Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

<your other fine points snipped>

She repeatedly claims that she has helped police with missing person cases, yet there is not one single example where anything she said actually helped any of these cases. So, in regards to that claim, she is at 0%. (Let's face it, getting a lucky hit on something now and then when her readings usually play the odds is no actual help to police. They're aware that in most cases when a child is missing for a long time, the child is probably dead. In an investigation, though, it's much better to keep an open mind unless or until the evidence points to a conclusion.)
Good stuff, Joe.

On helping police, where they are stymied with a current case or an open-unsolved case. It's possible that anyone can assist, when provided with the facts of a case, because of the "fresh eyes" effect. No psychic phenomena involved. We're all of us pattern-seekers and not one of us cogitates in exactly the same manner. And therefore it is possible that a person examining a case from a different perspective may be able to discern items that were not apparent to others.
 
Good stuff, Joe.

On helping police, where they are stymied with a current case or an open-unsolved case. It's possible that anyone can assist, when provided with the facts of a case, because of the "fresh eyes" effect. No psychic phenomena involved. We're all of us pattern-seekers and not one of us cogitates in exactly the same manner. And therefore it is possible that a person examining a case from a different perspective may be able to discern items that were not apparent to others.

Indeed
 
I would like to suggest that some people stop posting in this thread.

My reasoning: There's only one SylviaRox, and about 85 gajillion* JREFers posting here. Some significant progress has been made, but a 1:85 gajillion ratio doesn't really make for good discussion. Why don't some of us bow out and let SR talk to RS, TruthBeTold, and a few of the other folks who've really researched the issue.

SylviaRox: FWIW, welcome to the forum, and I'm glad you've been willing to listen and change your views--that's a very admirable quality, one which many people (including many skeptics) lack. Please stick around and check out the other areas of the forum. Also, I'd encourage you to talk to some of the former NS members here to get the skinny on what life inside Browne's world is really like. You may also want to PM RSLancaster to get an idea of where he's coming from; he's really a nice guy (terminally so), and I'm sure he'd be willing to talk to you.


* Number scientifically calculated by yanking it out of my butt
 
I would like to suggest that some people stop posting in this thread.

My reasoning: There's only one SylviaRox, and about 85 gajillion* JREFers posting here. Some significant progress has been made, but a 1:85 gajillion ratio doesn't really make for good discussion. Why don't some of us bow out and let SR talk to RS, TruthBeTold, and a few of the other folks who've really researched the issue.


Good point.

[mode.lurk=true]
 
I tried to read this whole thread, I really did. But I just didn't have the chops.

So, I apologize if this has already been covered.

There was a lot of discussion over how unlikely it would be that Sylvia would guess that the abductor's name was Michael, given that this is one of the most popular names given to children of the likely kidnapper demographic.

Let's say the probability of getting the name right is 10%.

The probability of getting the race right, let's say 20%.

Probability that he would have dreadlocks...maybe 2%.

Probability that he was tall and built like a basketball player...well, this is open to interpretation, but let's say 10% that he's tall, and another 10% that he's built like a basketball player (since either one of these would have been considered a hit in the absence of the other).

Probability that he drove the type of car she described -- 10%.

So, the real probability that SOMETHING she said would have been correct would (given these pretty charitable assumptions) be 10 + 20 + 2 + 10 + 10 + 10 = 62%.

It really wasn't that she guessed the person's name, it's that one of the list of guesses she made turned out to be right. The more guesses, the more likely that one of them would be correct. ANY correct guesses would be considered proof of her magic powers by true believers.
 
I would like to suggest that some people stop posting in this thread.

My reasoning: There's only one SylviaRox, and about 85 gajillion* JREFers posting here. Some significant progress has been made, but a 1:85 gajillion ratio doesn't really make for good discussion. Why don't some of us bow out and let SR talk to RS, TruthBeTold, and a few of the other folks who've really researched the issue.
I think you are completely off base here, Cleon. Kind of an elitist attitude, in my opinion. Only "certain" JREFers should now respond? Oh really? I've been in JREF for more than 10 years, but have been looking in on James Randi's activities for about 30 years. Should I cycle back to the end of the line? Or become a humble spectator because I'm not "qualified" to respond?

I, on the other hand, like the multiple input. One of the reasons - and maybe it's the main reason - that I come to the JREF forum is to learn from the spectrum of fascinating inputs I see every single day. I'd hate to see that suppressed, or for an attitude to develop among JREFers such that "Oh gee I better not say anything maybe I'm not smart enough"...
 
The wrong answers would be coming from other signals in the air. That's what I meant by the radio example. Wrong answers can indeed by psychic, just not from the person the psychic thinks they are from. I'm speaking hypothetically, of course.

We KNOW that wild guessing exists, and is therefore a likely explanation for a wrong answer. We DON'T know that these hypothetical "signals in the air" exist. Until there is some evidence for them, they are not an acceptable explanation.
 
I think you are completely off base here, Cleon. Kind of an elitist attitude, in my opinion. Only "certain" JREFers should now respond? Oh really? I've been in JREF for more than 10 years, but have been looking in on James Randi's activities for about 30 years. Should I cycle back to the end of the line? Or become a humble spectator because I'm not "qualified" to respond?

I, on the other hand, like the multiple input. One of the reasons - and maybe it's the main reason - that I come to the JREF forum is to learn from the spectrum of fascinating inputs I see every single day. I'd hate to see that suppressed, or for an attitude to develop among JREFers such that "Oh gee I better not say anything maybe I'm not smart enough"...

While I disagree with your interpretation of Cleon's intentions, I do have to agree with your point.
 
I think you are completely off base here, Cleon. Kind of an elitist attitude, in my opinion. Only "certain" JREFers should now respond? Oh really? I've been in JREF for more than 10 years, but have been looking in on James Randi's activities for about 30 years. Should I cycle back to the end of the line? Or become a humble spectator because I'm not "qualified" to respond?

I, on the other hand, like the multiple input. One of the reasons - and maybe it's the main reason - that I come to the JREF forum is to learn from the spectrum of fascinating inputs I see every single day. I'd hate to see that suppressed, or for an attitude to develop among JREFers such that "Oh gee I better not say anything maybe I'm not smart enough"...


[mode.lurk=false]

Darn it all, I had just finally settled in for a good lurk.

I'm going to have to disagree with you here, as I think the unsnipped version of Cleon's post did make a good point. Although I have found the various twists and turns of this thread enjoyable, much of it could have been taken to other threads, taken off-line, or just never posted in the first place (I include some of my posts in this last category).

Since SR's main problem seems to be with RSL's site, it may not hurt to let them work it out between them. Any one of us can start another thread in this same sub-forum, with links back here, if we find something pertinent to discuss, which would allow what may turn out to be a productive and educational exchange to develop without interference.

[mode.lurk=true, and will now stay true regardless of any provocation]
 
I'd hate to see that suppressed, or for an attitude to develop among JREFers such that "Oh gee I better not say anything maybe I'm not smart enough"...

Wow...that's what I always say to myself before hitting the "post reply" button! :eek:
A little shocked to see my name included in Cleon's post so I have to say 'thank you'. :)

Unfortunately this thread is a bunch of us talking about the same thing, going around and around in circles but never getting to the point where SylviaRox answers the questions posed.
It's quite frustrating although hopefully not futile.
I never lose hope.
 
So, the real probability that SOMETHING she said would have been correct would (given these pretty charitable assumptions) be 10 + 20 + 2 + 10 + 10 + 10 = 62%.
I understand what you are saying, but I need to point out that you cannot add probabilities that way. As a simple proof: The probability of tossing a coin and it coming up heads is 50%. So if you do it 3 times, there is 50 + 50 + 50 = 150% probability of having at least one heads!

You "add" proabilities by multiplying 1-p and then subtracting this from one. This is the probability that at least one would occur. In your example:

1 - (.9 * .8 * .98 *.9 * .9 * .9) = .485

IXP
 
I would like to suggest that some people stop posting in this thread.
While I understand your reasoning and intent, I don't think it necessary for others to bow out of the thread.

Other than a few wacky derails, I think the thread continues to be interesting and educational.

If Rox and I need to have a one-on-one conversation, we can do so via PMs (and already have, actually).
 
I think you are completely off base here, Cleon. Kind of an elitist attitude, in my opinion. Only "certain" JREFers should now respond? Oh really? I've been in JREF for more than 10 years, but have been looking in on James Randi's activities for about 30 years. Should I cycle back to the end of the line? Or become a humble spectator because I'm not "qualified" to respond?

I, on the other hand, like the multiple input. One of the reasons - and maybe it's the main reason - that I come to the JREF forum is to learn from the spectrum of fascinating inputs I see every single day. I'd hate to see that suppressed, or for an attitude to develop among JREFers such that "Oh gee I better not say anything maybe I'm not smart enough"...

Oh, FFS.

Look, my intent was fairly obvious. I didn't want to create a situation of people "ganging up" on SylviaRox, and allow him some space to converse with people without having to deal with 30,000 different replies. It's not about people being "qualified" or not to post on the subject--it's about making someone new feel welcome and not piling onto him en masse.

If you disagree, hey, fine. But if you want to misinterpret that as some sort of "elitism," or infer some bizarre notion of people not being "smart enough," well, I'm sure I don't need to specify which part of my anatomy you are invited to kiss.
 
Last edited:
JoeTheJuggler said:
I'm not sure what your current drift is. The fact that Sylvia has many critics and few apologists (on the web, that is) somehow makes her more credible?
If you read my last few posts more closely, you will see I was suggesting that her lack of defenders made it more difficult to make a decision regarding her legitimacy, as I have only seen two polarized perspectives (Sylvia and her organization, or StopSylviaBrowne.com). I was not suggesting it made her more legitimate.

OK. I do see the difference. It was my misunderstanding--sorry. You are reserving judgment on Sylvia's legitimacy because all the hard evidence you can find is on one side.

At any rate, the number of critics or supporters is completely irrelevant. What matters is the evidence. Again and again, Robert has offered to put evidence contrary to what he has presented on his website if anyone can provide it. They can't. JREF is offering a million bucks if Sylvia can prove her psychic claim. She can't. (Even though she agreed to take the challenge and even agreed with Randi on a protocol.)

This forum works that way too. You or anyone else are free to make your case here. (Posts are only edited if they violate the rules--not for their "editorial" content.) The evidence is usually video or transcripts of the readings compared to the facts of the case obtained from other sources (the news and whatnot). Testimonials that Sylvia is wonderful does not constitute evidence.

So the "two polarized perspectives" consist of those who argue based on the evidence on the one side and those who just repeat Sylvia's unfounded claims and say how wonderful she is on the other. Contrary to Fox News, the truth is not somehow a balance between the two perspectives. In this case, one is demonstrably right and the other wrong. That is the reason, I think, you can't find the other kind of website that you've been looking for.

Just because there are two sides to every story, doesn't make them both equally true.
 
I'm glad Robert is talking with SylviaRox behind the scenes.
I can't imagine anyone meeting Robert either face-to-face or through the written word that wouldn't like him and see that he's not a guy who gangs up on undeserving people but that he has a purpose and a way about him that makes him an incredible human being.
When I first told my husband (who's the jealous type) what Robert and I talk about in emails and I showed him his website, the first thing he said was "Invite him over for dinner! He seems like a great guy!"
Freaky!! :D
 
Good stuff, Joe.
Thanks--the strategy I learned from watching Sylvia is working: if I post often enough, I'm bound to say something that makes sense sooner or later!

aggle and IXP: I really like the idea of quantifying her readings to see what her "percentage" really is, but I think it should be done by taking a reading as a single gestalt whole. For example, as a whole, the Hornbeck reading was a miss. It was no help for police (even caused wasted time and effort) and caused unnecessary emotional suffering for the parents. So that's 0 for 1. If you go through all of her missing person cases, I suspect she's 0 for however many you care to investigate. For a net percentage of zero.

Otherwise, it's going to be really tough to count every possible hit or miss--especially when you allow for shoehorning, ambiguity and such. For instance, if Hornbeck's abductor were named Mikail or Mitchell, wouldn't supporters want to claim that as a hit? Also, her many guesses about a cause of death having to do with the head or chest are so broad that it's hard to think of a cause of death that would NOT be a hit.

And that doesn't take into account a lot of window dressing stuff: in the "she was shot" debacle, for instance, Sylvia gave a vague description of the girl (whose photo was being shown on screen). The parents never asked "What did our daughter look like?" Still, it looked like a string of "hits". How do you quantify that?

Also, what do you do with the many cases that remain unsolved (and may remain so forever)? Her claims that the body is in such-and-such a place, or the killer wore a flannel shirt or whatever are unresolved. Still, her claims, in these cases, to have helped the police are still wrong. In giving out rewards, they usually only go in exchange for information that leads to an arrest. I say we treat these things the same way. Her help has to at least solve the case somehow. What else could it possibly mean to successfully help in a case?

Again, in any meaningful way, she's batting .000 in helping police with missing person cases!
 
Oh, FFS.

Look, my intent was fairly obvious. I didn't want to create a situation of people "ganging up" on SylviaRox, and allow him some space to converse with people without having to deal with 30,000 different replies. It's not about people being "qualified" or not to post on the subject--it's about making someone new feel welcome and not piling onto him en masse.

If you disagree, hey, fine. But if you want to misinterpret that as some sort of "elitism," or infer some bizarre notion of people not being "smart enough," well, I'm sure I don't need to specify which part of my anatomy you are invited to kiss.
I see. Well obviously your intent was NOT fairly obvious. You were the one who specifically mentioned certain people who should be "allowed" to continue the conversation with SR - whilst the rest of us respectfully back off and don the mantle of hushed spectator. So apparently I misinterpreted and wrongly assumed elitism. Sorry about that.

Let's see. Got a person here with the forum name of SylviaRox - indicating tremendous devotion to the charlatan Slyvia Browne. Bangs onto the JREF forum with a combined RSL-blasting, SB-adoring first post. He's STILL defending Slyvia Browne. He brought the "ganging up" action upon himself. What'd he expect?

Maybe we went to different schools but I always figured that when I joined a group I'd wait awhile before getting uppity, even obnoxious. Is this the new way? Storm into a group, insult with your first words, back off a bit and then bask in all the wuv and acceptance? Who knew? I gotta get out even more, more.

Thank you for the invitation but I will not be kissing your ass anytime soon. :)

FFS - is that a British thing then? Shouldn't it be F@S?
 
Oh, FFS.

Look, my intent was fairly obvious. I didn't want to create a situation of people "ganging up" on SylviaRox, and allow him some space to converse with people without having to deal with 30,000 different replies. It's not about people being "qualified" or not to post on the subject--it's about making someone new feel welcome and not piling onto him en masse.

If you disagree, hey, fine. But if you want to misinterpret that as some sort of "elitism," or infer some bizarre notion of people not being "smart enough," well, I'm sure I don't need to specify which part of my anatomy you are invited to kiss.

Thank you Cleon, some posters have been very helpful, and others less so, but the more ridiculous off-topic posters seem to have gone away, and the more hostile users have toned it done somewhat (although one is still very active).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom