Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

[...]
But yes, I am more skeptical of Sylvia and Novus now, and I don't see myself doing anything more than, at most, reading a used book of hers.
I read Exploring the Levels of Creation not long ago, borrowed from the local library, to find out more about her religious philosophy. Took awhile to get through it, not because it was poorly written but because I wasn't very enthused about reading it. It also seemed to lack a bit of consistency, but that may just be to the nature of the subject(s).

Not having read anything else by her, I can't compare it at all. But as a bit of a summary, it has three main sections; the seven levels of the underworld (basically, categories of where entities fit, such as elves and dragons), seven levels of earth (her own take on child development and advice for adults; practically worthless with respect to learning about her spiritual philosophy) and seven levels of the other side (only the first couple levels and last level are insightful as to her philosophy, the rest of the levels seem more like hobbies for people on the other side). It finishes by 'revisiting' older subjects that were mildly interesting, but being filler didn't offer enough information at all.

It's recent and I guess, overall, it might be a good one for you to try. It would surely be a good choice compared to other recent titles such as Spiritual Connections or a book about animals or dreams. But having said that, she's written dozens of books, so you might be better served with one more suited to what you're looking for.

Hope this helps, though it probably doesn't. :)
 
However, I feel like it is a big stretch to say that feng shui experts, astrologers or tarot card readers seriously hurt anyone, and I don't even see why it's worth making 'skeptical inquiries' into them.

You are the leader of a large country with a very powerful military.

A crisis situation has come up, and you have fifteen minutes to decide whether to solve it with diplomacy or send in the marines or tactical nukes.

You spend that fifteen minutes consulting your wife's astrologer, who hasn't even heard of the country you need to deal with....
 
The posters in this thread have made a strong argument that certain psychics hurt people, particularly the ones who work in missing persons cases.

However, I feel like it is a big stretch to say that feng shui experts, astrologers or tarot card readers seriously hurt anyone, and I don't even see why it's worth making 'skeptical inquiries' into them.

Let's leave "harm" to the side for now. Is it ethical to take money for promising a service that is not real? A service that there is 1) no proof for and 2) that is contrary to evidence.
 
Let's leave "harm" to the side for now. Is it ethical to take money for promising a service that is not real? A service that there is 1) no proof for and 2) that is contrary to evidence.

Before I answer that question, would you consider the Catholic Church, or a similar organization, susceptible to this rule? As in, because there is no real service being done, because there is no evidence for God, they are possibly committing an unethical act?
 
You are the leader of a large country with a very powerful military.

A crisis situation has come up, and you have fifteen minutes to decide whether to solve it with diplomacy or send in the marines or tactical nukes.

You spend that fifteen minutes consulting your wife's astrologer, who hasn't even heard of the country you need to deal with....

I find it much more likely that people will be harmed be in the long term by 'theories' like Marxism, Fascism, psychoanalysis or multiculturalism than a supposed 'pseudo-science' like astrology.
 
Before I answer that question, would you consider the Catholic Church, or a similar organization, susceptible to this rule? As in, because there is no real service being done, because there is no evidence for God, they are possibly committing an unethical act?

They do pass a collection plate, but they don't exactly charge for a service, the way SB does. But many/most of us here are not big fans of religion.
 
Before I answer that question, would you consider the Catholic Church, or a similar organization, susceptible to this rule? As in, because there is no real service being done, because there is no evidence for God, they are possibly committing an unethical act?

Yes, read James Randi's book "The Faith Healers," he devotes a section to Catholic healing claims.

Please answer the question.
 
I am only vaguely familiar with the works of Blavatsky and Chopra, but I will answer this in a more general sense.

Certainly, there are purveyors of fluff and nonsense who may be said to be causing less (direct) harm than others.

But even the milder forms of "woo" (for lack of a better word) involve the willing suspension of logic and common sense. And by participating in these things, I think that a person opens themself up to the more directly harmful varieties of nonsense.

For example, you mention feng shui as being one of the less harmful delusions. What does it matter if someone thigs that rearranging their furniture based on this?

Well, feng shui is largely based on the concept of qi/chi, a magical (and unproven) force which supposedly runs through all things. If a person buys into that, it is a short hop to buying into all sort of Chinese "alternative medicines" which also are based on this supposed energy. And medical woo is among the most potentially harmful I can think of.

Accepting one bit of magical thinking can lead to accepting more and more. Does it always? No. But it often does, which is why a lot of us here try to nip it in the bud when we can.

I don't think it's fair to discount things merely because some irresponsible, childish-minded fool will take them too far. Should we reject Christianity because some people believe in faith healing? Or should we merely reject faith healing? Accepting the existence of some things on faith is necessary for many of us to get through life.
 
Can you give me the specific questions you want me to answer? I'm not going to answer hostile questions, or questions which are designed to force me to concede points which I'm not willing to concede.

Yes. You wrote:

1. The man demonstrates he does not speak or understand English on the level of what we generally consider an 'English speaker'.

2. Lancaster says the man speaks English.

3. I find that questionable.

However, James Randi wrote:

Robert: re the Bixby/Browne video, it should be said that I mixed with that section of our audience following the incident, and as far as I could tell, all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml

Thus, you are questioning the man "speaks English" despite having a direct quote from someone who was there that is contrary to your belief.

Why are you doubting Randi's knowledge of the German tourist?
 
Yes, read James Randi's book "The Faith Healers," he devotes a section to Catholic healing claims.

Please answer the question.

If you're going to include the Catholic Church, and similar organizations, then no. They provide a useful service by giving people meaning in their lives.
 
If you're going to include the Catholic Church, and similar organizations, then no. They provide a useful service by giving people meaning in their lives.

My original question was: Is it ethical to take money for promising a service that is not real?

You answered "no" then wrote "They provide a useful service by giving people meaning in their lives." Do you mean "yes it is ethical"?
 
Pardon my skepticism, but is there any chance that SylviaRox keeps this thread going so that the other poignant threads about Sylvia (Lori Pleasants and Jamie Barker threads to name a few) are lost and forgotten?
 
Pardon my skepticism, but is there any chance that SylviaRox keeps this thread going so that the other poignant threads about Sylvia (Lori Pleasants and Jamie Barker threads to name a few) are lost and forgotten?

If this thread is disturbing the website, an admin may feel free to lock it, and will receive no objection from me. My experience here has been positive.
 
If you're going to include the Catholic Church, and similar organizations, then no. They provide a useful service by giving people meaning in their lives.

"Meaning in their lives" How does having more children than you can love, feed and educate give a family meaning?

Don't even get me started! Speaking only for myself....as an atheist I do find all religion to be harmful. If you truly want meaning in your life...read a good book, mentor a child, listen to music or start a garden.

Susan
 
Pardon my skepticism, but is there any chance that SylviaRox keeps this thread going so that the other poignant threads about Sylvia (Lori Pleasants and Jamie Barker threads to name a few) are lost and forgotten?

Speaking of which, have you seen the one on Terry Webb whose daughters "want[ed] Browne to tell them where on the base, she believes, their father is buried."

Or the one about Anthony Urciuoli whose parents "spent $50,000 to find his missing son, Tony, including fees to some 10 or so psychics."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom