Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

If the concern is the title of the thread, I have no problem with it being renamed. If the concern is the length of the thread, or a change of direction, I really am intent to stick with this thread alone and then fly away when it's done.

SR Fella,

What Ms Anthope is saying has nothing to do with the title of the threads. She is saying, as you are branching out on other topics, it would be easier if you started a new thread for the new topics.
 
No, it's okay to 'con' someone as long as you don't know you're doing it. I have no problem with the morality of doctors who believed bleeding was an effective cure. They were dead wrong, but they were not immoral.

Are the moral if they refuse to place their claims to scientific testing? I think they are not.
 
No, it's okay to 'con' someone as long as you don't know you're doing it. I have no problem with the morality of doctors who believed bleeding was an effective cure. They were dead wrong, but they were not immoral.

So you have to read someone's mind in order to condemn them for charging money for reading minds?
 
You wrote:


then you wrote:



So if we can't know #2, then it is not "wrong." So we if can't know what was in Sonia Lorrain Adams' mind then you can't condemn:



Source: http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/2537420/detail.html

No, we can condemn it as a society because WE know that the service is not real. But we can't say that she committed an immoral act (the question was "is it moral", IIRC) unless we know for sure whether she believed it was real or not. And there are times when a criminal will indeed admit she knew what she did was wrong.
 
So you have to read someone's mind in order to condemn them for charging money for reading minds?

Condemn them morally, as in say they are a bad person? Yeah, you need to be a mind-reader, or they need to confess. Not being morally judgmental is one of those bizarre notions that Jesus had.

Fining or imprisoning them for claiming to perform a service which we know for sure doesn't exist? No, that's just fine. We need to punish them, even if they're sincere, for society's good.
 
Condemn them morally, as in say they are a bad person? Yeah, you need to be a mind-reader, or they need to confess. Not being morally judgmental is one of those bizarre notions that Jesus had.

Fining or imprisoning them for claiming to perform a service which we know for sure doesn't exist? No, that's just fine. We need to punish them, even if they're sincere, for society's good.

Okay, so Randi can't condemn Browne because Randi admits he cannot read minds?

No, we can condemn it as a society because WE know that the service is not real. But we can't say that she committed an immoral act (the question was "is it moral", IIRC) unless we know for sure whether she believed it was real or not. And there are times when a criminal will indeed admit she knew what she did was wrong.

So, "as a society," can we condemn psychics?
 
Please re-read my post: It is not irrelevant for people who are seeking truth over just feeling good.

I understood your post. I believe that your idea of seeking truth (scientific skepticism) most likely makes you feel good. You have to sacrifice some things (that's the "over just feeling good" part), but I'll bet you enjoy it in the long run.
 
The question of whether God exists or not (or his 'legitimacy'), or whether Jesus gave the keys to heaven to St. Peter, is irrelevant. The positive effect on my life was immediate and recognizable. I am happier with the beautiful Christian religion than I was with atheism. Therefore, I am not being ripped off, and my experience, at least, is verifiable and legitimate.

If that's where you want to be, in this respect, I have no opinion other than "whatever floats your boat." When religion or spirituality gets into politics and education, that's another thing.

There is a point when this comfort can be harmful. Prayer/Meditation over medical help, which you have rightly pointed out as a concern. What about the person who makes a decision that directly impacts their life based on what a card reader, psychic or even horoscope says? One might say they deserve what they get, but it's not a victimless crime. If someone is paying their hard earned money to be told to quit their job, dump their boyfriend, and not to travel (even to see a dying relative), and the advice is based on nothing, then it is a problem.

Star charts, card readings and psychic readings cost money. Hypnotic regression and books about this stuff cost money. People are making decisions about their lives based on these things. People ARE being hurt by these things. When the line crosses from comfort to impacting one's life, it is important that fraud be exposed. There is recourse for a person who rips you off in every type of business transaction. Yet somehow the disclaimer about "entertainment purposes only" gives these people a free pass.

Yep, I take issue with it and I want it exposed.

If you go to Catholic services, and you give an offering to support the church and the comfort and counseling it provides, I think that is fine, and wonderful for you. Sincerely. If, however, the money in that offering plate is going to fly some bishop to DC to lead an anti-abortion rally, pay a child molesting priest's out of court settlement to keep him out of jail, or lobby some politician to keep gay marriage illegal, then, I think you have a right to know, and decide whether you are supporting your need for spiritual comfort, or something else altogether. That establishment that provides you comfort unfortunately may be causing a whole lot of misery in the lives of people who choose to believe otherwise, or not at all.

That is what I take issue with.
 
Last edited:
Okay, so Randi can't condemn Browne because Randi admits he cannot read minds?



So, "as a society," can we condemn psychics?

He certainly can morally condemn them, I just don't think it's the right thing to do.

But yes, as a society we can condemn them if they are unable to prove they are providing a useful service.
 
Condemn them morally, as in say they are a bad person? Yeah, you need to be a mind-reader, or they need to confess. Not being morally judgmental is one of those bizarre notions that Jesus had.

Bizarre is correct. A person is bad because of their actions, not because of what they think of that action. Jesus was wrong.

Fining or imprisoning them for claiming to perform a service which we know for sure doesn't exist? No, that's just fine.

Like.. psychic services?
 
He certainly can morally condemn them, I just don't think it's the right thing to do.

So in your moral understanding, Randi should just shut his mouth, and let Browne continue without anyone in the world questioning her?

But yes, as a society we can condemn them if they are unable to prove they are providing a useful service.

Useful, in terms of doing what they claim?
 
Condemn them morally, as in say they are a bad person? Yeah, you need to be a mind-reader, or they need to confess. Not being morally judgmental is one of those bizarre notions that Jesus had.

So if Charles Manson didn't realize what he was doing was wrong we shouldn't condemn him for murder?

Personally, I don't care if Manson thought it was a good idea or really believed he was Jesus. He is a morally disgusting human being who belongs behind bars.
 
Last edited:
If that's where you want to be, in this respect, I have no opinion other than "whatever floats your boat." When religion or spirituality gets into politics and education, that's another thing.

There is a point when this comfort can be harmful. Prayer/Meditation over medical help, which you have rightly pointed out as a concern. What about the person who makes a decision that directly impacts their life based on what a card reader, psychic or even horoscope says? One might say they deserve what they get, but it's not a victimless crime. If someone is paying their hard earned money to be told to quit their job, dump their boyfriend, and not to travel (even to see a dying relative), and the advice is based on nothing, then it is a problem.

Star charts, card readings and psychic readings cost money. Hypnotic regression and books about this stuff cost money. People are making decisions about their lives based on these things. People ARE being hurt by these things. When the line crosses from comfort to impacting one's life, it is important that fraud be exposed.

If you go to Catholic services, and you give an offering to support the church and the comfort and counseling it provides, I think that is fine, and wonderful for you. Sincerely. If, however, the money in that offering plate is going to fly some bishop to DC to lead an anti-abortion rally, pay a child molesting priest's out of court settlement, or lobby some politician to keep gay marriage illegal, then, I think you have a right to know, and decide whether you are supporting your need for spiritual comfort, or something else altogether. That establishment that provides you comfort unfortunately may be causing a whole lot of misery in the lives of people who choose to believe otherwise, or not at all.

That is what I take issue with.

Thank you for being tolerant of my stance. If you were to give me a lie detector test to determine whether I believe in God or not, who knows how it would come out? I just find religion to be extremely appealing and it helps me cope with fear on both a personal and an abstract level.

I do feel it is unfair to link religion with all suffering, an attitude which seems somewhat popular these days. I do believe it is important to be skeptical of things like Stalinism (that's my bugbear) also, which have caused immense suffering in the world but which aren't religious in nature.

Do you think things like lobotomies, racialists like Lothrop Stoddard & Madison Grant, wackjob economic theories, deconstruction and other things like that shouldn't be addressed by skeptics and included in the Skeptic's Dictionary?
 
The question of whether God exists or not (or his 'legitimacy'), or whether Jesus gave the keys to heaven to St. Peter, is irrelevant. The positive effect on my life was immediate and recognizable. I am happier with the beautiful Christian religion than I was with atheism. Therefore, I am not being ripped off, and my experience, at least, is verifiable and legitimate.
But if your priest was to charge you $1000 to attend church and then another $700 for 1/2 an hour to hear your confession you *would* be getting ripped off.

This is what Browne does.

Also, think of the number of televangelists that have been gaoled for ripping off their flock.

While most of the major organised religions expect some donations to keep them going (or whatever they do with the cash) it can be argued that at least the fleeced are getting their money's worth.

It's the difference between $1 on a lottery ticket and $100 on a pyramid scheme. Both voluntary contributions triggered by greed.
 
So if Charles Manson didn't realize what he was doing was wrong we shouldn't condemn him for murder?

Personally, I don't care if Manson thought it was a good idea or really believed he was Jesus. He is a morally disgusting human being who belongs behind bars.

You can condemn him, and most people will. I just refuse to pass judgement on people on a moral level, I try to assume good faith and think about the possible reasons for them committing bizarre and evil acts and how they can be stopped (prison).

But how can he have committed an immoral act unless he was aware he was doing wrong? Can a mentally retarded person be morally disgusting?
 
Thank you for being tolerant of my stance. If you were to give me a lie detector test to determine whether I believe in God or not, who knows how it would come out? I just find religion to be extremely appealing and it helps me cope with fear on both a personal and an abstract level.

I do feel it is unfair to link religion with all suffering, an attitude which seems somewhat popular these days. I do believe it is important to be skeptical of things like Stalinism (that's my bugbear) also, which have caused immense suffering in the world but which aren't religious in nature.

Do you think things like lobotomies, racialists like Lothrop Stoddard & Madison Grant, wackjob economic theories, deconstruction and other things like that shouldn't be addressed by skeptics and included in the Skeptic's Dictionary?

I don't link religion/spirituality with all suffering. Non-religious ideologies can be just as horrid and destructive. The problem is, they seem to work in the same way, and at their roots, they are all ideologies.
 
You can condemn him, and most people will. I just refuse to pass judgement on people on a moral level, I try to assume good faith and think about the possible reasons for them committing bizarre and evil acts and how they can be stopped (prison).

Did you really just say you refuse to pass judgement on Charles Manson?

But how can he have committed an immoral act unless he was aware he was doing wrong? Can a mentally retarded person be morally disgusting?

Mentally disabled people, and children have limited capacity in understanding how their actions relate to others. Define your parameters, if you wish to continue.
 
Last edited:
You can condemn him, and most people will. I just refuse to pass judgement on people on a moral level, I try to assume good faith and think about the possible reasons for them committing bizarre and evil acts and how they can be stopped (prison).

:sehuh:

(I'm sorry guys, I have to do it)

I don't know how you can say this based on your opening post about Robert. It is completely contradictory. I'm honestly not trying to be hostile and inflammatory, but for the life of me I don't know how to type the words without it seeming so. Yes, you did backtrack, and that says a lot about the good nature of your character. But I just don't know how to reconcile this. That you would say such things but give a pass to frauds and geez, Manson?

But how can he have committed an immoral act unless he was aware he was doing wrong? Can a mentally retarded person be morally disgusting?
No, but a psychic can.
:hb:

(clearly I need to unsubscribe for a bit)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom