care; if expected afterlife, not surprised; if not the expected afterlife, surprised. Though in reality, surprised and not surprised require an afterlife and do not apply without one. And no afterlife eliminates any concern re:surprise or lack of same. We must do this again some time in the after/not after-life!!:D
 
Last edited:
Pretty childish, are we humans, at times. Every other species on the planet is perfectly fine with the cycle of birth, life, procreation, death. Except us.

Just because your consciousness ceases when you die, does not mean consciousness of you ceases. And there's the beauty, to me anyway. You'll "live" for decades afterwards. Maybe generations. Longer? I've got a picture of my grandfather and grandmother, both born in the late 1800s. And here we are into the 21st century and they are still, in a sense, "alive".

And what about offspring? That's the best answer to "eternal life" that Nature was able to devise. Works for me. I don't have kiddies yet, but some of my brothers and sisters do. They'll carry on our "line".

It's that unbroken string, that link-in-the-chain mindset of which you can indulge, to dispel the notion that when you die, it's all over. It is not.

Beautiful, just beautiful.
 
Pretty childish, are we humans, at times. Every other species on the planet is perfectly fine with the cycle of birth, life, procreation, death. Except us.

Just because your consciousness ceases when you die, does not mean consciousness of you ceases. And there's the beauty, to me anyway. You'll "live" for decades afterwards. Maybe generations. Longer? I've got a picture of my grandfather and grandmother, both born in the late 1800s. And here we are into the 21st century and they are still, in a sense, "alive".

And what about offspring? That's the best answer to "eternal life" that Nature was able to devise. Works for me. I don't have kiddies yet, but some of my brothers and sisters do. They'll carry on our "line".

It's that unbroken string, that link-in-the-chain mindset of which you can indulge, to dispel the notion that when you die, it's all over. It is not.


Hear, hear.
 
What reputation would that be? The reputation as a foul, repellant mass?
The reputation as a lying, money-grubbing fiend? The reputation as something that builds up peoples hope/or dashes them based on nothing except (apparently) her whim or her mouth running too fast for the brain stem? (Note for the concerned, I can't say that any of these are true - I only refer ,as noted, to reputation - I have not met Browne and have no desire to do so but have read in various places things that indicate that these fairly represent her reputation .)

She seems to think she has one, and places importance on it. Could be the only thing in her eyes that sets her apart from countless identical charlatans. Or maybe that was just the money. At any rate, if the former is remotely true, she'd think twice before sending someone.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.


I found that quote I mentioned and it is from a chapter where at the end, the author is discussing the Freudian denominator in scientific revolutions, which you implied in your post. Interestingly enough, it even ties in with the lovely post Raidey made earlier. This passage is from the book Phantoms in the Brain: Probing the Mysteries of the Human Mind by Dr. V.S. Ramachandran. Any typos are mine, and sorry for the length. The bolded portion was the quote in my sig.

Unlike other animals, humans are acutely aware of their own mortality and are terrified of death. But the study of cosmology gives us a sense of timelessness, of being part of something much larger. The fact that your own personal life is finite is less frightening when you know you are part of an evolving universe - an ever-unfolding drama. This is probably the closest a scientist can come to having a religious experience.

The same goes for the study of evolution, for it gives you a sense of time and place, allowing you to see yourself as part of a great journey. And likewise for the brain sciences. In this revolution, we have given up the idea that there is a soul separate from our minds and bodies. Far from being terrifying, this idea is very liberating. If you think you're something special in this world, engaging in a lofty inspection of the cosmos from a unique vantage point, your annihilation becomes unacceptable. But if you're really part of the great cosmic dance of Shiva, rather than a mere spectator, then your inevitable death should be seen as a joyous reunion with nature rather than as a tragedy.
 
I found that quote I mentioned and it is from a chapter where at the end, the author is discussing the Freudian denominator in scientific revolutions, which you implied in your post. Interestingly enough, it even ties in with the lovely post Raidey made earlier. This passage is from the book Phantoms in the Brain: Probing the Mysteries of the Human Mind by Dr. V.S. Ramachandran. Any typos are mine, and sorry for the length. The bolded portion was the quote in my sig.

Thanks for sharing that wonderful passage with us!
 
I found that quote I mentioned and it is from a chapter where at the end, the author is discussing the Freudian denominator in scientific revolutions, which you implied in your post. Interestingly enough, it even ties in with the lovely post Raidey made earlier. This passage is from the book Phantoms in the Brain: Probing the Mysteries of the Human Mind by Dr. V.S. Ramachandran. Any typos are mine, and sorry for the length. The bolded portion was the quote in my sig.
That's a very good one, H. And thank you for the mention of my post, and also to Miss A and Big L. Most kind.

I think it explains here in America, as well, why a large portion of us really buy into the religion and afterlife promises. There's almost a desperation to it. The American culture drumbeats the importance of the individual - me me me. A concept reflected so clearly in our advertising and our mania for materialistic acquisition. "You can have it all." "I want it and I want it NOW!" Too much lip service is given to the concepts of "we" and "us" and "a part of".

It's no wonder why we have our violence and an excess of restless unhappiness. People are in fear. And I think in spite of our fervent weekly attendance at rituals in grandiose buildings that insist, over and over and over, about that "soul" and "other life" and "paradise": Deep down I'll bet many people have real doubts. Yet they are far too afraid to pull everything out and have a tough, hard look.

They teach here in the USA that you're so important, God is going to see to it that you'll last and last just as you are - but even more better. They don't teach - or it's nearly impossible to find the classroom - that this 70 or 80-year existence (if you're lucky) is really it for an individual. That you live as long and as best and most importantly as kindly as you can and that by doing so: You provide that tiny impetus which expands the entire mass outward. Even after you leave. This should be taught FIRST. And then later, maybe, we can get into the wings and the clouds and the halos just for the fun of it. For those who need it.
 
Would you agree that skeptics generally discuss the paranormal and religion? I've seen many sites and books about skepticism, and they seem to be generally concerned with those subjects. My point is that a broader viewpoint should be taken by skeptics, to include all BS and not just paranormal or pseudo-scientific BS.


Paranormal and religious issues tend to be more cut and dried than political ones which often have lots of room for ambiguity. I don't think you'll find many of us disagreeing that a sceptical outlook should be extended indiscriminately.


I hope that NOT passing judgement on another human being isn't considered a moral weakness. Perhaps, I am just reading that incorrectly?

I firmly believe that it is the act not actor is judged. Whatever belief or lack of belief each of us carries, does it give any of us the 'right' to judge another human being (soul, or whatever name you chose to give it)?

Since I feel that I am no better than anyone else on this planet, I can't pass judgement. But, I certainly do have feelings about the actions of a lot of people, Manson included.


I have the right to think whatever I want about whomever I want, and you can think whatever you want of me for doing so.
 
That's a very good one, H.


And right back atcha with your latest. What is this, the JREF mutual admiration society?

Aha! I see it now. This really was a conspiracy to make all of us veteran bun-throwers act and post like the thoughtful, insightful people we really can be (yes Raidey, I am talking about you).

On a more serious note to SylviaRox, I hope you have learned as much from this scenic route of a thread as I have, and I do hope you continue along with the rest of us. Do post your thoughts, concerns, and questions, as there are many people here who have had similar thoughts, concerns, and questions. Some of us have even found a few answers. ;)
 
Paranormal and religious issues tend to be more cut and dried than political ones which often have lots of room for ambiguity. I don't think you'll find many of us disagreeing that a sceptical outlook should be extended indiscriminately.

I'm having trouble imaging exactly what extending the skeptical outlook indiscriminately would mean.

Can you offer examples?

Unless you mean about things like music and love.....
 
Reno, I have received emails from Browne fans and ex-Browne-fans, and they run the gamut from barely literate to very well-spoken.

Ithink that a careful reading of the thread shows that Rox said that very thing himself fairly early on. Apparently, he came in guns blazing not because he was a fan of Browne, but because he hated people unfairly attacking spiritual subjects, which is what he mistakenly thought I was doing.

If it is, it's far more subtle than anything I've seen them capable of.

Besides, has it accomplished any of those things? Not to my knowledge.

Hope I fall into the "well spoken" category
 
Pretty childish, are we humans, at times. Every other species on the planet is perfectly fine with the cycle of birth, life, procreation, death. Except us.

I think that's an over-simplification. We're all in the cycle, really. And the "balance" is only there because all species try to destroy everything simultaneously, and keep one another in check.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom