Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Thank you for being tolerant of my stance. If you were to give me a lie detector test to determine whether I believe in God or not, who knows how it would come out? I just find religion to be extremely appealing and it helps me cope with fear on both a personal and an abstract level.


I find talking to the dead appealing but that doesn't mean it's true.


I do feel it is unfair to link religion with all suffering, an attitude which seems somewhat popular these days. I do believe it is important to be skeptical of things like Stalinism (that's my bugbear) also, which have caused immense suffering in the world but which aren't religious in nature.

Do you think things like lobotomies, racialists like Lothrop Stoddard & Madison Grant, wackjob economic theories, deconstruction and other things like that shouldn't be addressed by skeptics and included in the Skeptic's Dictionary


First of all we do address those things, we've got a forum for politics. Second, don't you think that Stalin, Stoddard and Grant thought that they were doing what was right?
 
Did you really just say you refuse to pass judgement on Charles Manson?



Depands, so yes/no to your questions. Mentally disabled people, and children have limited capacity in understanding how their actions relate to others. Define your parameters, if you wish to continue.

Actually, I'd rather not continue my discussion with you. I find you excessively curt: "Define your parameters, if you wish to continue" is not the language of friendly discourse.

If you're at all shocked by my refusal to pass judgment on another human being, you might want to do a little reading on early Christian ideology, if only for cultural reasons.
 
I find talking to the dead appealing but that doesn't mean it's true.





First of all we do address those things, we've got a forum for politics. Second, don't you think that Stalin, Stoddard and Grant thought that they were doing what was right?

The "do they think what they are doing is right" question refers to whether I feel that I can pass moral judgment on them. It does not concern whether or not their theories are legitimate, nor whether or not society needs to be protected from them.

Would you agree that skeptics generally discuss the paranormal and religion? I've seen many sites and books about skepticism, and they seem to be generally concerned with those subjects. My point is that a broader viewpoint should be taken by skeptics, to include all BS and not just paranormal or pseudo-scientific BS.
 
If you're at all shocked by my refusal to pass judgment on another human being, you might want to do a little reading on early Christian ideology, if only for cultural reasons.

You will find many people on this forum used to be quite religious in the most sincere way. I considered myself a Christian for years after I discovered my psychic ability was little more than very well honed parlor tricks.
 
Actually, I'd rather not continue my discussion with you. I find you excessively curt: "Define your parameters, if you wish to continue" is not the language of friendly discourse.

I found your false dilemma regarding mentally disabled people in relation to murderers to be disingenuous.

If you're at all shocked by my refusal to pass judgment on another human being, you might want to do a little reading on early Christian ideology, if only for cultural reasons.

Yes, I am "shocked" that you won't pass judgement on Charles Manson, but called Robert Lancaster a "slanderer, liar, utterly vicious, fascists, and a leader of a campaign of terror." Did your refusal to pass judgement start after June 2, 2007?

Not like it matters, but I am well-versed in Christian theology.
 
Last edited:
Unlike helpful American tv progs, here there is no immediate update after the natural break. I've been at a festival for a few days, & i do not think i shall easily be able to catch up. Would it be possible for anyone to give me an update from page 18?
 
I don't link religion/spirituality with all suffering. Non-religious ideologies can be just as horrid and destructive. The problem is, they seem to work in the same way, and at their roots, they are all ideologies.

Have you ever thought that the new age movement might actual be defusing a certain fundamentalist tendency within religion which tends to lead towards violence?
 
Have you ever thought that the new age movement might actual be defusing a certain fundamentalist tendency within religion which tends to lead towards violence?

My main problem with religion is that it seemed to be the main cause of violence.
 
Actually, I'd rather not continue my discussion with you. I find you excessively curt: "Define your parameters, if you wish to continue" is not the language of friendly discourse.

If you're at all shocked by my refusal to pass judgment on another human being, you might want to do a little reading on early Christian ideology, if only for cultural reasons.
Hiya SR, it's ME! You're favorite JREFer, eh? Shucks, thanks, just don't go overboard with your praise, I'll get all embarrassed and such.

Actually QG's reply to you was fine. I think you're ducking his post because you might have to answer some hard questions.

You must acknowledge something. Secretly, you rejoice that others have the ability to pass judgment on other human beings, right? You're not going to, no way, that's against your philosophy of life. But oh boy are you ever thankful there are others out there to pickup the slack. Do you acknowledge that your refusal to pass judgment on another human being is, in fact, a rather glaring weakness?
 
Has anyone asked SR what he thinks about this quote from one of Sylvia's ex-husbands?

I said "Sylvia, how can you tell people this kind of stuff? You know it's not true, and some of these people actually are probably going to believe that." And she said - and I won't put it exactly the word that she said but she said - but "Screw 'em. Anybody who believes this stuff oughtta be taken." And that pretty much sums up Sylvia's philosophy about the psychic stuff. And it's carried over, you know, into her, quote, uh... fraudulent career.

Video of this here: http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/images/interview_dufresnes_tarot.mp4

Full article here: http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/interview_dufresnes.shtml
 
Have you ever thought that the new age movement might actual be defusing a certain fundamentalist tendency within religion which tends to lead towards violence?

New age philosophy is nothing new, nor is it effective at defusing fundamentalist violence.
 
Hiya SR, it's ME! You're favorite JREFer, eh? Shucks, thanks, just don't go overboard with your praise, I'll get all embarrassed and such.

Actually QG's reply to you was fine. I think you're ducking his post because you might have to answer some hard questions.

You must acknowledge something. Secretly, you rejoice that others have the ability to pass judgment on other human beings, right? You're not going to, no way, that's against your philosophy of life. But oh boy are you ever thankful there are others out there to pickup the slack. Do you acknowledge that your refusal to pass judgment on another human being is, in fact, a rather glaring weakness?

How'd you know that you were my favorite, ConspiRaider? You're actually right, I am avoiding "the hard questions": I'd rather not engage in a long, drawn out debate, which apparently is leading to no greater understanding on either side. Especially when that person has an especially unappealing way of phrasing things. Others here are much more pleasant and interesting to talk to, including you, friend.

It's a moral weakness that I won't pass judgement, eh? You're downright Nietzschean. Yes, I was wrong about RSLancaster. Certainly, I never claimed that I was a perfect exemplar of my belief system.
 
New age philosophy is nothing new, nor is it effective at defusing fundamentalist violence.

"New age philosophy is nothing new"

I'm sure the irony in that statement was intended...but the New Age movement as we know it can be traced back mainly to the Theosophical Society, which I believe was founded in the 1880s (that's new to me, at least in religious terms).

Certainly, notions that you would consider nonsense existed before that, but Theosophy had a different flavor than anything that came before.
 
I hope that NOT passing judgement on another human being isn't considered a moral weakness. Perhaps, I am just reading that incorrectly?

I firmly believe that it is the act not actor is judged. Whatever belief or lack of belief each of us carries, does it give any of us the 'right' to judge another human being (soul, or whatever name you chose to give it)?

Since I feel that I am no better than anyone else on this planet, I can't pass judgement. But, I certainly do have feelings about the actions of a lot of people, Manson included.
 
Last edited:
How'd you know that you were my favorite, ConspiRaider? You're actually right, I am avoiding "the hard questions": I'd rather not engage in a long, drawn out debate, which apparently is leading to no greater understanding on either side. Especially when that person has an especially unappealing way of phrasing things. Others here are much more pleasant and interesting to talk to, including you, friend.

It's a moral weakness that I won't pass judgement, eh? You're downright Nietzschean. Yes, I was wrong about RSLancaster. Certainly, I never claimed that I was a perfect exemplar of my belief system.
I expect no perfection from anyone. Assume I'm the least perfect person on the planet and the odds will be on your side. What I'm really saying is this:

Let's take Charles Manson as a rather protruding example. Manson's been in the Big House nigh on 40 years, but incredibly the law says he can still come up for parole - despite his heinous crimes. The media swarms his parole hearings, always good for ratings. Including the CBS show, 60 Minutes.

There was the one I remember where Charlie said (almost exact words): "You all are lucky I'm locked up in this prison, because if I ever get out? There wouldn't be a one of you left alive!"

Somebody - somebodies actually - amongst us had to step forward and say, in the case of Manson: Hey you! What you did was wrong and intolerable! Now you gotta pay the price!

Don't you feel fortunate people such as that exist? I've got weaknesses, you've got weaknesses, we've all got them. We put our heads together and cover for each other. Right? Don't you think it is a good thing that, whereas you may find it difficult or impossible to pass judgment upon anyone, others amongst us do not?
 
I expect no perfection from anyone. Assume I'm the least perfect person on the planet and the odds will be on your side. What I'm really saying is this:

Let's take Charles Manson as a rather protruding example. Manson's been in the Big House nigh on 40 years, but incredibly the law says he can still come up for parole - despite his heinous crimes. The media swarms his parole hearings, always good for ratings. Including the CBS show, 60 Minutes.

There was the one I remember where Charlie said (almost exact words): "You all are lucky I'm locked up in this prison, because if I ever get out? There wouldn't be a one of you left alive!"

Somebody - somebodies actually - amongst us had to step forward and say, in the case of Manson: Hey you! What you did was wrong and intolerable! Now you gotta pay the price!

Don't you feel fortunate people such as that exist? I've got weaknesses, you've got weaknesses, we've all got them. We put our heads together and cover for each other. Right? Don't you think it is a good thing that, whereas you may find it difficult or impossible to pass judgment upon anyone, others amongst us do not?

Exactly. Someone needed to say, "your actions have hurt society, therefore you must go to prison for the rest of your life". The previous statement does not morally judge the perpretator, it judges the effect of his actions on society.

That's not the same as saying, "You're an EVIL man, and you are morally disgusting to me. Because of this, you must stay in prison." Only God and Manson (or just Manson, for most of you) know whether he knew he was doing evil.

Remember: this all stemmed from a question asked to me by QG (I believe QG). He basically asked whether it is wrong to offer a service to someone which does not exist (i.e., cleansing money). I said I needed to know whether the offerer of the service knew what they were doing wasn't legit. If they knew, it's morally wrong. If they didn't know, it's not morally wrong, but we still have to fix it.
 
Last edited:
I hope that NOT passing judgement on another human being isn't considered a moral weakness. Perhaps, I am just reading that incorrectly?

I firmly believe that it is the act not actor is judged. Whatever belief or lack of belief each of us carries, does it give any of us the 'right' to judge another human being (soul, or whatever name you chose to give it)?

Since I feel that I am no better than anyone else on this planet, I can't pass judgement. But, I certainly do have feelings about the actions of a lot of people, Manson included.

Would you refuse to serve on a jury in a murder trial in order to not pass judgement on the defendent, even though you may have "feelings" about the defendents actions?
 
Last edited:
*sigh* a sys admin's work is never done.
Code:
#cd /etc/beliefs
#ls -l
lrw-rw-rw-    1 Fundie Wackos           3 Jun 06 11:44 Bible -> nonsense
lrwxrwxrwx    1 Islamist Wackos         3 Jun 06 11:44 Koran -> nonsense
lrw-rw-rw-    1 Scientologist Wackos    3 Jun 06 11:44 Dianetics -> nonsense
#sed 's/God/positive energy/g' Bible | sed 's/sin/bad karma/g > NewAge
#ln -s NewAge nonsense
#chown WooWoo NewAge
Yes, I know symbolic links don't work this way, but go with it.
(note that Koran has execute permissions...)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom