Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

But even the milder forms of "woo" (for lack of a better word) involve the willing suspension of logic and common sense. And by participating in these things, I think that a person opens themself up to the more directly harmful varieties of nonsense.

For example, you mention feng shui as being one of the less harmful delusions. What does it matter if someone thigs that rearranging their furniture based on this?

Well, feng shui is largely based on the concept of qi/chi, a magical (and unproven) force which supposedly runs through all things. If a person buys into that, it is a short hop to buying into all sort of Chinese "alternative medicines" which also are based on this supposed energy. And medical woo is among the most potentially harmful I can think of.

Accepting one bit of magical thinking can lead to accepting more and more. Does it always? No. But it often does, which is why a lot of us here try to nip it in the bud when we can.
Sorry Robert, but this is a logical fallacy called the Slippery Slope Fallacy. That doesn't mean that what you are saying is wrong, just that it is not a logical argument.

I dabbled in all sorts of mystical things like seances and astral projection, but it did not lead me to the hard stuff.

What I find is that wooish notions, like addictions, tend to occur in certain people and you can't really protect a person from them.
 
"Meaning in their lives" How does having more children than you can love, feed and educate give a family meaning?

Don't even get me started! Speaking only for myself....as an atheist I do find all religion to be harmful. If you truly want meaning in your life...read a good book, mentor a child, listen to music or start a garden.

Susan

Probably best not to derail, but I'll respond. I'm not a Catholic, but Catholic art, Catholic literature, Catholic symbolism and Catholic ceremony have been a major positive influence in my life, and in general, Christianity and Eastern religions have given me a personal satisfaction that I never had before. I agree that there are problems with the Church's stance on child-birth issues.
 
Probably best not to derail, but I'll respond. I'm not a Catholic, but Catholic art, Catholic literature, Catholic symbolism and Catholic ceremony have been a major positive influence in my life, and in general, Christianity and Eastern religions have given me a personal satisfaction that I never had before. I agree that there are problems with the Church's stance on child-birth issues.

Catholicism having a "positive influence for you" says nothing about it being correct, legitimate, true, or evidence based.

It's like saying Zeus also helps people. It may be helpful, but that does not respond to the question of whether the belief is evidence based.

Hezbollah engages in charity and poverty programs (see section on "Social services"). However, that does not make their religious beliefs correct or moral.
 
Last edited:
My original question was: Is it ethical to take money for promising a service that is not real?

You answered "no" then wrote "They provide a useful service by giving people meaning in their lives." Do you mean "yes it is ethical"?

"The JREF does not do that." Well, OK, then if enough voices suggest that this discussion ought to end, I'll leave.

It's a complex question, and each case is different. The following questions matter:

1. Does the service exist?
2. Does the giver of the service believe the service exists?
3. Is the service something abstract, like spiritual guidance (i.e., asking a priest or monk for counsel)?

If the answer is no to all three, then it is wrong.
 
Catholicism having a "positive influence for you" says nothing about it being correct, legitimate, true, or evidence based.

It's like saying Zeus also helps people. It may be helpful, but that does not respond to the question of whether the belief is evidence based.

Hezbollah engages in charity and poverty programs (see section on "Social services"). However, that does not make their religious beliefs correct or moral.

When did I state Catholicism was "correct, legitimate, true, or evidence based"? Certain parts of it merely work for me. I embrace things that make me happy, unless they begin to negatively influence me (i.e., take my money, make me give up real medical treatment).

Nor did I bring up charity or social services as reasons for why I think the Church has the potential to be a positive force in one's life. This is a debate I have had many times with many different people. I once was a very strong atheist, and I do understand your attitude.
 
"The JREF does not do that." Well, OK, then if enough voices suggest that this discussion ought to end, I'll leave.

It's a complex question, and each case is different. The following questions matter:

1. Does the service exist?
2. Does the giver of the service believe the service exists?
3. Is the service something abstract, like spiritual guidance (i.e., asking a priest or monk for counsel)?

If the answer is no to all three, then it is wrong.

Thought experiment:

1) Someone (a medium) is willing to cleanse "cursed" money.
2) The customer believes this service is real.
3) It makes the customer/believer feel good that the cursed money is gone and positive events can now occur.

Is that moral?
 
When did I state Catholicism was "correct, legitimate, true, or evidence based"? Certain parts of it merely work for me. I embrace things that make me happy, unless they begin to negatively influence me (i.e., take my money, make me give up real medical treatment).

When did I claim that you claimed such? I was merely pointing out that your argument does not address its validity.

Nor did I bring up charity or social services as reasons for why I think the Church has the potential to be a positive force in one's life. This is a debate I have had many times with many different people. I once was a very strong atheist, and I do understand your attitude.

You brought up positive aspects of religion, and so did I. My point was positive contributions have nothing to do with legitimacy.
 
Thought experiment:

1) Someone (a medium) is willing to cleanse "cursed" money.
2) The customer believes this service is real.
3) It makes the customer/believer feel good that the cursed money is gone and positive events can now occur.

Is that moral?

My second question was whether the giver of the service believed the service was real (or legit, so to speak), not whether the customer did. I need to know the answer to that. Of course, if the customer believed it were fake he would not be looking into the service.
 
"The JREF does not do that." Well, OK, then if enough voices suggest that this discussion ought to end, I'll leave.
Hi SR,

You are as entitled to post your thoughts as anyone here within the boundaries of the forum rules. Again, people are going to respond in all manner of ways, but it is not up to anyone to say "the discussion is over" for you. (Unless a mod thinks it should go into "Abandon all hope", that is!)

I think it may be a good idea to start a new thread, and engage in some of the ongoing topics (click "new posts" heading on the black bar). My reasons for this opinion are to distance the discussion from your original post and the post's title. Also, this discussion has moved quite a distance from that topic, and it's possible a moderator may decide to split it anyway. Now, this is a merely a sincerely helpful suggestion and my opinion, and in no way am I telling you what you must do.

I think you've opened up a whole new area of discussion and a new thread starting the discussion would bring in fresh posters and help keep the conversation closer to this new direction.
 
My second question was whether the giver of the service believed the service was real (or legit, so to speak), not whether the customer did. I need to know the answer to that. Of course, if the customer believed it were fake he would not be looking into the service.

Fine, how can you tell what a person "really" thinks? How do you know a tarot reader really believes their claims? Once you explain this I can respond.

I'd love to see proof that Browne, Edward, DuBios, Van Praagh, etc believe their own claims.
 
When did I claim that you claimed such? I was merely pointing out that your argument does not address its validity.



You brought up positive aspects of religion, and so did I. My point was positive contributions have nothing to do with legitimacy.

The question of whether God exists or not (or his 'legitimacy'), or whether Jesus gave the keys to heaven to St. Peter, is irrelevant. The positive effect on my life was immediate and recognizable. I am happier with the beautiful Christian religion than I was with atheism. Therefore, I am not being ripped off, and my experience, at least, is verifiable and legitimate.
 
Fine, how can you tell what a person "really" thinks? How do you know a tarot reader really believes their claims? Once you explain this I can respond.

I'd love to see proof that Browne, Edward, DuBios, Van Praagh, etc believe their own claims.

We can't know, but they know. Trust me, I'm sure they know, at least in moments when they are candid with themselves. And the moral decision is up to them, and whether they believe the service is legit or not is necessary for me to answer the original question.
 
The question of whether God exists or not (or his 'legitimacy'), or whether Jesus gave the keys to heaven to St. Peter, is irrelevant. The positive effect on my life was immediate and recognizable. I am happier with the beautiful Christian religion than I was with atheism. Therefore, I am not being ripped off, and my experience, at least, is verifiable and legitimate.

It is not irrelevant for people who are seeking truth over just feeling good.
 
It's a complex question, and each case is different. The following questions matter:

1. Does the service exist?
2. Does the giver of the service believe the service exists?
3. Is the service something abstract, like spiritual guidance (i.e., asking a priest or monk for counsel)?

If the answer is no to all three, then it is wrong.

Ah yes, the whole "it's okay to con a person as long as they don't know they've been conned" argument.
 
Hi SR,

You are as entitled to post your thoughts as anyone here within the boundaries of the forum rules. Again, people are going to respond in all manner of ways, but it is not up to anyone to say "the discussion is over" for you. (Unless a mod thinks it should go into "Abandon all hope", that is!)

I think it may be a good idea to start a new thread, and engage in some of the ongoing topics (click "new posts" heading on the black bar). My reasons for this opinion are to distance the discussion from your original post and the post's title. Also, this discussion has moved quite a distance from that topic, and it's possible a moderator may decide to split it anyway. Now, this is a merely a sincerely helpful suggestion and my opinion, and in no way am I telling you what you must do.

I think you've opened up a whole new area of discussion and a new thread starting the discussion would bring in fresh posters and help keep the conversation closer to this new direction.

If the concern is the title of the thread, I have no problem with it being renamed. If the concern is the length of the thread, or a change of direction, I really am intent to stick with this thread alone and then fly away when it's done.
 
Before I answer that question, would you consider the Catholic Church, or a similar organization, susceptible to this rule? As in, because there is no real service being done, because there is no evidence for God, they are possibly committing an unethical act?

I know I'm late and catching back up, but gotta touch this one too...

Yes, I would and I do.
 
Ah yes, the whole "it's okay to con a person as long as they don't know they've been conned" argument.

No, it's okay to 'con' someone as long as you don't know you're doing it. I have no problem with the morality of doctors who believed bleeding was an effective cure. They were dead wrong, but they were not immoral.
 
You wrote:
It's a complex question, and each case is different. The following questions matter:

1. Does the service exist?
2. Does the giver of the service believe the service exists?
3. Is the service something abstract, like spiritual guidance (i.e., asking a priest or monk for counsel)?

If the answer is no to all three, then it is wrong.

then you wrote:

We can't know, but they know. Trust me, I'm sure they know, at least in moments when they are candid with themselves. And the moral decision is up to them, and whether they believe the service is legit or not is necessary for me to answer the original question.

So if we can't know #2, then it is not "wrong." So we if can't know what was in Sonia Lorrain Adams' mind then you can't condemn:

A 64-year-old Greeley woman told police that the suspect told her that her money was cursed and needed to be cleansed following her husband's death. The woman said she gave the suspect nearly $5,000 in cash and wrote a check for $33,000 in June.

Source: http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/2537420/detail.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom