Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Yes, I don't believe homeopathy works. I also don't believe in healing touch, Reiki or similar therapies.

May one ask: Why not? What about the claims of these practices left you cold and skeptical...some smart people (wrongly IMO) have embraced these as both effective and have claimed scientific proof for them. Unlike Sylvia, for example, Homeopaths claim scientific validity for the practice (though rejected by "traditional" scientists).

My point is: why these? If the claims made by these practices left you unimpressed, why would you embrace practices, assertions and beliefs that are equally, if not more, disputed and refuted?
 
I don't believe that someone as eloquent and unfazed as SRox could believe in Sylvia Browne. Her believers are mainly semi-literate, unsophisticated individuals, whose posting skills are full of woo-clues: Caps use, wacky coloured lettering, references to angels/spirit guides, etc.

SRox has displayed none of the above characteristics. I say he (or she) has never believed in Sylvia Browne's claimed abilities. Furthermore, I am not unconvinced that this is not a serious effort by the Browne machine to halt/undermine/undo the good work Robert Lancaster and James Randi have been doing to expose Browne for the fraud she is.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe that someone as eloquent and unfazed as SRox could believe in Sylvia Browne. Her believers are mainly semi-literate, unsophisticated individuals, whose posting skills are full of woo-clues: Caps use, wacky coloured lettering, references to angels/spirit guides, etc.

SRox has displayed none of the above characteristics. I say he (or she) has never believed in Sylvia Browne's claimed abilities. Furthermore, I am not unconvinced that this is not a serious effort by the Browne machine to halt/undermine/undo the good work Robert Lancaster and James Randi have been doing to expose Browne for the fraud she is.

I'm tending to agree with you at this point Reno. That may be world-weary cynicism on my part, but my cynicism is powered by experience and this thread is looking as though the benefit of the doubt I've given SRox for the last couple of days won't repay my investment.
 
I don't believe that someone as eloquent and unfazed as SRox could believe in Sylvia Browne. Her believers are mainly semi-literate, unsophisticated individuals, whose posting skills are full of woo-clues: Caps use, wacky coloured lettering, references to angels/spirit guides, etc.

SRox has displayed none of the above characteristics. I say he (or she) has never believed in Sylvia Browne's claimed abilities. Furthermore, I am not unconvinced that this is not a serious effort by the Browne machine to halt/undermine/undo the good work Robert Lancaster and James Randi have been doing to expose Browne for the fraud she is.

I have said before, that to generalise in this fashion is wrong. I am literate, and educated, and never used caps, or wacky colours in emails and posts, yet I used to believe in Sylvia Browne. It is a fundamental error to create this specific vision of a type of believer in anything.

It's also quite insulting to those who previously believed and have learned otherwise.

Belief in these matters is rarely to do with education or intelligence, although to persist in belief against contrary evidence may be a different matter.
 
I don't believe that someone as eloquent and unfazed as SRox could believe in Sylvia Browne. Her believers are mainly semi-literate, unsophisticated individuals, whose posting skills are full of woo-clues: Caps use, wacky coloured lettering, references to angels/spirit guides, etc.

SRox has displayed none of the above characteristics. I say he (or she) has never believed in Sylvia Browne's claimed abilities. Furthermore, I am not unconvinced that this is not a serious effort by the Browne machine to halt/undermine/undo the good work Robert Lancaster and James Randi have been doing to expose Browne for the fraud she is.


I've had similar thoughts the past few days; I find it questionable that someone with such a "Robert Lancaster is a dirt bag" (my inaccurate paraphrase of the orignial see of this thread by SR), in a matter of a few forum posts over a day or two, moved to "Hey, I was wrong...RL is not a dirt bag at all" (again my paraphrase).

I could be wrong...just seems like a MAJOR shift in thinking/beliefs, and quickly at that.
 
Thank you Reno and all...
From Reno's Post:
Furthermore, I am not unconvinced that this is not a serious effort by the Browne machine to halt/undermine/undo the good work Robert Lancaster and James Randi have been doing to expose Browne for the fraud she is.​
That's what I was trying to say yesterday but it didn't come out as well.
 
Last edited:
Reno,

Sorry to disagree with you, but "mainly" is not appropriate here. Not only am I one of those who is not illiterate, etc, but, I have met an enormous group of people who were drawn to Sylvia and eventually the philosophy...who are bright, creative, and could maintain themselves on this or any board quite well.

If anyone references angels, guides, or whatever does NOT mean they are out to lunch. It just means, perhaps that it is not a diet that your palate could stomach.
 
I've had similar thoughts the past few days; I find it questionable that someone with such a "Robert Lancaster is a dirt bag" (my inaccurate paraphrase of the orignial see of this thread by SR), in a matter of a few forum posts over a day or two, moved to "Hey, I was wrong...RL is not a dirt bag at all" (again my paraphrase).

I could be wrong...just seems like a MAJOR shift in thinking/beliefs, and quickly at that.
I'd like to give an anecdote of someone doing a quick and complete turnaround in his opinion of a person.

This happened in the late 1980s, when I was active in an evangelical church. A noted Christian radio personality (whose name I have forgotten) was scheduled to speak at our church. I wasn't too interested in him myself, having never heard his program, but a friend of mine was. For a couple of weeks before the event he was enthusiastic about it, anticipating the wonderful things he would hear from this speaker in person.

After the event, much to my surprise, he had completely changed his opinion. The speaker said a few things in his presentation that clashed with the image he had carefully maintained on his radio program. After that, my friend would have nothing more to do with him or his program.

(The speaker was not Rush Limbaugh; that much I remember!)
 
I've had similar thoughts the past few days; I find it questionable that someone with such a "Robert Lancaster is a dirt bag" (my inaccurate paraphrase of the orignial see of this thread by SR), in a matter of a few forum posts over a day or two, moved to "Hey, I was wrong...RL is not a dirt bag at all" (again my paraphrase).

I could be wrong...just seems like a MAJOR shift in thinking/beliefs, and quickly at that.

I really hope that's not the case. Otherwise Sylvia is digging herself into a deeper hole that will ruin what's left of her reputation. Suppose Randi found out.
 
I don't believe that someone as eloquent and unfazed as SRox could believe in Sylvia Browne. Her believers are mainly semi-literate, unsophisticated individuals, whose posting skills are full of woo-clues: Caps use, wacky coloured lettering, references to angels/spirit guides, etc.
Reno, I have received emails from Browne fans and ex-Browne-fans, and they run the gamut from barely literate to very well-spoken.

I say he (or she) has never believed in Sylvia Browne's claimed abilities.
Ithink that a careful reading of the thread shows that Rox said that very thing himself fairly early on. Apparently, he came in guns blazing not because he was a fan of Browne, but because he hated people unfairly attacking spiritual subjects, which is what he mistakenly thought I was doing.

Furthermore, I am not unconvinced that this is not a serious effort by the Browne machine to halt/undermine/undo the good work Robert Lancaster and James Randi have been doing to expose Browne for the fraud she is.
If it is, it's far more subtle than anything I've seen them capable of.

Besides, has it accomplished any of those things? Not to my knowledge.
 
As an experiment I've reread much of the thread after taking a homeopathic preparation of confirmation bias. The effect was to perceive, on the part of SRox, an enormous amount of prevarication and obfuscation, an amount that generally raises flags round my way:duck:
 
Reno, I have received emails from Browne fans and ex-Browne-fans, and they run the gamut from barely literate to very well-spoken.
Thanks Robert. I hope I'm on the well-spoken side! :D That's funny. :D
Not all of us can be English Majors like Sylvia but some of us still put some effort in expressing ourselves through the written word. ;)
 
SR, I am giving you the benefit of the doubt in that this is not what you had intended in the post where you initially brought this up, but this topic really is a burr under my saddle. If you prefer not to go into this topic in-depth, I can certainly sympathize, but please understand that for me, this topic affects me personally fairly deeply. I will not derail this thread further regarding this, I just wanted my feelings to be made known. Thank you.

(Conspi, I'm getting a funny feeling, is there room on your bandwagon?)
*Message Begins*

I've made some space. I got your telegram at the rail station in Tucumcari, New Mexico and made immediate arrangements. In fact I've cleared out the first-class cabin of pesky passengers, so she's a waitin' for ya iffn you change yer mind. It went like this:

CONDUCTOR DAVE
(Enters 1st class cabin on ConspiRaider Bandwagon)
GET OUT!

HIGH AND MIGHTY COUPLE
B.b.but why?!? We paid in new $20 gold pieces!

CONDUCTOR DAVE
H.

Mr. and Mrs. High and Mighty didn't even take their stuff when they left, so it's yours iffn you arrive. I opened the sliding door in their cabin and they both did a big ole diving belly-flop right onto the station platform there in Tucumcari.

Can take you aboard in Amarillo, Texas, our next stop. Please advise.

*Message Ends*
 
whose posting skills are full of woo-clues: Caps use, wacky coloured lettering, references to angels/spirit guides, etc.

Excuse me? :halo: (halo)

(hehehe)
 
Last edited:
Reno,

Sorry to disagree with you, but "mainly" is not appropriate here. Not only am I one of those who is not illiterate, etc, but, I have met an enormous group of people who were drawn to Sylvia and eventually the philosophy...who are bright, creative, and could maintain themselves on this or any board quite well.

If anyone references angels, guides, or whatever does NOT mean they are out to lunch. It just means, perhaps that it is not a diet that your palate could stomach.

Actually, it's amazing how many very smart people believe in very stupid things. Thanks for bringing that up.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.
Pretty childish, are we humans, at times. Every other species on the planet is perfectly fine with the cycle of birth, life, procreation, death. Except us.

Just because your consciousness ceases when you die, does not mean consciousness of you ceases. And there's the beauty, to me anyway. You'll "live" for decades afterwards. Maybe generations. Longer? I've got a picture of my grandfather and grandmother, both born in the late 1800s. And here we are into the 21st century and they are still, in a sense, "alive".

And what about offspring? That's the best answer to "eternal life" that Nature was able to devise. Works for me. I don't have kiddies yet, but some of my brothers and sisters do. They'll carry on our "line".

It's that unbroken string, that link-in-the-chain mindset of which you can indulge, to dispel the notion that when you die, it's all over. It is not.
 
Any greater understanding of modern science would seem to deflate the human ego: i.e., we're descended from apes, we are not immortal, but temporal, and we are destined to complete oblivion. When we die, our consciousness ceases forever. That's a horrifying prospect to me, one that is functionally intolerable, even if it's the rational approach.
I know many others have already responded to this, but I thought I would give my on take on it anyway. I believe this is the ultimate argument from one who is nearly ready to take the naturalistic stance, I know it was for me.

My study of science allowed me to dispese with it easily. I think we would both agree that the human brain, if it is a machine, is the most incredible machine that we know of. A computer can do some things in a second that a human could not do in a lifetime, but, incredibly, the reverse is also true. We perform tasks of computation with ease that we cannot yet attack with all the power of a modern computer.

Now, which deflates the human ego more?

1. The fact that we have discovered a brilliant mechanism (evolution) wherby a few simple rules have resulted, over billions of years, in the development of this magificent brain and body, or

2. The denial that this is possible and the belief that we could only have come into existance by magical creation of a yet more magificient creature.

IXP
 
SR has made a market value argument in favor of SB and I think that this needs addressing, given that this is obviously a language he speaks.

The argument in short is that psychics provide a service that is paid for by their customers, and that the market clears giving both parties utility from the transaction.

I am usually very persuaded by this. I believe firmly that people have a right to be stupid (outside of matters concerning small children). I think there are several points on this matter where the argument breaks down.

The argument assumes that the consumer knows what they are buying. Many people want to believe, and are willing to pay money to support this desire. The claims made by SB about her money going to support chairities and her accuracy and customer satisfaction cast serious doubt over the level to which her customers are educated about the product they are purchasing. Sites like this are here to educate the public. They improve the market by allowing people to make better decisions with their money.

This argument also assumes that the psychic provides a serivice and people get ustility from the transaction. I'm sure some people get satisfaction from their interaction with psychics, but families like the hornbecks are an exception that shows that people don't always get utility from their interaction with psychics. Many people have ruined their lives spending money for or making decisions based on psychics. This bait and switch makes it hard to say that the market clears satisfying both sides. Again this site combats SB on the level of education. the more that people know about her and her services the more they will be able to make better decisions with her money.

Inherent in the market value argument is the idea that the market always clears without externalities and that no regulation is needed from outside actors (government and regulatory bodies) for the market to function smoothly. Many people are effected outside of the people who consult psychics. Police agencies, families, friends and dependents are effected by the advice, money and time involved with these people. A more subtle example is health care. No matter how much you would want to get plastic surgury from a guy in a basement in newark, you can only get it from someone who has recieved a medical degree and has been certified. The JREF serves to inform the public over their policy choices. Hopefully at some point people will have to prove that they are psychics in order to practice as such. I am just being too wishful, but there is always hope.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom