Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Wow...that's what I always say to myself before hitting the "post reply" button! :eek:
A little shocked to see my name included in Cleon's post so I have to say 'thank you'. :)

Unfortunately this thread is a bunch of us talking about the same thing, going around and around in circles but never getting to the point where SylviaRox answers the questions posed.
It's quite frustrating although hopefully not futile.
I never lose hope.

Can you give me the specific questions you want me to answer? I'm not going to answer hostile questions, or questions which are designed to force me to concede points which I'm not willing to concede.
 
We KNOW that wild guessing exists, and is therefore a likely explanation for a wrong answer. We DON'T know that these hypothetical "signals in the air" exist. Until there is some evidence for them, they are not an acceptable explanation.

The simplest explanation is not always correct. I'm aware of Occam's razor, of course, but it is important to at the very least acknowledge the possibility that forces exist in the universe we are unaware of.
 
The simplest explanation is not always correct. I'm aware of Occam's razor, of course, but it is important to at the very least acknowledge the possibility that forces exist in the universe we are unaware of.

Hmm... I'm not aware of any. :D

M.
 
Almo, please read through at least the more recent posts on this thread; Sylviarox has moderated his position somewhat, and replying directly to the OP at this point is a bit counterproductive.

[/delurk]

Actually, I had read around the thread a bit. I just missed the important bits apparently. Sorry about that.
 
The simplest explanation is not always correct. I'm aware of Occam's razor, of course, but it is important to at the very least acknowledge the possibility that forces exist in the universe we are unaware of.

True...but if there is only one explanation that has actually been shown to exist, then that's the one I'm betting on. Otherwise, you open the door to all kinds of nonsense. How could you function if you had to consider, before making up your mind about something, not only the reasonable possibilities, but an infinite number of imaginary possibilities as well?

It's marvelous that we can imagine so many fanciful possibilities, but only the sensible ones are useful in the real world.


ETA: By the way, give yourself ten brownie points for recognizing my mangled version of Occam's razor...
 
Last edited:
I understand what you are saying, but I need to point out that you cannot add probabilities that way. As a simple proof: The probability of tossing a coin and it coming up heads is 50%. So if you do it 3 times, there is 50 + 50 + 50 = 150% probability of having at least one heads!

You "add" proabilities by multiplying 1-p and then subtracting this from one. This is the probability that at least one would occur. In your example:

1 - (.9 * .8 * .98 *.9 * .9 * .9) = .485

IXP

Damn, looks like I'll have to dust off my textbook.

My main point stands, however.
 
Can you give me the specific questions you want me to answer? I'm not going to answer hostile questions, or questions which are designed to force me to concede points which I'm not willing to concede.


I can't blame you one bit SR!
If I were you I might have run away long ago so I applaud you!

I basically would like to know what you meant by the link to Novus' Hypnosis/Self-healing for HIV/AIDS classes but if it's too personal and you regret posting it, I understand.

I would, however, like to know if since you've been here if you've changed your mind at all to be more open to the possibility that what you have sunk your teeth in and *previously* defended so vehemently may have worms in it?

I understand that there will be people who will cling to Sylvia and Novus regardless of what truth comes out about them...solid proof...but at least I can breathe easier if I knew that when you go back, you will have an open mind and a closed wallet.
And I'm not saying that to be smart-allecked. I say it because it's true and I care.
(I defended SB & NS until solid proof came out that could no longer be denied)
 
Last edited:
I can't blame you one bit SR!
If I were you I might have run away long ago so I applaud you!

I basically would like to know what you meant by the link to Novus' Hypnosis/Self-healing for HIV/AIDS classes but if it's too personal and you regret posting it, I understand.

I would, however, like to know if since you've been here if you've changed your mind at all to be more open to the possibility that what you have sunk your teeth in and *previously* defended so vehemently may have worms in it?

I understand that there will be people who will cling to Sylvia and Novus regardless of what truth comes out about them...solid proof...but at least I can breathe easier if I knew that when you go back, you will have an open mind and a closed wallet.
And I'm not saying that to be smart-allecked. I say it because it's true and I care.
(I defended SB & NS until solid proof came out that could no longer be denied)

I'm disturbed that AIDS patients are turning to new age remedies. I am very open to spiritual ideas and concepts, but I think medical care is something you have to be highly skeptical about. I think it's great that Sylvia is offering the course for free, I just hope no one interprets past-life regression therapy as a real way to deal with their physical problems.

Sylvia is one of many spiritual leaders who I am interested in, some of whom make supernatural claims and some of whom don't. But yes, I am more skeptical of Sylvia and Novus now, and I don't see myself doing anything more than, at most, reading a used book of hers.
 
BRAVO SR!!
I give you a standing ovation and since I'm sitting on the floor instead of the traditional PC desk and chair, that means alot!! :D
 
I'm glad Robert is talking with SylviaRox behind the scenes.
Well, we're not pen-pals or anythiing, but we've PM'd a time or two.

When I first told my husband (who's the jealous type) what Robert and I talk about in emails and I showed him his website, the first thing he said was "Invite him over for dinner! He seems like a great guy!"
Set the table, I'm on my way! :) (Thanks, you're very kind.)

Thank you Cleon, some posters have been very helpful, and others less so, but the more ridiculous off-topic posters seem to have gone away, and the more hostile users have toned it done somewhat (although one is still very active).
Yeah, like the guy who started this thread! :D
 
Originally Posted by SylviaRox
Thank you Cleon, some posters have been very helpful, and others less so, but the more ridiculous off-topic posters seem to have gone away, and the more hostile users have toned it done somewhat (although one is still very active).

Posted by RSL:
Yeah, like the guy who started this thread!​

:D Robert, you crack me up!!
Sorry SR...it's been a long day.

But seriously, if you're ever out east, you and Susan are more than welcome!!
Just be fore-warned...I cook alot and I cook well!!
When I met my hubby I could see his ribs...2 weeks later they disappeared and I haven't seen 'em since!!
Then again...I think Susan's already taken care of that, hasn't she?

ZING!! :duck:
 
SylviaRox said:
... it is important to at the very least acknowledge the possibility that forces exist in the universe we are unaware of.
Hmm... I'm not aware of any. :D

M.
When it comes to metaphysics, you need to look at physics as well. And as far as physics goes, we're still trying to understand dark matter and dark energy (and I'm not referring to Sylvia's definition of "dark" here), and we're still looking for the Higgs boson.

But they have nothing to do with psychics.

So far a lot of searching for something physical (a particle, or perhaps a quantum effect) that can account for the effects supposed to exist by psychics, tarot card readers, astrologers, feng shui experts and the like has failed to turn up anything. That's the reason we're skeptics.
 
When it comes to metaphysics, you need to look at physics as well. And as far as physics goes, we're still trying to understand dark matter and dark energy (and I'm not referring to Sylvia's definition of "dark" here), and we're still looking for the Higgs boson.

But they have nothing to do with psychics.

So far a lot of searching for something physical (a particle, or perhaps a quantum effect) that can account for the effects supposed to exist by psychics, tarot card readers, astrologers, feng shui experts and the like has failed to turn up anything. That's the reason we're skeptics.

The posters in this thread have made a strong argument that certain psychics hurt people, particularly the ones who work in missing persons cases.

However, I feel like it is a big stretch to say that feng shui experts, astrologers or tarot card readers seriously hurt anyone, and I don't even see why it's worth making 'skeptical inquiries' into them.

After all, ideas seemingly more scientific and rational can hurt people much, more more (for example, Monsieur Le Bon, quoted in your signature, was an intellectual influence on Mussolini and Hitler, and the ideas of Marx are still taught favorably in universities). What's the harm if someone reads Madame Blavatsky or Deepak Chopra?

Also, I would say that the fact scientists have found no explanation for psychic powers does not make them less, or more, likely to exist. It just means we can't explain them, if they do exist.
 
Last edited:
BRAVO SR!!
I give you a standing ovation and since I'm sitting on the floor instead of the traditional PC desk and chair, that means alot!! :D

Well thank you...although all I really said was it might be a bad idea to give money to Sylvia.
 
I think, to some people's minds, allowing a small amount of woo leaves the door open to increasingly larger amounts of woo.

The thing is, of course, that some people won't just read Deepak Chopra, but attempt to live as if their advice were the absolute truth, no matter what.

Tarot card readings can be harmless - Goddess knows I've done enough of them myself - until you do one for someone who is so weak-minded and weak-willed, that he tries desperately to fit his life around the reading he gets! A dear, dear, stupid friend of mine once got a reading in which the reader told him that he would be betrayed by a blonde girl. Well, he immediately broke up with his girlfriend - a strawberry blonde he had been seeing for two years - and became hostile and hateful to her.

That was an extremely painful time for me, since this girl was like a sister to me. And though I tried my hardest to fix the situation, the two never did reconcile. The girl didn't date again during the three remaining years I knew her (before I left for Basic Training), because Mr. Dear, Dear, Stupid was her true love.

And I know this isn't a problem with tarot cards themselves, but with weak and stupid people. But the same urge that makes lawmakers enforce seat-belt laws and such, is the same urge that I think makes skeptics want to stop all woo cold... it's a protective instinct to keep people away from that slippery slope at all.

Just my $.02.
 
Originally Posted by TruthBeTold
BRAVO SR!!
I give you a standing ovation and since I'm sitting on the floor instead of the traditional PC desk and chair, that means alot!!

Posted by SylviaRox
Well thank you...although all I really said was it might be a bad idea to give money to Sylvia.​

Alright then...
And the thread goes on............
 
(snip)
However, I feel like it is a big stretch to say that feng shui experts, astrologers or tarot card readers seriously hurt anyone, and I don't even see why it's worth making 'skeptical inquiries' into them.

(snip)

Let's try an analogy.

1. You want your car tuned up and bring it to me. I keep it overnight, do nothing except wave my hands over the hood, and charge you $200.00 because I'm a faith mechanic. Have I done something wrong?

You want your fung shui tuned up. You call me in. I move a lamp, a chair, and a rug and charge you $200.00. Have I done something wrong?

2. I'm an X-Ray tech. Your doctor sends me a copy of your X-Rays and asks me to look at them for anomalies. I don't even take them out of the envelope, don't even look at them, but send your doctor a note: This patient is terminal, with no more than six months to live. I take $200.00 for my services. Have I done something wrong?

You come to me to read your tarot cards. I deal off a few and say, "You will get gravely ill in the next six months." I charge you $200.00. Have I done something wrong?

I have never seen any evidence that tarot or fung shui have any basis in reality--charging for the practices, in my opinion, is just as fraudulent as my hypothetical auto repair and X-Ray interpretation.
 
...
Also, I would say that the fact scientists have found no explanation for psychic powers does not make them less, or more, likely to exist. It just means we can't explain them, if they do exist.

I would disagree with this. Science hasn't tried to explain psychic powers because they can't be SHOWN to exist at all. That, to me, makes them less likely to exist.
 
<<The posters in this thread have made a strong argument that certain psychics hurt people, particularly the ones who work in missing persons cases.

However, I feel like it is a big stretch to say that feng shui experts, astrologers or tarot card readers seriously hurt anyone, and I don't even see why it's worth making 'skeptical inquiries' into them.

After all, ideas seemingly more scientific and rational can hurt people much, more more (for example, Monsieur Le Bon, quoted in your signature, was an intellectual influence on Mussolini and Hitler, and the ideas of Marx are still taught favorably in universities). What's the harm if someone reads Madame Blavatsky or Deepak Chopra?>>

I think that Carl Sagan in "the Demon-Haunted World" explained "I know that the consequences of scientific illiteracy are far more dangerous in our time than in any that has come before...how can we affect national policy - or even make intelligent decisions in our own lives - if we don't grasp the underlying issues?" and again "But superstition and pseudoscience keep getting in the way...providing easy answers, dodging skeptical scrutiny, casually pressing our awe buttons and cheapening the experience, making us...victims of credulity."

I think the Skeptic's Dictionary also includes a area called, "what's the harm?" http://skepdic.com/ that would answer this question better than I can.

Susan
 
What's the harm if someone reads Madame Blavatsky or Deepak Chopra?
I am only vaguely familiar with the works of Blavatsky and Chopra, but I will answer this in a more general sense.

Certainly, there are purveyors of fluff and nonsense who may be said to be causing less (direct) harm than others.

But even the milder forms of "woo" (for lack of a better word) involve the willing suspension of logic and common sense. And by participating in these things, I think that a person opens themself up to the more directly harmful varieties of nonsense.

For example, you mention feng shui as being one of the less harmful delusions. What does it matter if someone thigs that rearranging their furniture based on this?

Well, feng shui is largely based on the concept of qi/chi, a magical (and unproven) force which supposedly runs through all things. If a person buys into that, it is a short hop to buying into all sort of Chinese "alternative medicines" which also are based on this supposed energy. And medical woo is among the most potentially harmful I can think of.

Accepting one bit of magical thinking can lead to accepting more and more. Does it always? No. But it often does, which is why a lot of us here try to nip it in the bud when we can.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom